Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Felipe Massa's accident (and latest health report) (merged)
The AUTOSPORT Bulletin Board > Forums > Racing Comments
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33
sreevishnu
QUOTE (potmotr @ Jul 25 2009, 20:04) *
Who would be Ferrari's replacement?

Surely not Gene or Badoer.

with no testing allowed, i guess gene or badoer is the Only choice
MegaManson
**** me, lucky escape redface.gif
Ellios
Agree he won't be racing tomorrow - I hope he's just fine!!

seemed the track first aid took sometime to get to him, I thought he was slumped in his cockpit for quite sometime (1-2 minutes?)
Atreiu
QUOTE (sreevishnu @ Jul 25 2009, 11:05) *
with no testing allowed, i guess gene or badoer is the Only choice


Schumacher?
Orin
QUOTE (valachus @ Jul 25 2009, 14:59) *
Domenicali said already that he won't race - http://www.gazzetta.it/dilatua/Motori/Form...5624_full.shtml
"Intanto Stefano Domenicali, responsabile della gestione sportiva della Ferrari, ha già chiarito che "domani Felipe Massa non correrà il Gran Premio d'Ungheria. E' stato intubato, ma è cosciente e la situazione è sotto controllo"."
As close as a shave with - at least - permanent infirmity can get! Hope he gets well soon!


So it's conformed he's not racing then.
potmotr
QUOTE (sreevishnu @ Jul 25 2009, 15:05) *
with no testing allowed, i guess gene or badoer is the Only choice


I'd say Gene, he is younger, has more recent F1 race experience (for Williams in 2004) and won Le Mans last month.

I saw him at Goodwood recently and he appears to be in pretty good shape for a 34 year old.

Badoer has done nothing in a decade, other than pound around Ferrari test tracks.

He was also passed over for Mika Salo when in his prime.
mursuka80
No one drives another Ferrari tomorrow.Surely Massa is okay in 4 weeks time.
Radoye
QUOTE (sreevishnu @ Jul 25 2009, 10:05) *
with no testing allowed, i guess gene or badoer is the Only choice

...unless they decide to pull a certain multiple WDC out of retirement for a race or two.

Pingguest
QUOTE (potmotr @ Jul 25 2009, 15:04) *
Who would be Ferrari's replacement?

Surely not Gene or Badoer.


A replacement isn't possible any more.
SpeedRacer`
QUOTE (potmotr @ Jul 25 2009, 15:08) *
I'd say Gene, he is younger, has more recent F1 race experience (for Williams in 2004) and won Le Mans last month.

I saw him at Goodwood recently and he appears to be in pretty good shape for a 34 year old.

Badoer has done nothing in a decade, other than pound around Ferrari test tracks.

He was also passed over for Mika Salo when in his prime.

Badoer was racing for Minardi in 1999 though.
TheManAlive
QUOTE (Ellios @ Jul 25 2009, 15:07) *
Agree he won't be racing tomorrow - I hope he's just fine!!

seemed the track first aid took sometime to get to him, I thought he was slumped in his cockpit for quite sometime (1-2 minutes?)



I dont think they realised the issue at first. It did not look like that big an incident at first. The track marshalls were there ready to pull the car out but the revving engine made them hang back. When the medical car arrived they got straight in there. A bizarre accident and people wouldn't have known what had happend until they saw his helmet.
christoff
As none of the above mentioned as possible replacements have qualified for the race i would rate the chances of any of them starting the race as remote to say the least
z2z
QUOTE (raiseyourfistfor @ Jul 25 2009, 20:01) *
Hes lucky that we have a 4 week break until the next race.

