Jump to content


Photo

Highest ever downforce figure?


  • Please log in to reply
80 replies to this topic

#51 McGuire

McGuire
  • Member

  • 9,218 posts
  • Joined: October 03

Posted 13 August 2010 - 19:42

Thanks much for the info, I am glad to learn more about the realities of the RN program. I too thought that RN's operation was more sophisticated than that ... too bad.

The Breedlove operation's program manager was a young guy that rather ... ahem ... eccentric. During my short visit to the office/workshop he proceeded to explain to me that it was impossible to break the sound barrier on the ground because of a variety of technical issues. When I asked him why it was possible for rocket sleds used in military tests to routinely exceed M+1 he decided it was time for his afternoon bicycle ride to "maintain his energy levels." Breedlove's crew chief went on later to explain that a number of engineers brought on from CalTech, MIT, and a plethora of aerospace companies had clashed with this young guy and left.

The personalities involved are interesting, to say the least.


Dezso Molnar. Small world.

... of course, you have to have a few loose screws to be involved in this stuff, as FB noted. In terms of their dynamics, it might be more useful to regard these vehicles not so much as automobilies -- more like a missile with an exceptionally flat trajectory and casters underneath to keep from scraping up the bottom too much. Steering in the conventional sense is not really in the cards.

I once asked a Bonneville car owner what makes a good driver. "You want someone kind of sleepy, " he said. "A guy who doesn't try to react to every single little thing going on around him." Sure, a barbituate IV drip would probably help, too. I think I would ask for a blindfold.

Breedlove's car was sold to Steve Fossett who then had his unfortunate air crash. I believe someone else has taken over the project but I don't know much about it.

Advertisement

#52 OfficeLinebacker

OfficeLinebacker
  • Member

  • 14,088 posts
  • Joined: December 07

Posted 13 August 2010 - 19:52

I once asked a Bonneville car owner what makes a good driver. "You want someone kind of sleepy, " he said. "A guy who doesn't try to react to every single little thing going on around him." Sure, a barbituate IV drip would probably help, too. I think I would ask for a blindfold.

LMAO McGuire.

This makes me want to try this stuff though. How does one get involved? I guess by showing up one year in one of my own creations and trying to get noticed.

#53 Ross Stonefeld

Ross Stonefeld
  • Member

  • 71,182 posts
  • Joined: August 99

Posted 13 August 2010 - 19:58

Pulse jet gokart.

#54 dosco

dosco
  • Member

  • 1,623 posts
  • Joined: June 02

Posted 13 August 2010 - 20:12

Dezso Molnar. Small world.


Let me clarify that I was told that Mr. Molnar was the "Program Manager."

The crew chief was an older guy - whose name eludes me - that had experience with rocket-powered and jet-powered dragsters. He was very practical and knowledgeable.

I write this because I checked LinkedIn and noticed Mr. Molnar indicated that his position on Breedlove's team was as "crew chief."

So what's the deal with Mr. Molnar? Why is it a "small world?" (feel free to PM me if need be)

Edited by dosco, 13 August 2010 - 20:13.


#55 Dan333SP

Dan333SP
  • Member

  • 5,832 posts
  • Joined: March 10

Posted 13 August 2010 - 20:42

Glad that I started this thread, it's brought out some really interesting stories! I love this place, every other forum would be rampant speculation by 13 year olds (ie, the racing forum), but here I get to hear from people who helped develop land speed record cars and produced cutaway drawings proving the legality of Formula 1 cars at the behest of team principals, what a great resource!

Edited by Dan333SP, 13 August 2010 - 20:43.


#56 zac510

zac510
  • Member

  • 1,713 posts
  • Joined: January 04

Posted 13 August 2010 - 21:14

LMAO McGuire.

This makes me want to try this stuff though. How does one get involved? I guess by showing up one year in one of my own creations and trying to get noticed.


You could try for the propellor powered car record. That would get you noticed. On this forum, at least.

#57 dosco

dosco
  • Member

  • 1,623 posts
  • Joined: June 02

Posted 13 August 2010 - 21:15

You could try for the propellor powered car record. That would get you noticed. On this forum, at least.


Make sure the vehicle has a BEAM AXLE.




#58 DaveW

DaveW
  • Member

  • 431 posts
  • Joined: January 09

Posted 13 August 2010 - 21:28

Back to the topic, perhaps. If I remember correctly, Thrust SSC was estimated to generate a vertical force of 8.5 tons/degree of rake at Mach 1. They had data from a rocket sled test at Pendine, & a CFD analysis from Swansea University but (I was informed), athough they had pressure distributions, "they hadn't taught the computer how to calculate overall aerodynamic forces yet". Inspired confidence, I thought....



