Jump to content


Photo

Who is the best driver who could not pass from the Indy Lights to IndyCar?


  • Please log in to reply
30 replies to this topic

#1 GMiranda

GMiranda
  • Member

  • 1,505 posts
  • Joined: April 13

Posted 14 November 2026 - 16:39

Hello

I saw this question on Reddit and reposted it, but I think it would be interesting to discuss it here too.
I'd like to know your opinion about some of the names I consider worthy of this category. Of course, it would be an excellent opportunity to learn more about the ARS/Indy Lights/Indy NXT scene.

Here's a small list:

  • Steve Millen
  • Tommy Byrne
  • Calvin Fish
  • Johnny O'Connell
  • Pedro Matos Chaves
  • Steve Robertson
  • David Empringham
  • Claude Bourbonnais
  • Guy Smith
  • Jonny Kane
  • Jason Bright
  • Wade Cunningham
  • Jean-Karl Vernay
  • Esteban Guerrieri
  • Gustavo Yacamán
  • Santiago Urrutia
  • Félix Serrallés
  • Oliver Webb

 

 



Advertisement

#2 E1pix

E1pix
  • Member

  • 24,029 posts
  • Joined: January 11

Posted 14 November 2026 - 18:06

I would add Mike Snow to that list.

He was exceptional in Formula Ford, went straight up to Lights (ARS) in 1988 with little budget, and scored a fine 2nd behind Paul Tracy in, I think, Cleveland.

The only factor keeping Mike from moving up to IRL in 1996 was that team owner Brad Caulkins ran his son instead, who, to be fair, was not nearly as quick as Mike — but was co-Champion in the series anyway.

#3 GMiranda

GMiranda
  • Member

  • 1,505 posts
  • Joined: April 13

Posted 14 November 2026 - 18:45

I would add Mike Snow to that list.

He was exceptional in Formula Ford, went straight up to Lights (ARS) in 1988 with little budget, and scored a fine 2nd behind Paul Tracy in, I think, Cleveland.

The only factor keeping Mike from moving up to IRL in 1996 was that team owner Brad Caulkins ran his son instead, who, to be fair, was not nearly as quick as Mike — but was co-Champion in the series anyway.

Thanks!! I saw his name, but I don't know much about him. Many drivers who went through ARS/Indy Lights and didn't progress, be it for lack of money or talent, ended up in IRL in 1996.



#4 FLB

FLB
  • Member

  • 42,338 posts
  • Joined: February 01

Posted 14 November 2026 - 19:02

You also have those that could/should have had a shot straight from Atlantics to IndyCar, like Jacques Villeneuve and Patrick Carpentier did.

 

EX: Case Montgormery, Bill Auberlen (How Bill Auberlen was almost an IndyCar racer – twice – before building his legend in sports cars | RACER), etc.


Edited by FLB, 14 November 2026 - 19:04.


#5 GMiranda

GMiranda
  • Member

  • 1,505 posts
  • Joined: April 13

Posted 14 November 2026 - 19:04

You also have those that could/should have had a shot straight from Atlantics to IndyCar, like Jacques Villeneuve and Patrick Carpentier did.

 

EX: Case Montgormery

Never heard of him...



#6 FLB

FLB
  • Member

  • 42,338 posts
  • Joined: February 01

Posted 14 November 2026 - 19:07

Never heard of him...

Case Montgomery – Career Stats, DriverDB Rating & Results | DriverDB

 

Had very good seasons in 1995 and 1996. Under-funded.



#7 GMiranda

GMiranda
  • Member

  • 1,505 posts
  • Joined: April 13

Posted 14 November 2026 - 19:30

Case Montgomery – Career Stats, DriverDB Rating & Results | DriverDB

 

Had very good seasons in 1995 and 1996. Under-funded.

Thanks!!



#8 Michael Ferner

Michael Ferner
  • Member

  • 7,568 posts
  • Joined: November 09

Posted 16 November 2026 - 14:27

David Empringham and Claude Bourbonnais. Both were every bit as fast as Jacques Villenueve in Atlantics, but didn't have the name.