He will probably be ready for Valencia.


mad.gif
SpeedRacer`
QUOTE (christoff @ Jul 25 2009, 15:10) *
As none of the above mentioned as possible replacements have qualified for the race i would rate the chances of any of them starting the race as remote to say the least

We're talking about Valencia onwards, if Massa still isn't fit enough smile.gif
valachus
Maybe not from Massa's spot on the grid, but maybe a replacement could be allowed to start from pitlane?
Radoye
QUOTE (christoff @ Jul 25 2009, 10:10) *
As none of the above mentioned as possible replacements have qualified for the race i would rate the chances of any of them starting the race as remote to say the least

Sure, no replacement for tomorrow. But in case Felipe is not ready for the next race...
sreevishnu
QUOTE (christoff @ Jul 25 2009, 20:10) *
As none of the above mentioned as possible replacements have qualified for the race i would rate the chances of any of them starting the race as remote to say the least

we are not talking about tomorrow's race

if its that serious and he got some basilar skull fracture....surely he will be out for atleast a month
Motormedia
I wonder what safety measures Massa's incident will trigger. One meter high cockpit sides and drivers looking through a periscope? Two similar accidents in a week...
Wolbo
As nasty as the photo looks Massa is extremely lucky it didn't hit him e few centimeters lower or it would very likely have been fatal. Scary.
Tifoso05
19) CHANGES OF DRIVER
19.1 a) During a season each team will be permitted to use four drivers. Changes may be made at any time before the start of the qualifying practice session provided any change proposed after 16.00 on the day of scrutineering receives the consent of the stewards.
Additional changes for reasons of force majeure will be considered separately.

christoff
QUOTE (SpeedRacer` @ Jul 25 2009, 13:11) *
We're talking about Valencia onwards, if Massa still isn't fit enough smile.gif

sorry, teach me to jump in to a thread without reading the whole of it first
potmotr
QUOTE (Pingguest @ Jul 25 2009, 15:09) *
A replacement isn't possible any more.


I mean for Valencia.
wrighty
christ!! he's a lucky lad......my best wishes go out to him for a speedy recovery, he's really (metaphorically speaking) dodged a bullet there eek.gif

bit disappointed so many here seem to want to chuck someone into his seat....not much more to say really mad.gif are points really THAT important?
potmotr
QUOTE (SpeedRacer` @ Jul 25 2009, 15:09) *
Badoer was racing for Minardi in 1999 though.


Yes, but he was a Ferrari driver on loan.

And Ferrari didn't cite his Minardi contract as a reason not to take him in 1999.

They said Salo would do a better job.
Atreiu
So, will his grid spot remain empty or everybody jumps a place???
potmotr
QUOTE (Wolbo @ Jul 25 2009, 15:12) *
As nasty as the photo looks Massa is extremely lucky it didn't hit him e few centimeters lower or it would very likely have been fatal. Scary.


I think the visors are extremely strong these days, and are designed to withstand exactly this kind of impact without penetration.
wingwalker
QUOTE (Atreiu @ Jul 25 2009, 15:15) *
So, will his grid spot remain empty or everybody jumps a place???



He is classified at 10th and there is no penalty so empty slot I guess.
Spunout
QUOTE (pRy @ Jul 25 2009, 14:52) *
Photo of his helmet and the cut to his head, don't look if you don't like blood.

http://img.mtv3.fi/mn_kuvat/mtv3/urheilu/f...2009/755343.jpg


Lucky man. Based on how much damage that space age helmet took, direct hit to visor would have been fatal.

If there is no serious concussion etc, he´ll be fine. The injury shown in this pic doesn´t look bad at all.

Hopefully the initial reports are correct and we´ll see Felipe racing soon enough up.gif
Desdirodeabike
That posted picture sure looks like a scull fracture to me. He was 2 inches from death. He is unconscious in the picture too.
HP
That could have been much worse.

What puzzles me is that we don't see a car in front of him, so what gives that whatever it was bounces so dangerous on the track?

QUOTE (sreevishnu @ Jul 25 2009, 22:12) *
we are not talking about tomorrow's race

if its that serious and he got some basilar skull fracture....surely he will be out for atleast a month
There is a 4 week break after Hungary...
alg7_munif
Doesn't look all that bad but it could be worse. That kind injury is normal in boxing but not in Formula 1.
BRK
Poor guy,feel very sorry for him.That does look like a nasty hit.
Atreiu
QUOTE (wingwalker @ Jul 25 2009, 11:16) *
He is classified at 10th and there is no penalty so empty slot I guess.


