Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Raikkonen: Alonso paid to drive for Ferrari
The AUTOSPORT Bulletin Board > Forums > Racing Comments
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12
Magnus
QUOTE (anthony says @ Oct 16 2009, 10:42) *
I don’t think it’s accurate to say that Raikkonen was sacked. Ferrari clearly prefer Alonso, but not so much that they would pay €mega for the difference. However they needed to secure Santander as sponsors, and Santander would pay to make the KR departure possible, so why not? As ability was just one of many factors and nationality was easily the most important, ‘sacked’ is not the right way of putting it.


Ferrari got a sponsor to pay off (allegedly) a driver 1 year before his contract ended because they no longer wanted him. When your longer wanted and removed you are sacked. I know its not a nice word but its exactly what happened. Who paid what and how much is totally irrelevant. Kimi was not wanted and removed from the team. Sacked!
Sunflower
QUOTE (VresiBerba @ Oct 14 2009, 08:20) *
Poor reason in any case.



Really... what would the changes be of him winning a world championship with Ferrari next year if he stayed. Would Ferrari really give him the car that he needs or would they give it to Massa. Would they really let Kimi win the Championship and take the Number 1 to their biggest competitor?

I am glad he left i serouisly doubt they would have given him the opportunity to win the Title and leave.

Just my two cents
Magnus
QUOTE (anthony says @ Oct 16 2009, 12:15) *
He was not sacked. Sacked means dismissed, contract terminated whether the person sacked agrees to it or not. Ferrari didn't do that, nor anything like it, nor would they have got away with it if they had dared to try. He would have fleeced them in the courts.

He was dismissed and his contract was bought out which is basically terminated with a fee.
QUOTE (anthony says @ Oct 16 2009, 12:15) *
But my point was not the legal one, but that as far as we can tell the key factor was Spanishness, not driver ability. He therefore has no need to feel offended, which makes his remarks surprising - unless there is an explanation such as the one I suggested.


As far as we can tell , being spanish had nothing to do with it at all, thats just something made up by disgrunted Kimi fans so they can sleep better at night. Ferrari are in F1 to win, so they hire drivers on ability not nationality, which is why they were so eager to get Alonso in their team. They tried to it for 2009 but couldnt now they did it.
Taxi
QUOTE (Magnus @ Oct 16 2009, 14:42) *
Ferrari got a sponsor to pay off (allegedly) a driver 1 year before his contract ended because they no longer wanted him. When your longer wanted and removed you are sacked. I know its not a nice word but its exactly what happened. Who paid what and how much is totally irrelevant. Kimi was not wanted and removed from the team. Sacked!



agree. But I wonder... hadn't Felipe Massa got that accident, would they buy is contract instead?
Magnus
QUOTE (Menace @ Oct 16 2009, 01:19) *
Alonso is no better developer then many other top drivers. The sooner Arrow (aka the Truth, Razor or whatever his new nick happens to be that isn't banned) stop perpetuating this myth, the sooner people will stop ridiculing it. He might be great motivator and gives solid feedback, but he does not design the car. So if it is a lemon, it is a lemon, just like Domenicalli said.

smile.gif


You had better tell Renault, Mclaren and now Ferrari to stop perpetuating the myth because they have all said Alonso' development skills are exceptional. Its strange to read everyone in the paddock saying one thing then going into a forum and see someone totally denying it. Very strange way to behave.
Clatter
QUOTE (anthony says @ Oct 16 2009, 13:15) *
He was not sacked. Sacked means dismissed, contract terminated whether the person sacked agrees to it or not.


