The Autosport podcast and Kevin Turner have recently been doing a series of top tens related to the BTCC which I found really interesting and worth a discussion.
The first one was the top ten BTCC champions, effectively the GOAT debate for BTCC, and this was the list:
10. Matt Neal
9. Fabrizio Giovanardi
8. Yvan Muller
7. Jim Clark
6. Frank Gardner
5. Alain Menu
4. Jason Plato
3. Colin Turkington
2. Ash Sutton
1. Andy Rouse
In this episode, the guests Marcus Simmons and David Addison both suggested that Alain Menu should be top of the list and I can see an argument for this. I would certainly have him above Plato and Turkington and although my knowledge of pre-1991 BTCC is not fantastic, I also think Rouse should drop a few places. But I really think Ash Sutton is something special and even though he is early in his career, I think I would put him at the top of the list of greatest BTCC drivers. I said he should be close to it in 2021 and was sure that he would eventually find his way to the top, and by now I think that has happened. So I would have Sutton top and Menu second. The glaring absence from the list, in my opinion, is Rickard Rydell who I would probably rate as the fastest BTCC driver over one lap, certainly since 1991 (I have watched every BTCC race since 1991 but not many beforehand). He wasn't as complete as Menu but I think I would have him in the top five. I would also have Giovanardi a bit higher and would leave Neal off the list.
There was also a top ten drivers from the super touring era:
10. Steve Soper
9. Tim Harvey
8. James Thompson
7. Gabriele Tarquini
6. Joachim Winkelhock
5. Frank Biela
4. Laurent Aiello
3. John Cleland
2. Rickard Rydell
1. Alain Menu
For this ranking, I agree that Menu and Rydell should be the top two, and think they were a step ahead of the rest in this era. Arguably, the 2000 season in the Fords was a shoot-out between the two top drivers and while Rydell was generally faster in qualifying, Menu won the championship, and so I would have Menu ahead as the more complete driver but with Rydell the fastest and definitely deserving of second spot. But my main disagreement with this ranking is their decision to leave Anthony Reid in the 'honourable mentions.' I believe that Ford didn't just have the two best drivers of the era in their 2000 super-team, they had all three of them with Anthony Reid as well and I would place him third on this list. I think Reid measured up similarly against David Leslie in 1998 as Aiello did in 1999, and Aiello is near the top despite just one season. Then in 2000 he beat Rydell in the championship. I think Reid was super quick and consistent and would have him at number three after Menu and Rydell. Cleland is a bit too high, in my opinion, although he was the best driver of the start of the era, and I would drop Frank Biela down as he wasn't as clear of John Bintcliffe as Yvan Muller was in 1998. And Steve Soper at his best was the super touring era's greatest driver, with his drive at Silverstone in 1992 the most impressive that I think has been seen in the championship right up until he took out Cleland, but he only did one full season in the era, which was a disappointment as he was beaten by Winkelhock, so I am not sure I would include him. For what it's worth, my top ten would be Menu, Rydell, Reid, Aiello, Cleland, Winkelhock, Thompson, Tarquini, Muller, Biela.
And the third that I have listened to would be the top ten title deciders:
10. Brands Hatch 1958
9. Brands Hatch 2013
8. Brands Hatch 1977
7. Brands Hatch 1966
6. Silverstone 2000
5. Brands Hatch 2015
4. Brands Hatch 2019
3. Donington Park 2004
2. Brands Hatch 2009
1. Silverstone 1992
I think this was a nice podcast to listen to and would disagree with very little of the order. The only change I would make would be to remove 2013 which I don't think was a classic because it was clear early in the race that Jordan would win it, and so I would replace it with 2016 where Shedden had to pass Tordoff on track to take the title. 1958 is such an interesting and unique story that it has to make the list, but I had never heard of the 1966 or 1977 races but were very glad that I now have done because they were fascinating stories. I would suggest that 1977 sounded the better of the two but would elevate both above 2000. The top five were all great and I would probably have them in that exact order, except maybe demoting 2004 a bit because I didn't find it as memorable as the others. 2009 was perhaps my favourite ever season and had an incredible final day and final race in particular, but there is no way that 1992 can not be top of the list, that was one of the absolute best races in the history of any motorsport for so many reasons.
There are also rankings for the top ten BTCC cars, non-champions and liveries which I am yet to listen to, but so far I have really enjoyed this series and would recommend it to other BTCC fans. I would be interested to know how other people would shuffle these lists around.