Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Spa - The Race - Your comments (merged)
The AUTOSPORT Bulletin Board > Forums > Racing Comments
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17
primer
Originally posted by Spunout
Congrats to Lewis, it looks like the WDC will be his up.gif


This is being overlooked. All said and done, Lewis extended his lead over others, and the two Ferrari drivers are both 'incomplete' to fight against him. Today Kimi was faster than Felipe for much of the race. This was a big result, you could see it on Lewi's face post race and on podium.

What about Heikki Kovalainen

Both Finns are fin-ished tongue.gif
Bruce
Originally posted by BuzzingHornet
Had to come here after the race to witness the crying Hamilton anti-fanboys smile.gif The tears of true morons warms my cold heart.

Hamilton did a great drive today... I see no one is mentioning Kimi's run around the outside of the track to gather great speed for a run at Hamilton? Didn't think so ;)


No one mentioned it because it's a non-issue- going off the track in those conditions is to be expected, and KR re-joined behind LH - no harm, no foul. You really think Kimi looked at the tarmac and said to himself - ah - there will be lots of grip out THER where no one has been racing all afternoon! Yeas - I will pop across the grass, soaking my tires even more and get momentum!!!"

Ludicrous. I'd expect better from you Buzzing.

BTW - those of us who aren't in the Lewis-Love society don't cry - we manfully suck it up.... lol.gif
Yellowmc
Originally posted by TheSaltire


Source?


Another forum. AFAIK, it's plausible as yellows were out for raikkonens car and many people passed others in to the bus stop.
Leyser
Originally posted by DCult

Anything that can bring Kimi a few points is acceptable. wink.gif


and/or an STR podium?

I wish there was some proper coverage of the last lap battle for 3-7.

Originally posted by Bruce


No one mentioned it because it's a non-issue- going off the track in those conditions is to be expected, and KR re-joined behind LH - no harm, no foul. You really think Kimi looked at the tarmac and said to himself - ah - there will be lots of grip out THER where no one has been racing all afternoon! Yeas - I will pop across the grass, soaking my tires even more and get momentum!!!"

Ludicrous. I'd expect better from you Buzzing.


To be fair to Kimi, he's not been shy about using that tarmac. He obviously knows his runoff places better than Hamilton (but Hamilton times and places his spins much better!).

But don't mind me, I'm just fuming at my deteriorating Iceman putting my team's WDC challenge squarely on Massa's [insert damning adjective] shoulders.
Ricardo F1
Originally posted by Bruce
not surprising with the advantage that McLaren has in the wet on dry tires
Lewis has. Why can't people just understand the kid is rather useful in the wet?
Wouter
Originally posted by Gilles4Ever


gearbox

Thanks. That's the first tech problem for McLaren then (other than Kova's crash early in the season), a bit worrying. It could have been Lewis...
awake27
I think KR was on the green kurb at blanchimont, not surprising he spun (and crashed) because they dont have grip grip when is wet/.
DoubleWDC
Originally posted by Ricardo F1
Lewis has. Why can't people just understand the kid is rather useful in the wet?


It looks so because Kovalinen is so bad but it's all in the car and how it uses the tyres.
Nitropower
For me what's key here is: it's not the same to come out a corner BEHIND another car than come side by side. Hamilton had him tied this way. That must the point of the investigation. Whatever the otucome Raikk is out.
GerardF1
Anyone know if the last few laps have been posted to Youtube yet?
MichaelPM
Well now the dust has pretty much settled I have to say that was a brilliant race.

Dunno why I was angry at Kimi's bonehead performance in the closing laps because he actually gave Massa 2 more points and #1 status instead of stringing it out over the last few races. So in a way he did a good thing.

Another solid points position for Alonso aswell even if Heidfeld got the lucky pit timing which only cost Alonso 1 point in the end.

Very tense and hectic final laps was fun to watch aswell so was worth tuning in this weekend up.gif

<3 Spa
Ben
Originally posted by Ricardo F1
Lewis has. Why can't people just understand the kid is rather useful in the wet?


He's bloody useful in the wet, he was much better than Heikki at Silverstone and Monaco, but that doesn't mean that the McLaren is better than the Ferrari in those conditions, which it is IMO.

