Jump to content


Photo
* * * * - 13 votes

Scuderia Ferrari 2026 team thread


  • Please log in to reply
23093 replies to this topic

#23051 KWSN - DSM

KWSN - DSM
  • Member

  • 44,515 posts
  • Joined: January 03

Posted 14 November 2026 - 12:33

The English against Italian depth of knowledge and ability to field and run a competitive F1 team is a nonsense argument, they have as qualified engineers in Italy as they have in the UK, there are a mix of many nationalities at Ferrari, Mercedes, Red Bull.

 

This may not be the proper thread for it but since we are having the discussion - Top dog in the F1 teams

Team	        Team Principal	    Nationality
Mercedes	Toto Wolff	    Austrian
McLaren	        Andrea Stella	    Italian
Red Bull Racing	Laurent Mekies	    French
Ferrari	        Fred Vasseur	    French
Williams	James Vowles	    British
Racing Bulls	Alan Permane	    British
Aston Martin	Adrian Newey	    British
Haas	        Ayao Komatsu	    Japanese
Audi	        Mattia Binotto	    Italian
Alpine	        Flavio Briatore	    Italian
Cadillac	Marcin Budkowski    Polish


Advertisement

#23052 vlado

vlado
  • Member

  • 11,337 posts
  • Joined: September 06

Posted 14 November 2026 - 12:50

This may not be the proper thread for it but since we are having the discussion - Top dog in the F1 teams

Team	        Team Principal	    Nationality
Mercedes	Toto Wolff	    Austrian
McLaren	        Andrea Stella	    Italian
Red Bull Racing	Laurent Mekies	    French
Ferrari	        Fred Vasseur	    French
Williams	James Vowles	    British
Racing Bulls	Alan Permane	    British
Aston Martin	Adrian Newey	    British
Haas	        Ayao Komatsu	    Japanese
Audi	        Mattia Binotto	    Italian
Alpine	        Flavio Briatore	    Italian
Cadillac	Marcin Budkowski    Polish
You would need to look at the engineering staff and the whole point isn’t nationality but rather “networking” which promotes exchange of knowledge and ideas.

Silicon Valley isn’t made up of just American citizens, but everyone knows the benefits of attracting a large number of top software and hardware engineers from around the world and having them in close proximity geographically.

Even football went through something very similar in the 80s/90s with Central Europe becoming the hub and birthplace of modern football tactics, etc.


Exchange of technical knowledge amongst F1 teams by means of top tier engineering staff jumping from team to team and attracting engineers from all over the world is the main benefit of that Oxfordshire, Northamptonshire, and Buckinghamshire cluster that people refer to as “Motorsport valley”

It’s really hard to compete against. I’d say almost impossible, which is why what Ferrari was able to do in the late 90s early 2000s was absolutely incredible, but I don’t think Motorsport Valley was as well established as it is today.

Let’s see what Audi can do, but I think they are more or less “doomed” and that project won’t amount to much. Maybe one odd title if they get lucky, but a sustained dominance? Extremely unlikely.

Edited by vlado, 14 November 2026 - 12:52.


#23053 Sterzo

Sterzo
  • Member

  • 7,896 posts
  • Joined: September 11

Posted 14 November 2026 - 15:29

You would need to look at the engineering staff and the whole point isn’t nationality but rather “networking” which promotes exchange of knowledge and ideas.
 

I think you're agreeing furiously with KWSN-DSM. He, you, I and others are saying: team members' nationality doesn't matter.



#23054 KWSN - DSM

KWSN - DSM
  • Member

  • 44,515 posts
  • Joined: January 03

Posted 14 November 2026 - 15:42

I think you're agreeing furiously with KWSN-DSM. He, you, I and others are saying: team members' nationality doesn't matter.

 

I say that, and I say that teams can be located outside the UK without having to be sneered for drawbacks they place themselves in.



#23055 nemanja

nemanja
  • Member

  • 4,681 posts
  • Joined: April 14

Posted 14 November 2026 - 15:56

Ferrari: the engine’s combustion side was a real problem in 2026, leaving the team well beyond 4% behind. Maranello did, however, manage to limit the consequences of that deficit by working on hybrid energy management.
 
Progressive software optimization improved energy usage and helped the team regain performance over the course of the season. The lack of power remained a handicap, but being a manufacturer gave Ferrari the means to respond and salvage a season that could have been far more difficult.
 
