Javascript Disabled Detected

You currently have javascript disabled. Several functions may not work. Please re-enable javascript to access full functionality.

F1 2024 Media driver ratings

Started by Ivanhoe , Mar 04 2024 11:50

Prev

Please log in to reply

110 replies to this topic

#101 jcbc3

RC Forum Host

12,978 posts
Joined: November 04

Posted 22 April 2024 - 12:12

Re Autosport: That's a generous score for Stroll

Re AMUS: Stroll not worst? Can't say I agree. Nice story for Zhou. As good as Bottas? Nope. Magnussen (through gritted teeth) also too high a score.

Re The Race: Usual gripe. Straw is controversial for controversiality's sake. Norris was the star peformer. And if you believe Verstappen is, I accept that. But Norris only third? Yes, he hung out too long with Lewis. The rest of his weekend was a 10.

Back to top

#102 Heyli

RC Forum Host

8,846 posts
Joined: May 17

Posted 22 April 2024 - 14:04

Re Autosport: That's a generous score for Stroll

Re AMUS: Stroll not worst? Can't say I agree. Nice story for Zhou. As good as Bottas? Nope. Magnussen (through gritted teeth) also too high a score.

Re The Race: Usual gripe. Straw is controversial for controversiality's sake. Norris was the star peformer. And if you believe Verstappen is, I accept that. But Norris only third? Yes, he hung out too long with Lewis. The rest of his weekend was a 10.

I also dont understand why the Ferrari boys are so high with the Race...

Back to top

#103 southernstars

Member

2,207 posts
Joined: February 23

Posted 23 April 2024 - 08:25

Re Autosport: That's a generous score for Stroll

Re AMUS: Stroll not worst? Can't say I agree. Nice story for Zhou. As good as Bottas? Nope. Magnussen (through gritted teeth) also too high a score.

Re The Race: Usual gripe. Straw is controversial for controversiality's sake. Norris was the star peformer. And if you believe Verstappen is, I accept that. But Norris only third? Yes, he hung out too long with Lewis. The rest of his weekend was a 10.

AMUS definitely has some kind of "always rate Sargeant last no matter what anyone else does" challenge going on.

Back to top

#104 Ali623

Member

3,555 posts
Joined: March 18

Posted 23 April 2024 - 08:32

The Race - Edd Straw's Chinese GP driver rankings

(race weekend performance)

1st - Verstappen

2nd - Leclerc

3rd - Norris

4th - Sainz

5th - Hulkenberg

6th - Russell

7th - Gasly

8th - Ocon

9th - Hamilton

10th - Albon

11th - Alonso

12th - Perez

13th - Bottas

14th - Ricciardo

15th - Piastri

16th - Zhou

17th - Magnussen

18th - Sargeant

19th - Tsunoda

20th - Stroll

Edd's justification for Gasly ahead of Ocon was because Ocon had the upgrades and Gasly didn't, completely ignoring the fact that Ocon outperformed Gasly in every session except sprint qualifying. (As he has done all season so far regardless of upgrades)

Back to top

#105 DW46

Member

1,861 posts
Joined: December 21

Posted 23 April 2024 - 08:37

Automated top half rating for Alex Albon cause he’s always free for interviews. Also known as the Paul Di Resta approach.

Back to top

#106 ARTGP

Member

29,814 posts
Joined: March 19

Posted 23 April 2024 - 20:48

Autosport's Chinese GP driver ratings

(race weekend performance)

Verstappen - 9

Norris - 9

Hulkenberg - 8

Leclerc - 7

Sainz - 7

Russell - 7

Alonso - 7

Hamilton - 7

Ocon - 7

Bottas - 7

Piastri - 6

Albon - 6

Gasly - 6

Zhou - 6

Ricciardo - 6

Perez - 5

Tsunoda - 5

Magnussen - 4

Sargeant - 4

Stroll - 3

Harsh on Perez. He didn't crash. Finished on podium in all races. Qualified 2nd for the GP. It wasn't "out of this world", but a 5? unserious :lol:

Edited by ARTGP, 23 April 2024 - 20:50.

Back to top

#107 SenorSjon

Member

17,651 posts
Joined: March 12

Posted 24 April 2024 - 07:42

Harsh on Perez. He didn't crash. Finished on podium in all races. Qualified 2nd for the GP. It wasn't "out of this world", but a 5? unserious

Without the SC's, he would probably be gapped by 35-40s. And he didn't finish 2nd in either Sprint or Race.

Back to top

#108 selespeed

Member

1,195 posts
Joined: May 05

Posted 24 April 2024 - 07:51

without sc he would have finished 2nd...he had a double non-drs overtake in sprint (:-))...two non-drs overtakes in a race...

Back to top

#109 Astandahl

Member

5,599 posts
Joined: June 18

Posted 24 April 2024 - 09:14

Harsh on Perez. He didn't crash. Finished on podium in all races. Qualified 2nd for the GP. It wasn't "out of this world", but a 5? unserious

Not more than 6. He had a car capable of finishing P2 easily in both races and failed to do so.

He made a huge mistake in sprint quali in the last corner losing 2s and therefore P2. Couldn't overtake slower cars in the sprint races which didn't allow him to reach Hamilton and was overperformed by Norris in a slower car in the main race.

Edited by Astandahl, 24 April 2024 - 09:15.

Back to top

#110 MikeTekRacing

Member

12,310 posts
Joined: October 04

Posted 24 April 2024 - 15:19

Not more than 6. He had a car capable of finishing P2 easily in both races and failed to do so.

He made a huge mistake in sprint quali in the last corner losing 2s and therefore P2. Couldn't overtake slower cars in the sprint races which didn't allow him to reach Hamilton and was overperformed by Norris in a slower car in the main race.

Nobody was overtaking in DRS trains.

In the main race he was not stellar, but also unlucky with the SC

Back to top

#111 MikeTekRacing

Member

12,310 posts
Joined: October 04

Posted 24 April 2024 - 15:22

Without the SC's, he would probably be gapped by 35-40s. And he didn't finish 2nd in either Sprint or Race.

he wouldn't have been gapped that much.

Without the SC he wouldn't have messed his tyres having to overtake cars. Unable to follow in S2 through the fast corners (so sliding them around) wrecked his tyres. He had to overtake at the end of S1 non DRS