Italian underachievers
#1
Posted 06 October 2001 - 17:34
Michele Alboreto - With Tyrrell in 1982 was often as quick as that years World Champion and fellow DFV front runner, Keke Rosberg. Won the last GP for the DFV at Detroit in 1983 when the turbos had a massive power advantage. His five years at Ferrari provided only three wins in his first two seasons there.
Ricardo Patrese - Showed immense promise with Shadow and Arrows yet he never became a consistant race winner despite having arguably the best car on the grid for at least three of the seasons he raced in F1.
Andrea De Cesaris - When he was good he was very very good, when he was bad (often in the same race) he was very very bad!
Giancarlo Fisichella - Leads German GP in first year with Jordan. Managed to steer his career steadily downhill since then.
Jarno Trulli - Led the Austrain GP in 1997. Rest ditto Giancarlo Fisichella.
Jean Alesi - Okay he might officially be French but he has Italian ancestary. An amazing first year and a half in F1 in the very unfancied Tyrrell. The next seven years he manages one victory despite driving tow of the best cars on the grid.
Others worthy of a mention: Alex Caffi, Alex Zanardi, Stefano Modena, Bruno Giacomelli, Teo Fabi
Please don't take this post as an anti-Italian message. I remember most of the drivers very fondly as they were not only good drivers but wonderful human beings. I just can't help thinking that they could have achieved so much more.
Chris
#3
Posted 06 October 2001 - 18:13
;);)
It was quite funny though:lol:
Chris
#4
Posted 06 October 2001 - 18:15
#5
Posted 06 October 2001 - 18:23
#6
Posted 06 October 2001 - 18:24
Originally posted by Barry Boor
I think Ivan Capelli fits the criteria pretty well too.
Yes, I can't understand why I forgot him!
Chris
#7
Posted 06 October 2001 - 18:33
#8
Posted 06 October 2001 - 21:36
I think the problem is actually Ferrari: every red-blooded Italian wants to drive for them, but when they manage it the press and public expectations destroy their chances. Odd that the two most successful Ferrari drivers have been German speakers ...
#9
Posted 06 October 2001 - 22:33
And there might be the question of perception... Most people (no, no offence is meant here either) want another Italian champion and tend to look at the contenders for that spot with less critical eye. And, as Mr.Bolshewik pointed out with what I tend to agree, it is much easier to show signs of greatnes in underachieving machinery. I belive that Brit (and Brasilian, come to think of it) drivers, through chiefly british motorsport media, get in the same situation which proves perilous for them when they get in more competitive machinery and fail to deliver. As an example I present one Rubens 'Teletubbie' Barrichelo. And look what fuss Brits made about Jenny Buttons, only to see him soundly beaten by Fisichela.
#10
Posted 07 October 2001 - 07:03
"And look what fuss Brits made about Jenny Buttons, only to see him soundly beaten by Fisichela."
Wolf, you MUST not get British motor sport fans mixed up with the British media. If you lived here you would understand. There is an element in our press corps (and that includes some of the specialist motor sporting mags too) who simply CANNOT look realistically at anything.
The moment they see anything even remotely good, they blow it up out of all proportion and make it into something it isn't.
They are totally and wholly responsible for 'Mansell Mania' and had a fair go with Damon too. Now it's Jenson's turn.
I know this is slightly O.T, but I bet the opinions of British posters on TNF would be much more reserved vis-a-vis young Button than perhaps you would expect.
As for the Italian under-achievers, I actually believe that quite a few of them would have done VERY well had they fetched up in the right team at the right time. There is a very fine line between success and mediocrity; had Senna not died, where would Coulthard be now......?
#11
Posted 08 October 2001 - 03:10
#12
Posted 08 October 2001 - 07:23
#13
Posted 08 October 2001 - 07:44
#14
Posted 08 October 2001 - 08:11
Originally posted by Kuwashima
Dare I mention Apicella, Bertaggia, Langes??
Kuwashima, I refer you to the first post, this is supposed to be a thread about promising but ultimately unfulfilled Italian drivers. Did Langes really show any "promise"?
#15
Posted 08 October 2001 - 08:22
#16
Posted 08 October 2001 - 09:31
Originally posted by Vitesse2
... I think the problem is actually Ferrari ... Odd that the two most successful Ferrari drivers have been German speakers ...
Not wishing to get too much OT, I, too, think Vitesse makes a good point. I find it interesting, too, to observe that another significant turnaround for Ferrari when they had got into one of their muddles was in large part driven by another head kicker, albeit not of Germanic origins, John Surtees. This despite the efforts of Dragoni to stay in muddledom!
