No, he's not, and no, one doesn't.
Sure, he doesn't get everything right, and he can be tiresome from time to time, but his blog is still one of the best F1-blogs.
One can like his style of writing, no problem. I like Gail Collins's opinion pieces -- and her excellent wit.
My issue arises from a journalistic point of view. He attempts to be one (a journo) in his blog entries, that is plain awful and an utter waste of time for readers. Only time I have ever seen him right about something, news wise, is when others, long before him, have already broken the news. Then that is just copy/paste journalism.
Sorry mate, I do not buy into your strain of thought.
Apology for wandering OT here.