
Worst F1 accidents you've either seen at the track or on a live broadcast.
#1
Posted 24 January 2002 - 02:08
1. Gerhard Berger (1989 - Imola). Straight off at Tamborelo - same accident as Senna's but Gerhard's Ferrari went straight in and caught on fire. Never before nor after had I been so concerned after an accident (remember Senna moved his head in 1994 after his car had already been motionless - thus giving the perception that he was still alive).
2. Rubens Barichello - Jordan 1994 at Imola on Saturday morning. I was amayzed at the accident - especially the way the car flew - level, through the air and nailed the retaining fence/tire wall with such an enormous impact.
Other mentions....
Michael Andretti (Brazil 1993).
Michael Schumacher (Imola 1995)
How bout you?
Advertisement
#2
Posted 24 January 2002 - 02:36
BARnone.
#3
Posted 24 January 2002 - 02:36

Same in Australia this year. I seriously feared for Villeneuve's life as all we were shown on the telly was lots of dust and then Ralf running somewhere off, and the camera followed him for a while and then stopped before he arrived at the BAR. I imagined the worst of course, and seeing the actual crash in slow motion didn't actually help. The total incompetence of the commentators didn't help either, thankfully I had the AtlasF1 live commentary on so I got to know that both drivers were OK more than 20 minutes before the commentators on the telly mentioned it. And then when you thought everything was safe, the ambulance arrived, and drove around the track ever so slowly with Graham Beveridge on board...

Burti's accidents this year were also terrifying, especially the last one.

Others that come to mind right now would be the BARs at the top of Eau Rouge the other year, funny looking back, but at the time it was bloody scary...
There are probably many more...

#4
Posted 24 January 2002 - 02:44
It's amayzing that I can remember 1989 but forget an accident that happened this season...WTF aportinga????;)
#5
Posted 24 January 2002 - 02:46
Martin Brundle, Monza, 1989 (?). Went a bit too wide at Paraboloica, into the outside barriers, and slide down the front straight on his lid.
de la Rosa, Monza, 2000. The dust made it look even worse, but seeing his Arrows cartwheeling through the secene, several seconds after the accident seemed to end did not look like it would turn out well.
Diniz, Brazil, 1998 (?). Simple incident, but tragic-looking consequences when his roll-hoop broke away.
You name the driver and year, Eau Rouge. Jacque has a few that were spectacular. And Zanardi had a bad one several years ago (Lotus) before the run-off area was improved. (actually, those were during practice, not seen live, so they really shouldn't count here, but...)
That's all that pop into the brain right now. The really sad thing is that these don't even come close the useless carnage seen in CART recently (Zanardi, Krosnoff, and Moore especially).
#6
Posted 24 January 2002 - 02:47
As for all of motorsport. The Greg Moore crash at Fontana still takes the bottom of the valley.
#7
Posted 24 January 2002 - 02:54
#8
Posted 24 January 2002 - 02:54

Rubens accident, shocking, but was ok

Roland on qualifying day

then
Ayrton Senna




#9
Posted 24 January 2002 - 03:13
Its moments like that that make me question my enjoyment of motor racing. In 95 and even 96 I was not nearly as much of a fan of F1 as I was before (or am now).
#10
Posted 24 January 2002 - 03:19
#11
Posted 24 January 2002 - 03:21
Ayrton Senna - May 1st, 1994. Autodromo Enzo y Dino Ferrari, San Marino.


The most horrible:
Greg Moore - California Speedway, Fontana, California.
Originally posted by aportinga
2. Rubens Barichello - Jordan 1994 at Imola on Saturday morning. I was amayzed at the accident - especially the way the car flew - level, through the air and nailed the retaining fence/tire wall with such an enormous impact.
It was on Friday.
#12
Posted 24 January 2002 - 03:28
The most horrifying weekend I've ever witnessed, took the life of Roland Ratzenberger, and my hero Ayrton Senna


