Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Massa or Lewis - who do you support?
The AUTOSPORT Bulletin Board > Forums > Racing Comments
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
undersquare
Originally posted by bond
He was faster tha alonso arriving at turn 4, but alonso braked earlier and that was the cause he went offtrack...
He has already explained this at fuji...


Well I heard him say that, I watched it again last night (hoping the pain is going to be healed this weekend tongue.gif ), he tracks FA to the inside, then dives to the outside as Fernando brakes. Well if he wasn't challenging he'd have stayed on the normal line on the outside, not followed him to the inside. Fernando only barely made the corner himself, so he couldn't have braked any later. So I think Hammy's memory was playing tricks on that one, though when FA braked I daresay he had to dive right to avoid him, tucked right up with no air on his front wing.

I think actually drivers are often not really aware of what's happened as it goes off, just reacting in real time while we play it over and over one frame at a time. Not sure they even bother watching it afterwards either, probably not that interesting after actually doing it.
VresiBerba
Originally posted by as65p
Time might tell what Kova is really worth.
Time was not suspended at the Italian Gp, neither was it at the German GP. Heikki showed his worth right there, I think.
pingu666
weather he felt the pressure is to a certain extent iirelivent, that wasnt what put him out :\
VresiBerba
Originally posted by bankoq
So what is your interpretation of his own words from the conference? He says in front of your eyes the pressure got to him in last race in 2007 and you still claim it's not true?
Lewis said he felt pressure, whether that pressure resulted into something leaves the beholder to decide. Some do, some does not.

The desperate attempts to pin Lewis on the gearbox failure in Brasil last year are turning desperate. Just give it a rest will you rolleyes.gif
undersquare
Originally posted by bankoq
I didn't say he lost the title because of the pressure. I think his mistake at the start of the race was probably because of the pressure got to him (and it would cost him much more than 5s because his pace would be compromised by slower cars) but of course it wasn't the reason why he lost it. You win or lose the title by driving all season long.


Ah the 2 part of your post hadn't arrived when I replied. I agree. So now I really don't understand what you were gloating about with his quote. 22 years old defending a lead in the wdc, of course he felt pressure. Still does at 23, and Massa, whatever words they're using to prepare themselves.
Turn 1
Originally posted by VresiBerba
Time was not suspended at the Italian Gp, neither was it at the German GP. Heikki showed his worth right there, I think.



I don't know about time suspended, but it certainly feels like your watching slow motion when your on board with heikki. It really frustrates me because there seems to be no answer to his slugness. And I dont buy the 'weaker strategy' bollox.
pingu666
i guess he cant drive the car in the way it needs tobe to get whatever lewis gets out of it, atleast consistanly
gaston_foix
I voted for Hamilton. I want to see Ferrari losing.

So c'mon Lewis, u can do it...
bankoq
Originally posted by bond
He was faster tha alonso arriving at turn 4, but alonso braked earlier and that was the cause he went offtrack...
He has already explained this at fuji...


It's totally false. Watch the incident again. I don't know why Lewis didn't tell how it really was, did he do it on purpose (to taunt Alonso?) or maybe he simply didn't remember the incident clearly enough?

Originally posted by VresiBerba
The desperate attempts to pin Lewis on the gearbox failure in Brasil last year are turning desperate. Just give it a rest will you


I didn't use a single word where I claimed it was Hamilton's fault. The situation still isn't perfectly clear for me so far.

Originally posted by undersquare Ah the 2 part of your post hadn't arrived when I replied. I agree. So now I really don't understand what you were gloating about with his quote. 22 years old defending a lead in the wdc, of course he felt pressure. Still does at 23, and Massa, whatever words they're using to prepare themselves.


I just wanted to point the fact it's the first time he said the pressure got to him last year and he reacted to it. Earlier he didn't want to admit it and some fanboys claimed he like nobody else - he doesn't feel pressure but everyone else does which is BS.
airwise
Originally posted by bankoq


It's totally false. Watch the incident again. I don't know why Lewis didn't tell how it really was, did he do it on purpose (to taunt Alonso?) or maybe he simply didn't remember the incident clearly enough?