Ben
pingu666
fantastic end to the race.

so awsome comments here too, properly roflmao.gif here
Mila
that was some hard defending from KR on his teammate on the opening lap. probably the last time we'll see that this season.

interesting how perceptible it was that HK overtaking of RK on the Kimmel was set up by RK's less-than-ideal entry into La Source. likewise, it was easy to see how much more track NP's Renault was using up through the corners before his retirement.

I would not be surprised if there is some tension building between RK and BMW.

it was a fascinating race, already, without the rain. I'm very surprised to see both KR and LH risk so much on that penultimate lap. ok, they both wanted to win, but it's only two points between first and second place. for me, fortune smiled on LH and not KR. I'd also have to say that, when the rain arrived, at least a half dozen drivers behind them kept it much more together and that, of the top three in the standings, the guy who kept his eye on the WDC prize was FM. and, yes, we have to wonder why Ferrari didn't pit him for inters at the end.

those final laps just go to show that, once again, it pays not to be the guy in front when the rain hits.

in terms of sportsmanship, I don't see any problem with KR defense at the Bus Stop. I have no idea what posters here are going on about.
Leyser
Originally posted by DoubleWDC


It looks so because Kovalinen is so bad but it's all in the car and how it uses the tyres.


HK is useless, but that doesn't mean LH isn't pretty damn useful.

I mean, that would be like saying FA's performances in Renault flatter to deceive because he looks way too good next to NP. wink.gif

In any case, the original argument stands: the McLaren looks better than the Ferrari in the conditions.
Man of the race
Short analysis of the race:

The end result was a bit unfortunate for some, more presentful for the others. Sometimes a mistake is more costly, sometimes troubles can not be avoided and sometimes trying to stay away of those wouldn't get other's respect and not even self respect. Sometimes one does not do so much but achieves a lot. is it fair. No. That is how it is in the life. I would not call racing unfair, I would call it racing to the extreme. What I would have hated to see was laying back and not going for it and not taking risks. This is the F1 I want to see even though the result is not always the best. It is never good for everybody. It is not a priest's wish. What a fresh shower after the boredom of Valencia.
Jamelon
Lewis got an advantage out of his move on Kimi, he ended up much closer than he should have been just before corner 1. I think he should be penalised as this has happened before, ask Alonso.

The result would have been the same as his car had much better handling in those conditions, but if you take the rulebook and previous similar investigations the decision is pretty obvious...except for his fanboys of course.
Bruce
Originally posted by Ricardo F1
Lewis has. Why can't people just understand the kid is rather useful in the wet?


Sorry Ricardo - even James"Mrs. Hamilton" Allen states that the McLaren has an advantage in those circumstacnes.

- Having said that - I don't believe anything else that twat says - why should I believe that? lol.gif
Wouter
Originally posted by GerardF1


Agreed good race - would have liked to see Kimi get 2nd - but wasn't to be.

BMW doesn't seen to have a lot of faith in Heidfeld and want to dangle his seat in front of Alonso. Can't see it happening . He would be walking into the same position as he had at McLaren - the other driver being a favoured son.

Doesn't McLaren still have a "free" engine swap available for Hamilton? I am not sure if is starting Monza on a fresh engine as well?

Either way Monza will be a big race.

McLaren does have a "free" engine swap available, for both cars, and Ferrari has one for Massa. Only Raikkonen used it already AFAIK.

Kimi second would have been a "better" result, I agree, he deserved at least to be in front of Massa and on the podium after his race.

Heidfeld performed very well all weekend, I guess he will keep his seat after all. Perhaps likewise for Bourdais.

Great race from Alonso, to. They switched him too late to intermediates, apparently.
Ben
Originally posted by DoubleWDC


It looks so because Kovalinen is so bad but it's all in the car and how it uses the tyres.


It's not "all car" and it's not "all driver"

Why do you tedious fanboys have to reduce everything to black and white.

Lewis screwed up today, so did Kova, so did Kimi. Massa didn't screw up as such, but was just too slow compared with the front two. The end result was a great finish to the race.

Being unable to admit when someone's done a good job just because you don't "like" them is horribly immature. How old are you BTW?