Seems to me that you have described quite nicely what has happened to KR, if not he would be driving for Ferrari next year.
BMW_F1
QUOTE (Taxi @ Oct 16 2009, 18:50) *
agree. But I wonder... hadn't Felipe Massa got that accident, would they buy is contract instead?

why would they.? he was performing better than Kimi and making a lot less money.. Over this fact what would be the reason to keep Raikkonen over Massa?
Taxi
QUOTE (BMW_F1 @ Oct 16 2009, 14:58) *
why would they.? he was performing better than Kimi and making a lot less money.. Over this fact what would be the reason to keep Raikkonen over Massa?


the dream team Raikkonen /Alonso.
BMW_F1
QUOTE (Taxi @ Oct 16 2009, 19:00) *
the dream team Raikkonen /Alonso.

to please the fans you mean.. rolleyes.gif
giacomo
QUOTE (Menace @ Oct 16 2009, 03:19) *
Alonso is no better developer then many other top drivers. The sooner Arrow (aka the Truth, Razor or whatever his new nick happens to be that isn't banned) stop perpetuating this myth, the sooner people will stop ridiculing it. He might be great motivator and gives solid feedback, but he does not design the car. So if it is a lemon, it is a lemon, just like Domenicalli said.

Problem:
Many F1 insiders, people from Renault, McLaren and Ferrari said that Alonsos skills concerning development are above the norm.
So suggesting that only one certain forumer is saying that is just dishonesty; as dishonest as calling this fact a myth.

Callisto
QUOTE (halifaxf1fan @ Oct 16 2009, 00:48) *
it is simple. knowing he was going to ferrari Alonso is saving the 7 tenths from this year and will add it to next years 7 tenths for a net of 1.4 seconds he will bring to Ferrari next season. pure genius.

up.gif roflmao.gif
RodrigoL
QUOTE (giacomo @ Oct 16 2009, 15:25) *
Problem:
Many F1 insiders, people from Renault, McLaren and Ferrari said that Alonsos skills concerning development are above the norm.
So suggesting that only one certain forumer is saying that is just dishonesty; as dishonest as calling this fact a myth.


Insiders like Bob Bell? wink.gif drunk.gif
giacomo
QUOTE (RodrigoL @ Oct 16 2009, 16:47) *
Insiders like Bob Bell? wink.gif drunk.gif

No idea what you are trying to tell us.
britishtrident
QUOTE (TT6 @ Oct 15 2009, 08:53) *
I think this is not a first time when Ferrari decides to change driver after they've produced a lemon. Nicely brings forward the idea of when Ferrari wins it's the car, when Ferrari doesn't win it's the drivers.


There was a time when Ferrari thought handling and aero didn't matter only engines mattered and as Ferrari always had the best engines so if they were not winning it was the drivers fault so old Enzo would give the driver a very public verbal Italian tune up ;-)

Irony was when they were not wining Ferrari often had some of the best drivers on the grid, Surtees, Amon, Mario Mario Andretti, Jody Scheckter Giles Villenuve ............
Henrik B
QUOTE (BMW_F1 @ Oct 16 2009, 15:37) *
seriously kimi fans should stop accusing others of claiming alonso is a car developer. Where did this bs started?. Most sound fans know this is not the case. You are just twisting people's words in order to bash.

there is a huge difference between a developer and someone who pushes the team forward and is a great team player who provides very detail technical feedback.


QUOTE (giacomo @ Oct 16 2009, 16:25) *
Problem:
Many F1 insiders, people from Renault, McLaren and Ferrari said that Alonsos skills concerning development are above the norm.
So suggesting that only one certain forumer is saying that is just dishonesty; as dishonest as calling this fact a myth.


So giacomo isn't a "sound fan"? Check. Have to update my list.

Many things has been said over the years about Alonsos ability to lead, develop a car in the right direction and lifting a team. Some of them has even been said Alonso himself. I have no way of KNOWING if it's true, but this year seem to suggest those qualities has been a bit exaggerated over the years.
Clatter
QUOTE (Henrik Brodin @ Oct 16 2009, 16:11) *
So giacomo isn't a "sound fan"? Check. Have to update my list.

Many things has been said over the years about Alonsos ability to lead, develop a car in the right direction and lifting a team. Some of them has even been said Alonso himself. I have no way of KNOWING if it's true, but this year seem to suggest those qualities has been a bit exaggerated over the years.


That's true. It was he that claimed to have brought the 6/10s to Mac.
RodrigoL
QUOTE (giacomo @ Oct 16 2009, 16:00) *
No idea what you are trying to tell us.


"They know that the day that Fernando has a good race car, he will respond because he always know how to get out the maximun performance of the car. Look what he did in Singapore [2008] !" - Bob bell.

