765 replies to this topic

[kosmos]

Australia

Petrov 10
Perez 10
Vettel 9
Hamilton 9
Di Resta 9
Buemi 8
Alonso 7
Sutil 7
Kobayashi 7
Glock 7
D'Ambbrosio 7
Rosberg 6
Maldonado 6
Button 6
Alguersuari 6
Kovalainen 6
Trulli 6
Luizzi 6
Massa 5
Schumacher 5
Webber 4
Barrichello 3
Heidfeld 1
Karthikeyan "no score"

[Yolandy]

Australia

Petrov 10
Perez 10
Vettel 9
Hamilton 9
Di Resta 9
Buemi 8
Alonso 7
Sutil 7
Kobayashi 7
Glock 7
D'Ambbrosio 7
Rosberg 6
Maldonado 6
Button 6
Alguersuari 6
Kovalainen 6
Trulli 6
Luizzi 6
Massa 5
Schumacher 5
Webber 4
Barrichello 3
Heidfeld 1
Karthikeyan "no score"

9 for Vettel coz he did every thing right in a faster car? lol

[wrexter]

9 for Vettel coz he did every thing right in a faster car? lol

10 for Perez for listening to team instructions and staying out? lol

[BennyJohnson]

You can't give Hamilton and Vettel the same score.

Hamilton should be a 10 IMO.

[Lord_Shaitan]

You can't give Hamilton and Vettel the same score.

Hamilton should be a 10 IMO.

Especially for his off road episode... 9 for Hamilton is a very proper IMO.

[jcbc3]

And Barrichello was three times as good as Heidfeld?

Heidfeld made 1 mistake on his first qualifying run. The second run was compromised by Karthekiyan and Schumi (that gor a reprimand for it).
In the race Heidfeld made a good start but picked up extensive damage. (Pictures in the relevant thread).

Barrichello on the other hand beached his car in qualifying. Had a lousy start of the race and ended up assualting Rosberg taking him out.

[gm914]

Liuzzi 6

Is Joe Saward one of the judges, or is Tonio getting all-around pity points these days?

Edited by gm914, 31 March 2011 - 06:26.

[Bonaventura]

Especially for his off road episode... 9 for Hamilton is a very proper IMO.

The floor broke before his off, he must have lost a lot of downforce balance etc.
but Lewis managed to drive the damaged car for nearly the half race and still got 2nd.

[Lord_Shaitan]

The floor broke before his off, he must have lost a lot of downforce balance etc.
but Lewis managed to drive the damaged car for nearly the half race and still got 2nd.

And I appreciate his effords and his great job all weekend long and that's why I think 9 is ok. Lewis was great but not flawless

[Cenotaph]

oh for pity's sake... don't start the lewis was perfect thing already...

btw, liuzzi a 6? for what exactly, beating a guy that doesn't even deserve to be rated?

and why does di resta deserve two points over sutil? mind boggling, considering kobayashi didn't get the upper hand on perez based on qualifying time. autosport driver ratings as confusing as ever ;)

and there's plenty of other questionable stuff there. the overrating of virgin drivers continues

Edited by Cenotaph, 31 March 2011 - 06:41.

[Zava]

Vettel only 9? he had a superb quali, a great start, a crucial overtake for the victory, and after that controlling the race well. what should have he done for 10? lap the whole field?

also, Button and Kobayashi under, di Resta overrated by these points.

Edited by Zava, 31 March 2011 - 06:49.

[thuGG]

Why Vettel only 9? What did he do wrong? Ridiculus.

[Madras]

What did Vettel have to do to get a 10?

[gillymuse]

What did Vettel have to do to get a 10?

Walk on water.

[Cenotaph]

if you have the best car you can never be perfect. Don't you guys remember how bad Mansell and Prost were in 92 and 93?

[Madras]

if you have the best car you can never be perfect. Don't you guys remember how bad Mansell and Prost were in 92 and 93?

How can anyone be judged perfect?

[Brandz07]

Why Vettel only 9? What did he do wrong? Ridiculus.

well i reckon half the grid could of done what he did ;)

[Zava]

well i reckon half the grid could of done what he did ;)

yeah, like Webber.

