Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: The Alonso Factor in Brazil (merged)
The AUTOSPORT Bulletin Board > Forums > Racing Comments
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9
airwise
No they didn't. Haug never said that. Is English your second language?
Nadsat
Originally posted by airwise


Interesting that Norbert Haug rather intimated the same thing - and of course he has access to the telemetry.



Well, Alonso could do it once he had overtaken Hamilton in the start. No problem with it. It's called racing.
ensign14
Originally posted by Nadsat



Well, Alonso could do it once he had overtaken Hamilton in the start. No problem with it. It's called racing.

Wow. This is the most ignorant statement that has ever appeared on atlasf1, and that is some achievement.

Brake testing is NOT racing, it is the absolute antithesis of racing. It is not just stupid, but highly dangerous. There have been several deaths and very serious injuries in F1 alone from cars riding up the back of other cars. You are saying that creating a situation like that DELIBERATELY is not only acceptable, but RACING? Lewis Hamilton can tool around at the start, wait for Massa to lap him, and then braketest him into the championship? What's clever about that?

Nadsat, if that is your idea of "racing", please do everyone a favour and eff off to watch demolition derbies instead.
K-One
Originally posted by Nadsat



Well, Alonso could do it once he had overtaken Hamilton in the start. No problem with it. It's called racing.


Not it's not, but maybe for Alonso fans brake testing is "racing" down.gif down.gif rolleyes.gif

Wonder if someone brake tested Alonso, how would you feel then? Alonso has a long list of brake testing, Hamilton, Coulthard, Doornbos -shows what a fair guy he is
Rinehart
Originally posted by BMW_F1


and do you think all things considered he is a better driver then Alonso and that the record books represent that last year..?


Yes Lewis was a better driver than Alonso last season.

Remember too that Alonso cheated last season - testing his car with set up information via Pedro from Stepney - Hamilton didn't.
Smudger
Originally posted by Nadsat



Well, Alonso could do it once he had overtaken Hamilton in the start. No problem with it. It's called racing.



What complete rubbish.
DiStefano
Originally posted by K-One


Not it's not, but maybe for Alonso fans brake testing is "racing" down.gif down.gif rolleyes.gif

Wonder if someone brake tested Alonso, how would you feel then? Alonso has a long list of brake testing, Hamilton, Coulthard, Doornbos -shows what a fair guy he is



When did he brake test Hamilton?
At Bahrain? Actually Hamilton rammed Alonso TWICE roflmao.gif
PS even showed the telemetry you bloody muppet.

He didn't brake test Coulthard either, Renault showed the stewards the telemetry too and they decided to take no action.

The only one he did that to was Doorknob and that was during a FP where that guy was being a c***, not that it makes it fair but cut the "he has a long list" crap.

Originally posted by Rinehart


Yes Lewis was a better driver than Alonso last season.


Oh is this why Alonso beat him 10-7 in the races?
Mackey
Wonder if someone brake tested Alonso, how would you feel then? Alonso has a long list of brake testing, Hamilton, Coulthard, Doornbos -shows what a fair guy he is


LOL, you ran out of excuses to bash Alonso and made up that BS.

Remember too that Alonso cheated last season - testing his car with set up information via Pedro from Stepney - Hamilton didn't.


Of course, that information was only available to Fernando and Pedro. Nobody at McLaren knew about it. Seems that the british propaganda really works.
bankoq
Originally posted by Rinehart


Yes Lewis was a better driver than Alonso last season.

Remember too that Alonso cheated last season - testing his car with set up information via Pedro from Stepney - Hamilton didn't.


Hamilton had been copying Alonso's setup for many races so he did used illegal information as did Fernando.
El_Capitán
Originally posted by Rinehart


Fantasy. Both Massa and Kimi have signed contract extensions SINCE Alonso has been available.


When Massa and Kimmi signed the extension to the their contracts Alonso WAS under contract with Renault for 1 year, with the posibility to exercise a second year with the French team if the performance was to Alonso's specifications.

What do you mean Alonso was "available"?

Get some glasses.
El_Capitán
Originally posted by Rinehart


And the Spanish press you gobble up is the definition of objectivity right? roflmao.gif

Like the headline 'Alonso sings for Ferrari' roflmao.gif


No, what I am saying, and you seem to have difficulty reading, is that most media are biased. The only difference is that while we in Spain KNOW our media is biased, we also know YOURS is also biased.

Do you understand now or would you like me to translate it into Goidelic?
El_Capitán
Originally posted by mkay


It is not favoritism. Alonso withdrew himself from the team. Don't forget that HE BLACKMAILED Ron Dennis, his boss (and by association, the whole team) to get what he wants. I wouldn't have expected the team to react well to this.