#59 dosco

dosco
  • Member

  • 1,623 posts
  • Joined: June 02

Posted 13 August 2010 - 21:43

Back to the topic, perhaps. If I remember correctly, Thrust SSC was estimated to generate a vertical force of 8.5 tons/degree of rake at Mach 1. They had data from a rocket sled test at Pendine, & a CFD analysis from Swansea University but (I was informed), athough they had pressure distributions, "they hadn't taught the computer how to calculate overall aerodynamic forces yet". Inspired confidence, I thought....


Heh.

When I was getting the tour of Breedlove's car by the crew chief (not Dezso), I asked about the foreplanes and tabs on the trailing edges of the wing stubs. Without active downforce, Craig would judge the downforce by "feel" and then change the incidence of the foreplanes and install different tabs (with more or less angle) on the wing stubs.

As I recall he made a run after he rolled the Spirit, but with substantial downforce dialed in on the foreplanes and with rather large, angled tabs on the wing stubs ... I think they generated too much drag and he wasn't able to get her to go any faster than he had previously.

The more I think about it, the more odd details I recall. The crew chief told me that the engines were "F-4 engines" (J79s, presumably) setup to run on gasoline provided by their sponsor, Shell. Furthermore, the compressor blades had been coated by one of their sponsors (I forget if they were chrome plated ... they sure looked like it). The team had removed the engine fuel control and the engine was set to run in a couple of throttle positions.

The jet engine air intakes and "tub" were constructed from CF by a "local artist" ... again, I was appalled. The gent mentioned that they had FODed a number of engines out and were quickly going through their "supply" of spare engines. Amazing.

Edited by dosco, 13 August 2010 - 21:45.


Advertisement

#60 McGuire

McGuire
  • Member

  • 9,218 posts
  • Joined: October 03

Posted 14 August 2010 - 06:49

So what's the deal with Mr. Molnar? Why is it a "small world?" (feel free to PM me if need be)


Only that I've met him under similar circumstances and gathered a similar impression.

Speaking of BEAM AXLES, Art Arfons' Green Monster had one on the front. Straight out of a 1939 Dodge truck. Was doing over 600 mph when it crashed and rolled; wheel bearing failed (not front).

That Green Monster had a J79, which Art bought at an aircraft yard in Ohio for $600 -- despite the engine being classified at the time. When he attempted to obtain the manuals the Feds tried to confiscate it. When he FODed it, he would remove opposing blades to maintain balance. His test stand was a large tree. He passed away Christmas '07 with Alzheimer's. I keep in close touch with his family, nice people. His daughter-in-law Shari is one of the sharpest and sweetest automotive people around. Breedlove is a great guy as well and doing very well t last report. Looked like a million bucks the last time I saw him.

The two-year battle between Arfons and Breedlove for the absolute LSR is one of the epic stories in motorsports. Couldn't even happen today.

#61 Brandz07

Brandz07
  • Member

  • 3,500 posts
  • Joined: February 10

Posted 14 August 2010 - 11:31

this isn't really related to the highest ever downforce, but it's an interesting video :)

http://www.youtube.c...feature=related

#62 dosco

dosco
  • Member

  • 1,623 posts
  • Joined: June 02

Posted 14 August 2010 - 16:15

Only that I've met him under similar circumstances and gathered a similar impression.


I see. Interesting.

After googling his name, it appears he travels in some interesting circles. He was on the Ansari X-prize judging committee, and is a participant in the Rocket Racing League.



Speaking of BEAM AXLES, Art Arfons' Green Monster had one on the front. Straight out of a 1939 Dodge truck. Was doing over 600 mph when it crashed and rolled; wheel bearing failed (not front).

That Green Monster had a J79, which Art bought at an aircraft yard in Ohio for $600 -- despite the engine being classified at the time. When he attempted to obtain the manuals the Feds tried to confiscate it. When he FODed it, he would remove opposing blades to maintain balance. His test stand was a large tree. He passed away Christmas '07 with Alzheimer's. I keep in close touch with his family, nice people. His daughter-in-law Shari is one of the sharpest and sweetest automotive people around. Breedlove is a great guy as well and doing very well t last report. Looked like a million bucks the last time I saw him.

The two-year battle between Arfons and Breedlove for the absolute LSR is one of the epic stories in motorsports. Couldn't even happen today.


Good story, thanks for sharing.