[marcoferrari]

9 for Vettel coz he did every thing right in a faster car? lol

I am also surprised to see Vettel with a nine... It was an excellent weekend for him with a Pole Position and a win... His pace advantage over team mate Webber was enormous...

Edited by marcoferrari, 31 March 2011 - 07:12.

[kosmos]

yeah, like Webber.

with a damaged chassis.

[SteF1an]

Vettel 9

[Mastah]

As always some very strange marks. Seb outqualified his teammate by 9 tenths, had phenomenal start without KERS, did crucial overtake on Jenson and all he got is 9... Lewis also trashed Jenson in quali by 7 tenths in reality (he was without KERS on his final try), but botched the start, which could really change how the race looked and also got 9 . Paul qualified ahead of Adrian, but from sector times he was 6 tenths slower and finished race behind teammate - Paul 9, Adrian 7 . Timo destroyed Jerome in quali by 1 second, had better pace in the race eventhough he was few laps behind because of some problem and they both got 7. Tonio did good job, but Narain, returning 5 years after his last season in F1, qualified 1.2 second behind his teammate, not that slower than Jenson and Mark behind theirs, and received no score. WTF?

[P123]

You guys do realise that these aren't actual points being awarded towards the championship..... some of the reactions area a tad OTT. There will never be a list from anybody that everybody agrees with.

[HopkinsonF1]

For anyone who says Lewis was perfect, don't forget his start. That alone could have cost him a chance of challenging for the lead in the early laps.

[ZZei]

Heidfeld 1? Kovalainen and Trulli both 6? Vettel 9? Alonso 7?
Heidfeld was lucky to even finish the race, kovalainen outperformed Trulli by a clear margin, Alonso was unlucky at the start but made crusial overtakes at the starting laps and outperformed Massa by a clear margin, and what did Vettel do wrong?

[SK99]

Vettel should have got a 5.

It's quite obvious he should have lapped the field in that car.

Typical Ed Straw bias - sack him.

Edited by SK99, 31 March 2011 - 12:22.

[AlanWake]

I would have given an 8 to Alonso and a 10 to Vettel.

[joshb]

I think I'd have bumped Vettel up to a 10 and maybe Hamilton too.
Not sure about Di Resta getting a 9, after all he came 12th (nothing spectacular) maybe a 7 was about right, on a par with Sutil
D'Ambrosio barely got into the race and was 4 laps down so his pace has to be questioned (althogh maybe the car had a problem). I'd give him 5 or 6
The rest I dont have a problem with.

Edited by joshb, 31 March 2011 - 13:03.

[Grenada]

Especially for his off road episode... 9 for Hamilton is a very proper IMO.

In a broken car.

[ktsayshi]

Liuzzi 6

Is Joe Saward one of the judges, or is Tonio getting all-around pity points these days?

I actually think that one might be kinda fair. Liuzzi got within 1.7 seconds of qualifying with fewer than 15 laps in the Rolling Chicane. On the other hand, giving Rosberg the same score for getting torpedoed by Rubens and Heidfeld a 1 for being blocked in qualifying and having a bomb go off in his sidepod is a little eyebrow-raising.

[moonraker]

Kova 6? He battled with Sauber and STR before giving up...
Glock & d'Ambrosio 7? Trulli 6? the marussia's weren't even racing, they were just driving around albert park. Trulli was fast as hell on soft tyres, and he lapped them

Liuzzi 6? Joe, is that you?

[H2H]

Heidfeld 1? Kovalainen and Trulli both 6? Vettel 9? Alonso 7?
Heidfeld was lucky to even finish the race, kovalainen outperformed Trulli by a clear margin, Alonso was unlucky at the start but made crusial overtakes at the starting laps and outperformed Massa by a clear margin, and what did Vettel do wrong?

The 1 for Heidfeld buggers me a bit. IMHO no vote would have been better, if we consider his troubles and the traffic in Q1 and the massive bodywork damage suffered after an excellent start.

[flyer121]

So a 10 to Petrov because previously he was not rated high.

What does Autosport think of Kubica then? Godlike ??

[Sausage]

I thought Barri deserved a 0 for that pathetic attempt at a pass.