@GiulyDuchessa
 

Edited by nemanja, 14 November 2026 - 16:13.


#23056 Counterbalance

Counterbalance
  • Member

  • 1,934 posts
  • Joined: May 15

Posted 14 November 2026 - 15:58

I say that, and I say that teams can be located outside the UK without having to be sneered for drawbacks they place themselves in.


That's a much.

#23057 vlado

vlado
  • Member

  • 11,337 posts
  • Joined: September 06

Posted 14 November 2026 - 17:10

I say that, and I say that teams can be located outside the UK without having to be sneered for drawbacks they place themselves in.


If you look at who’s been winning the majority of WCC titles in Formula 1 for the past 30 years you will quickly find out that teams outside “Motorsport Valley” win far less overall.

Of course, there are far less of them, but Ferrari and Toyota are solid examples, and now we await Audi’s inevitable demise of course.

#23058 Raest

Raest
  • Member

  • 1,922 posts
  • Joined: August 14

Posted 14 November 2026 - 20:37

 

Ferrari: the engine’s combustion side was a real problem in 2026, leaving the team well beyond 4% behind. Maranello did, however, manage to limit the consequences of that deficit by working on hybrid energy management.
 
Progressive software optimization improved energy usage and helped the team regain performance over the course of the season. The lack of power remained a handicap, but being a manufacturer gave Ferrari the means to respond and salvage a season that could have been far more difficult.
 
@GiulyDuchessa
 

 

I'll digress a bit but in the article Duchessa clearly states that the 2026 projects started in 2022. Vasseur became Ferrari's TP in the start of 2023. Can we therefore stop blaming him for the engine performance? There are plenty of other issues to blame him for. 



#23059 baddog

baddog
  • Member

  • 32,131 posts
  • Joined: June 99

Posted 15 November 2026 - 00:07

In the end, Its all been aboyt the engine.

 

All the talk of drivers, strategy, operations etc.. is all deckchairs on the Titanic stuff.

 

The engine department failed to deliver, hell the rest of the operation has in fact been immensely successful when you consider the deficit they have been facing, but the actual big prizes are not obtainable with the engine no matter who drives or runs the race team.

 

Management can of course be blamed for the engine side, that's entirely fair.



Advertisement

#23060 BleuMurmure

BleuMurmure
  • Member

  • 1,216 posts
  • Joined: June 22

Posted 15 November 2026 - 05:55

In the end, Its all been aboyt the engine.

 

All the talk of drivers, strategy, operations etc.. is all deckchairs on the Titanic stuff.

 

The engine department failed to deliver, hell the rest of the operation has in fact been immensely successful when you consider the deficit they have been facing, but the actual big prizes are not obtainable with the engine no matter who drives or runs the race team.

 

Management can of course be blamed for the engine side, that's entirely fair.

I disagree, some of these things are independent of each other.

 

They need to sort out the driver situation, they will have the same pairing next year, no Bottas for Hamilton, or Barrichello for Leclerc.

Same for race engineer comms, strategy, track ops. Are these areas where they execute well? I don't think so, but Vasseur sees no problems and that's a problem. :)

 

Serra did a good job. Can he keep the aero advantage in 2027 with the FTM going away?

 

As for the engine. It's convenient to blame Zimmermann for everything and yes, engine design has a long lead time. 

But the ADUO 1 and 2 upgrades failed to deliver and the same team will work on a 'new concept' for 2027. I have my doubts.


Edited by BleuMurmure, 15 November 2026 - 05:56.


#23061 baddog

baddog
  • Member

  • 32,131 posts
  • Joined: June 99

Posted 15 November 2026 - 05:58

I disagree, some of these things are independent of each other.

 

They need to sort out the driver situation, they will have the same pairing next year, no Bottas for Hamilton, or Barrichello for Leclerc.

Same for race engineer comms, strategy, track ops. Are these areas where they execute well? I don't think so, but Vasseur sees no problems and that's a problem. :)

 

Serra did a good job. Can he keep the aero advantage in 2027 with the FTM going away?

 

AS for the engine. It's convenient to blame Zimmermann for everything and yes, engine design had a long lead time. 

But the ADUO 1 and 2 upgrades failed to deliver and the same team will work on a 'new concept' for 2027. I have my doubts.

 

Oh I'm not saying those other criticisms aren't real, I'm saying they make no difference to the result here, which is a car that cannot hope to win either championship with that engine whatever the race team and driver do with it.