Ben
Two Jags
Isn't this a better result for Ferrari fans than if Kimi won? Hamilton would gain 2 points on Massa regardless whether they finished 2-3 or 1-2, but if Kimi had won Ferrari would have the problem of having both their drivers fighting for the championship & taking points off each other. Ferrari are free to concentrate all their resources on Massa now & Kimi is more likely to take points from Mclaren than Kova is from Ferrari.

As for the 'investigation'.. I hate to think what today's stewards would have made of Gilles Villeneuve vs Rene Arnoux.
DoubleWDC
Originally posted by Mila

in terms of sportsmanship, I don't see any problem with KR defense at the Bus Stop. I have no idea what posters here are going on about.


Craneboy and his fanboys wish Kimi should have let their hero past so he would not have needed to take plan B into action (cut the chicane).
Bruce
Originally posted by Ben


It's not "all car" and it's not "all driver"

Why do you tedious fanboys have to reduce everything to black and white.

Lewis screwed up today, so did Kova, so did Kimi. Massa didn't screw up as such, but was just too slow compared with the front two. The end result was a great finish to the race.

Being unable to admit when someone's done a good job just because you don't "like" them is horribly immature. How old are you BTW?

Ben
up.gif
carbonfibre
Originally posted by primer


This is being overlooked. All said and done, Lewis extended his lead over others, and the two Ferrari drivers are both 'incomplete' to fight against him. Today Kimi was faster than Felipe for much of the race. This was a big result, you could see it on Lewi's face post race and on podium.

What about Heikki Kovalainen

Both Finns are fin-ished tongue.gif
So it's easy to forget about the last couple of races where hamilton didnt have an anwser to massa so it seems. We will see but i think lewis won't get it easy against massa.
Galko877
Originally posted by Ricardo F1
Lewis has. Why can't people just understand the kid is rather useful in the wet?


I think it's a combination of both. Lewis is a great wet weather driver but I think the McLaren car too is superior to the Ferrari in the wet and that makes Lewis look even better than he is. This was a similar situation to Nürburgring 2007 IMO with Alonso and Massa. Massa dominated the race in dry but when it started to rain he was lost. I know what people think of Massa's wet weather ability but I think that is partly unfair and I do think Alonso's superiority there wasn't just his but also the McLaren's. The same here today.
britishtrident
Originally posted by DoubleWDC


Hamilton put himself into a position that he knew would result into cutting a chicane because there was no other place to go. He choiced to cut the chicane before committing to his "move". It was a deliberate decision and hence should be punished.


I think both Lewis and Kimi were too focused on not spinning out to think of any of the cynical tactics we have seen from a couple of ex-WDCs of recent memory.
DoubleWDC
Originally posted by Two Jags
Isn't this a better result for Ferrari fans than if Kimi won?


When did WCC stop mattering?
Bruce
Originally posted by Two Jags

As for the 'investigation'.. I hate to think what today's stewards would have made of Gilles Villeneuve vs Rene Arnoux.


They would have been banned for life. The FIA knows that such entertainment is not good for the sport.
primer
Originally posted by AFCA
Bourdais deserved better, he did a great race with a bridge wing that was cut in two pieces.


rolleyes.gif His wing wouldn't have been broken if he didn't use Jarno's Toyota as a ramming target.
J
I was certain that McLaren would have an advantage at the end as every one was on the harder tires, and it started to rain.

If it´s colder than expected - Advantage Macs

If it´s hotter than expected - Advantage Ferrari

Try to remeber it. It makes following the races more intresting...


-J
Enkei
Any vids of the race on youtube yet?
DoubleWDC
Originally posted by britishtrident


I think both Lewis and Kimi were too focused on not spinning out to think of any of the cynical tactics we have seen from a couple of ex-WDCs of recent memory.


If there had been wall in place of runoff area there would not have been a move in the first place.
Bruce
Originally posted by DoubleWDC


When did WCC stop mattering?


When did it EVER matter? lol.gif
Bloggsworth
Originally posted by DoubleWDC


Hamilton put himself into a position that he knew would result into cutting a chicane because there was no other place to go. He choiced to cut the chicane before committing to his "move". It was a deliberate decision and hence should be punished.