 

I always had a soft spot for Calvin Fish and Guy Smith, but in retrospect I think they didn't belong in Indycars.

 

And, of course, Sammy Swindell rates a mention...


Edited by Michael Ferner, 16 November 2026 - 14:30.


#9 Ross Stonefeld

Ross Stonefeld
  • Member

  • 71,197 posts
  • Joined: August 99

Posted 16 November 2026 - 15:51

You also have those that could/should have had a shot straight from Atlantics to IndyCar, like Jacques Villeneuve and Patrick Carpentier did.

 

EX: Case Montgormery, Bill Auberlen (How Bill Auberlen was almost an IndyCar racer – twice – before building his legend in sports cars | RACER), etc.

 

I remember reading that at the time and being confused, how were they going to get a 6l V12 non-turbo into Indycar? Just use the same block and redesign it as a CART engine? 



#10 GMiranda

GMiranda
  • Member

  • 1,505 posts
  • Joined: April 13

Posted 16 November 2026 - 16:32

David Empringham and Claude Bourbonnais. Both were every bit as fast as Jacques Villenueve in Atlantics, but didn't have the name.

 

I always had a soft spot for Calvin Fish and Guy Smith, but in retrospect I think they didn't belong in Indycars.

 

And, of course, Sammy Swindell rates a mention...

In 1993, Empringhan took the Formula Atlantic title, closely followed by Bourbonnais and Villeneuve (only 10 points separated them). Villeneuve had the name, but he was probably the fastest and youngest, so they might have seen on him more potential to develop?



#11 GMiranda

GMiranda
  • Member

  • 1,505 posts
  • Joined: April 13

Posted 16 November 2026 - 16:35

David Empringham and Claude Bourbonnais. Both were every bit as fast as Jacques Villenueve in Atlantics, but didn't have the name.

 

I always had a soft spot for Calvin Fish and Guy Smith, but in retrospect I think they didn't belong in Indycars.

 

And, of course, Sammy Swindell rates a mention...

Guy Smith did a couple of races in CART in 2003, I forgot it. Indeed, he found his place in Endurance, where he excelled both in Prototypes and GT's.

 

Calvin Fish did well in the British F3, but I don't recall him on F2 or F3000, so perhaps money was already short.

 

Sammy Swindell did some CART races outside the Indy 500, including being part of Patrick Racing in 1985. Why did he never tried to do more?



#12 ensign14

ensign14
  • Member

  • 68,894 posts
  • Joined: December 01

Posted 16 November 2026 - 16:40

In 1993, Empringhan took the Formula Atlantic title, closely followed by Bourbonnais and Villeneuve (only 10 points separated them). Villeneuve had the name, but he was probably the fastest and youngest, so they might have seen on him more potential to develop?

 

Every time I saw Empringham's name in the media, he was winning something.  How come Players didn't take him into Indycar in 1998?  Better bet than e.g. Carpentier.



#13 Ross Stonefeld

Ross Stonefeld
  • Member

  • 71,197 posts
  • Joined: August 99

Posted 16 November 2026 - 16:54

If I recall at the time, internet wisdom was they wanted one Canadian and one French Canadian, hence Carpentier over Empringham, Lee Bentham would never get a shot, etc. Then they did Carpentier/Tagliani so who knows.



#14 Michael Ferner

Michael Ferner
  • Member

  • 7,568 posts
  • Joined: November 09

Posted Yesterday, 10:03



In 1993, Empringhan took the Formula Atlantic title, closely followed by Bourbonnais and Villeneuve (only 10 points separated them). Villeneuve had the name, but he was probably the fastest and youngest, so they might have seen on him more potential to develop?

 

Villeneuve was defintely not faster than DE or CB. Yes, I think he was younger, and new to the US/Canadian scene, but he had two or three years of Italian and Japanese F3 behind him, so not short on experience, either. It was just the name.



#15 Michael Ferner

Michael Ferner
  • Member

  • 7,568 posts
  • Joined: November 09

Posted Yesterday, 10:10

Guy Smith did a couple of races in CART in 2003, I forgot it. Indeed, he found his place in Endurance, where he excelled both in Prototypes and GT's.

