Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Will USF1 make it to the 2010 grid? (merged)
The AUTOSPORT Bulletin Board > Forums > Racing Comments
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77, 78, 79, 80, 81, 82, 83, 84, 85, 86, 87, 88, 89, 90, 91, 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97, 98, 99, 100, 101, 102, 103, 104, 105, 106, 107, 108, 109, 110, 111, 112, 113, 114, 115, 116, 117, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 125, 126, 127, 128, 129, 130, 131, 132, 133, 134, 135, 136, 137, 138
DFV
QUOTE (luskiiimj @ Dec 25 2009, 18:01) *
I love the "PR exercise gone too far" comment. If PW is such a master of PR BS, then why was he not one step ahead of the awful press USF1 has been getting?


Me too, if it was a PR excercise then it could be used as a schoolbook example of how to fail miserably at PR excercises. It would probably be classed as anything but a marketing excercise in a publicists book. And why put up a factory and show the build of an actual car if it's just to be a PR excercise?

My question to this is also if they will still say it's a PR excercise if the USF1 cars show up in Bahrain...???
Captain Tightpants
QUOTE (VoidNT @ Dec 26 2009, 02:33) *
The site looks like a blog made by some Charlotte student. I bet it was made by Windsor and every word and every photo there is by Windsor. And he is a master at bullsh*tting.

Pay attention, kids: this is what we call a total denial of reality. It might not look like the most professional website in the world - but the website, combined with the videos on the team's YouTube channel offer proof that they are well on their way to making the grid.

QUOTE (VoidNT @ Dec 26 2009, 02:33) *
USF1 is not a hoax though, it was a PR exercise went too far.

Do you even know what public relations is? The whole point of PR is that you're promoting or selling something. And it is clear from the very beginning what it is that you are promoting or selling. So let me ask you this: what the hell is USF1 promoting or selling?

QUOTE (luskiiimj @ Dec 26 2009, 04:01) *
I'm relieved to see the website running. Can anybody tell me why windsor is so hated by so many? I'm not saying he should or shouldn't be, I just don't understand where it comes from.

It'e because people believe him to be an inferior journalist. Hatred of Formula 1 journalists - Windsor, Allen, Legard - is right up there wil the hatred of Mosley, or Ecclestone, of new circuits and of pretty much anything else you could care to name.
undersquare
QUOTE (Captain Tightpants @ Dec 25 2009, 22:11) *
Pay attention, kids: this is what we call a total denial of reality. It might not look like the most professional website in the world - but the website, combined with the videos on the team's YouTube channel offer proof that they are well on their way to making the grid.


Where are the sponsors though?
santori
QUOTE (luskiiimj @ Dec 25 2009, 19:01) *
I'm relieved to see the website running. Can anybody tell me why windsor is so hated by so many? I'm not saying he should or shouldn't be, I just don't understand where it comes from.


He's condescending, smug, self-important, pompous, verbose, vicious, self-righteous, crap and dishonest.
One
Donno what to say except that I am looking forward to it competing against,... where? smile.gif

Great effort, it looks like they will be there.
slideways
My favourite is the way he switches branded microphones mid interview so he can get material for all of the stations he sells to. One time when he did it Schumi just walked off mid sentence. tongue.gif
William Hunt
A friend of my brother just signed a contract to work as an engineer for USF1. He is now packing & moving to Charlotte immediately to go and work there. I assure you USF1 is real and they will be there next year.
Captain Tightpants
QUOTE (undersquare @ Dec 26 2009, 09:18) *
Where are the sponsors though?

Why are you not asking the same of Campos or Lotus? We don't know who their sponsors are.
undersquare
QUOTE (Captain Tightpants @ Dec 26 2009, 12:00) *
Why are you not asking the same of Campos or Lotus? We don't know who their sponsors are.


Lotus have Proton and the Malaysian government. Campos seem to be up the same creek as USF1, I'm just not so interested in them.

Fact is, the website would show the sponsors, if there were any. Since there aren't, it looks bad for them. Doesn't mean that pleases me, at all.
potmotr
QUOTE (Captain Tightpants @ Dec 26 2009, 12:00) *
Why are you not asking the same of Campos or Lotus? We don't know who their sponsors are.