#63 gruntguru

gruntguru
  • Member

  • 7,765 posts
  • Joined: January 09

Posted 15 August 2010 - 10:15

this isn't really related to the highest ever downforce, but it's an interesting video :)

http://www.youtube.c...feature=related

Nice. Any opinions out there on the "transient particles in airbox" simulation and whether the intake pulses in the ram-tubes were anywhere near realistically modelled?

(My vote says no.)

Edited by gruntguru, 15 August 2010 - 10:15.


#64 cheapracer

cheapracer
  • Member

  • 10,388 posts
  • Joined: May 07

Posted 15 August 2010 - 11:22

The two-year battle between Arfons and Breedlove for the absolute LSR is one of the epic stories in motorsports. Couldn't even happen today.



Why not?

#65 J. Edlund

J. Edlund
  • Member

  • 1,323 posts
  • Joined: September 03

Posted 16 August 2010 - 06:33

Another problem was the skirts jamming, as they and the channel that they worked in was curved to go round the inside of the rear wheels, and used to stick. I hadn't heard about the suspension problems.


I wonder if it isn't better to seal the tunnels around the rear wheels by putting 'plates' on the hubs (or other unsprung part) of the rear wheels instead?

Well, I was asking what the highest downforce for each type of racing car was, so F1 was included in that... I'm sure things like Sprint Cars and the Pikes Peak unlimited cars have lots of downforce, but just having a giant wing or two can't possibly produce as much downward thrust as a car with a fully contoured underbody AND wings like the group C cars and GTPs? Apparently the Allard J2X from the last year of the GTP series matched the MKIII Eagle with around 10,000 lbs of df at 200 mph, though the car had so much drag and so little power that it would never be able to approach that speed even on the fastest track...
Posted Image


Cars that ran road courses in the IMSA series in the early nineties provided some very high downforce levels, many of them probably had more than 10,000 lbf at 200 mph. This did however come with a drag penalty, so top speeds were probably not greater than around 150 mph in high downforce configuration. Pikes Peak cars can also have some very high downforce levels, but that is mainly because of two reasons: a) the low top speeds at Pikes Peak and b) the low air density at the altitude they are competing.

F1 probably had their highest downforce levels in 1993 at around 3500 lbf at 150 mph, but the L/D ratios were probably better on the ground effects cars of the early 1980.

#66 McGuire

McGuire
  • Member

  • 9,218 posts
  • Joined: October 03

Posted 16 August 2010 - 12:04

Why not?


Costs too much.

#67 Fat Boy

Fat Boy
  • Member

  • 2,594 posts
  • Joined: January 04

Posted 16 August 2010 - 16:16

I see. Interesting.

After googling his name, it appears he travels in some interesting circles. He was on the Ansari X-prize judging committee, and is a participant in the Rocket Racing League.



I'm also guessing that he was the lunatic that came on the board several years ago with the 'Propster' car/idea. It was a prop driven LSR car with BEAM AXLES (which he always capitalized?) One of those bizzaro guys that happens across our collective path from time to time.

#68 dosco

dosco
  • Member

  • 1,623 posts
  • Joined: June 02

Posted 16 August 2010 - 16:20

I'm also guessing that he was the lunatic that came on the board several years ago with the 'Propster' car/idea. It was a prop driven LSR car with BEAM AXLES (which he always capitalized?) One of those bizzaro guys that happens across our collective path from time to time.


Franklin ... yes, I remember.

Not sure that was Deszo, perhaps Mr. McGuire can enlighten us.




#69 McGuire

McGuire
  • Member

  • 9,218 posts
  • Joined: October 03

Posted 16 August 2010 - 16:48

Franklin Ratliff and Deszo Molnar are two very real but totally different people. Franklin is also sort of an Internet meme -- he's disrupted nearly every motorsports message board in existence; also various NASA and aeronautical forums -- and always with the same crackpot theories, combative attitude, and CAPITAL LETTERS. I have nothing to say about Deszo Molnar except what a great name. With that handle he could be a character in Buckaroo Banzai, like Dr. Emilio Lizardo.

#70 cheapracer

cheapracer
  • Member

  • 10,388 posts
  • Joined: May 07

Posted 16 August 2010 - 16:56

Franklin Ratliff and Deszo Molnar are two very real but totally different people. Franklin is also sort of an Internet meme -- he's disrupted nearly every motorsports message board in existence; also various NASA and aeronautical forums -- and always with the same crackpot theories, combative attitude, and CAPITAL LETTERS. I have nothing to say about Deszo Molnar except what a great name. With that handle he could be a character in Buckaroo Banzai, like Dr. Emilio Lizardo.