 

Calvin Fish did well in the British F3, but I don't recall him on F2 or F3000, so perhaps money was already short.

 

Sammy Swindell did some CART races outside the Indy 500, including being part of Patrick Racing in 1985. Why did he never tried to do more?

 

For Swindell it was a problem of money, and culture. He tried a lot (NASCAR as well), but as a professional racing driver he had to put food on the table, and not pay to drive. His pedigree wasn't in demand at CART at the time, and he couldn't bring money, a combination which limited his choices. In fact, it only left the crumbs off the table (i.e. uncompetitive rides).

 

As for Smith and Fish, "they didn't belong" is a harsh formulation - better say: Indycar didn't miss out on their talents.



#16 GMiranda

GMiranda
  • Member

  • 1,505 posts
  • Joined: April 13

Posted Yesterday, 11:33

 

Villeneuve was defintely not faster than DE or CB. Yes, I think he was younger, and new to the US/Canadian scene, but he had two or three years of Italian and Japanese F3 behind him, so not short on experience, either. It was just the name.

Oh, my mistake. I thought Villeneuve, despite a slow start in the Italian F3 series, built a strong reputation in Japan and performed immediately well in the Atlantic series, even though he was beaten by his more experienced teammates. Of course I know it was his name and management that helped him to progress, but I must admit I find Jacques a very talented and all-round driver, whose career was derailed by mistakes on different levels, but certainly not for lack of talent and speed.



#17 GMiranda

GMiranda
  • Member

  • 1,505 posts
  • Joined: April 13

Posted Yesterday, 11:37

For Swindell it was a problem of money, and culture. He tried a lot (NASCAR as well), but as a professional racing driver he had to put food on the table, and not pay to drive. His pedigree wasn't in demand at CART at the time, and he couldn't bring money, a combination which limited his choices. In fact, it only left the crumbs off the table (i.e. uncompetitive rides).

 

As for Smith and Fish, "they didn't belong" is a harsh formulation - better say: Indycar didn't miss out on their talents.

 

Yeah, I understand. I disagree with you about Guy Smith; I believe he was talented enough for single-seaters, but his main focus was already in Endurance with Audi/Bentley, and that second Rocketsports car in 2004 wasn't performing at the top with any driver.
 
I believe Sammy Swindell, being extremely successful in the USAC scene, found it hard to come to CART without competitive machinery, and his USAC sponsors might not have been interested in CART or the amounts it required.


 

Edited by GMiranda, Yesterday, 11:40.


#18 ensign14

ensign14
  • Member

  • 68,894 posts
  • Joined: December 01

Posted Yesterday, 11:45

Swindell had one real shot at NASCAR with the Morosos but had a dreadful Daytona 500 and they elbowed him.  He came damn close to qualifying for Indy in 1987 in an old March a Pontiac engine, bumped with about 20 minutes to go by Ed Pimm with a Hail Mary go, engine on the point of expiration.   



#19 GMiranda

GMiranda
  • Member

  • 1,505 posts
  • Joined: April 13

Posted Yesterday, 11:49

Swindell had one real shot at NASCAR with the Morosos but had a dreadful Daytona 500 and they elbowed him.  He came damn close to qualifying for Indy in 1987 in an old March a Pontiac engine, bumped with about 20 minutes to go by Ed Pimm with a Hail Mary go, engine on the point of expiration.   

Yeah I think I read about it.

 

But he did a chance to do the Superspeedways for Pat Patrick in 1985 if I'm not mistaken.



Advertisement

#20 Disco Stu

Disco Stu
  • Member

  • 200 posts
  • Joined: July 02

Posted Yesterday, 14:03

 

Villeneuve was defintely not faster than DE or CB. Yes, I think he was younger, and new to the US/Canadian scene, but he had two or three years of Italian and Japanese F3 behind him, so not short on experience, either. It was just the name.

 

Villeneuve had more poles than Empringham and Bourbonnais combined that year, and 5 wins to go along with it.  The name certainly helped, and Empringham never getting a shot was a joke, but let's not pretend Villeneuve wasn't quick.



