84 replies to this topic

[Jovanotti]

Here we go guys, sorry that it took a bit longer. Thanks again to everyone participating and making for a slightly shorter off-season . The "Don't change the template"-rule needs some serious tweaking (or rather enforcement) for next year I guess, but for now I've included also the strongly altered ones because of the sheer amount of creativity. You may consider this in your vote if you want and only give points to designs which are on the template.
 

 

Please pick your three favourites (none of your own entries) and rank them - the first place will get 3 points/second 2 points/third 1 point.

(If you can't be bothered to pick more than one, your single vote will simply count three points)

 

Voting is open until 22th of February.

 

 

Liveries by order of submission:

 

#1 Fox Polaris Racing Team by Icetrala

#2 by Ducks

 

 

#3 by Sheepmachine

 

#4 Bob Marley GP by Disgrace

#5 Porsche Formula 1 Team by Speedoholic

#6 Haas F1 by Knot

 

#7 NSA F1 by Disgrace

 

#8 Caterham F1 by DampMongoose

 

#9 Scumbag F1 Team by ninetyzero

 

#10 by ollebompa

#11 by fZero

#12 by DampMongoose

 

#13 by Anja

#14 by Ducks

#15 Skoda Factory Team by Vepe1995

#16 McLaren-Honda by Denaris

#17 by Sheepmachine

 

#18 by automovelbrilhante

 

#19 by automovelbrilhante

 

#20 by Radoye

#21 by Anja

#22 by August (and a non-alcohol-sponsorship variation)

Edited by Jovanotti, 09 February 2015 - 11:10.

[Jovanotti]

Part II
 

#23 by automovelbrilhante

 

#24 by Jackmancer

#25 by DampMongoose

 

#26 by Owen

#27 by geoffd

#28 by Disgrace

#29 by Sheepmachine

 

#30 by DampMongoose

#31 by automovelbrilhante

 

#32 by automovelbrilhante

 

#33 by automovelbrilhante (and variation)

#34 by automovelbrilhante

 

#35 by automovelbrilhante

 

#36 by Frood

#37 by RottenAli (and variation)

 

#38 by Frood

#39 by SaveTheRing

#40 Tic Tac AMR by MatthewA

#41 by automovelbrilhante (and variation)

 

#42 by automovelbrilhante

 

#43 by automovelbrilhante

[Jovanotti]

Part III

 

#44 by automovelbrilhante

#45 by automovelbrilhante (and variation)

#46 Team Alonso by Lotusseven

#47 by Lotusseven

#48 by danmills

 

#49 Tango-Foxtrott Racing by Donkey

#50 by Tenmantaylor

#51 by Lemans (and variations)

#52 by Lemans (and variations)

 

#53 by Lemans (and variations)

#54 by Lemans (and variations)

#55 by Lemans (and variation)

#56 by Lemans

#57 by August

 

#58 CM-02 by jonpollak

Edited by Jovanotti, 11 February 2015 - 06:56.

[Jovanotti]

Oh yeah, and my votes:

 

1st: the McLaren-Honda by Denaris #16

2nd: Anja's beautiful Peugeot #13

3rd: the Skoda factory team #15

[Anja]

#36

#40

#22

[BrokenBaculum]

My first vote is #20 by Radoye

 

Second is #22 by August (both liveries)

 

And third is #36 by Frood.

[ollebompa]

1st: The Audi E-tron #14

2nd: Castrol/7-up-Hyundai #36

3rd: Sony-Peugeot #13

Edited by ollebompa, 09 February 2015 - 16:07.

[Disgrace]

#3, #13, #26.

[Gilles4Ever]

16

15

31

[item3785]

#16, #20, #23

[Lotusseven]

1. #16 

2. #38

3. #13

[Beamer]

#16 by FAR!
#5 nice porche
#14 audi would be nice too

[Radoye]

#40

#52

#13

[SealTheDiffuser]

#18  / #10 / #25

[DinocoBlue]

#16

#40

#42

[DampMongoose]

Good Evening Jovanotti, this is Mongoose calling.   A big thankyou for all your hard work with such a splendid competition...

 

Anyway, on with the voting... here are the results of the Mongoose jury...

 

In third place... #56 Olivetti Alfa Romeo, One point!  En troisième place ... #56 Olivetti Alfa Romeo , un point.

 

 

In second place...#13 Sony Peugeot, Two points!  En deuxième place ... #13 Sony Peugeot , les points Deux .

 

 

In first place... #3 My Wooly Earth Sheep Dreams, Three points!!!  En premier lieu ... #  Rêves de moutons Mon Wooly Terre , Trois points !!!