It's interesting in light of the quote below from Haug. After all - Haug has the benefit of telemetry. Of course he's probably lying and it's all a conspiracy....


Everyone says Lewis got it wrong last but that is not correct. The gearbox went wrong, he didn't get it wrong.

"His teammate was not nice to him, but he was fighting for the championship as well.
bankoq
Originally posted by airwise


It's interesting in light of the quote below from Haug. After all - Haug has the benefit of telemetry. Of course he's probably lying and it's all a conspiracy....



And that Haug's quote proves what exactly? I think you missread what we are discussing about.

I was refering to Lewis' going off the track at the start of Brazilian GP last year and not his problem with gearbox. And bond claims Lewis went off because it was Alonso who forced him to do that because he braked too early while it's not true because Lewis had inside line and just decided to attack Alonso while could trail him in 4th place. Even undersquare who always has excuses for Hamitlon's mistakes admits Lewis didn't describe the situation how it really was (probably because he simply didn't remember it clearly enough).
undersquare
Originally posted by bankoq


Even undersquare who always has excuses for Hamitlon's mistakes...


Sometimes I have to counter posts from members who are not content to support their own driver in a positive way, but seem to think inventing and exaggerating criticisms of competing drivers somehow makes their guy better wink.gif .
bankoq
I should have put there wink.gif after claiming you always look for Lewis' mistakes excuses. biggrin.gif
undersquare
Originally posted by bankoq
I should have put there wink.gif after claiming you always look for Lewis' mistakes excuses. biggrin.gif


OK tongue.gif smile.gif
ali_M
Originally posted by MonzaOne
I prefer Massa because I just enjoy the way he drives and he has matured - his overtaking of KOV and HAM at Hungaroring was superb.

As for Lewis - he has gained a year's experience and it shows. He is not as impressive this year as last because Alonso is not his competition, but I do like his natural tendency to want to win at the first corner.

I think he will do it this year and will be a tremendous ambassador for motor racing after the morose attitude and essentially pathetic driving this year of the tatooed RAI. Sometimes I wonder if RAI takes drugs! ambivalent.gif

I think that both MAS or HAM would be great world champions and I sincerely hope it is a great grand prix at Interlagos.


Hmmmm.

You think Raikkonen takes drugs and then think Massa has matured? smile.gif

The car clearly suites Massa more than Raikkonen, especially in the mid-season. In the last 2 races, Raikkonen has been getting on top of the car.

Schumacher substantiated this in his recent BBC interview.

It's sort of flattering to Raikkonen and not very complementary to Massa, that if he's going slower than Massa, he must be on drugs. smile.gif

The thing is that Massa always had pace, but lacked consistency. We could see his pace relative to M. Schumacher in 2006. It was only a matter of time before he ironed out his consistency. He's giving Kimi a very good run in that Kimi has to have everything right to be consistently in front of Massa.
as65p
Originally posted by VresiBerba
Time was not suspended at the Italian Gp, neither was it at the German GP. Heikki showed his worth right there, I think.


Well those two races (as well as most others this season, why did you single them out?) showed that he isn't in the same class as Hamilton.

The only time this season were he truly looked able of fighting Lewis was Silverstone practice.

The question is, can he improve and get there or will he stay a level below drivers of Lewis' calibre through is career? Historically the chance for the former is small, but still it exists.

That's what I meant with "time will tell".
ali_M
Originally posted by BMW_F1


Its all about your POV vs that of other posters here..
Mass Damper and Michellin tires were not infringements.. they had passed all checks in prior years/races.. Obviously the FIA changed their interpretation/regulations to favor Ferrari in a championship during the middle of the 2003/2006 seasons.
I was equally pissed off as a Montoya supporter back in 2003 then as Lewis's fans are today or Alonso supporters were in 2006..

The montoya /shucmacher incident cannot be controversial when you can clearly see from the vid footage that 1. JPM was in front of MS and 2. MS oversteers into JPM. If any penalty had to handed it must have been to MS and not Juan.


As to passing prior tests, what about moving wings (flexiwings) that pass initial tests? smile.gif Same for moving floorboards? smile.gif Those were Ferrari developments and were banned as they were discovered and the inspections tests adjusted accordingly.

