QUOTE (Slyder @ Sep 15 2009, 15:35)

Sorry, but Lopez never impressed me much in GP2. And you can say whatever you want about Piquet, Kova, Speed and the rest, but if they were bad in F1, do you really expect Lopez to be any better? Probably just another Gaston Mazzacane.
Argentina should busy themselves in putting money on a young talent that actually is worth something, not some has-been who never made the grade.
Also, if Peter Windsor is claiming that Lopez is now in line for USF1, then its slowly but surely becoming clear (and it pains me to say this) that he's going to need a pay driver after all.
There's no way for López to be another Mazzacane, simply because López is a much better driver: he has been far more succesful than Mazzacane in the junior series (the only thing Mazzacane did was winning an Italian f2000 title, after that, nothing...) and they have been racing together in Argentina and the difference is huge (López fights for wins every weekend, Mazzacane has a good weekend if he becomes a mid-fielder). The same can be said in comparison to Tuero (although Tuero is clearly better than Mazzacane too). Now, as I said before, Tuero wasn't bad at all in F1 considering the car he was driving and his short age and experience, so there's no reason to think López will do worse: logically, he should do better with the same guns...
Now, somke GP2 results, let's see:
2005: Team: DAMS
Round 1: San Marino
Q: 3rd (teammate Fauzy:21st)
r1:2nd (Fauzy: DNF)
r2:11th (Fauzy: 12th)
Round 2: Spain
Q: 3rd (Fauzy: 26th)
r1: 6th (Fauzy: 12th)
r2: 1st (Fauzy: 7th)
Round 3: Monaco
Q: 23rd [out] (Fauzy: 19th)
R: DNF (Fauzy: DNF)
Round 4: Europe
Q: 6th (Fauzy 26th)
R1: 13th (Fauzy 14th)
r2:DNF (Fauzy: 10th)
Round 5: France
q: 7th (Fauzy 19th)
r1: 2nd (Fauzy: 14th)
r2: DNF (Fauzy 10th)
Round 6: Britain
q: 7th (Fauzy 19th)
r1: 9th (Fauzy DNF)
r2: DNF (Fauzy DNF)
Ropund 7: Germany
q: 20th (Fauzy 21st)
r1: dnf (fauzy DNF )
r2: 10th (Fauzy 16th)
Round 8: Hubgary
q: 17th (Fauzy 19th)
r1: DNF (Fauzy DNF)
r2: DNF (Fauzy 13th)
Round 9: Turkey
q: 3rd (Fauzy 15th)
r1: 6th (Fauzy DNF)
r2: 7th (Fauzy 17th)
Round 10: Italy
Q: 5th (Fauzy 23rd)
r1: DNF (Fazuy 13th)
r2: DNF (Fauzy 11th)
Round 11: Belgium
Q: 10th (Fauzy 16th)
r1: 10th (Fauzy 13th)
r2: 7th (Fauzy 14th)
Round 12: Bahrein
q: 12th (Fauzy 20th)
r1: 4th (Fauzy 11th)
r2: 4th (Fauzy 10th)
CHAMPIONSHIP STANDINGS:
Rosberg (ART): 120
Kovalainen (Arden): 105
Speed: (ISport) 67.5
Prèmat (ART) 67
Carroll (Supernova) 53
Pantano (Supernova) 49
Jani (Racing Engeneering) 48
Piquet (Piquet) 46
López (DAMS) 36
Bruni (Coloni) 35
2006: Supernova
Round 1 Valencia:
Q: 6th (teammate Fauzy: 22nd)
r1: 5th (Fauzy: DNF)
r2: DNF (Fauzy 10th)
Round 2: San Marino
Q: 2nd (Fauzy: 23rd)
r1: DNF (Fauzy: DNF)
r2: DNF (Fauzy 15th)
Round 3: Europe
q: 5th (Fauzy: 25th)
r1: 4th (Fauzy: DNF)
r2:3rd (Fauzy: 9yh)
Round 4:Spain
q: 8th (Fauzy: 25th)
r1: DNF (Fauzy: DNF)
r2: DNF (Fauzy: 14th)
Round 5: Monaco
q: 15th ( Fauzy: 21st)
r: DNF (Fauzy: DNF)
Round 6: Britain
q: 18th (Fauzy: 23rd)
r1: DNF (Fauzy: 12th)
r2: 15th (Fauzy: 8th)
Round 7: France
q: 1st (Fauzy: 23rd)
r1: 3rd (DNF)
r2: DNF (15th)
Round 8: Germany
q: 26th (out) (Fauzy: 17th)
r1: 7th (Fauzy: DNF)
r2: 2nd (Fauzy: 10th)
Round 9: Hungary
q: 2nd (Fauzy: 25th)
r1: 8th (Fauzy: DNF)
r2: DNF (Fauzy: DNF)
Round 10: Turkey
q: 2nd (25th)
r1: 9th (DNF)
r2: 11th (DNF)
Round 11: Italy
q: 15th (25th)
r1: DNF (DNF)
r2 DNF (10th)
CHAMP:
Hamilton (ART) 114
Piquet (Piquet) 102
Prémat (ART) 66
Glock (BCN/Isport) 58
Pantano (FMS) 44
Viso (Isport) 42
Bruni (Trident) 33
Carroll (Racing Engineering) 33
Lapierre (Arden) 32
López (Supernova) 30
As I said, López was far from mediocre in qualy (he showed that before in the fr v6 and in Argentina nowadays). His irregular race results could be analysed by many points of view: there are some driving mistakes, of course, but those miostakes you commit when you try to be faster than the car you are driving, there are several machanical failures too, and team mistakes, like in France 2006, when López was building an inmense win from pole and the Supernoiva guys threw it all away with a horrible pitstop. López was lucky to grab a podium at the end. You can also see what his teammate did at the same time (the bteammate is th efirst point of comparison: how can we know what L´ñopez could have done on an ART car? The only time he tested for ART he got tyhe fastest time, half a second faster than the second classified, testing teammate Nelsinho Piquet....

I am concerned specially in the speed, which you can see in qualy performances more than races (there are a lot more factors involved in races that raw speed). Now think someonme like Mazzacane wouldn't have done better than Fauzy at that time (I consider Fauzy a better driverv than Mazzacane, but let's think they are equaly good)... Now, since he has been racing in Argentina, López has showed more and more consistent and intelligent behind the wheel: he's not the rush-of.blood-to-the-head driver he was two or three years ago. An he has kept his great raw speed. He would be much better than Mazzacane: now if he will be just an OK driver like someone like Buemi or being something else, that's a thing we still have to see, if he gets a seat next year, of course...