 

I have little faith next year can be much better also.



#23062 vlado

vlado
  • Member

  • 11,337 posts
  • Joined: September 06

Posted 15 November 2026 - 06:14


Ferrari: the engine’s combustion side was a real problem in 2026, leaving the team well beyond 4% behind. Maranello did, however, manage to limit the consequences of that deficit by working on hybrid energy management.

Progressive software optimization improved energy usage and helped the team regain performance over the course of the season. The lack of power remained a handicap, but being a manufacturer gave Ferrari the means to respond and salvage a season that could have been far more difficult.

@GiulyDuchessa

https://autoracer.it...re-costruttore/


And people still think that Verstappen would’ve traded his Red Bull for the SF26…

#23063 jonpollak

jonpollak
  • Member

  • 53,061 posts
  • Joined: March 00

Posted 15 November 2026 - 11:48

Lewis on his past relationship.

https://x.com/otun_s...gIrIusoxwk&s=46

Jp

#23064 vlado

vlado
  • Member

  • 11,337 posts
  • Joined: September 06

Posted 15 November 2026 - 11:53

Maybe this is what Antonelli was talking about

IMG-7940.jpg

#23065 tyker

tyker
  • Member

  • 1,859 posts
  • Joined: April 11

Posted 15 November 2026 - 11:58

Maybe this is what Antonelli was talking about

IMG-7940.jpg

That will also help with the races being slightly shorter next year.



#23066 monolulu

monolulu
  • Member

  • 3,760 posts
  • Joined: March 10

Posted 15 November 2026 - 13:04

Lewis on his past relationship.

https://x.com/otun_s...gIrIusoxwk&s=46

Jp

I don’t think so!



#23067 FLB

FLB
  • Member

  • 42,332 posts
  • Joined: February 01

Posted 15 November 2026 - 13:10

I don’t think so!

Yeah. He wasn't on Graham Norton's guest list this week: BBC One - The Graham Norton Show - Episode guide

 

(I can't believe I just posted that  :eek:  :lol:)



#23068 SCUDmissile

SCUDmissile
  • Member

  • 9,740 posts
  • Joined: May 11

Posted 15 November 2026 - 13:34

Lewis on his past relationship.

https://x.com/otun_s...gIrIusoxwk&s=46

Jp


AI slop

#23069 jonpollak

jonpollak
  • Member

  • 53,061 posts
  • Joined: March 00

Posted 15 November 2026 - 13:49

Sorry folks.
It sounded fairly plausible…

Deduct points as required…

Jp

#23070 vlado

vlado
  • Member

  • 11,337 posts
  • Joined: September 06

Posted 15 November 2026 - 15:03

That will also help with the races being slightly shorter next year.


Right and the teams and drivers will have to recalibrate and adjust.

Antonelli only mentioned the front tires so I wonder if they are only changing those and rears remain the same? Sounds kinda of crazy but I don’t know

#23071 Bendo

Bendo
  • Member

  • 913 posts
  • Joined: July 20

Posted 15 November 2026 - 16:34

As for the engine. It's convenient to blame Zimmermann for everything and yes, engine design has a long lead time.
But the ADUO 1 and 2 upgrades failed to deliver and the same team will work on a 'new concept' for 2027. I have my doubts.


There is no new concept. Engine rules are clear there engine is effectively frozen. Some changes are permitted mainly related to intake and obviously Ferrari still have 2 ADUO changes, but it's tweaks to the current engine no radical new concept.

No idea where the new concept talk that keeps on being spouted in this thread comes from.

#23072 flyboym3

flyboym3
  • Member

  • 2,494 posts
  • Joined: July 21

Posted 15 November 2026 - 19:20

In the end, Its all been aboyt the engine.

All the talk of drivers, strategy, operations etc.. is all deckchairs on the Titanic stuff.

The engine department failed to deliver, hell the rest of the operation has in fact been immensely successful when you consider the deficit they have been facing, but the actual big prizes are not obtainable with the engine no matter who drives or runs the race team.

Management can of course be blamed for the engine side, that's entirely fair.

Strong disagree and the wrong mindset I feel Vasseur is also hiding behind.

You know when Horner had a weak engine he optimised everything else he was in control of. Then when the just good enough engine came - bang they were ready for greatness because every other department was on top of their game.

