Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Guess the podium: Imola results
The AUTOSPORT Bulletin Board > Forums > Racing Comments > RC's Bets & Games
Schummy
Ahh… at last a "normal" GP!wink.gif The proper Mike's win, the proper lack of overtakings, the good ol' days are here again tongue.gif

Seriously now, appart from 1st position, the race was worthy to watch because the fight for 2-3-4 positions, or at least, what is considered "fight" in F1 terms smile.gif However, I missed some spice in the show, like some Verstappen stunt , a Williams messed pitstop or somebody stopping without fuel .

Reviewing this week's guesses (something I find interesting to track what people thinks about drivers), we saw again MS in command with 31 out of 35 guessers (89%), then Rubinho 22 (63%). It seems we recognize KR as a proper WDC contender , because he is 3rd with 19 edging slightly Coulthard (15). Frank's boys and gals (no, I'm joking , I meant Frank's boys cat.gif ) were not worthy of a lot of confidence, although they are clearly seen as belonging to the top club : Monty 10 () and a slighty recovered (in people's favour) Ralf with 5 ().

Those 6 drivers from the 3 top teams (they are there forever, are not they ;) ) are ligth years ahead the rest . Only "residual" singular votes go to Alonso, Jacques and Button (well, from JensonFan ;) ), and Alonso's was from MAX lol.gif Notwhitstanding the rare events of the three first GPs, nobody seems to think the power has changed hands in F1. (And I suppose I'm the first in this: my guess was MS-RB-JPM, it is not possible a more coward guess smile.gif )

As we can see, we have come to the usual great scores for the winners of the round: Jimmino, DeathMasteR, JensonFan (welcome back!), Nasty McBastard, rich42, dynamite7 and TT6 got 5 points out of a maximum of 6

I want to welcome back to scheivlak up.gif, and he has a great nick (very nice corner from Zandvoort). Sadly we have to regret our previous leader kismet missing this round. It will be a big handicap to overcome, but… who knows.


Name:          Pt

-----------------

Jimmino         5

DeathMasteR     5

JensonFan       5

Nasty           5

rich42          5

dynamite7       5

TT6             5

garth_b         4

Sammyed         4

Viss1           4

fisichella_2001 4

Double          4

dbltop          4

Estwald         4

jun             4

Pioneer         4

SeanValen       4

gerry           4

KWSN            4

sek             4

Makarias        4

Schuting        4

scheivlak       4

Schummy         4

BERNIE          4

Ric             3

WillieF1        3

weasle          3

Zawed           3

shays           3

LB              3

d_view7         3

MAX             2

lukywill        2

CaptnMark       2

-----------------

In the "total" classification, we are beginning to get some profile . TT6 is our new leader clap.gif (and will be crowned as deserves by Ecclestone in the next GP in Montmeló…) with 11 points in 3 rounds, averaging 3.67 per round . A great score, having in consideration all the difficult GPs we have had! Second appears a classic gamer here: DeathMasteR , 10 points, he shows that he knows everything about this game and how to put a guess. And what we can say about the bronze position, fisichella_2001 (9 points)? He is in the same level as DeAtHmAsTeR tongue.gif , even getting two perfect scores last year!

There is a bunch of people with 8 and 7 points prepared to leap at the minimal failure of the top three. The game is yet open, will win it the "Prost guessers" confused.gif or the "Gilles Villeneuve players" drunk.gif ? If one makes a "strange" guess and lose, he/she can be surpassed by many other people. If one get too conservative, certain people can do a great hit and win a susprising guess, leaping over many others. The only certain thing is … I will not rest up there for long time!wink.gif


Name:           M B S  T

------------------------

TT6             4 2 5 11

DeathMasteR     3 2 5 10

fisichella_2001 3 2 4  9

LB              3 2 3  8

RicBol          3 2 3  8

garth_b         3 1 4  8

Pioneer         3 1 4  8

Schummy         2 2 4  8

sek             2 2 4  8

rich42          3 0 5  8

dynamite7       2 1 5  8

Jimino          2 1 5  8

NastyMcBastard  2 1 5  8

jun             3 0 4  7

Viss1           3 0 4  7

SchutingStar    2 1 4  7

kismet          4 2 *  6

Shays           2 1 3  6

Estwald         2 0 4  6

Makarias        2 0 4  6

SeanValen       2 0 4  6

gerrynassar     1 1 4  6

Sammyed         1 1 4  6

MAX             1 2 2  5

Zawed           2 0 3  5

BERNIE          1 0 4  5

dbltop          1 0 4  5

KWSNDSM         1 0 4  5

JensonFan       * * 5  5

WillieF1        1 * 3  4

Double          * * 4  4

scheivlak       * * 4  4

AD              3 * *  3

Ghostrider      3 0 *  3

jangkrik        3 * *  3

titrisol        3 * *  3

Bjorn           2 1 *  3

JForce          1 2 *  3

CaptnMark       1 0 2  3

d_view7         * * 3  3

weasle          * * 3  3

Apex            * 2 *  2

QdfV            2 0 *  2

wioyet          0 2 *  2

lukywill        0 0 2  2

Tumppi@BXL      * 1 *  1

axterix         1 0 *  1

PAULF1          1 * *  1

thegreatone     1 * *  1

nichotj         0 1 *  1

joachimvanwing  * 0 *  0

OnlyMassa       * 0 *  0

philhitchings   * 0 *  0

TheRedBaron     * 0 *  0

boost           0 * *  0

HiTest          0 * *  0

------------------------

We will meet in Spain. Montmelo is usually previsible and there are not a lot of probabilities of wet weather there in May, so… someone thinking about a two Ferrari and Kimi guess?wink.gif