As to Montoya's penalty, I was not at all surprised by it. He strong armed his way through and not tidily. It was all so unnecessary really. But I guess you're in favour of Montoya and not Schumacher. This will tint your lens a little. smile.gif

POV's can develop when looking only in one direction.
BMW_F1
Originally posted by ali_M




As to Montoya's penalty, I was not at all surprised by it. He strong armed his way through and not tidily. It was all so unnecessary really. But I guess you're in favour of Montoya and not Schumacher. This will tint your lens a little. smile.gif

POV's can develop when looking only in one direction.


you are perhaps confusing Indy03 with Malaysia02.. In Malaysia Shumi crashed into Montoya's sidepod..
BTW, I was just making a point that unjust penalties have been handed in the past and that this isn't about Ferrari or Lewis.. Its the same as when a referee makes a bad call and pulls a red car or annuls a goal for being off-side when it wasn't.
Dooly Tilly
Massa takes back the lead in our poll. cat.gif
cheapracer
Originally posted by BMW_F1


you are perhaps confusing Indy03 with Malaysia02.. In Malaysia Shumi crashed into Montoya's sidepod..
.


Mate this just isn't factually true. You are making a judgement I presume off one camera angle and yet those who have seen the other camera angles and pictures from journo's trackside clearly show that Montoya unfairly sueezed MS onto the curbs and created the contact - even Montoya himself was exclaiming "I gave him room, I gave him room" while serving his drive through obviously not realising he didn't.

If you feel the need to argue I will find the pictures for you but I suggest you look carefully at the Montoya incar at the start and notice when he turns in that MS's front spoiler is just in view still ahead of Montoya's front tyre.

http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=IJJXIgnjug0&feature=related

We have to start a campaign to get Montoya back to F1, surely Honda want him.
cheapracer
Originally posted by Dooly Tilly
Massa takes back the lead in our poll. cat.gif


177 Vs 177 , yeah, quite a lead.
pacwest
Massa cut the chicane.
Craven Morehead
looks like a very even split between the fans then. here's to a great, fair, and safe finale to a great season. either protagonist will make a worthy wdc imo. up.gif
scotchman
I have to say I'm really keen to see Felipe Massa win the title this weekend.

The odds are against him with Hamilton only having to finish 5th or better, but I'd love to see Felipe win the race and the championship on home turf.

He's got a new engine this weekend compared to Hamilton's 'race 2' power unit, so who knows, will we see a Mercedes go boom when the pressure is on?

That said, we've seen Ferrari power plants lunch themselves throughout the year, race 2 or 1 so who knows!

I just want to see a good race with real battles going on up and down the grid - but Massa scooping the title to the acclamation of his home fans!!



clap.gif clap.gif
bankoq
Originally posted by Craven Morehead
looks like a very even split between the fans then. here's to a great, fair, and safe finale to a great season. either protagonist will make a worthy wdc imo. up.gif


It would the best if there was no difference between them in points and finishing positions so virtually who would finish Brazil race higher would become WDC. That would be something!
BMW_F1
Originally posted by cheapracer


Mate this just isn't factually true. You are making a judgement I presume off one camera angle and yet those who have seen the other camera angles and pictures from journo's trackside clearly show that Montoya unfairly sueezed MS onto the curbs and created the contact - even Montoya himself was exclaiming "I gave him room, I gave him room" while serving his drive through obviously not realising he didn't.

If you feel the need to argue I will find the pictures for you but I suggest you look carefully at the Montoya incar at the start and notice when he turns in that MS's front spoiler is just in view still ahead of Montoya's front tyre.

http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=IJJXIgnjug0&feature=related

We have to start a campaign to get Montoya back to F1, surely Honda want him.


Montoya gave MS plenty of room, it is not fair to penalize a driver for attempting to overtake a car into T1.. MS could have easily made the corner but you can clearly see that he oversteered into Montoya who was at the time already infront of Michael . I've seen that video plenty of times plus the race live.
BMW_F1
Hamilton's engine will not last I am afraid.. I don't think he's had any engine failures from a race in two years.. its about time I think..
bankoq
Hamilton had best reliability from all drivers on the grid in last 2 years. Sooner or later it will balance out.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.