Well, stand aside for a second. Here's Fernando, a 2 x WDC, coming into a British team and finding out that the team has ILLEGAL information of Ferrari's development.

Now, what WE DO KNOW if how the FIA reacted to Alonso's and Lewis' testimony: 100 million dollar fine, no WCC and the stigma of having been caught lying. We know the FIA did not punish De la Rosa, Lewis or Alonso, so, from this, we can only conclude that NONE of these three individuals did anything wrong or illegal.

What Ronald Dennis and his bitches did, is plant a story, like they do many times, in the British specialized press, which always happily complies without even checking to see if what is being reported is fact or just mere gossip (hence is a de-facto propaganda machine) saying that Alonso had blackmailed the team.

Now, we all know the FIA is French and we all know how much the Brits dislike to be controlled by a French body of power (hence the constant criticism by what some call the "British lobby," meaning Windson, Matchett, etc; is it me or does it seem the criticism for the FIA ONLY seems to come from the British teams?) but we can only make conclusions from facts, and the fact is that Alonso was not penalised by the FIA.

Now, you have another choice, which is to believe a story planted in the British specialized press by one of Ronald Dennis' bitches, mere uncorroborated gossip from a guy that has just been busted LYING.
fnz
Hasn't this been discussed in various topics whole year long? As far as i know this is about the "alonso factor @ interlagos 2008"
ensign14
Originally posted by El_Capitán

What Ronald Dennis and his bitches did, is plant a story, like they do many times, in the British specialized press, which always happily complies without even checking to see if what is being reported is fact or just mere gossip (hence is a de-facto propaganda machine) saying that Alonso had blackmailed the team.

Funny, nobody has ever managed to find any evidence that Alonso did not blackmail McLaren. No counter-stories, no counter-suggestions, nothing. Nothing in the foreign media, I understand. Was there anything in the Spanish media stating that Alonso did not threaten Dennis that he would not pass emails on to the FIA if he did not get number 1 status? Because regardless of any planting Ron Dennis was the one who provided the smoking gun evidence to the FIA.

Originally posted by El_Capitán
Now, we all know the FIA is French and we all know how much the Brits dislike to be controlled by a French body of power (hence the constant criticism by what some call the "British lobby," meaning Windson, Matchett, etc; is it me or does it seem the criticism for the FIA ONLY seems to come from the British teams?) but we can only make conclusions from facts, and the fact is that Alonso was not penalised by the FIA.

It is also a fact that the FIA lied to justify penalizing McLaren and only the British media pointed out that fact. Perhaps that means that the British media are the only media that actually care about reporting the truth?
Rinehart
Originally posted by Mackey


LOL, you ran out of excuses to bash Alonso and made up that BS.



Of course, that information was only available to Fernando and Pedro. Nobody at McLaren knew about it. Seems that the british propaganda really works.


Two words 'court transcript' rolleyes.gif
Rinehart
Originally posted by El_Capitán


When Massa and Kimmi signed the extension to the their contracts Alonso WAS under contract with Renault for 1 year, with the posibility to exercise a second year with the French team if the performance was to Alonso's specifications.

What do you mean Alonso was "available"?

Get some glasses.


I can't argue with the ridiculous, sorry.
Rinehart
Originally posted by El_Capitán


No, what I am saying, and you seem to have difficulty reading, is that most media are biased. The only difference is that while we in Spain KNOW our media is biased, we also know YOURS is also biased.

Do you understand now or would you like me to translate it into Goidelic?


I understand that you have got issues and that you like wielding your big wide brush.
airwise
Originally posted by El_Capitán


WWe know the FIA did not punish De la Rosa, Lewis or Alonso, so, from this, we can only conclude that NONE of these three individuals did anything wrong or illegal.


The Spaniards were offered immunity from prosecution in exchange for grassing. Alonso and De La Rosa were clearly cheating and happy to do so.
El_Capitán
Originally posted by ensign14

Funny, nobody has ever managed to find any evidence that Alonso did not blackmail McLaren. No counter-stories, no counter-suggestions, nothing. Nothing in the foreign media, I understand. Was there anything in the Spanish media stating that Alonso did not threaten Dennis that he would not pass emails on to the FIA if he did not get number 1 status? Because regardless of any planting Ron Dennis was the one who provided the smoking gun evidence to the FIA.


But that is precisely what I am saying: How do you know that Fernando Alonso backmailed Ronald Dennis or McM? Were you THERE when this alledged incident took place?

As far as the rest of the media NOT carrying the story, or as you choose to know it "nobody has ever managed to find any evidence that Alonso did not blackmail McLaren"; I think it has more to do with not trusting the source (British specialized media) than them actually not wanting to pursue the incident.