Bog off you big girl's blouse, this is F1, Hamilton wanted to pass, Kimi didn't want him to so he ran wide in the first part of the chicane forcing Hamilton onto the run-off. Hamilton slowed down out of the chicane, let Kimi past, pulled in directly behind him to show he wasn't going faster, then Kimi outfoxed himself going into La Source compromising his own braking, and Lewis took the inside and got past - Nothing to investigate if it had between between Hamilton and any other team car but a Ferrari.
gincarnated
Originally posted by DoubleWDC


It looks so because Kovalinen is so bad but it's all in the car and how it uses the tyres.


It's all on Lewis if the tires fail though right. Anything to make him look bad.
anthony says
Funnily enough, if Hamilton had pitted for tyres instead of taking on Kimi at the chicane, he would have won easily, and maybe Kimi would have been second.

It’s interesting to look at the lap times for the final lap – fastest was Glock 1-59.4, then Heidfeld 2-01.3, but Alonso did 2-22.3, despite pitting for inters. I don’t know what happened to Alonso, but he must have made a mistake but still finished 14 seconds behind Massa and 29 sec behind Hamilton. So if he had lapped around Glock/Heidfeld’s pace he would have been easily second and maybe even pressured Hamilton into a mistake.
BunnyK
What Hamilton did was the same Alonso did at Suzuka '05 with Klien, jumped the casio chicane, got advantage, slowed a little bit but just enough to pick up the slipstream so he could overtake in the First corner, exactly the same situation, I don't think it is very sportsmanlike knowing that you gained speed by cutting the chicane but I don't think there's a rule about how many cars should be let once you do that...

Both Raikkonen and Hamilton went wide at Pouhon, and Raikkonen didn't gain any position there, what happened is that he braked earlier in Stavelot, Lewis went wide into the grass, Raikkonen went ahead but found a Williams in his way, then at the exit of the second corner of Stavelot spinned and Hamilton regained the lead. So both were far from perfect but Lewis still kept the car on the tarmac in the final laps.

No heroes today, Bourdais started well but fade away with the rain, just like Alonso who made a mistake pitting on the last lap as he could have scored a podium had he stayed on hards, anyway it was an exciting finish with Vettel 1 tenth of a second behind eek.gif , and Heidfeld didn't shine through the race but was smart enough to pit two laps before the end of the race...

Anyway, great race up.gif up.gif up.gif up.gif and great track up.gif up.gif up.gif
gaston_foix
Hammilton comments about Kimi:

"He pushed me wide," Hamilton complained. "I was a little bid ahead, he could have been fair.


"He pushed me so that I either went into him or off. I then let him past on the straight. He was ducking and diving left and right by I got past. Then he hit me from behind on the apex."
w00dy
I will take the stewards' decision whatever it may be. But my secret hope is that all those people who say they'll never watch F1 again if the FIA does xxxxx would really leave. not that they ever will.
Pharazon
Originally posted by DoubleWDC


Hamilton put himself into a position that he knew would result into cutting a chicane because there was no other place to go. He choiced to cut the chicane before committing to his "move". It was a deliberate decision and hence should be punished.


err...sure...

shouldn't you be under a bridge somewhere?
primer
Originally posted by Lada Lover
Trulli is under investigation for breaking all know laws of physics at the start.


lol.gif up.gif
britishtrident
Originally posted by Bruce


No one mentioned it because it's a non-issue- going off the track in those conditions is to be expected, and KR re-joined behind LH - no harm, no foul. You really think Kimi looked at the tarmac and said to himself - ah - there will be lots of grip out THER where no one has been racing all afternoon! Yeas - I will pop across the grass, soaking my tires even more and get momentum!!!"

Ludicrous. I'd expect better from you Buzzing.

BTW - those of us who aren't in the Lewis-Love society don't cry - we manfully suck it up.... lol.gif


Yes 90% of those who criticise the most on this forum can't imagine just how difficult it would be to race any kind of single seater in those conditions never mind a current F1 car without any driver aids and dry weather Bridgestone control tyres.
Atreiu
Originally posted by J
I was certain that McLaren would have an advantage at the end as every one was on the harder tires, and it started to rain.

If it´s colder than expected - Advantage Macs

If it´s hotter than expected - Advantage Ferrari

Try to remeber it. It makes following the races more intresting...