You once tried to use this quote as some sort of 'proof' that Alonso is a superior car developer. So, if you still don't get it, please take caution when referring to these so called 'insiders', as it seems Alonso's cousin from Shell has more credibility drunk.gif
giacomo
QUOTE (RodrigoL @ Oct 16 2009, 17:16) *
"They know that the day that Fernando has a good race car, he will respond because he always know how to get out the maximun performance of the car. Look what he did in Singapore!" - Bob bell.

You once tried to use this quote as some sort of 'proof' that Alonso is a superior car developer. So, if you still don't get it, please take caution when referring to these so called 'insiders', as it seems Alonso's cousin from Shell has more credibility drunk.gif

I once tried to use this quote as some sort of 'proof' that Alonso is a superior car developer?!?

The 'drunk' smilie fits your postings pretty well.
giacomo
QUOTE (Henrik Brodin @ Oct 16 2009, 17:11) *
So giacomo isn't a "sound fan"? Check. Have to update my list.

I don't give a damn if you consider me being a 'sound fan' or not.

QUOTE (Henrik Brodin @ Oct 16 2009, 17:11) *
Many things has been said over the years about Alonsos ability to lead, develop a car in the right direction and lifting a team. Some of them has even been said Alonso himself. I have no way of KNOWING if it's true, but this year seem to suggest those qualities has been a bit exaggerated over the years.

So you have new, negative insider statements about Alonsos ability to lead, develop a car in the right direction and lifting a team?
Please share.
RodrigoL
QUOTE (giacomo @ Oct 16 2009, 16:20) *
I once tried to use this quote as some sort of 'proof' that Alonso is a superior car developer?!?


http://forums.autosport.com/index.php?show...p;#entry3727326

wave.gif
BMW_F1
QUOTE (Henrik Brodin @ Oct 16 2009, 21:11) *
So giacomo isn't a "sound fan"? Check. Have to update my list.

Many things has been said over the years about Alonsos ability to lead, develop a car in the right direction and lifting a team. Some of them has even been said Alonso himself. I have no way of KNOWING if it's true, but this year seem to suggest those qualities has been a bit exaggerated over the years.

the moment I read his post, I knew it was going to lead to misinterpretation. I understand giacomo's point very well, others want to suggest that what he said is that Alonso develops the car.. when that is not what he said.. - he leads developers with very good technical feedback - it then becomes the task of those working behind the car to make the car fast.
giacomo
QUOTE (RodrigoL @ Oct 16 2009, 17:27) *

"Fernando has helped us a lot. It doesn’t mean that a driver, whatever, has a direct influence on the technical development of the car, or he tells us how it should be the shape of the spoiler. Fernando is much more than the exceptional driver everybody knows. He is a very, very good test driver. He is intelligent, wise, precise, consistent in each lap. He can tell exactly what's wrong with your car in every moment, to point the finger at the problem so that arises. Working with him is equvalent to a form of security: do not have to ask yourself if you are right or not. The answer is yes, "says Bob Bell.
"In addition, continued on the impact of Alonso in the Renault-progress, it is the overboost which has given the team. ( It is also important..) when you ask people to make an extra effort when they are giving the maximun. They know that the day that Fernando has a good race car, he will respond because he always know how to get out the maximun performance of the car. Look what he did in Singapore!"


This is the full Bob Bell quote from that thread. What you made out of it say everything about you. Go for more vodka drunk.gif
HoldenRT
Every day with F1 these days there is a new soap opera quote. lol.gif

I think if I followed every quote like I used to my head would be exploding right about now.
BMW_F1
also remember when he joined Mclaren, Ron said that Alonso's technical skills immediately brought him back to his memories of Senna. That since then he's never had a driver seat on his cars with such a talent on this aspect.
RodrigoL
QUOTE (giacomo @ Oct 16 2009, 16:37) *
"Fernando has helped us a lot. It doesn’t mean that a driver, whatever, has a direct influence on the technical development of the car, or he tells us how it should be the shape of the spoiler. Fernando is much more than the exceptional driver everybody knows. He is a very, very good test driver. He is intelligent, wise, precise, consistent in each lap. He can tell exactly what's wrong with your car in every moment, to point the finger at the problem so that arises. Working with him is equvalent to a form of security: do not have to ask yourself if you are right or not. The answer is yes, "says Bob Bell.
"In addition, continued on the impact of Alonso in the Renault-progress, it is the overboost which has given the team. ( It is also important..) when you ask people to make an extra effort when they are giving the maximun. They know that the day that Fernando has a good race car, he will respond because he always know how to get out the maximun performance of the car. Look what he did in Singapore!"


