Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Should Great Britain have two Grand Prixs?
The AUTOSPORT Bulletin Board > Forums > Racing Comments
Pages: 1, 2, 3
THE "driverider"
Should Great Britain have two Grand Prixs?

Well, I think yes! The first reason being it seems by 2010 that Great Britian should have two fully functioning FIA Grade 1 circuits (I said should). Also if you haven't realised already Britain is home to the last two Formula One World Champions in Lewis Hamilton and Jenson Button. Spain currently has two Grand Prixs for (what it seems) having Fernando Alonso as a double World Champion. Britian has two different champions that won the championships back-to-back. I also don't get how Spain is allowed to have two Grand Prixs after the racial abuse directed to Lewis Hamilton last year during pre-season testing and this year at the Spanish Grand Prix, as well as the Valencia street circuit being a terrible F1 circuit. So i do not see why Donington Park can have the British Grand Prix and Silverstone having the European Grand Prix, maybe one at the start of summer and one at the end.
Sin Plomo
We could have 6 Grand Prix if we flash enough cash.

British Grand Prix
English Grand Prix
Scottish Grand Prix
Welsh Grand Prix
Isle of Man Grand Prix
Birmingham Grand Prix

drunk.gif
Brawn BGP 001
No country should have more than one GP a year IMO.
Owen
If we get team Todtley, we'll be lucky if we get one.
Anomnader
At this point in time I'd be grateful with just one!

Maybe they should not keep the European GP at Valencia, strange decision, the Euro GP should be rotated, one year in UK, another at San Marino
P123
With so many countries chasing a GP none should have two.
britishtrident
QUOTE (Anomnader @ Oct 20 2009, 21:00) *
At this point in time I'd be grateful with just one!

Maybe they should not keep the European GP at Valencia, strange decision, the Euro GP should be rotated, one year in UK, another at San Marino


All to do with who is on Max's & Toads buddy list.
andrew.
There should be 20 GPs, in 20 different countries. I don't care if Jenson and Lewis take the next 10 driver's titles.
lustigson
Strictly speaking, I'd like to see a single Grand Prix per country. However, by B.C. Ecclestone's, M.R. Mosley's, and the Fédération Internationale de l'Automobile's previous logic -- of allowing Italy, because of Ferrari, Germany, because of M. Schumacher, and most recently Spain, because of F. Alonso Díaz -- the United Kingdom, with 2 different Formula One World Drivers' Champions in the field, should indeed have 2 Grands Prix, let alone the number of World Constructors' Champions for McLaren and Williams in the past 30-odd years.
Pegaso
I agree about the fact that Spain shouldn't have two grand prixe$$$$, but like it or not this is modern F1 for you.

I also find it funny that you talk about Great Britain when you actually mean England (both the drivers and the teams that have recently won the championships are English, especially McLaren whose boss Ron Dennis only congratulated ENGLISH fans after their victory last year), because the fact that there could be a GP in any other territory of Britain that it's not England hasn't even crossed your mind, right?
Clatter
QUOTE (lustigson @ Oct 20 2009, 21:14) *
Strictly speaking, I'd like to see a single Grand Prix per country. However, by B.C. Ecclestone's, M.R. Mosley's, and the Fédération Internationale de l'Automobile's previous logic -- of allowing Italy, because of Ferrari, Germany, because of M. Schumacher, and most recently Spain, because of F. Alonso Díaz -- the United Kingdom, with 2 different Formula One World Drivers' Champions in the field, should indeed have 2 Grands Prix, let alone the number of World Constructors' Champions for McLaren and Williams in the past 30-odd years.


I was going to say the same thing.
Clatter
QUOTE (Pegaso @ Oct 20 2009, 21:25) *
I agree about the fact that Spain shouldn't have two grand prixe$$$$, but like it or not this is modern F1 for you.

I also find it funny that you talk about Great Britain when you actually mean England (both the drivers and the teams that have recently won the championships are English, especially McLaren whose boss Ron Dennis only congratulated ENGLISH fans after their victory last year), because the fact that there could be a GP in any other territory of Britain that it's not England hasn't even crossed your mind, right?


Is there any other track that is anywhere near F1 standard other than in England?
Tenmantaylor
No, Interlagos should have two GPs!
Owen
QUOTE (Tenmantaylor @ Oct 20 2009, 21:31) *
No, Interlagos should have two GPs!

roflmao.gif
The Ragged Edge
No.
raiseyourfistfor
I think they should. There are a lot of British F1 fans and they actually want to pay for tickets. Most teams are based in England as well. If there are 2 tracks that are good enough then why not? I'd rather have a 2nd GP there than somewhere where nobody cares for F1 like Bahrain or China.
Crafty
QUOTE (THE @ Oct 20 2009, 20:54) *
Should Great Britain have two Grand Prixs?