#21 E1pix

E1pix
  • Member

  • 24,029 posts
  • Joined: January 11

Posted Yesterday, 14:10

My memory is Empringham was typically a 3rd-place car — though consistently scoring decent points — and Bourbonnais was blazing fast on his day, but didn’t have nearly enough of those days.

#22 Michael Ferner

Michael Ferner
  • Member

  • 7,568 posts
  • Joined: November 09

Posted Yesterday, 16:47



Villeneuve had more poles than Empringham and Bourbonnais combined that year, and 5 wins to go along with it.  The name certainly helped, and Empringham never getting a shot was a joke, but let's not pretend Villeneuve wasn't quick.

 

That's not what I wanted to convey - JV was super quick, and he did very well in Indycar, to the point that I doubt wether CB or DE could have achieved similar results! The point was, though he did well in Atlantics, he wasn't really a standout. I think Players liked the idea of promoting a Villeneuve, and let's be honest, JV didn't really shine in F3 (in an age when most would expect a 'real talent' to at least win a race in his first year, and be champion within two, JV didn't deliver in three), but he was very young, and the fact that he did what he did in Atlantics was enough, thanks to his name alone.

 

I wrote the above posts from memory, and now that I can check my records I can counter your facts with other figures: yes, Villeneuve did win five races, but his teammate won seven and finished so far ahead in points that JV couldn't catch him with one race left. And yes, Villeneuve led the season in pole positions, but his average qualifying was only 0.5 points better than Bourbonnais, not much to write home about. And when both cars finished, it was mostly Bourbonnais in front, 5-to-2. Yes, Bourbonnais was a bit wild, and apt to overshoot the target, but so was Villeneuve - the final tally was one chassis destroyed by either, and three to four race crashes in favour of JV.

 

And then there was Empringham. Yes, he won only once, and qualified two places lower on average, but he was the single driver in a shoe-string team, fighting a two-car cigarette-sponsored star Indycar filière that was highly favoured - he knew his only chance was consistency, and so it proved. He had more top three finishes than either Forsythe driver had in the top six, and that was enough when the scoring is 20-16-14-12-11-etc. Egg on Players face!!



#23 JacnGille

JacnGille
  • Member

  • 3,016 posts
  • Joined: July 02

Posted Yesterday, 16:49

 

I always had a soft spot for Calvin Fish ...



#24 LittleChris

LittleChris
  • Member

  • 4,612 posts
  • Joined: April 01

Posted Yesterday, 17:11

Thought Calvin was quite quick in FF2000 but didn't really translate it to F3 in 83 when Senna, Brundle & Jones were generally quite a bit ahead of the rest from memory. 



#25 FLB

FLB
  • Member

  • 42,338 posts
  • Joined: February 01

Posted Yesterday, 17:33

 

And then there was Empringham. Yes, he won only once, and qualified two places lower on average, but he was the single driver in a shoe-string team, fighting a two-car cigarette-sponsored star Indycar filière that was highly favoured - he knew his only chance was consistency, and so it proved. He had more top three finishes than either Forsythe driver had in the top six, and that was enough when the scoring is 20-16-14-12-11-etc. Egg on Players face!!

Speaking once to somebody who was close/involved with the tobacco programme at the time, they were caught by surprise with Villeneuve. Based on his past F3 results, they weren't expecting much out of him. The star was supposed to be Claude Bourbonnais. Barry Green and Tony Cicale saw Villeneuve's potential for progress and the rest is history.

 

As for Empringham, the main reasons were a) his age, b) his blandness (he was described to me as 'too nice') and, more importantly, c) they saw Greg Moore coming... 


Edited by FLB, Yesterday, 17:39.


#26 Bob Riebe

Bob Riebe
  • Member

  • 3,348 posts
  • Joined: January 05

Posted Yesterday, 19:38

For Swindell it was a problem of money, and culture. He tried a lot (NASCAR as well), but as a professional racing driver he had to put food on the table, and not pay to drive. His pedigree wasn't in demand at CART at the time, and he couldn't bring money, a combination which limited his choices. In fact, it only left the crumbs off the table (i.e. uncompetitive rides).