With Vasseur/your mindset Ferrari could have an equal engine/aero performance car and they still wont bring it home because everything else is so poor.

Maybe they could bring the wdc home if they built a car that had a 2 tenths advantage but thats not the mindset they should approach with. It should be we have a car that is within 1 tenth of RBR and we can bring it home because we have optimised and execute well in every other area.

Vasseur exhibits whataboutery and isnt taking ownership.

Edited by flyboym3, 15 November 2026 - 19:21.


#23073 flyboym3

flyboym3
  • Member

  • 2,494 posts
  • Joined: July 21

Posted 15 November 2026 - 20:12


This may not be the proper thread for it but since we are having the discussion - Top dog in the F1 teams

Team	        Team Principal	    Nationality
Mercedes	Toto Wolff	    Austrian
McLaren	        Andrea Stella	    Italian
Red Bull Racing	Laurent Mekies	    French
Ferrari	        Fred Vasseur	    French
Williams	James Vowles	    British
Racing Bulls	Alan Permane	    British
Aston Martin	Adrian Newey	    British
Haas	        Ayao Komatsu	    Japanese
Audi	        Mattia Binotto	    Italian
Alpine	        Flavio Briatore	    Italian
Cadillac	Marcin Budkowski    Polish
Ferrari like to primarily hire Italians. And while other teams will poach the best Italians Ferrari tends not to poach the best non Italians. This absolutely has to have an effect.

#23074 Bliman

Bliman
  • Member

  • 13,795 posts
  • Joined: April 16

Posted 15 November 2026 - 20:51

So Ferrari doesn't operate in England? That makes it more difficult to hire the best imo. After all you rather like stay in the lights of the other teams by staying at close proximity of each other. Networking becomes much easier and you stay in the picture.

#23075 PrinceBira

PrinceBira
  • Member

  • 3,493 posts
  • Joined: October 24

Posted 15 November 2026 - 21:05

In the end, Its all been aboyt the engine.

All the talk of drivers, strategy, operations etc.. is all deckchairs on the Titanic stuff.

The engine department failed to deliver, hell the rest of the operation has in fact been immensely successful when you consider the deficit they have been facing, but the actual big prizes are not obtainable with the engine no matter who drives or runs the race team.

Management can of course be blamed for the engine side, that's entirely fair.


I don’t get this thinking.

Let’s do a thought experiment. We start 2026 from the beginning and this time Ferrari has a PU equal to RB and Mercedes.

Would all the other issues Ferrari has shown throughout the year magically be fixed?

#23076 baddog

baddog
  • Member

  • 32,131 posts
  • Joined: June 99

Posted 15 November 2026 - 21:42

I don’t get this thinking.

Let’s do a thought experiment. We start 2026 from the beginning and this time Ferrari has a PU equal to RB and Mercedes.

Would all the other issues Ferrari has shown throughout the year magically be fixed?

 

This year Ferrari built the best chassis and aero package out of the gate. So yes they would have immediately been in the championship race from day one, and yes a lot of the crap that happens would not have happened.

 

Over previous years? If you mean if they engine AND chassis teams both made a top tier car, then yes. Ferrari have extracted, for the most part, the results the car deserves. I cannot actually think of a year where they finished in a worse placing than the actual car deserves. Their drivers have been extremely effective, and pit mistakes and stuff, while not ideal, are no worse than those made by Mac or even Mercedes.

 

Mistakes, dumb strategic errors, infighting etc.. all happen far more when you are trying to win races you are not actually equipped to win. When you actually have the car suddenly you can just use straightforward strategies. You can even play silly arses like Mac did last year and still win. 

 

One area they could do better is politics when arguing the rules and managing the FIA enforcement and the like. Toto has been very effective there as Christian was.

 

Now could they improve everything and get better. They certainly could. But acting like they uniquely are a clownshow is in fact nonsense. Their engineering has simply never put a good enough car and engine package together at the same time. Everything else is jam on top.

 

They could go for a straight number one and hope their top star to overperform as Max has done but I hope they never do.



#23077 vlado

vlado
  • Member

  • 11,337 posts
  • Joined: September 06

Posted 15 November 2026 - 21:54

It’s significantly easier to avoid mistakes at the pit wall if you have a fast car.

#23078 Flyhigh

Flyhigh
  • Member

  • 4,816 posts
  • Joined: July 09

Posted 15 November 2026 - 21:57

In the end, Its all been aboyt the engine.