Well, I think yes! The first reason being it seems by 2010 that Great Britian should have two fully functioning FIA Grade 1 circuits (I said should).


I wouldn't hold your breath on that one.

I agree the European GP should rotate around the countries though.
fastlegs
Try giving one to the USA first.

Preferably the west coast. smile.gif
F3000man
OK, where?

Thruxton? Snetterton? Brands Hatch? Or simply Silverstone and Donington?

I dislike these last two ones. Silverstone was once a legendary circuit and Donington is good for motocycles.
pacificquay
The plural is Grands Prix, not Grand Prixs
Pegaso
QUOTE (F3000man @ Oct 20 2009, 22:56) *
OK, where?

Thruxton? Snetterton? Brands Hatch? Or simply Silverstone and Donington?

I dislike these last two ones. Silverstone was once a legendary circuit and Donington is good for motocycles.


Donington is considered to be too up north by many fans. Silverstone should held two, no wait, three GPs. The English GP, the Commonwealth GP and the GP of the British Empire. lol.gif
maccaFTW
I think the European Grand Prix should rotate among countries year to year. So every few years, Britain gets it.

The question is weather to have it on a permanent circuit or a street circuit. I'm not a fan of any of the British circuits besides Silverstone, so I say street circuit. West London, anyone?
SPBHM
abu dhabi should have 5 GPs!
DOF_power
Bo it shouldn't.
Clatter
QUOTE (maccaFTW @ Oct 20 2009, 22:07) *
I think the European Grand Prix should rotate among countries year to year. So every few years, Britain gets it.

The question is weather to have it on a permanent circuit or a street circuit. I'm not a fan of any of the British circuits besides Silverstone, so I say street circuit. West London, anyone?


How about Croydon? I hear they are looking out for Lewis there.
maccaFTW
QUOTE (Clatter @ Oct 20 2009, 17:19) *
How about Croydon? I hear they are looking out for Lewis there.


I don't know anything about Croydon. My time in London is limited to two months of studying abroad there. The furthest west I got was Hammersmith.
V8 Fireworks
It seems FOM hasn't heard of NASCAR and how well it works.

Maximum ticket price $20

Season to consist of 36 GPs (testing completely banned, rookies can drive in FP1 for practice), with double GPs in France, Australia, Germany, Spain, USA, UK and Italy up.gif New GPs in exciting places like Sweden etc
Captain Tightpants
QUOTE (Brawn BGP 001 @ Oct 21 2009, 06:58) *
No country should have more than one GP a year IMO.

I agree. There's nothing particularly special about Great Britain, and where would a race be held? Donintong Park is struggling, and te BRDC only care about the history of the race as opposed to the future of it.
OnyxF1
No it shouldn't. Besides, we are barely clinging on to the one we have. Personally I'd like to see a new circuit built in the UK. Silverstone and Donington are well past their heydays and are either horribly outdated or mangled shadows of their former glory. Silverstone produces crap racing as well. We need a dedicated motorsports facility, not a slew of half-developed, half-arsed circuits run by old boys' clubs and Jonathan Palmer.
Crafty
Without significant investment I don't think there is another track in the UK that could take a GP.

Brands - needs fencing/run offs in GP loop section & deffo more seating.

Rockingham - just no on every level - mickey mouse infield section, pits aren't big enough, pitlane itself not suitable, not enough seating. Horrible location.

Thruxton - more run offs at the chicane needed I would think - they'd arrive at 200+ unless a chicane was put in the back straight.

Snetterton - Seating !

Donington - Currently dug up !

I think the best bet out of the above would be brands but it'd need a fair bit of dosh spent, even there the pits are probably a bit small (remember its not just F1 but all the support races too). I could see the actual track being changed away from what it is now, it could spoil it..
Thruxton would be second choice, but this would need a metric tonne of money spent for infrastructure, VIP area, seating, you name it, it would need money.

I'd be in favour of all of these tracks staying as they are instead of ruining them to become GP circuits once every few years
noikeee
QUOTE (Pegaso @ Oct 20 2009, 21:25) *
I agree about the fact that Spain shouldn't have two grand prixe$$$$, but like it or not this is modern F1 for you.