I personally am of the opinion that Fernando Alonso was USED shamelessly, by Ronald Dennis and his bitches, as a scapegoat to the whole spying scandal. I mean, look at the British media's reaction to the supposed "blackmail" incident vs the spying scandal. Does it look fair and balanced??? And the way McM has their bitches critizising the FIA every chance they get... I mean, total rubbish. I've never seen anything like this (in sports) in my life.

It is also a fact that the FIA lied to justify penalizing McLaren and only the British media pointed out that fact. Perhaps that means that the British media are the only media that actually care about reporting the truth?


The FIA lied in what?? Again, BACK WHAT YOU SAY MAN!!!

The fact that the British media pointed out something is irrelevant to me. I do not trust their information. Period. Anything they say, unless corroborated by another news outlet, I (metaforically) would hold with a pair of tweezers, at arm's length, while holding my breath.
marcusgearey
I think everything needs to be put into perspective:

http://www.pitflaps.co.uk/

seems about right to me, especially the February issue.

I would also like to know who Ron's "bitches" are because I'm not sure Autosport have done a story on them and it would be good if we could all be kept informed of useful information like this.
Rob
Originally posted by El_Capitán
The FIA lied in what?? Again, BACK WHAT YOU SAY MAN!!!


It's in the court transcript.
Anomander
El captian, if you have such a problem with the British and British media, where do you insist on visiting a british media site, why not go pollute a spanish site where you can spew you endless tripe and hate about McLaren and how baddly Alonso was done to.
Showty
According to Cadena SER Haug and Dennis spoke to Alonso´s manager to ask him to play safe.
potmotr
Originally posted by Anomander
El captian, if you have such a problem with the British and British media, where do you insist on visiting a british media site, why not go pollute a spanish site where you can spew you endless tripe and hate about McLaren and how baddly Alonso was done to.


My thoughts exactly.
potmotr
Originally posted by Showty
According to Cadena SER Haug and Dennis spoke to Alonso´s manager to ask him to play safe.


I think that would be an extremely foolhardy thing for Dennis to do. Alonso has made it clear that he doesn't owe McLaren -and particularly Dennis- any favours at all. It would be like a red rag to a bull I'd imagine.

Here's hoping Alonso breaks a driveshaft off the line...
Showty
Originally posted by potmotr


I think that would be an extremely foolhardy thing for Dennis to do. Alonso has made it clear that he doesn't owe McLaren -and particularly Dennis- any favours at all. It would be like a red rag to a bull I'd imagine.

Here's hoping Alonso breaks a driveshaft off the line...


Not only that, there´s no point at asking that.

It´s a great opportunity for Alonso, Vettel...to get a great result since Hamilton does not need a W, they all have to push and try to overtake him asap because they know he shouldn´t take many risks.
El_Capitán
Originally posted by marcusgearey
I think everything needs to be put into perspective:

http://www.pitflaps.co.uk/

seems about right to me, especially the February issue.

I would also like to know who Ron's "bitches" are because I'm not sure Autosport have done a story on them and it would be good if we could all be kept informed of useful information like this.


Have you ever read anything else aside from Autosport? Did you ever noticed how some papers seem strangely reticent to pursue certain news that are worth investigating because it involves Team X while they will jump on the stupidest gossip story known to mankind just because it benefits Team X? Have you ever wandered why this is so?

There is a reason for this, and it involves many papers in many countries. Have you ever noticed how Marca never says anything negative about Real Madrid? Have you ever noticed how it is difficult to find negative news about McM in Autosport magazine?

Nowadays access to teams/athletes may mean the difference between having a career as a writer or not. Hence you have writers, and not necesarily investigators, writing what athletes or teams want, which may or may not coincide with the truth. Now, as of lately this level of intellectual servitude has taken to the additional task of demonizing "the opposition," and are doing so actively. Marca does it with Barcelona all the time.

Now, all of these relationships of interest have had a big impact of the quality of the writing, sometimes resorting to mere gossip and not investigating what is most important. Hence that is why Austosport will NEVER pursue a serious investigation of the entire spying scandal but yet will elaborate INSATIABLY about the supposed or alledged blackmailing incident with Alonso. Or Marca's outright denial that (as per Ferguson's correct accusation) Real Madrid distorts the player's markets so that they could make "a bundle" by overvalueing their players and planting FALSE accusations about other rising starts that conflict with their market.

The ones who get involved in this game without any remorse I like to call "bitches", because they do what the "pimp" wants them to do.
El_Capitán
Originally posted by Anomander
El captian, if you have such a problem with the British and British media, where do you insist on visiting a british media site, why not go pollute a spanish site where you can spew you endless tripe and hate about McLaren and how baddly Alonso was done to.


Because I trust and like British people, but not some of their institutions.
El_Capitán
Originally posted by Rob


It's in the court transcript.