Vanwall.
#17
Posted 08 October 2001 - 11:21
My oppinion is that only two Italian drivers in that period had a real chance to achieve something great (not counting Alesi as an Italian). Michele Alboreto was well on the way to Championship in 1985 - he actually led it with five races to go! But his Ferrari couldn't finish neither of these remaining races (or he had much more common with Trulli than I think:lol: ). Alessandro Nannini was very fast in underpowered Benneton and, shouldn't he want to learn how to fly a helicopter, I was pretty convinced that he should be a championship contender in a right car...
#18
Posted 08 October 2001 - 11:33
I remember both of these men as outstanding drivers who never had much success with the Prancing Horse.
Sorry if this sounds like Ferrari - bashing, I don't intend it that way:(.
Bobbo
#19
Posted 08 October 2001 - 11:55
Not so sure about Scarfiotti though. Yes, he won a GP, but it was a Monza slipstreamer at the start and the more fancied front runners had dropped out before half-distance. He had Parkes as a tail-gunner holding Hulme off and was able to win quite easily.
And in fact, just checking his record, I note that he actually announced his retirement from F1 in 1964 after his shunt at Reims.
No dispute about his sports car record though: like Vaccarella he was a man for the long haul, not the short sprint.
Advertisement
#20
Posted 08 October 2001 - 13:34
Originally posted by dmj
... Michele Alboreto was well on the way to Championship in 1985 - he actually led it with five races to go! ...
Can someone put me out of my misery please. I fondly recall Michele's splendid start to that season - 8 podiums (podia?) out of the first ten races including two wins - then it all went to merde at the end.
I have a memory of his coming into the pits at some point with flames emerging from the derriere of the Ferrari, Michele jumping out in disgust whilst it was still moving and stalking off as if to say: "Sticka de car where de sun she dona shine!"
Bizarrely, I remember this as Brands but the British GP was at Silverstone in '85 and Michele finished 2nd!
So you see, I need help here!
Vanwall.
#21
Posted 08 October 2001 - 14:06
The Brands Race was the European GP and also Mansells first F1 victory.
Chris
#22
Posted 08 October 2001 - 14:11
What, beside the promise of money? Hehehe, point taken ZawedKuwashima, I refer you to the first post, this is supposed to be a thread about promising but ultimately unfulfilled Italian drivers. Did Langes really show any "promise"?
But good ol' Claudio did come 4th in European F3 in 1984, and scored 15 points in his 35 F3000 races, which aint tooooo bad. Not to mention being Champion in Italian 125cc karts in 1978!!
#23
Posted 08 October 2001 - 14:27
#24
Posted 08 October 2001 - 14:39
Wasn't it Monza where he parked the smoking Ferrari right alongside team position on the Pit wall?
Fred
#25
Posted 08 October 2001 - 15:05
But I will never forget his race in Monaco that year, when he spun on oil left after Piquet-Patrese wreckage (while in lead), fell a few places down the grid and... almost win again. He passed both "de"s (Angelis and Cesaris) and almost caught Prost, driving as nobody told him that it is Monaco, where supposedly shouldn't exist any places where you can overtake other car...
I was also fascinated with a story published about same time that he gave a million dollars to an Italian hospital for disabled children. With today's sallaries it shouldn't be so much, but I don't think he earned multi-million cheques in '80s.
#26
Posted 08 October 2001 - 21:42
About Scarfiotti:
Good Point. Thanks!
Bobbo
#27
Posted 08 October 2001 - 22:41
Lorenzo Bandini, who was, in my opinion, royally screwed by Ferrari,
Bobbo, Vitesse, what do you mean by that?
#28
Posted 08 October 2001 - 23:15
Dropped in favour of Mairesse (!!!) for 1963. Rebuilt his career in sports cars and Centro-Sud BRMs. Got his seat back only when Wild Willy crashed and injured himself.
1964-5: loyal number 2 to Surtees, but increasingly unhappy with his lot. Won at Zeltweg 1964.
1966: promoted to team leader when Surtees left. Missed out on two wins because of mechanical failures (France & Italy).
1967: started with a bang with sports car wins at Daytona and Monza, 2nd in Race of Champions. Then came Monaco ...
