Lewis Carl Davidson Hamilton MBE is arguably the most talented road racer of his generation. To watch him carry his car late into a corner, brake so late, make the transition appear perfectly precise, seamless and effortless before getting on the gas to drive out of the corner is a pure joy to watch. This is a skill very few can do, and he does it every lap. Amazing, the man was born to be a racer, it is in his DNA.
But at times I am critical of his decisions, and although I still hold true on some, when he sometimes decides to ignore his instructions from the pits, I applaud the man. He is there to win, not just drive around.
The men who run the Mercedes AMG Pertonas Formula One team, namely Toto Wolff and Niki Lauda have just one simple mandate from the Mercedes Board of Directors. Finish each race 1-2, win both titles. Now it gets ugly, in how they implement this policy. Instead of two separate sides of the garage that compete against each other on race day, they have just one strategist and all decisions are centralized. What does that mean?
In qualifying, all is fair and equal, the better man on that day is rewarded by starting ahead of his teammate. So far so good. On the start of the race, the drivers are expressly forbidden to make contact. Not allowed, there will never be a repeat of Spa. And this is when the stench begins to register, something putrid and unacceptable. Once the race is underway, the team does everything possible to make sure that their drivers never get close to each other, that they never fight each other. After the first two laps, everything becomes a game of stasis.
The current regulations, definitely the tires, are there to create situations of an ebb and flow in pace, where a driver may choose to start on the slower tire and be fast at the end, or vice versa. And at times, it has delivered some wonderful races where a driver charges through the pack and we the fans get to see some quality action. Not the boring and mind-numbing situation where the order after the first pit stop is the same when the checkered flag flies.
But under the Mercedes practice, if one driver makes a change and actually attempts to close up with his team mate ahead, the team just inform the driver ahead to mirror his actions, and the status quo is maintained. We saw it in Spain, where after battling to get back to second place, Hamilton was told to just hold station. He attacked, attempted to close the gap on Rosberg. And Rosberg just picked up the pace, the gap was stabilized, nothing happened. In Montreal Rosberg had to conserve his rear brakes. But once his car was healthy enough, he attempted to close the gap on Hamilton, trying to close up, and battle for the win. And what did Hamilton do? Yup, he picked up his pace.
All of this was dictated by the pits.
So although the Mercedes team is to be applauded for building and running an utterly dominant car, they have decided to implement a method and strategy that creates a boring scenario where the possibility of the drivers actually battling for the win becomes improbable. The odds are that a Mercedes will win every race for the remainder of the season. The odds are much greater that whatever driver is leading after lap two, he will win. No battles for the lead, no challenges, nothing but the desire to turn the TV off after lap two because we know who the winner will be.
OK back to Hamilton. There have been times in the last two years when he was told to hold station, and instead ignored their request and went on the attack (or didn't just allow Rosberg to drive past just because he had better tires). I criticized him, but in hindsight, I was wrong. He was not an aggressive idiot just charging without regard to his car's health, but instead he realizes that if he follows their instructions all the time, he will never be allowed to close up and battle Rosberg for position. He wants to be the master of his own fate.
Hamilton is not there just to drive around, he is there to race, to win, because he is a RACER.