That criticism is true for Campos, but it's quite clear Lotus has lots of Air Asia cash behind it, plus money from the Malaysian state.
Seanspeed
QUOTE (Captain Tightpants @ Dec 26 2009, 07:00) *
Why are you not asking the same of Campos or Lotus? We don't know who their sponsors are.

Because some people just *want* USF1 to fail.
bonneville
After seeing their latest video on USF1team youtube channel, I have no more doubts USF1 will be on track in Bahrain !



I hope they manage to sign a high profile name to generate some publicity in the US...
bonneville
Oops. We just showed a mockup of the car on our youtube channel...




Found at 1 min 07 sec in this video
JeffrieNL
Well, the website of USf1 is just online now.

http://www.usgpe.com/index.html
Lazarus II
QUOTE (luskiiimj @ Dec 25 2009, 13:01) *
I'm relieved to see the website running. Can anybody tell me why windsor is so hated by so many? I'm not saying he should or shouldn't be, I just don't understand where it comes from.

Anyway, glad to see them working. I suppose with all the negative comments/energy, I was worried that they were not working/out of money or whatever. Nice to see that they were working on the car, not on the website.

I love the "PR exercise gone too far" comment. If PW is such a master of PR BS, then why was he not one step ahead of the awful press USF1 has been getting?

Bad press where? oh that's right from everyone who wants US F1 to fail - who cares what the 'press' says. They obviously have very limited access - seeing as they are mostly all 3k miles away and mostly want them to fail.
rmac923
http://www.usgpe.com/schedule.html

Perhaps someone should inform them Brazil and Abu Dhabi has switched dates. tongue.gif
MegaManson
Very uninspiring website

Not a mention of a single sponsor, Virgin rolled out loads

A load of PR fluff and spin from Peter Windsor

A brief history of America in F1 that is not a patch on DDavid or Forix or 8W

No F1 database from that journo guy

A design that looks like it was created by a college student

USF1.com is just MyNameIsPeterWindsorArentIWonderful.com as most of it seems to be a Windsor bumfest

potmotr
QUOTE (Seanspeed @ Dec 26 2009, 13:29) *
Because some people just *want* USF1 to fail.


I don't want them to fail, but I've yet to be convinced they will make it.

Lotus have convinced me, Virgin have convinced me.

Campos has convinced me a little, because they actually have a driver.

USF1 is leaving everything pretty damned late.

And for a team affiliated with a web zillionaire, USF1's website is, frankly, embarrassing.
undersquare
QUOTE (Seanspeed @ Dec 26 2009, 13:29) *
Because some people just *want* USF1 to fail.


Some people do want an F1 team in the US but can see that there are NO SPONSORS.

A superficial website doesn't make any difference at all, except to highlight that awkward truth. 11 weeks to the first race, who's going to start sponsoring now?
rmac923
QUOTE (undersquare @ Dec 26 2009, 12:57) *
Some people do want an F1 team in the US but can see that there are NO SPONSORS.

A superficial website doesn't make any difference at all, except to highlight that awkward truth. 11 weeks to the first race, who's going to start sponsoring now?


If you everyone actually read what Windsor has said, you'll know that drivers and sponsors won't be announced until January. So they likely have sponsorship, but are waiting for everything to come together for an announcement.

Motormedia
I think USF1 could have done a lot more to prove the rumours wrong. Everything about the video looks like it was staged, Windsors denial did nothing to prove that things are on track. It is quite possible that things are on track but they sure make a damned bad job of communicating that.
potmotr
QUOTE (rmac923 @ Dec 26 2009, 18:31) *
If you everyone actually read what Windsor has said, you'll know that drivers and sponsors won't be announced until January. So they likely have sponsorship, but are waiting for everything to come together for an announcement.


Why are Windsor and his pals waiting?

This was supposed to be the birth of a team we'd see through a multi-media extravaganza.

Seems to me that every tiny bit of good news that Windsor has had (getting a factory, hiring a staff member, getting an engine) is shouted from the rooftops.

So keeping mum on sponsors, drivers etc just doesn't fit his modus operandi.

I think they're in deep shit.
Amrl
Why are everyone misunderestimating USF1? They have the Youtube-guy. No reason why they can't do what Brawn GP did this year. They even have a proven champion in Villeneuve.
potmotr
QUOTE (Amrl @ Dec 26 2009, 18:48) *
Why are everyone misunderestimating USF1? They have the Youtube-guy.