This is the full Bob Bell quote from that thread. What you made out of it say everything about you. Go for more vodka drunk.gif


I picked out the most significant part of it. If Mr. Bell actually believes Singapore 08 was a true reflection of Alonso's qualities as a driver...so be it. Wonder how many people would actually take him seriously after that though. Although you certainly did, and that seems to be the word of God around here... wink.gif
giacomo
QUOTE (BMW_F1 @ Oct 16 2009, 17:32) *
the moment I read his post, I knew it was going to lead to misinterpretation. I understand giacomo's point very well, others want to suggest that what he said is that Alonso develops the car.. when that is not what he said.. - he leads developers with very good technical feedback - it then becomes the task of those working behind the car to make the car fast.

Misinterpreting quotes - no matter if quotes of F1 insiders or of fellow forumers - is the bread and butter of those fanboy trolls. Compare how RodrigoL treated the Bob Bell quote.
giacomo
QUOTE (BMW_F1 @ Oct 16 2009, 17:46) *
also remember when he joined Mclaren, Ron said that Alonso's technical skills immediately brought him back to his memories of Senna. That since then he's never had a driver seat on his cars with such a talent on this aspect.

Here is the quote. The Kimi fans will love it.

“It’s very obvious that all the guys who drive cars are competent drivers, but until you work with them as individuals, you don’t know how much knowledge they have of the car, what makes a car go fast, and how to communicate to the engineers and designers in such a way that you’re moving the development of the car in the right direction."
“He’s clearly in a class of his own. It took me immediately back to the experiences I had working with Ayrton Senna and Niki Lauda and Alain Prost. He really knows what he wants, and he’s able to explain it to the engineers in such a way that we can give him what he needs.”

Menace
QUOTE (Henrik Brodin @ Oct 16 2009, 08:11) *
So giacomo isn't a "sound fan"? Check. Have to update my list.

Many things has been said over the years about Alonsos ability to lead, develop a car in the right direction and lifting a team. Some of them has even been said Alonso himself. I have no way of KNOWING if it's true, but this year seem to suggest those qualities has been a bit exaggerated over the years.



Indeed. There you go Rob. No sooner you say no reasonable fan has claimed it, we have a couple of posts saying ecactly what I said they would. So please feel free to call their BS so I don't have to. wink.gif
giacomo
QUOTE (RodrigoL @ Oct 16 2009, 17:46) *
I picked out the most significant part of it. If Mr. Bell actually believes Singapore 08 was a true reflection of Alonso's qualities as a driver...so be it. Wonder how many people would actually take him seriously after that though. Although you certainly did, and that seems to be the word of God around here...wink.gif

Nobody here was talking about Alonsos qualities as a driver... Must be the vodka drunk.gif
giacomo
QUOTE (Menace @ Oct 16 2009, 17:56) *
Indeed. There you go Rob. No sooner you say no reasonable fan has claimed it, we have a couple of posts saying ecactly what I said they would. So please feel free to call their BS so I don't have to. wink.gif

Mr High Horse again.

What about the Ron Dennis statement concerning Alonsos skills? Myth in your book?
Menace
In my post Giacomo, I clearly did NOT question his feedback abilities and perhaps motivational abilities. I di however question that whether he is "head and shoulders" above most other top pilots. Once again, alonso has probably great feedback abilities. Agreed.
Menace
QUOTE (giacomo @ Oct 16 2009, 08:58) *
Mr High Horse again.

What about the Ron Dennis statement concerning Alonsos skills? Myth in your book?