#29
Posted 09 October 2001 - 05:57
I believe the problem in 62/63 was a conflict of fuel contracts. I'd not heard that Bandini was "increasingly unhappy with his lot in 63/64". I think most would agree that Surtees was the better driver at this time. but it is arguable that Bandini sometimes received preferential tratment over Surtees: I'm sure John would have preferred the Flat-12 earlier in 65 and the V6 at Monaco in 66. Lorenzo certainly raised his game after Surtees left, although we'll never know how well he would have worked in the longer term with Chris Amon. Certainly Chris was full of praise for Bandini in the short time they were team mates.
i still can't see how any interpretation of this justifies the term "royaly screwed" though.
#30
Posted 09 October 2001 - 07:00
Originally posted by Chris Bloom
Giancarlo Fisichella - Leads German GP in first year with Jordan. Managed to steer his career steadily downhill since then.
Chris
i would say his machinery has steered his career downhill...
#31
Posted 09 October 2001 - 13:20
A classic case, in my view, was Stefano Modena. He entered F1 with all the right credentials and was widely expected to be a real star (he even had an apt name for a F1 champion!). But then he just faded away without achieving very much at all, except for a well earned reputation for superstition (IIRC he would only get in and out of the car from one side, amongst others).
Wracking my brains, the only top-line drivers from Italy that I can think since 1970 are Alboreto, Nannini and Reggazoni (and he's Swiss, isn't he?).
I know that we should not use national stereotypes, but it is tempting to muse about whether the traditional "Italian temperament" is not conducive to F1 success (or indeed to top-line world rally success, where a similar story exists - the only real Italian rallying superstars that I can think of are Sandro Munari and Miki Biaision)
#32
Posted 09 October 2001 - 13:39
Originally posted by Roger Clark
I'd not heard that Bandini was "increasingly unhappy with his lot".
Doug Nye on Bandini in Georgano Encyclopaedia:
"... for 1965 Bandini was again number two to Surtees, although he made it obvious he did not like the arrangement ... the rift between him and Surtees had widened throughout the year ...[1965 again]"
Steve Small:
" [in 1965] ... he was increasingly unhappy with the status quo and relationships with Surtees were becoming a little strained ... the friction in the team continued into 1966 ... the situation could not last ..."
#33
Posted 10 October 2001 - 06:57
However, I'm sorry to labour the point, but I still don't see how Bandini was "royally screwed" by Ferrari
#34
Posted 10 October 2001 - 08:40
#35
Posted 10 October 2001 - 11:41
And if Alesi's Italian, then how about Andretti? - the one with the talent I mean, who was born in Italy (OK or Croatia). Hardly an under-achiever.
Roger Clark - how right you are about Bandini. I don't think he had too many problems chez Ferrari, but, like everyone else including Ferrari, he had problems with Surtees - everyone did. His real problem was the fragility of a '60s F1 car...
#36
Posted 10 October 2001 - 13:07
And if Alesi's Italian, then how about Andretti? - the one with the talent I mean, who was born in Italy (OK or Croatia). Hardly an under-achiever.
Well, you know, since we never had a F1 driver from our country we must take a chance in this case... Mario is definitely a 100% Italian but he is born in a beautiful small town that is now part of Croatia - enough for me and my compatriopts to be proud of his achievements.
#37
Posted 10 October 2001 - 20:05
#38
Posted 10 October 2001 - 22:08
For me, Eddie has had that nickname for decades!
"Stands back and awaits flak......."
#39
Posted 11 October 2001 - 03:09
I think it have worked out the reason for all this underachievement. 95% of the guys mentioned so far I have been keen fan of. The link is me! I jinxed them all.
Advertisement
#40
Posted 11 October 2001 - 07:14
#41
Posted 11 October 2001 - 10:59
But you probably got the picture: Eddie's racing pedigree is Italian, rather than Arizonian...
#42
Posted 11 October 2001 - 18:24
I always thought he had the potential to be something better than testdriver for Ferrari. Remember his great race on that tragic day in may 1994 when he brought his Ferrari home in third place at Imola?
#43
Posted 12 October 2001 - 08:15
Remember his great race on that tragic day in may 1994 when he brought his Ferrari home in third place at Imola?
He was second.
#44
Posted 13 October 2001 - 11:40
#45
Posted 15 October 2001 - 15:23
#46
Posted 15 October 2001 - 18:55
maybe they just want to race and aren't as bothered as drivers from other nations about where it is. Hence the Italian domination of kart racing, which takes just as much talent as sports cars (for example) to win in but has bugger-all status in a lot of the motorsport world