Then where is the money? Doesn't appear that they have two pennies to rub together in F1 terms.

QUOTE (Amrl @ Dec 26 2009, 18:48) *
No reason why they can't do what Brawn GP did this year.


No reason apart from the fact they haven't got years of Honda investment in top notch facilities, Ross Brawn spending 18 months working on their new car, two very good drivers and a full budget for the coming season provided by the Japanese car giant trying to get rid of the team...

QUOTE (Amrl @ Dec 26 2009, 18:48) *
They even have a proven champion in Villeneuve.


No they don't.
MegaManson
QUOTE (Amrl @ Dec 26 2009, 18:48) *
Why are everyone misunderestimating USF1? They have the Youtube-guy. No reason why they can't do what Brawn GP did this year. They even have a proven champion in Villeneuve.


1) Hurley is putting $20m into USF1 and offering consultancy - $20m is nothing in the grand scheme of things

2) Ross Brawn worked on the 2009 car from early part of the 2008 season and had a big internal infrastructure

3) Much as I like JV him joining USF1 will never happen, Windsor is using him for PR, the same Windsor that called JV a marshal murderer in F1Racing, JV is also nearly 40 so much as I like the guy there are serious doubts as to whether he still has it
potmotr
QUOTE (MegaManson @ Dec 26 2009, 18:53) *
the same Windsor that called JV a marshal murderer in F1Racing


Did he?

What edition?

I subscribed to that magazine for years and never read that.
Amrl
why do you hate america durrr
MegaManson
QUOTE (potmotr @ Dec 26 2009, 18:55) *
Did he?

What edition?

I subscribed to that magazine for years and never read that.


In his column near the back of F1Racing some years ago, I can't remember the edition sadly, he called JV a murderer for what happened to the marshal and the move JV made that caused the accident

I gave away my copies of F1Racing when I moved
potmotr
QUOTE (Amrl @ Dec 26 2009, 18:58) *
why do you hate america durrr


I don't hate America.

I've spent plenty of time there and think Americans are mostly very decent people, and the country has a great motorsports history.

For that reason if someone is going to form an F1 team in their name, they deserve much more than the current half-arsed effort we're seeing from Windsor, who isn't actually American.
undersquare
QUOTE (rmac923 @ Dec 26 2009, 18:31) *
If you everyone actually read what Windsor has said, you'll know that drivers and sponsors won't be announced until January. So they likely have sponsorship, but are waiting for everything to come together for an announcement.


Just find that totally unconvincing. Why wait? Why now launch a video from July? Why delay the website and then launch it now? With no sponsor presence in either?
potmotr
QUOTE (MegaManson @ Dec 26 2009, 18:59) *
In his column near the back of F1Racing some years ago, I can't remember the edition sadly, he called JV a murderer for what happened to the marshal and the move JV made that caused the accident


That's a total scandal.

Villeneuve had a racing accident with Ralf Schumacher.

Can't possibly suggest it was a pre-meditated act.
MegaManson
QUOTE (Amrl @ Dec 26 2009, 18:58) *
why do you hate america durrr


Its nothing to do with hating America, I like America and many American people but do not trust Windsor, this going pear shaped will damage the reputation of America in motorsport for a generation
ezequiel
http://www.usgpe.com/partners.html
potmotr
QUOTE (ezequiel @ Dec 26 2009, 19:26) *


All of those are suppliers.

Perhaps USF1 gets a minor discount for naming them on their site and on their car (whenever it turns a wheel), but companies like McLaren Automotive are hardly helping prop up the team.

It's a cliche, but Peter Windsor, show us the money.
ezequiel
http://www.campeonesnet.com.ar/?m=15&sec=48&id=18704

Mmm... crash tests next week...
potmotr
QUOTE (ezequiel @ Dec 26 2009, 19:43) *


Don't get me wrong, I'd like to see this team on the grid.

But it isn't stacking up so far.

And they're running out of time.

fer312t
Just looking at the USF1 video...

Question, Isn't the rollhoop an integral part of the chassis tub?
Seanspeed
QUOTE (potmotr @ Dec 26 2009, 11:29) *
And for a team affiliated with a web zillionaire, USF1's website is, frankly, embarrassing.

I dont think Youtube is really some 'genius' work of technology or anything. It was just a good idea that caught on. It was hardly the only 'video sharing' site out there, ya know? But we do know the guy has money, thats the main thing.