-J




Maybe Ferrari should have used the hard tyre for the second stints of their pilots. The seconds stints were short ones compared to the 3rd. It would have been nearly impossible for Lewis to pass Kimi on a dry track and, looking at the weather, they would have been on better rubber when the rain came.

Hindsight is a great thing.
Wouter
Originally posted by Ben


It's not "all car" and it's not "all driver"

Why do you tedious fanboys have to reduce everything to black and white.

Lewis screwed up today, so did Kova, so did Kimi. Massa didn't screw up as such, but was just too slow compared with the front two. The end result was a great finish to the race.

Being unable to admit when someone's done a good job just because you don't "like" them is horribly immature. How old are you BTW?

Ben

Correct. Kovalainen had a very, very bad start /first corner (he seemed to break way early), and the incident with Webber was his fault (though the penalty was harsh IMO), but he was pretty much on fire when overtaking, and he was well in the points near the end (the gearbox failure ended his race, don't know if he had pitten for intermediates by that point). He's not as good as Massa, Hamilton, Raikkonen, Alonso, Kubica but he is hardly "useless".
britishtrident
Originally posted by awake27
I think KR was on the green kurb at blanchimont, not surprising he spun (and crashed) because they dont have grip grip when is wet/.


Yes something needs done about those slippery lines and kerbs before next season.
Leyser
Originally posted by primer


rolleyes.gif His wing wouldn't have been broken if he didn't use Jarno's Toyota as a ramming target.


Braking aid, more like. cry.gif
Pharazon
Originally posted by BunnyK
Both Raikkonen and Hamilton went wide at Pouhon, and Raikkonen didn't gain any position there, what happened is that he braked earlier in Stavelot, Lewis went wide into the grass, Raikkonen went ahead but found a Williams in his way, then at the exit of the second corner of Stavelot spinned and Hamilton regained the lead. So both were far from perfect but Lewis still kept the car on the tarmac in the final laps.


no, you look at the onboards.. Hamilton doesn't go wide, he had to take to the grass to avoid Rosberg. Raikonnen had to change direction but managed to stay on. If the Williams wasn't here, Hamilton wouldn't have left the track.
Slowinfastout
Originally posted by britishtrident


Yes 90% of those who criticise the most on this forum can't imagine just how difficult it would be to race any kind of single seater in those conditions never mind a current F1 car without any driver aids and dry weather Bridgestone control tyres.


Exactly, you can carry this over to some of the FIA people as well, I'm afraid they just don't get it.. starting to hand out penalties in such conditions (last part of the race) is very very strange call for someone not in driver's seat to make..
gaston_foix
Originally posted by anthony says
Funnily enough, if Hamilton had pitted for tyres instead of taking on Kimi at the chicane, he would have won easily, and maybe Kimi would have been second.

It’s interesting to look at the lap times for the final lap – fastest was Glock 1-59.4, then Heidfeld 2-01.3, but Alonso did 2-22.3, despite pitting for inters. I don’t know what happened to Alonso, but he must have made a mistake but still finished 14 seconds behind Massa and 29 sec behind Hamilton. So if he had lapped around Glock/Heidfeld’s pace he would have been easily second and maybe even pressured Hamilton into a mistake.


Alonso did 2-22.3 because he pited "clever" Hamilton fan.
DoubleWDC
Originally posted by Bloggsworth


Bog off you big girl's blouse, this is F1, Hamilton wanted to pass, Kimi didn't want him to so he ran wide in the first part of the chicane forcing Hamilton onto the run-off. Hamilton slowed down out of the chicane, let Kimi past, pulled in directly behind him to show he wasn't going faster, then Kimi outfoxed himself going into La Source compromising his own braking, and Lewis took the inside and got past - Nothing to investigate if it had between between Hamilton and any other team car but a Ferrari.


You certainly could buy a clue or two so hopefully momma will give you a dime. Hamilton wanted to pass where it was not possible because Kimi was there so he made the decision to cut the chicane (=cheat) and gained an advantage for the next corner. If Craneboy had taken the bus stop correctly like Kimi he would have been nowhere near him on the straight and not had a chance to pass at La Source.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.