Thanks to share this game here, and good luck in these two weeks! wave.gif
Ghostrider
I missed this round, can't believe it. frown.gif
TT6
clap.gif
Schummy
Ghosty, oh, no! frown.gif With a zero and a miss, the season is going to be an stepped uphil =:-o

I hope you go on playing here, you are one of our classics! Last year was great, only slipping back when you did a (smart) bet on Williams-BMW power in Monza... it didn't work ambivalent.gif smile.gif At the end you were one of the few who outperformed MAX&BERNIE smile.gif

(Lol, this looks an obituary up.gif )
Ric Bol
Go Ric Go!!!!!!! clap.gif
Sammyed
I left the basement, finally. smile.gif
SeanValen
Originally posted by Schummy
[B]Ghosty, oh, no! frown.gif With a zero and a miss, the season is going to be an stepped uphil =:-o

I hope you go on playing here, you are one of our classics! Last year was great, only slipping back when you did a (smart) bet on Williams-BMW power in Monza... it didn't work ambivalent.gif smile.gif At the end you were one of the few who outperformed MAX&BERNIE smile.gif

(Lol, this looks an obituary up.gif ) [/B]


Give Ghostrider say 2 points for free, be generous, I will give you anything you want, money, islands etc. Rules are meant to be broken, then new rules come in. smoking.gif
up.gif
Ghostrider
Originally posted by SeanValen
Give Ghostrider say 2 points for free, be generous, I will give you anything you want, money, islands etc. Rules are meant to be broken, then new rules come in. smoking.gif
up.gif


smile.gif

Thanx for support fellow competitor! up.gif

But I will bounce back anyway in Barcelona. I have done a lot of testing there. smoking.gif
Estwald
A better guess for me this week. Finally! biggrin.gif

Looks like I picked the wrong McLaren to be on the podium :\

Thanks Schummy clap.gif
kismet
Schummy,

Begging for some mercy here: I know I missed this round but it really was a force majeure situation (i.e. I didn't have access to a working computer while the competition was up and running). However, I did post on Guess the Result thread - can't you just take my top three (MS, KR, DC - if I remember correctly) from there? Just this once. Please please please...
Jimmino
Grat result for me tongue.gif Thanks! up.gif
Schummy
I have had a Deep Thought wink.gif about the "missing rounds" issue and after consults to FIA eek.gif , I have taken a decision:

With effect retroactive from the first "official" round until the end of the season, each round those who miss that round will get a score determined as follows:

Article 1: rolleyes.gif
"Third better score for that round minus three. The resulting score MUST be always between 0 and 2 points, adjusting it as needed"

For example, in this season, scores for missing rounds are:

Malaysia: third best score=3, miss-score=0
Brazil: third best score=2, miss-score=0
San Marino: third best score=5, miss-score=2

The rationale of it is reward "misses" depending on the difficulty of the round. I have done calculations about last year's results and it works well. Missing rounds are scored less than almost every one who made a guess (except some rare cases of disasters wink.gif ), and on the other side, missing rounds are not penalized as harshly as always zero.

Article 2: cat.gif
"In order to eliminate unneeded calculations, I only will add miss-scores to players who guessed more than half of number of rounds so far (it's to say, with three rounds, those who guessed two times)"

Applying it, there are 8 players with added points:

kismet 6 + 2 = 8
Ghostrider 3 + 2 = 5
Bjorn 3 + 2 = 5
JForce 3 + 2 = 5
Qdfv 2 + 2 = 4
wiofet 2 + 2 = 4
asterix 1 + 2 = 3
nichotj 1 + 2 = 3

As can be seen, only kismet is really "there" with a good scoring smile.gif The rest of them have had troubles in the first two rounds and are distanced by now, but I hope a quick response (are you listening me, Ghostrider and Bjorn?wink.gif )

Article 3:
"In case of a tie in the final classification, the first rule to untying is the player with less miss-scores is above the player with more miss-score."

I hope this procedure can serve well to the develop of the game. Bear in mind that our little game is just for fun, although I try it to be fair and fun to everybody smile.gif

Good week for everybody wave.gif
kismet
OK, that's better than nothing, I suppose. ambivalent.gif

Nevertheless, I reserve the right to bitch and moan like no tomorrow if I end up losing positions in the final standings because I missed the 3 extra points that I would've scored from Imola, had you accepted my top 3 from the GTR thread. evil.gif I also reserve the right to consider myself a moral co-leader of this competition after round 4. cool.gif
QdfV
I am in favour! (since it equals my highscore so far ;) )
Ghostrider
Thanx Schummy! up.gif

I will have a strong next round, I can feel it. cool.gif
Schuting Star
I'm not in favour. If you don't play you don't score, it's simple. The rules are the same for the other games. I don't really think it acceptable that someone that doesn't play can feasibly (even with those carefully thought out rules) beat someone that bothered to. Having said that, it would help if the game was up a little earlier ;) .

Thanks again for the game Schummy, at least I'm above Max and Bernie for a change! biggrin.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.