Its criticism like this that makes me think some of you are just really *searching* to find things to fault. You say you dont want them to fail, but it truly is how many of you come across, and continue to come across, despite your denials.
potmotr
QUOTE (Seanspeed @ Dec 26 2009, 20:01) *
Its criticism like this that makes me think some of you are just really *searching* to find things to fault. You say you dont want them to fail, but it truly is how many of you come across, and continue to come across, despite your denials.


So on the flipside of that, for the optimists, what are the glimmers of hope you see that will ensure this team is on the grid in 11 weeks?
spacepig
QUOTE (fer312t @ Dec 26 2009, 12:58) *
Question, Isn't the rollhoop an integral part of the chassis tub?


No, it's typically a separate piece that's bonded on. It's a much thicker layup than the rest of the chassis, so it would be a hassle to lay it up at the same time.
Seanspeed
QUOTE (potmotr @ Dec 26 2009, 15:06) *
So on the flipside of that, for the optimists, what are the glimmers of hope you see that will ensure this team is on the grid in 11 weeks?

Well there's two categories of evidence here:

- Things we know about USF1.

- Things we dont know about USF1.

You seem to be using the 2nd category as 'evidence' that they're not going to make it.

And I can easily just use the 1st category for 'evidence' for why I do think they'll make it(even if I dont expect them to be all that competitive first year out).
potmotr
QUOTE (Seanspeed @ Dec 26 2009, 20:15) *
Well there's two categories of evidence here:

- Things we know about USF1.

- Things we dont know about USF1.

You seem to be using the 2nd category as 'evidence' that they're not going to make it.

And I can easily just use the 1st category for 'evidence' for why I do think they'll make it(even if I dont expect them to be all that competitive first year out).


What's the purpose of the team waiting so long to announce some fairly fundamental pieces of the jigsaw then?
BMW_F1
QUOTE (rmac923 @ Dec 26 2009, 21:05) *
http://www.usgpe.com/schedule.html

Perhaps someone should inform them Brazil and Abu Dhabi has switched dates. tongue.gif

perhaps someone should update Williams that Rosberg is now Mercedes property and Naka is history..
http://www.williamsf1.com/team/profiles/
they also need to update their sponsors.

http://www.williamsf1.com/team/partners

Seanspeed
QUOTE (potmotr @ Dec 26 2009, 15:16) *
What's the purpose of the team waiting so long to announce some fairly fundamental pieces of the jigsaw then?

How should I know? ohwell.gif
potmotr
QUOTE (BMW_F1 @ Dec 26 2009, 20:20) *
perhaps someone should update Williams that Rosberg is now Mercedes property and Naka is history..
http://www.williamsf1.com/team/profiles/
they also need to update their sponsors.

http://www.williamsf1.com/team/partners


All those contracts expire on January 1 don't they?
potmotr
QUOTE (Seanspeed @ Dec 26 2009, 20:22) *
How should I know? ohwell.gif


Case closed then. ambivalent.gif
Seanspeed
QUOTE (potmotr @ Dec 26 2009, 15:23) *
Case closed then. ambivalent.gif

confused.gif

No, I'm just not going to pretend to know whats going on behind the scenes and/or their reasoning for not announcing major sponsors and their drivers yet. It wouldn't be the first time a team announces these sorts of things later on. Just cuz I dont know doesn't mean there isn't a reason.
potmotr
QUOTE (Seanspeed @ Dec 26 2009, 20:27) *
confused.gif

No, I'm just not going to pretend to know whats going on behind the scenes and/or their reasoning for not announcing major sponsors and their drivers yet. It wouldn't be the first time a team announces these sorts of things later on.


I guess we'll know in a month or so.

I've always thought new teams try and get things squared away and announced early, so new sponsors join the snowball.
fer312t
Not a major deal, but spending $500 to outfit the workers with some USF1 polo shirts would have gone a long way as far as creating the allusion of an actual professional race team.... ohwell.gif
Menace
QUOTE (potmotr @ Dec 26 2009, 11:52) *
Don't get me wrong, I'd like to see this team on the grid.

But it isn't stacking up so far.

And they're running out of time.


Bullshit.

Based on everything we can see right now, they should be on the grid when the season starts.

USF1 is for real now. The speculation about them making the grid seems a little silly now... as much as I do hate that whinger.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.