 

All the talk of drivers, strategy, operations etc.. is all deckchairs on the Titanic stuff.

 

The engine department failed to deliver, hell the rest of the operation has in fact been immensely successful when you consider the deficit they have been facing, but the actual big prizes are not obtainable with the engine no matter who drives or runs the race team.

 

Management can of course be blamed for the engine side, that's entirely fair.


It´s always something, last year was the aero/chassis, the other year deployment, etc.   I mention the same thing last year talking issues in isolation is missing the trees for the forrest.  



#23079 BleuMurmure

BleuMurmure
  • Member

  • 1,216 posts
  • Joined: June 22

Posted 15 November 2026 - 22:05

It’s significantly easier to avoid mistakes at the pit wall if you have a fast car.

maybe, but the teammate rivalry would be even more explosive if they were running for 1-2 instead of p5-6 regularly.



Advertisement

#23080 Bliman

Bliman
  • Member

  • 13,795 posts
  • Joined: April 16

Posted 15 November 2026 - 22:14

It’s significantly easier to avoid mistakes at the pit wall if you have a fast car.

if you have a superior car otherwise the pressure is the same or even higher.

#23081 baddog

baddog
  • Member

  • 32,131 posts
  • Joined: June 99

Posted 15 November 2026 - 23:41

It´s always something, last year was the aero/chassis, the other year deployment, etc.   I mention the same thing last year talking issues in isolation is missing the trees for the forrest.  

 

Yep its always something. The technical direction of the team has failed over and over. Best engine, crap aero. Best chassis, bad engine. Good both, bad tyre management. etc etc. Year after year.

 

I just think race operations and driver drama is being used as a convenient way to both push agendas and ignore the actual underlying issue which is design/development.



#23082 Wuzak

Wuzak
  • Member

  • 10,102 posts
  • Joined: September 00

Posted Yesterday, 02:11

There is no new concept. Engine rules are clear there engine is effectively frozen. Some changes are permitted mainly related to intake and obviously Ferrari still have 2 ADUO changes, but it's tweaks to the current engine no radical new concept.

No idea where the new concept talk that keeps on being spouted in this thread comes from.


From earlier in the thread:
 

Crankcase is ADUO.
Cylinder Head is ADUO, except for combustion chamber, ports, injection ports.
Camshaft is ADUO, but not camshaft profiles.
Water pumps, oild pumps, oil scavenge pumps, non-hydraulic actuators and valve air compressors which are mounted to the ICE can be changed only through ADUO.
 
PU mounted fuel system components downstream of high pressure pump can be upgraded with ADUO.
ICE fluid filters can be upgraded with ADUO.
High pressure pump and fuel injectors cannot be upgraded (fuel injection spray pattern tuning is free to upgrade).
 
Hydraulic syste actuators for PU control can be upgraded with ADUO.
 
All of these items are free to upgrade for 2028.



No, the crankcase, crankshaft, block, various covers, pumps and drives cannot be changed for 2027.
 
They can change the combustion chamber, including the cylinder head, piston con-rods, valve cam profiles, inlet and exhaust ports, intake air system (trumpets, plenum, etc), some other intake items, "injector spray pattern tuning feature" (but not fuel injectors), spark plugs, the turbo and exhaust system, wastegate and pop-off valve, fuel, oil, coolant and some sensors and filters.
 
Items that can be improved with ADUO allows upgrades to everything but injectors, high pressure fuel pump, some sensors, a couple of MGUK sensors, and the boost pressure sensor.
 
So they could, with ADUO, redesign most of the PU.
 
According to 2026 technical regulations, issue 19. They may have changed since then.


To summarise:

The combustion concept can be changed freely for 2027.

They can change the block/head design if they use an ADUO token.



#23083 vlado

vlado
  • Member

  • 11,337 posts
  • Joined: September 06

Posted Yesterday, 02:17

maybe, but the teammate rivalry would be even more explosive if they were running for 1-2 instead of p5-6 regularly.


Good!

#23084 vlado

vlado
  • Member

  • 11,337 posts
  • Joined: September 06

Posted Yesterday, 02:25

To summarise:
The combustion concept can be changed freely for 2027.
They can change the block/head design if they use an ADUO token.

That’s great news by in my opinion they are two years behind the English PU projects development wise, but despite that I don’t think they will be further behind in 2027 than they were in 2026, so if they get their chassis right and maybe get on top of the new tires, we might have a bit more fun in 2027.