[dau]

Liuzzi 6? For driving three laps and then not qualifying the car? Hey, i could've done that. Heidfeld worse than Gravelchello? Di Resta 9? His race wasn't that special really. ..ah, why bother..

[Afterburner]

Liuzzi at 6? What... the... #$*&!

[apoka]

Vettel only a 9. Liuzzi and Heidfeld should get a "no score" (did they bother to look at his car?) and Perez not a 10. Perez was half a second slower than Kobayashi in qualy. That's still good for a rookie, but an 8 would be enough. His pace is probably not on Hamilton/Vettel level.

[korzeniow]

So a 10 to Petrov because previously he was not rated high.

What does Autosport think of Kubica then? Godlike ??

Yeah, in next Unreal Tournament there should be rank "Kubicca" instead of Godlike

[Roni]

Yeah, in next Unreal Tournament there should be rank "Kubicca" instead of Godlike

Do you play DotA? There is beyond godlike kill streak, so there should be K-k-k-k-kubicaLike after "beyond godlike".

[kojack]

So Alonso qualifies his team mate by 7 tenths, finishes the race 40 seconds ahead of him, and storms from 10th to 4th, yet only gets a 7? Ridiculous. His bad start was a situational thing, that often happens , it was not overly his fault. He deserved an 8 or maybe 9.

[kosmos]

Malaysia


Vettel 10
Di Resta 9
Button 9
Heidfeld 9
Kobayashi 8
Alonso 7
Sutil 7
Hamilton 7
Petrov 7
Perez 7
Luizzi 7
Massa 7
Schumacher 7
Webber 7
Kovalainen 7
Glock 7
Barrichello 6
Karthikeyan 6
Buemi 6
D'Ambbrosio 6
Rosberg 5
Maldonado 5
Trulli 5
Alguersuari 4

[lbennie]

So Alonso qualifies his team mate by 7 tenths, finishes the race 40 seconds ahead of him, and storms from 10th to 4th, yet only gets a 7? Ridiculous. His bad start was a situational thing, that often happens , it was not overly his fault. He deserved an 8 or maybe 9.

eh?

and a 40 second gap to philipe is not what it used to be, the little fella has lost some mojo. you saw the way webbo drove around him at turn one - when he had absolutely no right to do so.

[jcbc3]

Is there an official love-in with di Resta at Autosport offices?

I'll give that he has driven very well, but....

[midgrid]

China

Hamilton - 10
Webber - 9
Rosberg - 9
Vettel - 8
Massa - 8
Di Resta - 8
Kobayashi - 8
Kovalainen - 8
Button - 7
Alonso - 7
Schumacher - 7
Petrov - 7
Liuzzi - 7
D'Ambrosio - 7
Heidfeld - 6
Barrichello - 6
Sutil - 6
Buemi - 6
Alguersuari - 6
Trulli - 6
Karthikeyan - 6
Glock - 6
Maldonado - 5
Pérez - 4

[thuGG]

8 for Vettel? I don't remember him doing anything wrong, the strategy was wrong, but it's not his fault.

[Carlo's]

Webber should have got 10.

[clipper]

8 for Vettel? I don't remember him doing anything wrong, the strategy was wrong, but it's not his fault.

see webber's 7 for malaysia where he didn't have KERS and gets shuffled back in the pack. Both probably made slow starts but you're right not much mistakes in their drives

[bauss]

Vettel had a poor start...
Webber totally screwed up qualifying...

[OwenC93]

Webber should have got 10.

He didn't even get out of Q1.

[Kvothe]

I think Kovalainen should have got a 9 for what seemed to be a faultless race.

If Vettel is given an 8 so should Rosberg, he outbroke himself into the hairpin, and got overtaken by Button. which meant he ultimately lost out to Mark.

Webber's score is spot on if we look at the race weekend as a whole, and the fact that he has the fastest car.

I would have given Sutil higher. Desperately unlucky to have had Perez swing into him, and had been running 11th, and so was on course to beat Diresta

Liuzzi jumpstarted, yet is given a 7 in comparison to Barichello (6) who got 13th, probably the maximum out of the car.

Edited by Kvothe, 21 April 2011 - 12:34.