Jeff Krosnoff - 1996
Greg Moore - 1999
Gonzalo Rodriguez - 1999
#13
Posted 24 January 2002 - 03:29
Gerhard's Imola accident in '89 was horrifying, too. Watching him sit there for quite a few seconds in the fire was terrifying. That goodness he came out of that one.
Fyi....I think people are getting Brundle mixed up w/ Derrick Warwick in the accident at Monza, 1990.
#14
Posted 24 January 2002 - 03:34
Originally posted by aportinga
The track Marshals death should go without saying. However I forgot about the actual accident itself...perhaps because both JV & RS escaped shortly after their cars came to a halt. However the sound of JV's car hitting the retaining wall...hearing the actual engine rev so violently has to force one to take note. This was perhaps the most horrid and violent sounding accident I've ever heard for certain!
It's amayzing that I can remember 1989 but forget an accident that happened this season...WTF aportinga????;)
I agree. The sound as JV's car hit the wall was amazing...does anyone have that video link that was posted not long after, showed inside views and outside vievs....possibly Bernievision.....i lost it, but be keen to get it again...horrific...

#15
Posted 24 January 2002 - 04:02
2. Jeff Krosnoff at Toronto
3. Danny Ongais at Indy, 1981. How he could have possibly survived that is beyond me.
#16
Posted 24 January 2002 - 04:03
It wasn't captured by tv cameras well, but I read his comments in an interview later on.
He was right behind Zonta's BAR at the approach to the second corner. Zonta noticed the yellow flags and slowed down, but PDLR couldn't see them (since he was blinded by the BAR). So he smashed into the back of Zonta and was launched into the air at a very high speed.
He then landed on Herbert's Jaguar and destroyed the rear end of the Jag. He was then launched into a multiple barrel roll as he went straight on at the corner.
Then he hit DC's McLaren and his car rolled end over end, and ended up upside down on Barrichello's Ferrari.


#17
Posted 24 January 2002 - 04:09
Mexico 1989
Monza 1990
Germany 1993
Which one was scarier?
I Think Germany 1993 was scarier since he dug it in the gravel, pretty deep
#18
Posted 24 January 2002 - 04:20
The other horrible impact I have seen was the awful Indy race in Geramny last year with Tagliani and Zanardi...
I saw Senna die, Krosnoff die, Moore die, Paletti die, Berger's accident at Imola, which were all terible, and of course, the first four with far more dire results, but none of those accidents looked as horrible as the two I mentioned above....
#19
Posted 24 January 2002 - 04:24

JV @ Melbourne 2001

Monza carnage in 2000
and Greg Moore's accident at Fontona. I will never forget watching the sports report to find out if Montoya won the CART title (the races are not live in Oz) and hearing the reporter say "Now this is a tragic story, Canadian Greg Moore died.........."





Advertisement
#20
Posted 24 January 2002 - 04:26
#21
Posted 24 January 2002 - 04:29
#22
Posted 24 January 2002 - 04:32


Tom Pryce. no other contenders in F1
I am glad I have not seen that one. By all reports people who have seen it regret seeing it for the rest of their lives.

#23
Posted 24 January 2002 - 05:15
Never seen the Smiley crash mentioned before, if anyone knows of an URL - PM me.
I bet I look like a right ghoul now.
#24
Posted 24 January 2002 - 05:31
#25
Posted 24 January 2002 - 05:51
Tom Pryce - nothing but silence by the time he hits the marshall. The crash was incredibly shocking to watch. I never watch the crash ever again.
Stan Fox at Indy 95 - crashed head on (taking a few others) and the car disentigrated. All it was left was the tub.
Alessandro Zampedri, Eliseo Salazar, Roberto Guerrero at Indy 96 - Guerrero loses at turn 4 on the last lap, Zampedri runs into Guerrero and gets catapulted in the air. Salazar gets collected and goes over Zampedri who was still in the air. Zampedri broke both of his legs in the crash.
Jeff Krosnoff at Toronto (RIP Jeff; God rest your soul)
11 car fiery crash at IRL Atlanta
Airton Dare at Nashville
Blaise Alexander and Kerry Earnhardt at Charlotte (RIP Blaise; God rest his soul)
1993 Talledega - the usual multicar crash in a restrictor plate race; Jimmy Horton flies out of the track. Surprised he survived with just scratches and returned three weeks later. It was the reason why there's a chainlink fence.
Another wreck on the same race was the late Neil Bonnett flipping consider he had serious head injuries in a crash years before.
1998 Spa - DC lose and hear comes a chain reaction. Rossett still on the gas plows through the crash.
Alex Zanardi at Germany
Mark Martin in 1994 or 1995, can't remember the track - got involved in a wreck and he goes grass riding into the inside track walls. The camera was onboard his car and the impact was unbelievable.
#26
Posted 24 January 2002 - 07:04