2028/29 is probably when they will finally be on par or at least very close to the best PU on the grid.


Hopefully I’m wrong and they can make a huge jump this winter, but realistically that’s not how F1 works.

Audi and Honda are also on their way…

Edited by vlado, Yesterday, 02:26.


#23085 PrinceBira

PrinceBira
  • Member

  • 3,493 posts
  • Joined: October 24

Posted Yesterday, 10:34

This year Ferrari built the best chassis and aero package out of the gate. So yes they would have immediately been in the championship race from day one, and yes a lot of the crap that happens would not have happened.

 

Over previous years? If you mean if they engine AND chassis teams both made a top tier car, then yes. Ferrari have extracted, for the most part, the results the car deserves. I cannot actually think of a year where they finished in a worse placing than the actual car deserves. Their drivers have been extremely effective, and pit mistakes and stuff, while not ideal, are no worse than those made by Mac or even Mercedes.

 

Mistakes, dumb strategic errors, infighting etc.. all happen far more when you are trying to win races you are not actually equipped to win. When you actually have the car suddenly you can just use straightforward strategies. You can even play silly arses like Mac did last year and still win. 

 

One area they could do better is politics when arguing the rules and managing the FIA enforcement and the like. Toto has been very effective there as Christian was.

 

Now could they improve everything and get better. They certainly could. But acting like they uniquely are a clownshow is in fact nonsense. Their engineering has simply never put a good enough car and engine package together at the same time. Everything else is jam on top.

 

They could go for a straight number one and hope their top star to overperform as Max has done but I hope they never do.

 

This to me reads like the prevalent point I see in the Ferrari thread for years:

 

 Just fix 'X' or 'Y' and the rest will follow.

 

I don't see it like this at all. Structural embedded issues will surface in almost ALL scenarios, apart from the one where you have the fastest car by a large margin and there is enough buffer to mitigate the consequence of these structural issues.

 

Even with a on par PU this year, there would have been a lot of races where they wouldn't dominate, but would only win with very precise execution. We still would have communication issues pit-rider / rider-pit in scenarios where the pressure is on. We still would have fluctuations in form by Leclerc / Hamilton. We would have an even bigger internal fight between Hamilton / Leclerc if a WDC would be on the line, which would have escalated much sooner and much more violently. 

 

If you keep those root cause things lingering, they will always pop-up. 

 

Thinking that a magic bullet can fix 'everything else too' is a fantasy. 



#23086 Mosrite

Mosrite
  • Member

  • 1,162 posts
  • Joined: December 14

Posted Yesterday, 10:38

When does Hamilton's contract run out? I can't see him in Ferrari past next season, unless ferrari is back on top. He doesn't seem as liked as he would like to be within Ferrari and only wins can change that, not making drama out of everything else



#23087 vlado

vlado
  • Member

  • 11,337 posts
  • Joined: September 06

Posted Yesterday, 12:58

https://autoracer.it...in-ottica-2027/

“Leclerc and Hamilton will be focused primarily on results. Both have been given free rein to fight for second place in the Drivers’ Championship: a tough challenge against Russell and, above all, Verstappen.”

Good.

#23088 lewislorenzo

lewislorenzo
  • Member

  • 8,477 posts
  • Joined: March 14

Posted Yesterday, 13:12

https://autoracer.it...in-ottica-2027/

“Leclerc and Hamilton will be focused primarily on results. Both have been given free rein to fight for second place in the Drivers’ Championship: a tough challenge against Russell and, above all, Verstappen.”

Good.


Max has 2nd sealed anyways

#23089 BleuMurmure

BleuMurmure
  • Member

  • 1,216 posts
  • Joined: June 22

Posted Yesterday, 14:04

Max has 2nd sealed anyways

And neither of them cares about being second. But they desperately want to finish ahead of the other one. P5-6 incoming, especially if Norris has form.



#23090 Gravelngrass

Gravelngrass
  • Member

  • 3,526 posts
  • Joined: April 21

Posted Yesterday, 14:31

Maybe this is what Antonelli was talking about

IMG-7940.jpg


They are so stupid and/or corrupt, that they can’t see getting rid of mandatory pit stops will allow the same. At the end of the day, everything is so optimized that strategies will tend to converge towards the same anyway. Maybe the no-stop race is inevitable and desirable.