Can we use every quote Mr Dennis has said about Kimi as proof about his superiority to both Alonso and MS? Or do we just pick and choose the once we see fit our beliefs? Because I got to tell you, Ron would be a stupid man not to be high on his new multi-million dollar driver. wink.gif
Magnus
QUOTE (Menace @ Oct 16 2009, 15:59) *
In my post Giacomo, I clearly did NOT question his feedback abilities and perhaps motivational abilities. I di however question that whether he is "head and shoulders" above most other top pilots. Once again, alonso has probably great feedback abilities. Agreed.


One of the most experienced members of the paddock who has worked with a number of past greats, strongly disagree's with you. I think its fair to assume hes in a better position to judge Alonso's feedback than a bunch of internet kiddies. You dont have to admitt you are wrong but it doesnt mean the rest of the world doesnt already know you are.
giacomo
QUOTE (Menace @ Oct 16 2009, 18:01) *
Can we use every quote Mr Dennis has said about Kimi as proof about his superiority to both Alonso and MS? Or do we just pick and choose the once we see fit our beliefs? Because I got to tell you, Ron would be a stupid man not to be high on his new multi-million dollar driver. wink.gif

Bring on your quotes.
BMW_F1
QUOTE (giacomo @ Oct 16 2009, 21:49) *
Here is the quote. The Kimi fans will love it.

“It’s very obvious that all the guys who drive cars are competent drivers, but until you work with them as individuals, you don’t know how much knowledge they have of the car, what makes a car go fast, and how to communicate to the engineers and designers in such a way that you’re moving the development of the car in the right direction."
“He’s clearly in a class of his own. It took me immediately back to the experiences I had working with Ayrton Senna and Niki Lauda and Alain Prost. He really knows what he wants, and he’s able to explain it to the engineers in such a way that we can give him what he needs.”


yep, that's the one..
there is also this..
"We'd love to have him," concurred team principal Brawn, "because he is the best.
Of all the drivers right now, he is the only one that I see as totally complete, as Michael [Schumacher] was."
- Brawn.
giacomo
QUOTE (Menace @ Oct 16 2009, 17:59) *
In my post Giacomo, I clearly did NOT question his feedback abilities and perhaps motivational abilities. I di however question that whether he is "head and shoulders" above most other top pilots. Once again, alonso has probably great feedback abilities. Agreed.

"He’s clearly in a class of his own." Ron Dennis.
Panch
I´m sorry for the off topic but that Belgium site seems to be the only place where that Kimi quote is.


Now please continue.
BMW_F1
QUOTE (Menace @ Oct 16 2009, 21:59) *
I di however question that whether he is "head and shoulders" above most other top pilots. Once again, alonso has probably great feedback abilities. Agreed.


you can question that all you want but that becomes a simple opinion which weights a lot less than what is common knowledge in the paddock..
RodrigoL
QUOTE (BMW_F1 @ Oct 16 2009, 17:06) *
yep, that's the one..
there is also this..
"We'd love to have him," concurred team principal Brawn, "because he is the best.
Of all the drivers right now, he is the only one that I see as totally complete, as Michael [Schumacher] was."
- Brawn.


Indeed. No other driver comes with a $100m sponsor package and guaranteed WMSC hearings..

If only my favourite driver could be like that ambivalent.gif ambivalent.gif
giacomo
QUOTE (RodrigoL @ Oct 16 2009, 18:14) *
Indeed. No other driver comes with a $100m sponsor package and guaranteed WMSC hearings..

If only my favourite driver could be like that ambivalent.gif ambivalent.gif

meat
QUOTE (giacomo @ Oct 16 2009, 16:37) *
"Fernando has helped us a lot. It doesn’t mean that a driver, whatever, has a direct influence on the technical development of the car, or he tells us how it should be the shape of the spoiler. Fernando is much more than the exceptional driver everybody knows. He is a very, very good test driver. He is intelligent, wise, precise, consistent in each lap. He can tell exactly what's wrong with your car in every moment, to point the finger at the problem so that arises. Working with him is equvalent to a form of security: do not have to ask yourself if you are right or not. The answer is yes, "says Bob Bell.
"In addition, continued on the impact of Alonso in the Renault-progress, it is the overboost which has given the team. ( It is also important..) when you ask people to make an extra effort when they are giving the maximun. They know that the day that Fernando has a good race car, he will respond because he always know how to get out the maximun performance of the car. Look what he did in Singapore!"