And?? Link?? Can you please elaborate? What does the transcript say?
potmotr
Originally posted by El_Capitán


The ones who get involved in this game without any remorse I like to know "Dennis' bitches" as well as I call their Spanish counterparts "Calderón's bitches".


El Crapitan, the rest of your ranting post made some sense, but what does this last sentence mean?
Rinehart
Originally posted by El_Capitán


And?? Link?? Can you please elaborate? What does the transcript say?


So you've never read the most famous FIA court transcript in F1 history, yet you want to tell us all how the world works? You take the biscuit.
El_Capitán
Originally posted by potmotr


El Crapitan, the rest of your ranting post made some sense, but what does this last sentence mean?


It's El Capitán. I don't think I ever insulted you, so I'm going to play nice and ask you to calm down a little.

What I meant with the last sentence of my comment is that those who report the news are no longer independent in the sense that they can report that which they deem is worth reporting. Nowadays people report things that go through various "filters" (aka censorship) before they are published.

Hence the freedom to write is gone (partially at best) and we end up with teams/athletes dictating what is newsworthy and what is not. Of course, they do not do this directly, but if you have direct access to such and such player or team, get invited to all of their parties and then, out of the blue, you get invited no more because you wrote a piece the team/athlete did not find "suitable" for their marketing needs... you kinda get the point. Ya know what I mean?
Rinehart
Originally posted by Showty
According to Cadena SER Haug and Dennis spoke to Alonso´s manager to ask him to play safe.


I don't believe that for a nanosecond.
El_Capitán
Originally posted by Rinehart


So you've never read the most famous FIA court transcript in F1 history, yet you want to tell us all how the world works? You take the biscuit.


So what did it say??? Do you have a link???
potmotr
Apologies, was just needling you.

Yes, I do take your point but I'm afraid I don't agree with it.

Some elements of the media have an agenda for sure, but as a reader I always strive to find an objective view point.

I think some, but not all, of the specialist press writers in the UK offer this.
El_Capitán
Originally posted by potmotr
Apologies, was just needling you.

Yes, I do take your point but I'm afraid I don't agree with it.

Some elements of the media have an agenda for sure, but as a reader I always strive to find an objective view point.

I think some, but not all, of the specialist press writers in the UK offer this.


No harm done my friend!

As far as you finding an "objective point" of view... I do not deny that, but look at half of the posts here and tell me the stupidity in the writing hasn't percolated to people's opinions. I mean, if you find gossip as damaging and morally wrong as spying and lying... It's kind of hard to find any objectivity there. Don't you think?
Craven Morehead
Haven't we argued enough about last season? There will never be any agreement on that stuff, so can we just move on? This thread is about brazil 2008. Alonso will not do anything untoward to Lewis today. Any contact between any of the runners would be purely incidental to the racing. Fred does not have a agenda against Lewis. And he has made it clear that crashing an f1 car into another on purpose is just fanboy fantasy rubbish.
Showty
Originally posted by Craven Morehead
Haven't we argued enough about last season? There will never be any agreement on that stuff, so can we just move on? This thread is about brazil 2008. Alonso will not do anything untoward to Lewis today. Any contact between any of the runners would be purely incidental to the racing. Fred does not have a agenda against Lewis. And he has made it clear that crashing an f1 car into another on purpose is just fanboy fantasy rubbish.


Agreed 100%, but i think if a crash happens with Hamilton involved people will say it was on purpose bla bla bla.
SeanValen
Originally posted by Craven Morehead
Haven't we argued enough about last season? There will never be any agreement on that stuff, so can we just move on? This thread is about brazil 2008. Alonso will not do anything untoward to Lewis today. Any contact between any of the runners would be purely incidental to the racing. Fred does not have a agenda against Lewis. And he has made it clear that crashing an f1 car into another on purpose is just fanboy fantasy rubbish.




up.gif

Also in this day and age where dnfs are more costly, and the points system rewards the winner less, it's harder to run away with wins alone, you need not to dnf, so drivers are or have to be more friendly to a certain basis and have a peace eventually, as they depend on each other for some sort of rational racing interaction on track where the very championship foundations hangs in the balance.

The equalibrium of f1 drivers solidarity in relation to racing is much more clearly defined, the days of Senna and Prost messing with each other, will likely not happen again, f1 cameras, f1 public, f1 drivers have all changed into a new beast. 2007 was a accident, no one was expecting Alonso and Hamilton to be in the same team, it lasted one year, didn't work out, but it was exciting to see, ashame it didn't continue, we needed something like to get our minds off the fia's messing with the sport
smoking.gif smoking.gif smoking.gif
up.gif

THE EQUALBRIUM SHIFTS
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.