#27
Posted 24 January 2002 - 07:48
One is missing, though: Martin Donnelly who crashed so heavy with his Lotus in Jerez (1990?) that the car got apart and he landed, still strapped into the seat in the middle of the track. The seat was about the only part left from the car, and he survived the horrific crash only by a miracle and very fast and efficient work by Prof. Watkins. It finally ended his career and resulted in a track modification of Jerez. That was a terrible crash as well!
Zoe
#28
Posted 24 January 2002 - 09:03

#29
Posted 24 January 2002 - 09:08
#30
Posted 24 January 2002 - 10:18
BY FAR THE WORST I have seen is Moore's though. I normally have total confidence in the car that the driver will walk away fine but with Moore I had that sick in the gut feeling he wasn't going to survive that. That was enormous.
#31
Posted 24 January 2002 - 11:06
Australia 01 on TV
Monza 01
Spa 01 live with Burti and Irvine, although i never saw the accident, was at a different part of the track, was a scary moment trying to find out what was going on as the none of us could understand the commentary at the circuit and was calling home to find out info
#32
Posted 24 January 2002 - 11:18
Worst accidents I remember:
- Kyalami 77, Tom Pryce
- Nürburgring 76, Lauda
- Zandvoort 73, Williamsson
others:
Imola 89, Berger
Spa 98 Start
Monza 00, Start
Melbourne 01, Villeneuve
Hockenheim 01 Start
#33
Posted 24 January 2002 - 11:20
#34
Posted 24 January 2002 - 11:28

2nd. Gilles Villeneuve (Spa)

3rd. Roland Ratzenberger (Imola)

4th. Ayrton Senna (Imola)

5th. Mika Häkkinen (Adelaide)
#35
Posted 24 January 2002 - 11:38
I'm not going to talk about it.
This thread gives me SUCH an uneasy feeling....
How many drivers have been sooo lucky. How many near misses. How many "just a bit earlier and..."s, how many wheels missing heads by inches, cars landing on other cars....
I can't help thinking that sooner or later...
And next time I won't start watching again after a few years off, next time is for keeps