[Donkey]

1st - #3 - Baa!

2nd - #46 - Alonso would be proud.

3rd - #29 - F1 should do a special race at Christmas.

 

Honourable mentions to:

 

#16 - Looks like this may win based on votes cast so far, and it is nice, but I think this is too close to being a fantasy livery with the sponsors and colours.

#35 - Very clever but outside the template and a gif.

#58 - Very creative but outside the template

[Nonesuch]

Third: #38 by Frood - I'm partial to the black/white/red colour scheme, and this case is a good example of that combination.
Second: #13 by Anja - This seemed rather simplistic at first, but I think it could work. It's a shame the template doesn't allow us to see the top side of the nose, because I think the added white would balance it out quite nicely.
First: #36 by Frood - Thanks to the combination of the sponsor logo's and the livery itself, I'm sure this car would be instantly recognizable.
 
Honourable mention: #14 by Ducks - A nice adaptation of the Audi WEC livery to the F1 template.

 

Thanks Jovanotti, and of course to all the participants, for keeping this tradition going!

Edited by Nonesuch, 09 February 2015 - 16:27.

[automovelbrilhante]

Was going to vote #16, but no need... It's the unrealistic shoeshine that's doing the trick. : P  No, that's just my Kanye West moment. Clever design, like the ones in the megathread. 'grats Denaris.

 

Without further ado: #8 #47 #54 (a bit random, on the minimalist side, from a list of 10+)

 

Well done everyone, special commendations (props) to Jovanotti. BTW I think MatthewA's Gulf livery is missing?  

Edited by automovelbrilhante, 09 February 2015 - 23:10.

[muramasa]

#43

#3

#58

[Jovanotti]

BTW I think MatthewA's Gulf livery is missing?

Yup, because it really is too close to the original Gulf livery imo.

[Imateria]

I'll go for these:

 

1. Tequila Patron #45

2. Fox Polaris Racing #1

3. Porsche Formula 1 Team #5

[Ducks]

*16

**14

***53

[geoffd]

1. 40

2. 21

3. 36

 

And my thanks to Jovanotti.

 

Geoff

[Maustinsj]

No. 50

No. 12

No. 8

 

In that order.

[Cirta]

First place: #40, hit a soft spot!

Second place: #13, simple, lovely

Third place: #36, just a nicely put together car with matching sponsors and company colours!

 

Cheers for all the nice designs!

[MatthewA]

Yup, because it really is too close to the original Gulf livery imo.

 

That's no problem with me

 

Anyway, votes time!

1st - #16

2nd - #45

3rd - #13

 

Honorable mentions: #3, #8, #22, #36, #41, #42, #48, #54, #56

 

Edited by MatthewA, 09 February 2015 - 21:59.

[Sukhoi]

1st - #9

2nd - #22

3rd - #35

[P123]

1- 45
2- 14
3- 10

[arebin]

1st 53
2nd 50
3rd 12

Edited by arebin, 09 February 2015 - 22:30.

[DanardiF1]

1st - #50 - stunning and something that whilst is 'retro' is so classy that it doesn't come as too nostalgic.

 

2nd - #13 - Nice clean lines and good use of the Peugeot motorsport colours, why they never used these on the 908 LMP cars I don't know...

 

3rd - #56 - Simple and effective, and very nice integration of the sponsor into the livery.

[YoungGun]

1st - 40

2nd - 50

3rd - 51

[DinosaursRoarForHugs]

1st - #3 (brilliant as the others are, this made me laugh the most and is unforgettable)

2nd - #11 

3rd - #16

[ninetyzero]

1. #45

2. #36

3. #38

 

[Sheepmachine]

1.#58
2.#48
3.#25
This was a fun competition to be a part of. Good luck to all!!

[jonpollak]

#58 - Very creative but outside the template

 

Ahh..but it isn't you see...I made sure the design team kept to the template.

Pollock would be silly to flounder around and let y'all carp on had you smelt something fishy.

Nope, everything is in it's proper plaice.

Jp

[RottenAli]

Really enjoyed this competition, thanks for the chance to put forward my votes.

In reverse order, I want to credit everyone, so I must start with a "OMG what were you thinking of?" Sorry, harsh of me but my round up of those in my view who fell a little too short...
3, 10, 11, 17, 25, 29, 44, 48 & 58.

Not my cup of tea... 5, 6, 8, 28, 32, 33 & 34.

Good but a bit too over designed... 18, 19, 23, 43, 45 & 49.