I also find it funny that you talk about Great Britain when you actually mean England (both the drivers and the teams that have recently won the championships are English, especially McLaren whose boss Ron Dennis only congratulated ENGLISH fans after their victory last year), because the fact that there could be a GP in any other territory of Britain that it's not England hasn't even crossed your mind, right?


Grand Prix of Scotland in Knockhill! up.gif
ensign14
Northern Ireland Grand Prix at Dundrod.

And the Welsh could always have the Targa Anglesey.
johnap
Have the European Grand Prix at Donington when its finished (ditch that horrible track at Valencia)

Have the British GP at Silverstone.

Easy.
pingu666
knockhill would be a giggle, and it would be interesting to see f1 on the rockingham oval biggrin.gif
r4mses
QUOTE (Tenmantaylor @ Oct 20 2009, 22:31) *
No, Interlagos should have two GPs!


and two at Spa!

(or just tell the saudis or americans in vegas to copy spa 1:1 with irrigation system tongue.gif)
Just waiting
no, and No and NO and NO

cant even take care of the one they got now
JarnoA
The UK currently has one circuit that is capable of hosting a GP. That is Silverstone.

Unfortunately, Silverstone doesn't have a bag of cash.

Donington was never going to go, and Bernie knew this which is why he gave the contract to them. It gives him an excuse to remove a historic GP which is paying a quarter of the great motorsport nations such as India and Russia, to get more cash.

Bernie would host 12 GP's in North Korea if Kim Jong il gave him enough cash.
scheivlak
QUOTE (Sin Plomo @ Oct 20 2009, 20:57) *
We could have 6 Grand Prix if we flash enough cash.

British Grand Prix
English Grand Prix
Scottish Grand Prix
Welsh Grand Prix
Isle of Man Grand Prix
Birmingham Grand Prix

drunk.gif

Wot?

No Gibraltar Grand Prix?

sad.gif

tongue.gif
Anssi
No.
dexter311
If the US doesn't get one at all (yay for Montreal comeback!), why should any one country have 2 Grands Prix? I'm looking at you Valencia...
Owen
QUOTE (paranoik0 @ Oct 20 2009, 23:09) *
Grand Prix of Scotland in Knockhill! up.gif

Fastest lap would be way under a minute!
Rob29
I remember when england had 7 non-championship F1 races.2 on the same day wave.gif
Snetterton
Goodwood
Aintree
Silverstone
Crystal Palace & Mallory Park
Oulton Park

These had bigger crowds than some championship rounds today.14 world championships have been won by britons-most teams since 1958 have been based in england.So there would seem to be good reason for more races in UK?
Rob
QUOTE (Crafty @ Oct 20 2009, 22:47) *
Snetterton - Seating !


Most people bring fold-up chairs to Snetterton so seating is never a problem! smile.gif
slideways
One maximum per country.

At least one GP per continent.

Wildcard second GP each year in the WDC's country.

Two wildcard races (one in each half of the season) that must be held in a different country each year (and not the same country in the past 5 years).

Following GPs are permanent fixtures:

Spa
Monza
Silverstone
Monaco
Suzuka

ForeverF1
QUOTE (Rob @ Oct 21 2009, 09:12) *
Most people bring fold-up chairs to Snetterton so seating is never a problem! smile.gif


Very true, also flasks of coffee/tea and sandwiches, although, the standard of sustenance has greatly improved in Tyrrell's Bar and Restaurant.

The 'noise' license imposed on Snetterton prohibits F1 car races there. cry.gif
krapmeister
QUOTE (JarnoA @ Oct 21 2009, 08:30) *
...Bernie would host 12 GP's in North Korea if Kim Jong il gave him enough cash.



A truer word was never typed... up.gif frown.gif
Turbo4
no.

Turbo4
QUOTE (slideways @ Oct 21 2009, 19:18) *
At least one GP per continent.


yes, cant wait for that Antarctic Grand Prix to kick off. confused.gif
krapmeister
Give it 50 years or so...
egg1980
QUOTE (Anomnader @ Oct 20 2009, 21:00) *
At this point in time I'd be grateful with just one!

Maybe they should not keep the European GP at Valencia, strange decision, the Euro GP should be rotated, one year in UK, another at San Marino



Total agreement with this comment.
Why should the European GP stay at one venue for several years at a time. It should go to whichever venue is most likely to put on the best show and fill the most seats. On that basis GB should most definitely have two GPs - as things stand at least - the sad thing is, we only have one venue capable of staging the event. If only a London GP could be turned into a reality!!!
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.