#36
Posted 24 January 2002 - 11:42
- Andretti Brazil 93, if you see the film you'll wonder at the miracle that the car didn't end up in the grandstand at the end of the front straight.
- Zanardi Spa 93, there was bugger all run off at Eau Rouge in those days and he smacked the armco like a rocket, the fact that Senna came spinning in after arriving to quick and damn near cleaned up the marshels only made it worse.
- Hakkinen Adelaide 95, was there that year at the track we all feared he was dead.
- Hakkinen Spa 97, during practice he had a catastrophic rear suspension failure that sent him into the barriers. When the suspension failed at 300kph you would have sworn he had driven over a landmine the rear suspension appeared virtually to explode as it tore itself to pieces.
- Spa 98, the first corner multi car pile up, how nobody was killed in that owed as mutch to blind luck as it did to chassis integrity of the cars involved.
#37
Posted 24 January 2002 - 11:49
[list=1]
[*]Ayrton Senna: I could not watch F1 untill the 96 season after that, I basically missed MS' first two championships. The only picture I remember of 94 after Imola was MS dedicating his WDC to Ayrton, saying that Ayrton was the one supposed to win it and he wished he had won it against Ayrton. F1 without him was not the same anymore. JV coming in 96 against now 2-times WDC MS motivated me again to watch F1 more regularly.
[*]Berger, when his car caught fire: the reaction at the time was incredible, my heart was pounding in my chest like crazy, and I was so relieved to see the marshalls act so swiftly. That was quite incredible and a very good work then.
[*]Niki Lauda at the Nurburgring, can't remember the year and did not see it live, but it was damn scary, with no marshalls to help immediatly.
[*]Monza pile up in 2000. I was at the track but at the entry of the parabolica (where Button went out at the restart) but did not see the first accident at Roggia, only on TV in the evening and that is when we learnt that someone died, not during the race itself. It was a sad end to a very exciting day.
[*]JV and Ralf in Oz last year. It was very impressive, cost the life of a marshal (even though the probability for such an accident is very low), but I was amazed that JV then jumped on a scooter and was driven away. He could have lost consciousness then and hurt himself even more. I once had a bike accident and fell unconscious for 24 hours 5 minutes after the fall. Had I been back on my bike at the time, it would have been much worse.
[*]Zanardi: what to say? The front end of the car was just gone. I wish the other car had hit the rear end instead. What a lesson of courage by Alex, unbelievable, great man.
[/list=1]
The list is very long as I said. I remember a few CART accidents that looked very very bad, but I don't know the details of the names of drivers and tracks. Does anyone remember the guy in a crazy race last year in CART and he went into a wall on his right-hand side, in a left fast corner under a bridge, and it was so long for the marshals to get him out. He came out safe, but I thought he was dead at the time or he would be paralysed forever.
#38
Posted 24 January 2002 - 11:54

Worst F1: Gilles Villeneuve. (the way that car came apart)
Worst Ever: Gordon Smiley. (total destruction of the car, the actual track suface had to be repaired)
#39
Posted 24 January 2002 - 12:13
The worse accident I have ever seen by far in a racing car was Swede Savage at Indy, I think in the early 70's. If you want to really see something horrible have a look at that.
Of course going back before, Mercedes flying into the crowd at Lemans is probably Number One.
Worse crash from me in 2001, (remember Im talking about what LOOKED bad), was Burti and Irvine at Spa. I felt certain Burti was hurt critically if not killed in that. Of course it turned oout to be nothing.
Just to lighten the mood, since this one turned out OK, but the most hilarious crash, was whoever that was that ended up on top of Nigel Mansell at Indy UNDER A CAUTION FLAG!!!!!!!!!. Now that was strange.
Advertisement
#40
Posted 24 January 2002 - 12:29
Just to lighten the mood, since this one turned out OK, but the most hilarious crash, was whoever that was that ended up on top of Nigel Mansell at Indy UNDER A CAUTION FLAG!!!!!!!!!. Now that was strange.
This one turned out OK, too.
There was a similar accident at the CART race at Road America a few years ago when a driver (Herta?) spun off the track going into a tight left-hander and ended up facing the wrong way. Another driver lost it under braking, and the cars hit head-on, with the second car literally landing on top of the first. The driver underneath couldn't get out of his car until the other had been removed.
#41
Posted 24 January 2002 - 12:59
Originally posted by StickShift
As for all of motorsport. The Greg Moore crash at Fontana still takes the bottom of the valley.
I'll never forget watching Greg Moore crash (God rest his soul). It was by far the most brutal, savage, ferocious motorsport accident I have ever seen. I almost stopped watching auto racing because of it.
It's wierd, I still have the tape of that race but will never watch it again but I won't throw it away either. It's kind of like a memorial to Greg. I thought he had the makings of a Champion.
As for F1, the pile up at the start of Spa a few years ago was like watching a train wreck. It's amazing no one got seriously injured. I have only been following F1 since 97 so Burti's crash at Spa this year is the crash where I was most concerned about the safety of the driver.
I must also mention Alex Wurz flipping through the sand trap at Canada a few years back. To see him get out of the car and jog back to his backup ride made me understand the different attitudes towards safety in F1 vs. CART. I don't think a CART driver who suffered such a massive shunt would have been allowed to restart without visiting the medical station. I'm not saying either attitude is better I'm just pointing out the different priorities in the two series.
F1=The show must go on, drivers are paid to take risks
CART=Driver safety first, the show can wait
#42
Posted 24 January 2002 - 13:06