Jolly good... 1, 24, 26, 30, 36, 39, 50, 51(top one), 52, 53, 54 & 55.

Really good... 4, 7, 12, 15, 20, 21, 41, 46, 47 & 57.

Exceptional. Just missed out on my favourite top three... 9(bit scumbaggy), 13(light blue curve needed to match the stripe), 14(needed a stronger red), 16(needed a car number), 27(love the big number roundell) 31(really? Whiskas?), 35(bit dark but I like it), 38(too McLaren) & 56(too Alonso).

3rd place, number 2, by Ducks, all works very well, Danny Ric' car number 3, new engine supplier, like it all.
2nd place, number 40, by MatthewA, really, really good. Tic Tac colours. JB #22. Only concern being like number 27, would Mercedes really supply an Aston Martin entry?
So...
In 1st place, it has to be number 22, by August, Kimi's Finlandia Vodka Audi car #7. August, you did well to also consider the situation of not being able to exploit marketing at some races and you provided a nicelly re-worked car for the non vodka scheme. In MS paint too - Top marks

Edited by RottenAli, 11 February 2015 - 01:17.

[RoboCAT]

1st is #23
2nd is #13
3rd is #16

[Andy35]

1. #3

2. #58

Edited by Andy35, 11 February 2015 - 07:19.

[Andy35]

I've just noticed that rather like the FIA engine rules the voting rules are quite lax and as long as I vote by 22nd I can do as many votes as I want.

 

So I'd like to vote again also please

 

1. #3

2. #58

 

[Andy35]

I'd also like to vote in the reverse order, as I like Sheep and Jon equally

 

1.#58

2 #3

 

Hopefully the prize for either will be some colouring lessons down the local technical college
 

[Jovanotti]

I think I might just decide that the last entry gets double points this year (that's what Jon was aiming for from the start anyway I suppose).

Edited by Jovanotti, 11 February 2015 - 07:46.

[rghojai]

1: 13, 2: 40, 3: 45

[Jarulas]

#16

#23

#3 

[Zava]

1: #50
2: #15

3: #38

[DampMongoose]

Really enjoyed this competition, thanks for the chance to put forward my votes.

In reverse order, I want to credit everyone, so I must start with a "OMG what were you thinking of?" Sorry, harsh of me but my round up of those in my view who fell a little too short...
3, 10, 11, 17, 25, 29, 44, 48 & 58.

Not my cup of tea... 5, 6, 8, 28, 32, 33 & 34.

Good but a bit too over designed... 18, 19, 23, 43, 45 & 49.

Jolly good... 1, 24, 26, 30, 36, 39, 50, 51(top one), 52, 53, 54 & 55.

Really good... 4, 7, 12, 15, 20, 21, 41, 46, 47 & 57.

Exceptional. Just missed out on my favourite top three... 9(bit scumbaggy), 13(light blue curve needed to match the stripe), 14(needed a stronger red), 16(needed a car number), 27(love the big number roundell) 31(really? Whiskas?), 35(bit dark but I like it), 38(too McLaren) & 56(too Alonso).

3rd place, number 2, by Ducks, all works very well, Danny Ric' car number 3, new engine supplier, like it all.
2nd place, number 40, by MatthewA, really, really good. Tic Tac colours. JB #22. Only concern being like number 27, would Mercedes really supply an Aston Martin entry?
So...
In 1st place, it has to be number 22, by August, Kimi's Finlandia Vodka Audi car #7. August, you did well to also consider the situation of not being able to exploit marketing at some races and you provided a nicelly re-worked car for the non vodka scheme. In MS paint too - Top marks

 

I feel obligated to defend the #25 Granny Smith entry, you have mistakenly listed under the "OMG what were you thinking of?" section. If you had read the thread you would have seen the following post:

 

 

RCRC, on 21 Dec 2014 - 21:05, said:

 

 

How about an Apple inspired design?

 

 

A clear design brief which was fulfilled in 'only' 13 hours. Personally, I think I nailed it!

[midgrid]

#16, #40, #50

[molpid]

TOP 3:

 

#13 by Anja
#14 by Ducks

#50 by Tenmantaylor

 

Kill it with fire award:

 

#58 CM-02 by jonpollak

 

[Alexis*27]

This contest is moot (or it would be if there was a cow themed car). There is only one winner:

 

#3 by Sheepmachine

Edited by Alexis*27, 11 February 2015 - 10:18.

[RedBaron]

1. #32 by automovelbrilhante
2. #16 McLaren-Honda by Denaris
3. #55 by Lemans

Edited by RedBaron, 11 February 2015 - 10:30.