 

I would say that part killed many very talented drivers chance of getting into good rides or rides at all.
 



#27 Michael Ferner

Michael Ferner
  • Member

  • 7,568 posts
  • Joined: November 09

Posted Yesterday, 20:11

Thought Calvin was quite quick in FF2000 but didn't really translate it to F3 in 83 when Senna, Brundle & Jones were generally quite a bit ahead of the rest from memory. 

 

Spot on!  :up:

 

Speaking once to somebody who was close/involved with the tobacco programme at the time, they were caught by surprise with Villeneuve. Based on his past F3 results, they weren't expecting much out of him. The star was supposed to be Claude Bourbonnais. Barry Green and Tony Cicale saw Villeneuve's potential for progress and the rest is history.

 

As for Empringham, the main reasons were a) his age, b) his blandness (he was described to me as 'too nice') and, more importantly, c) they saw Greg Moore coming... 

 

I was going to say, if their names had been Smith & Jones, nobody would've picked Villeneuve over Bourbonnais, but that is probably not true. Those on the inside could see the potential, and I think it was Cicale who once remarked how bright Villeneuve was in communication with the team. I haven't spoken to Bourbonnais, never read an interview or even only a quote, so I don't want to insult his intelligence, but it's sometimes these small things that make the difference. Not something you can see from the outside. But really, I would have loved to see CB in an Indycar, he had the fire in his belly that fitted those cars at the time. And Empringham was the complete opposite, a thinking man's driver who was just too good to let go. As a remarkable piece of irony, JV turned out to be a blend of those two characters, and the right choice for Forsythe. 



#28 GMiranda

GMiranda
  • Member

  • 1,505 posts
  • Joined: April 13

Posted Yesterday, 21:56

Speaking once to somebody who was close/involved with the tobacco programme at the time, they were caught by surprise with Villeneuve. Based on his past F3 results, they weren't expecting much out of him. The star was supposed to be Claude Bourbonnais. Barry Green and Tony Cicale saw Villeneuve's potential for progress and the rest is history.

 

As for Empringham, the main reasons were a) his age, b) his blandness (he was described to me as 'too nice') and, more importantly, c) they saw Greg Moore coming... 

Villeneuve's first seasons in F3 weren't particularly brilliant, but he had a great season in the Japanese F3 in 1992.

 

In the 1993 Atlantic Championship, David Empringham won with 195 pts (1 win), followed by Claude Bourbonnais with 191 pts (7 wins) and Jacques Villeneuve with 185 pts (5 wins).



#29 10kDA

10kDA
  • Member

  • 1,897 posts
  • Joined: July 09

Posted Yesterday, 22:36

Sammy Swindell was used to doing things his own way as well. Unless he was calling the shots he probably would not have been happy, and not stuck around long in IndyCar anyway.



#30 E1pix

E1pix
  • Member

  • 24,029 posts
  • Joined: January 11

Posted Today, 01:53

On Swindell and Kinser, we have to realize that Outlaws cars have absolutely nothing in common with Indy cars.

The days of long and lazy USAC Sprint cars prepping anyone for Indy started its end with Foyt and Rutherford and Parnelli, and forever stopped with Tony Stewart.

In those last days, put Castroneves or Franchitti or Montoya or Zanardi in one, and see the very same result.

#31 Bob Riebe

Bob Riebe
  • Member

  • 3,348 posts
  • Joined: January 05

Posted Today, 03:08

On Swindell and Kinser, we have to realize that Outlaws cars have absolutely nothing in common with Indy cars.

The days of long and lazy USAC Sprint cars prepping anyone for Indy started its end with Foyt and Rutherford and Parnelli, and forever stopped with Tony Stewart.

In those last days, put Castroneves or Franchitti or Montoya or Zanardi in one, and see the very same result.

OH YEAH - well , Gordon Johncock came out of modifieds - so take that -  hummph!


Edited by Bob Riebe, Today, 03:08.