The curious case of the French
#1
Posted 12 October 2001 - 17:02
We have seen Talbot and Renault, Bugatti and Delahaye, Ligier and Matra, Panhard and Peugeot - no shortage of marques. But the success of French drivers rarely seem to have matched the success of their cars.
Why is this? And who would you identify as France's best drivers? My favourite has always been Francois Cevert, the very epitome of the 1960/70s GP driver in looks, manner and talent. What a tragic loss he was.
#3
Posted 12 October 2001 - 17:51
#4
Posted 12 October 2001 - 19:35
I've always been partial to Raymond Sommer and Jean Alesi, the lion-hearted drivers of two different generations.
#5
Posted 12 October 2001 - 20:09
If you look at the 30s-50s era the most stricking point about french drivers is that most of the best of them were hardcore privateers who didn't really seem to fit with factory spirit. Raymond Sommer, Fifi Etancelin and Louis Rosier were great drivers but never really had top cars. Yes Sommer was part of the Scuderia Ferrari in the very begining of it but he prefered to be his own boss. Same for Etancelin who often was an official Maserati driver pre-war but he had more success in his own cars.
The two exceptions of this era were Trintignant and Behra but, altough world class drivers they maybe lacked a little something to match JMF, Moss & Ascari's pace.
There also seems to be some kind of curse over top french drivers. Guy Moll (shooting star : often forgotten but really a top driver), Jean-Pierre Wimille, François Cevert, Didier Pironi, Patrick Depailler really had what it takes to be World Champions but tragic accidents prevented them from making it.
One of the best era for french drivers was the first 20 years of motorsport history. From Gaston de Chasseloup-Laubat to Louis Wagner with Jules Goux, André Boillot, René Thomas, Victor Hémery, Théry, Duray, Guyot, Bablot... all really at the top of the sport, winning everything from Grand Prix racing to Indianapolis.
#6
Posted 12 October 2001 - 20:10
#7
Posted 12 October 2001 - 20:50
for instance Pironi (almost WDC '82); Trintignant; Arnoux; the quiet but great Laffite; Jabouille (the hero of the turbo invention period); the tragically died Behra, Cevert and Depailler and so on
But they had the greatest driver ever!!!!!
#8
Posted 13 October 2001 - 03:09
his win at monaco showed how talented he was... under the rain, the driving was more manageable for him and his only "good" arm... in terms of talent, he certainly was "able"
cheers,
jmp85
#9
Posted 13 October 2001 - 07:38
#10
Posted 13 October 2001 - 08:20
#11
Posted 13 October 2001 - 08:50
Originally posted by byrkus
How about Wolfgang von Trips?? He was also German, and had 2 wins!!
oops sorry, a brain fart there!
#12
Posted 13 October 2001 - 08:59
#13
Posted 13 October 2001 - 09:32
#14
Posted 13 October 2001 - 16:06
guys, it really does seem, the french are having problems, in F1.
i mean, let's look at Rally!
they have many stars there, actually.
what about Gilles Panizzi, and Francois Delecour?
do you think, the french have a certain special talent?
ciao,
liran biderman.
#15
Posted 15 October 2001 - 05:12
#16
Posted 15 October 2001 - 07:22
#17
Posted 15 October 2001 - 08:05
Originally posted by Prostfan
Chiron was not French
Oh yes he was. He was born in that ridiculous money-grubbing little chocolate box tax-haven by the sea , but had dual natonality due to his father being French.
#18
Posted 15 October 2001 - 08:09
Think Prostfan mentioned the "greatest driver ever" a few posts back - not the same guy ??;)Originally posted by Wolf
One name is surprisingly not mentioned, yet.
#19
Posted 15 October 2001 - 11:37
have not been in the right place at the
right time. For example Jean Pierre Jarier,
surely one of the best drivers ever to never
win a Grand Prix Race.
Advertisement
#20
Posted 15 October 2001 - 11:46
I did name Prost in my original post as the exception to what I see as a surprisingly low level of success otherwise for French drivers. But when you look for the next best Frenchman, you hjhave to look a long way down the "roll of honour".Originally posted by Wolf
One name is surprisingly not mentioned, yet.
I see that no-one has really contested my assertion but also no-one has ventured any real ideas about why it should be. France has long had an active motor racing culture which by the laws of averages should have turned up a few champions by now. I know that there were some sad losses like Cevert and Depailler who might have done better but where were the rest of the great French drivers? FEV has rightly pointed to the very early days but since then it has been a story of might-have-beens. Yes, there have been some memorable drivers culminating in every one's favourite, Jean Alesi, but the wins and the WDCs haven't been there. I remain puzzled why this should be...
#21
Posted 15 October 2001 - 12:02
#22
Posted 15 October 2001 - 14:49
The 1955 le Mans disaster also played a role. A lot of races dissapeared for ever, giving less opportunities for these same young drivers to learn racing.
Another point could be the reactionary look of french over the evolution of motorsport. Before WWII basically anyone who could afford it could buy a Grand Prix car (or at least a Voiturette) and go racing with the great names. If you were good at it than you could make a life of it (as it was the case for Wimille, Moll and the others). After WWII the sport became more and more organised. Junior formulae began to be run giving young drivers opportunities to learn racing. France didn't follow the F3/FJunior trend like Britian, Italy or Germany did. The aspiring french drivers of the 50s still had a pre-WWII approch to the sport, as probably had the all french motorsport scene.
#23
Posted 19 October 2001 - 04:59
#24
Posted 19 October 2001 - 09:58
#25
Posted 19 October 2001 - 10:03
Originally posted by cabianca
I thought Guy Moll was Algerian, not French.
Just what I was going to say FEV!
#26
Posted 19 October 2001 - 14:59
#27
Posted 19 October 2001 - 15:54
Algeria can be considered a colony for it was an independant country since 1710 and remained one until France invaded it in 1830. At some point early in the 20th century (can't remember the date) it did become a proper french department (sort of equivalent of english county) but still, not many of the algerians considered themselves as french and every french living there was seen as a settler.
#28
Posted 19 October 2001 - 19:00
#29
Posted 19 October 2001 - 19:27
So France-Algeria history is the one and only subject in which I might have a superior knowledge to you - you're one of my maestroes (maestri ?) here.;)
#30
Posted 20 October 2001 - 08:45