#43
Posted 24 January 2002 - 13:53
Personally I'm lucky enough never to have witnessed a fatality of a driver in a live motor race, excluding a Roadracing 250cc race at Hockenheim at around 1989-1990. There was a crash in the stadium section and one of the pilots was tragically killed, does anyone know more about this incident?
I somehow managed to miss Senna/Ratzenberger as well as Greg Moore's and Jeff Krosnoff's crashes live.
The worst crash I've seen live was Gerhard Berger's crash at Imola in 1989. Those 16 seconds he was engulfed in flames seemed like 16 years, and it took a long while before any news came around about his condition.
Another crash that looked really bad at the time was Ukyo Katayama's startline crash at Estoril in 1995 wher he flipped and barrell-rolled several times down the main straight before coming to a rest upside down.
Also, the Zanardi/Tagliani crash was horrifying. It really shocked me.
The startline crashes at Monza 2000 and Spa 1998 were chilling in the same way; just when you thought the crash was over, De La Rosa/Rosset came tearing down through the debris.
Other than those, I'd definately rate Tom Pryce hitting a fire marshall as the most gruesome piece of footage I have ever seen, not just limited to motor racing (though the 'sound' of the extinguisher hitting Pryce has been added to the clip that's available on-line).
David Purley trying in vain to rescue Roger Williamson at Zandvoort 1973 is heart-breaking...
Greg Moore at Fontana and Gilles Villeneuve at Zolder would be the most graphically violent crashes I've seen.
There are tons of other crashes that are just horrible to watch, Lorenzo Bandini receiving lethal burns at Monaco 1967, Siegfried Stohr hitting his teammates mechanic at Zolder in 1981...
Crashes that I have not seen, but seem to be extremely awful indeed are Gordon Smiley at Indy 1982 (?), Didier Pironi at Hockenheim 1982, Francois Cevert at Watkins Glen 1973 and Peter Revson at Kyalami 1974.
#44
Posted 24 January 2002 - 13:58
#45
Posted 24 January 2002 - 14:46
Greg Moore and Kroznoff's crashes also come to mind. Kroznoff's being absolutely horrific.
Niall
#46
Posted 24 January 2002 - 15:30
The worst accident I witnessed live would have to be Stan Fox's on the first lap of the 95 Indy 500. I was at this race, in the first turn and saw the whole thing happen. You could literally hear his car crack. It's amazing he lived through this accident. He had a limp and he was, to put it delicately, touched. Story and picture in link below. FYI...This was the start of the Indy 500 that Jacques Villeneuve won.
I actually have a picture of this accident autographed by Stan with the salutation of "Chris, All I can say is oops". The picture was purchased and autographed in 2000 while attending the USGP.
I've been to Indy more times than can remember cause, yes...I'm from Indiana (I live in Chicago now, so give me some slack

IT was funny to watch GP visitors from other nations who didn't really follow USAC or CART in the Photo Gallery. They were examining the pictures of Stan's accident hanging on the wall only to learn that the person involved in this horrific accident was standing less than 10 feet away. When they discovered Stan standing there, jaws were dropping.
The sad end to this story is that Stan was killed in 2000 in a two car accident in either Australia or New Zealand in a MiniVan.
May Stan RIP.
CNNSI article on Stan Fox
cts
#47
Posted 24 January 2002 - 16:25
#48
Posted 24 January 2002 - 16:27
Originally posted by Slyder
Jeff Krosnoff - 1996
Greg Moore - 1999
Both horrible crashes. I had a terrible feeling watching both crashes that both drivers were injured very badly.
Just thinking about the pictures of Moore's crash makes me shudder. No way should Champ cars be running on those superspeedways.
#49
Posted 24 January 2002 - 16:37
#50
Posted 24 January 2002 - 17:24
filling in a few gaps
Tifosi - Dennis Vitolo landed on Mansell
Ravachol - Lauda was 1976 Nurburgring
Rediscovery - The Mechanic Stohr hit actually survived albeit with broken legs