:lol: Franklin's posts can still be found thru search.



#71 dosco

dosco
  • Member

  • 1,623 posts
  • Joined: June 02

Posted 16 August 2010 - 17:53

:lol: Franklin's posts can still be found thru search.


Don't you mean:

FRANKLIN's posts can STILL be found thru SEARCH.

(just type in "BEAM AXLE" ... lolzor)




#72 Cxxx

Cxxx
  • Member

  • 53 posts
  • Joined: July 02

Posted 16 August 2010 - 21:18

A good point - I realize now that I had totally dismissed the possibility that they might actually calculate the downforce based on shape (CFD on slide rules ... well not quite, I suppose). I actually have no idea how advanced these equations and lookups were at the time - especially concerning those dang spinning wheels!


I think they probably did have a very good idea of the downforce they were expecting to achieve, but very little idea whether they were achieving that on track. Remember that car aerodynamics are usually a lot more complex and difficult to model than aeroplanes, with a lot more turbulent areas of flow, and also a lot less likely to experience the idealised uniform flow used for most calculations - aircraft are much more likely to be producing something close to your predictions than a racing car will be.

I used to work in F1 aero, and even current F1 engineers rarely know exactly how much downforce the car is producing on track. Of course they have an exact number for what they expect from their wind tunnel, but measuring a direct comparison accurately on track is very difficult, even with today's technology. For example, with load sensors on the suspension, how do you measure how much downforce is generated by bodywork outside this point, e.g. brake ducts?


#73 gruntguru

gruntguru
  • Member

  • 7,765 posts
  • Joined: January 09

Posted 17 August 2010 - 00:50

Franklin Ratliff and Deszo Molnar are two very real but totally different people. Franklin is also sort of an Internet meme -- he's disrupted nearly every motorsports message board in existence; also various NASA and aeronautical forums -- and always with the same crackpot theories, combative attitude, and CAPITAL LETTERS. I have nothing to say about Deszo Molnar except what a great name. With that handle he could be a character in Buckaroo Banzai, like Dr. Emilio Lizardo.

Ratliff v's McGuire. I'd like to see that!

#74 cheapracer

cheapracer
  • Member

  • 10,388 posts
  • Joined: May 07

Posted 17 August 2010 - 09:33

Remember that car aerodynamics are usually a lot more complex and difficult to model than aeroplanes, with a lot more turbulent areas of flow,


I wouldn't go telling that to the aerospace industry.

Not sure how much you fly but you only remind me of my second to last flight landing at Geelong (Avalon) from Sydney and for 20 minutes being buffeted akin to being inside a washing machine. Many people were sick and some had to be helped off the plane at the airport - darn You Yangs.


#75 MatsNorway

MatsNorway
  • Member

  • 2,867 posts
  • Joined: December 09

Posted 17 August 2010 - 14:26

I believe air planes operate with more laminar air flow than a F1 car, were they speculate in turbulence to get improvements or at least try to minimise the problems from it.

If you cut trough the turbulent air fast the turbulence would have less affect on the airflow over the wings, as the turbulence and its movement gets less time to move around on the surface.

Also the frequency the plane gets by the turbulence would increase i believe.

Just some thoughts.

#76 dosco

dosco
  • Member

  • 1,623 posts
  • Joined: June 02

Posted 17 August 2010 - 16:52

I believe air planes operate with more laminar air flow than a F1 car, were they speculate in turbulence to get improvements or at least try to minimise the problems from it.


Not sure about that ... many times the wind tunnel will give different answers than reality. Which may seem obvious, but until someone goes hunting for all the drag losses, particular areas of separation and turbulent flow may go unnoticed or unknown.

A nice example is the SR-71, after much investigation the team found areas of reverse flow near the intersection of the engine nacelle and inboard wing. They didn't find it in the wind tunnel, and only went looking for it when NASA embarked on a supersonic transport study with the SR-71 being the "test hack."

Another example is the aft end of the B-737 fuselage. Take a look at a modern B-737 (i.e. the "Next Generation" models 737-600 and above) and you will see a row of vortex generators on the tailcone, you will also note a strake over the APU intake. These were not present on earlier models.

If you cut trough the turbulent air fast the turbulence would have less affect on the airflow over the wings, as the turbulence and its movement gets less time to move around on the surface.

Also the frequency the plane gets by the turbulence would increase i believe.


Not sure where you are going with this, but I can say that the short period and long period modes of the airplane are major issues with regards to dynamic stability. The analysis invoved is not trivial, however I'm not sure I'd go around and say that airplanes are more complex than cars (and vice versa). Each have their issues.

