See post #2, Darren, this is the man (but he didn't finish the free-for-all, he retired early on). Since my earlier post I found one more appearance for Bill Turner, Sep 16 in 1911, New York State Fair in Syracuse, finished second to Bob Burman (Opel) in a 5-mile heat and second to Ralph de Palma (Simplex) in a ten-mile heat, both times driving an Amplex. He was a likely starter in the 50-mile main event, but results are difficult to find since this was the infamous event in which Lee Oldfield crashed, killing nine or even eleven spectators (sources differ). Turner didn't win, though, de Palma did.
Returning to the
Indianapolis Star article, it's quite puzzling to find it loaded with nonsense - usually, those short driver resumés were quite accurate! Probably a junior hack getting the lowdown from the man himself. Anyway, Turner definitely did not finish second at Fairmount Park in 1909, neither overall nor in class, and I doubt he won the mentioned 24-hour and 50-mile races. Difficult to say if he partook in the Glidden Tours, since I never paid too much attention to those, but I know that "a perfect score" doesn't mean much - several dozen driving crews appear to have achieved that feat each year. Researching drivers with common names is always difficult, because personal names are rarely mentioned and often confused, but there were comparatively few Turners competing in America in those days, and most don't fit our William. There was, however, a minor hill climb in Colorado in 1913, won by a "Bill Turner" in a Maxwell - if he indeed ended up in California, that just might have been our man!?
Thanks for the correction of the birth place, another indication for the theory that the short
Star bio probably emanated from Turner himself. Your story also explains
why he may have given this false info - hiding from the family! Another puzzle that remains is that he, apparently, competed exclusively on Amplex cars, a company based in Mishawaka (IN). Amplex cars were built by the Simplex Motor Car Co., which is often confused with the more prominent Simplex Automobile Co. in New York, yet Bill Turner appears to have been based in New York - or was that another case of subterfuge?