Okay.
potmotr
From that photo I could believe a skull fracture, but not a basal skull fracture.
hello86
I hope that he gets well soon.

Must be a scary situation for his pregnant wife. ambivalent.gif
Harrelson
Get well soon Massa
VicR
2009 sporting regulations.

Pages 7 (bottom) and 8.

Here
wingwalker
QUOTE (HP @ Jul 25 2009, 15:17) *
That could have been much worse.

What puzzles me is that we don't see a car in front of him, so what gives that whatever it was bounces so dangerous on the track?




A small part can bounce for quite some time after falling off at 250km/h or the likes.
MichaelPM
QUOTE (pRy @ Jul 25 2009, 14:52) *
Photo of his helmet and the cut to his head, don't look if you don't like blood.

http://img.mtv3.fi/mn_kuvat/mtv3/urheilu/f...2009/755343.jpg

Anyone else getting a shiver down their spine looking at that and thinking of what happened 15 years ago to another Brazil driver?
Scudetto
QUOTE (potmotr @ Jul 25 2009, 08:20) *
From that photo I could believe a skull fracture, but not a basal skull fracture.


A basal skull fracture refers not only to fractures at the base of the skull, but may also include the bony structures around the orbital socket. Judging by that photo, damage to the orbital socket is a possibility.

Edit: God speed to Felipe for a quick, complete recovery.
katmen
bigger pic:
http://www.f1csatorna.hu/webimages/2009/07/massa.jpg

hope for recovery, nothing is sure, 24 hours will be critical
Natalia
Can anyone please indicate the article in Sports Regs saying you cannot change driver after qualy? All I found is what other people already posted: 19.1 Additional changes for reasons of force majeure will be considered separately.
Insane111
Was extremely worried when I saw him not moving from the car, and when I saw the straight skidlines from before the corner. Seemed almost identical to the tragic incident last week, albeit showing that he'd at least managed to brake the car somewhat.

The picture is quite shocking, but I'm delighted to hear he's at least conscious and talking. Hope he's back and racing soon.

These incidents seem to have an awful London Bus like frequency rate, lets hope this is the last of them..
OfficeLinebacker
QUOTE (MichaelPM @ Jul 25 2009, 10:23) *
Anyone else getting a shiver down their spine looking at that and thinking of what happened 15 years ago to another Brazil driver?

+1
Jambo
The driver qualifies, not the car. Any driver that wishes to take over will not have qualified for the race. Its quite simple.
SpeedRacer`
Jacques Villeneuve for replacement if he is not ready for Valencia?
potmotr
The cut looks as if it was caused by compression of the helmet about his left eye.

That's what the helmet is designed to do of course.
potmotr
QUOTE (SpeedRacer` @ Jul 25 2009, 15:26) *
Jacques Villeneuve for replacement if he is not ready for Valencia?


God, please no.

How about Anthony Davidson?
Touti
QUOTE (wrighty @ Jul 25 2009, 10:14) *
bit disappointed so many here seem to want to chuck someone into his seat....not much more to say really mad.gif are points really THAT important?


It's got nothing to do with points. By regulations teams must race two cars at every event, if Massa can't drive the next race Ferrari has to put someone else in the car.
Anomnader
QUOTE (HP @ Jul 25 2009, 15:17) *
That could have been much worse.

What puzzles me is that we don't see a car in front of him, so what gives that whatever it was bounces so dangerous on the track?

There is a 4 week break after Hungary...



Yes but you must remember the speeds these cars are travelling when something drops off or kicked up. I can remember several years ago whilst travelling on the motor a stone kicked up by a lorry that seemd about a 1/4 of mile away, I actually watched travel towards, me, just thinking thats going to hit, and then bang, a big chip in my windscreen, it was really quite sureal.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.