Edited by dosco, 17 August 2010 - 16:54.


#77 dosco

dosco
  • Member

  • 1,623 posts
  • Joined: June 02

Posted 17 August 2010 - 16:56

FYI here is an interesting paper regarding the flight of birds ... some of the graphs illustrate the continuum of flight from insects through jumbo-jets.

Unfotunately she doesn't put racing cars in her graphs, but you should get the idea.

#78 Cxxx

Cxxx
  • Member

  • 53 posts
  • Joined: July 02

Posted 17 August 2010 - 18:22

Not sure about that ... many times the wind tunnel will give different answers than reality. Which may seem obvious, but until someone goes hunting for all the drag losses, particular areas of separation and turbulent flow may go unnoticed or unknown.

A nice example is the SR-71, after much investigation the team found areas of reverse flow near the intersection of the engine nacelle and inboard wing. They didn't find it in the wind tunnel, and only went looking for it when NASA embarked on a supersonic transport study with the SR-71 being the "test hack."

Another example is the aft end of the B-737 fuselage. Take a look at a modern B-737 (i.e. the "Next Generation" models 737-600 and above) and you will see a row of vortex generators on the tailcone, you will also note a strake over the APU intake. These were not present on earlier models.



Not sure where you are going with this, but I can say that the short period and long period modes of the airplane are major issues with regards to dynamic stability. The analysis invoved is not trivial, however I'm not sure I'd go around and say that airplanes are more complex than cars (and vice versa). Each have their issues.


Please note that I didn't say (or certainly mean!) that cars are more complex to design than aircraft, but that the flow patterns are usually more complex to model. Turbulent flow (by which I mean flow that varies with time) is always more complicated to model, and in fact most modelling systems are just a best estimate, if we're talking CFD. If we're talking wind tunnels, I think it's fair to say that aircraft can in general expect to spend a decent chunk of their flight time operating in something close to the flow conditions of a wind tunnel, while racing cars very rarely see those conditions. But aircraft design and aerodynamics can obviously be incredibly complex, in part because there are a lot more factors to take into consideration, and especially when you start getting into transonic and supersonic flight!

I think it is probably true to say aircraft deal more with laminar flow (than cars do), both on a boundary layer level and at a larger scale. I believe that some aircraft designs for example try to reduce drag by extending laminar boundary layers over a larger portion of the wings, whereas laminar boundary layers are rarely, if ever, seen on F1 cars. F1 design certainly does face the same issue though of finding problems on the full size car that are not seen in the wind tunnel!


#79 meb58

meb58
  • Member

  • 603 posts
  • Joined: May 09

Posted 17 August 2010 - 19:55

Not a question about aero per se, but don't we get an increase in tire growth and a huge increase in deflection at the contact patch? Among many things tires seem to pose an aero limitation of sorts... I've always though about that deflection as aero puches down on a car and how that flat spot getting ever flatter equates to advantageous gearing...?

Whether I have respect for engineers of the past is irrelevant (for the record, I do have an immense amount). But I think we'd both agree that the use of the word 'exactly' above is hyperbolic. I doubt they even knew the downforce within 10% with any confidence. Even in your example, is the car bottoming due to the downforce, or due to a bump in the road? Still, you're only getting a binary answer with a finite set of springs you have on hand. Throw in non-linear geometry (and bumpstops, as somebody mentioned), tire growth and spring rates at the given speed and camber, etc. and it simply takes more time to calculate than is worth it.

They'd be far more interested in what the stopwatch said than anything else. And it's not much different now, considering how little we really understand about tires.


Edited by meb58, 17 August 2010 - 19:58.


Advertisement

#80 Tony Matthews

Tony Matthews
  • Member

  • 17,519 posts
  • Joined: September 08

Posted 17 August 2010 - 22:06

...insects through jumbo-jets.

Anything on insects into windscreens?

#81 gruntguru

gruntguru
  • Member

  • 7,765 posts
  • Joined: January 09

Posted 17 August 2010 - 23:32

I believe air planes operate with more laminar air flow than a F1 car, were they speculate in turbulence to get improvements or at least try to minimise the problems from it.

If you cut trough the turbulent air fast the turbulence would have less affect on the airflow over the wings, as the turbulence and its movement gets less time to move around on the surface.

Also the frequency the plane gets by the turbulence would increase i believe.

When discussing turbulent vs laminar flow, the turbulence is small scale - eddies much smaller than the flow length. When discussing aircraft turbulence of the nauseating kind, the turbulence is large scale.