This is the full Bob Bell quote from that thread. What you made out of it say everything about you. Go for more vodka drunk.gif



"Look what he did in Singapore" roflmao.gif roflmao.gif roflmao.gif
BMW_F1
QUOTE (RodrigoL @ Oct 16 2009, 22:14) *
Indeed. No other driver comes with a $100m sponsor package and guaranteed WMSC hearings..

If only my favourite driver could be like that ambivalent.gif ambivalent.gif


you should stop posting this type of nonsense unless you want people to not take you seriously..
f1rules
http://www.motorsport-total.com/f1/news/20...n_09101619.html

barrichello exspecting fireworks in the ferrari garage, he says massa better then kimi, but alonso better then massa
Flat and Out
QUOTE (BMW_F1 @ Oct 16 2009, 19:25) *
you should stop posting this type of nonsense unless you want people to not take you seriously.


You don't have to worry anybody would take you seriously. So troll on.


prty
QUOTE (Menace @ Oct 16 2009, 17:01) *
Can we use every quote Mr Dennis has said about Kimi as proof about his superiority to both Alonso and MS? Or do we just pick and choose the once we see fit our beliefs? Because I got to tell you, Ron would be a stupid man not to be high on his new multi-million dollar driver.wink.gif


Ron on his multi-million dollar driver at the time:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8LIcleMr8sM

wink.gif
giacomo
QUOTE (Menace @ Oct 16 2009, 18:01) *
Can we use every quote Mr Dennis has said about Kimi as proof about his superiority to both Alonso and MS? Or do we just pick and choose the once we see fit our beliefs? Because I got to tell you, Ron would be a stupid man not to be high on his new multi-million dollar driver. wink.gif


QUOTE (giacomo @ Oct 16 2009, 18:05) *
Bring on your quotes.


No Ron Dennis quotes from Menace so far. Quel surprise.

What about this one for a starter:
"Fernando and the Renault team did a great job in 2005. They brought a good package which was reliable for the first race and did the job while our drivers psychologically overreacted to problems at the first round of the world championships and definitely didn't respond to the pressure."
conseillo
QUOTE (Razer @ Oct 15 2009, 10:03) *
Yep exactly. Its no different to ross brawn 'failing' in 1996 when michael left. or Schumacher failing in 2005. Both are brillaint are make a difference but sometimes they are so limited by their resources they cannot make a difference. Alonso has proven is ability over his entire career to help bring teams forward, and 1 year doesnt negate all of that. Only in the mind of a desperate basher.


bell... : alonso very very good as test driver...bla bla bla...in order to lead the team in the righ direction..bla bla bla...

then, 1 year without in-season testing....voila...renault quit about mid season the development of the car (i know there are more reasons for this)---final result:the only year alonso team dont finish in good form...

draw your conclusions

edit razer this post was not directed to you,just quoting to comment this year lack of development
Gag Bueno
So nothing new, Domenicali (what about Fridays / Saturdays...? ) is rather stupid, and when he sees a micro easily becomes lobotomized, Costa was a mediocre designer at Minardi and still is ( the first one to go if they want to win somewhere else than at SPA... with Al...sorry Santand...sorry somebody at the wheel...Who was the guy?) and I can't believe KR said this... real link/vid?
maccaFTW
QUOTE (BMW_F1 @ Oct 16 2009, 12:06) *
yep, that's the one..
there is also this..
"We'd love to have him," concurred team principal Brawn, "because he is the best.
Of all the drivers right now, he is the only one that I see as totally complete, as Michael [Schumacher] was."
- Brawn.


Bear in mind, Dennis said that before Lewis Hamilton and Sebastian Vettel even had an instant of a Formula One race under their belts.

Also bear in mind that Dennis said that after a very ugly split with Raikkonen.

I'm not doubting that Alonso gives great feedback. But I doubt he's in a "class of his own," and quite frankly, I don't think he is the best.
Simon Says
QUOTE (potmotr @ Oct 13 2009, 16:15) *
I don't get this.

Why do people think Alonso is paying to drive at Ferrari.

Someone please explain in simple language, I'm none too smart.


Cause only rookies need sponsers like Santander to get a drive for a team.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.