#23091 baddog

baddog
  • Member

  • 32,131 posts
  • Joined: June 99

Posted Yesterday, 20:48

This to me reads like the prevalent point I see in the Ferrari thread for years:

 

 Just fix 'X' or 'Y' and the rest will follow.

 

I don't see it like this at all. Structural embedded issues will surface in almost ALL scenarios, apart from the one where you have the fastest car by a large margin and there is enough buffer to mitigate the consequence of these structural issues.

 

Even with a on par PU this year, there would have been a lot of races where they wouldn't dominate, but would only win with very precise execution. We still would have communication issues pit-rider / rider-pit in scenarios where the pressure is on. We still would have fluctuations in form by Leclerc / Hamilton. We would have an even bigger internal fight between Hamilton / Leclerc if a WDC would be on the line, which would have escalated much sooner and much more violently. 

 

If you keep those root cause things lingering, they will always pop-up. 

 

Thinking that a magic bullet can fix 'everything else too' is a fantasy. 

 

 

I think you have it right but the wrong way around. Your 'Magic Bullet; is blaming everything on race-ops. I don't think race execution or driver competition is the root cause AT ALL, its an effect and/or a secondary.

 

I think that until ALL development departments can work together to make a package that is best you aren't winning a thing, except for the occasional race.. and winning the occasional race but never beeing serious for the championship is exactly the story of Ferrari you rail against. Its the car.



#23092 vlado

vlado
  • Member

  • 11,337 posts
  • Joined: September 06

Posted Yesterday, 21:12

Some good info on what the changes to the ICE might cause for next season

https://www.newsf1.i...ress-meccanico/

#23093 F1Lurker

F1Lurker
  • Member

  • 3,095 posts
  • Joined: February 07

Posted Yesterday, 23:48

I think you have it right but the wrong way around. Your 'Magic Bullet; is blaming everything on race-ops. I don't think race execution or driver competition is the root cause AT ALL, its an effect and/or a secondary.

 

I think that until ALL development departments can work together to make a package that is best you aren't winning a thing, except for the occasional race.. and winning the occasional race but never beeing serious for the championship is exactly the story of Ferrari you rail against. Its the car.

If your theory were right, Ferrari would certainly have won a championship since 2007. The fact that they cannot perform at the top level consistently shows that they have a much larger organizational problem.

 

You are saying, "Oh, if their power unit was sorted, they would be challenging for the championship this year." However, when they have a strong car, they can't maintain it over a season, and they waste results with poor race operations. So, I actually think you have it the wrong way around. Only when they fix their foundation can they build a world championship-winning team.

 

Actually, even in 2007, they lucked into that championship because McLaren messed up with Hamilton.


Edited by F1Lurker, Yesterday, 23:50.


#23094 baddog

baddog
  • Member

  • 32,131 posts
  • Joined: June 99

Posted Today, 00:05

If your theory were right, Ferrari would certainly have won a championship since 2007. The fact that they cannot perform at the top level consistently shows that they have a much larger organizational problem.

 

You are saying, "Oh, if their power unit was sorted, they would be challenging for the championship this year." However, when they have a strong car, they can't maintain it over a season, and they waste results with poor race operations. So, I actually think you have it the wrong way around. Only when they fix their foundation can they build a world championship-winning team.

 

Actually, even in 2007, they lucked into that championship because McLaren messed up with Hamilton.

 

In year development is certainly part of the development I was referring to. The foundation of a team is the ability to build and prepare and upgrade a WCC level package. Managing driver fights and pit strategy is not the foundation at all. 

 

I am not saying 'all they need is a better power unit' in general. this year that was the big failure. Other years its been other things.. but at no point in recent time have they actually put together all the parts and kept up with the others through the year.

 

In as much as the TP is responsible for the whole team including the development and engineering, he is to blame.

 

Race operations at Mac and driver-interaction were HORRIBLE last year, way worse than Ferrari this year, but the car was great and they still won.

 

Now if they can be at the leading edge, then yes then the fine margins of strat and race management will be vital. Those things are important and should be improved constantly, but they wont make you the winners if you arent, and they aren't actually as bad at Ferrari as they are painted. The fact they are always chasing from behind causes half the problems.

 

Its realistic to suggest that the core policy of not having official 1-2 drivers is a thing you could argue costs them WDC points for one driver. You could also argue it gains them WCC points overall. I don't think that core policy is what we are discussing here, if it is let me know.