Jump to content


Photo

Last title won with inferior car.


  • Please log in to reply
49 replies to this topic

#1 Manson

Manson
  • Member

  • 2,064 posts
  • Joined: October 00

Posted 30 November 2000 - 19:24

When was the last time an F1 WDC was won by a driver who didn't have the best car that year (or equal to)? My opinion is Prost in 86 (and I'm certainly no fan of the Professor).

Advertisement

#2 Nikolas Garth

Nikolas Garth
  • Member

  • 12,019 posts
  • Joined: January 99

Posted 30 November 2000 - 19:27

1995

#3 AD

AD
  • Member

  • 3,364 posts
  • Joined: January 00

Posted 30 November 2000 - 19:29

2000 maybe, but definately 1995.

#4 Piquet_1

Piquet_1
  • Member

  • 344 posts
  • Joined: January 00

Posted 30 November 2000 - 19:29

1986

#5 Ross Stonefeld

Ross Stonefeld
  • Member

  • 71,197 posts
  • Joined: August 99

Posted 30 November 2000 - 19:30

There's a big difference in a team/driver winning with an inferior car, and a team/driver losing with a superior car; no matter what the year

#6 Todd

Todd
  • Member

  • 18,936 posts
  • Joined: September 99

Posted 30 November 2000 - 19:31

1995. 2000 was extremely close, but 1995 was no judgement call. The Williams was MUCH better that year.

#7 Manson

Manson
  • Member

  • 2,064 posts
  • Joined: October 00

Posted 30 November 2000 - 19:33

My point (if there is one) is that it doesn't happen very often 'cause the drivers are very close in talent. The top drivers anyway.

#8 magic

magic
  • Member

  • 5,678 posts
  • Joined: June 00

Posted 30 November 2000 - 19:45

benneton '95.

benneton winning constructors with 35 points diff.
same engine as the williams.
byrne and brawn vs newey and head.
pretty much equal packages.

jh , yes the same jh who was beaten senseless by ms, hhf, rb and irvine, winning twice, yes twice.
jh endung up with 45 points, dc in the williams 49 points.
dh 59 points, ms 102 points.
dh vs ms.
dh alas inferior to ms.

the benneton was hard to drive, but a great car.

if ms had won with the inferior ferrari in '96 it would be as great as ap in '86, who btw was lucky that nm and np robbed eachother.

#9 Peeko

Peeko
  • Member

  • 4,075 posts
  • Joined: October 99

Posted 30 November 2000 - 19:48

1995, and definately 1991. Once Williams fixed their reliability problems, it was easily the car to beat, and the springboard for the most dominating car of all-time.

#10 Todd

Todd
  • Member

  • 18,936 posts
  • Joined: September 99

Posted 30 November 2000 - 20:00

magic,

Herbert only did as well as he did because there was almost no competition from the 3rd best team. McLaren built a dog and Ferrari had numerous reliability problems. Herbert was a lap down to the race leaders, but still ahead of 5th place. Look at Herbert's wins:

Monza: Coulthard spun. Damon crashed out Schumacher. both Ferraris faltered ahead of him. Who did he have left to beat? Just Hakkinen in a car that looked as bad as it ran. Attrition was so high that both MP4-10s, both Saubers, and a Tyrrell were in the points that day. Were they almost as good as the Williams?

Silverstone: Once again, Damon crashed Schumacher from behind. Coulthard was penalized out of the lead for a pit speed violation. Hardly shows that the B195 could put Herbert on terms with the Cube or Damon.

Williams didn't score more points or wins because their drivers threw it all in the toilet. Damon Hill crashed 5 times that season. All were his fault.

#11 John B

John B
  • Member

  • 8,138 posts
  • Joined: June 99

Posted 30 November 2000 - 20:02

It was a good thing Senna made the most of the first four races that year, remember also that Mansell lost 10 points in Canada with the last lap crowd wave, a day that Senna didn't finish the race and got no points....

#12 Piquet_1

Piquet_1
  • Member

  • 344 posts
  • Joined: January 00

Posted 30 November 2000 - 20:07

I don't think Herbert ever be on terms with Hill or DC, just as DC can almost never be on terms with MS regardless of the car he has.

#13 Peeko

Peeko
  • Member

  • 4,075 posts
  • Joined: October 99

Posted 30 November 2000 - 20:21

It was a good thing Senna made the most of the first four races that year, remember also that Mansell lost 10 points in Canada with the last lap crowd wave, a day that Senna didn't finish the race and got no points....


John B, absolutely. Senna scored 52 pts when Mansell didn't finish, wheras Nigel was only able to score 11 without Senna!!

#14 Todd

Todd
  • Member

  • 18,936 posts
  • Joined: September 99

Posted 30 November 2000 - 21:09

Fun with quotes:

Originally posted by magic
benneton '95.

benneton winning constructors with 35 points diff.
same engine as the williams.
byrne and brawn vs newey and head.
pretty much equal packages.


Same day. Same magic. Different side of an argument:

Originally posted by magic
senna was right after all.

dh almost winning the wdc in '94, throwing away the '95 wdc in spite of having the best car, '96 winning the wdc thanx to having the best car, than jv winning the '97 also thanx to the top 2 williams.


Thanks magic. ;)

#15 Peeko

Peeko
  • Member

  • 4,075 posts
  • Joined: October 99

Posted 30 November 2000 - 21:12

:lol: :lol:

#16 magic

magic
  • Member

  • 5,678 posts
  • Joined: June 00

Posted 30 November 2000 - 21:17

hi todd,
i saw that one coming.
don't forget the context my friend.

_________________________________
Todd ... but 1995 was no judgement call. The Williams was MUCH better that year....
_________________________________

my response
_________________________________
benneton '95.

benneton winning constructors with 35 points diff.
same engine as the williams.
byrne and brawn vs newey and head.
pretty much equal packages.
_________________________________


"pretty much equal" as opposed to "MUCH better".

not better, but pretty much equal.
as in: the williams (maybe) slightly better.

only the "dh factor" making things too easy for ms to beat williams in '95.

would not have happened with senna at the wheel, my other point in another tread, another context

thanx for paying attention.

#17 Todd

Todd
  • Member

  • 18,936 posts
  • Joined: September 99

Posted 30 November 2000 - 21:34

magic,

Lets look at some 1995 numbers. Unless you think Damon and DC were faster than Michael, which is another issue completely, you can't get around the pace advantages of the Williams. Look at pole positions. 12 for Williams to 4 for Benetton and 1 for Ferrari. Look at podiums. 17 for Williams to 15 for Benetton, inspite of Williams drivers taking themselves out 9 times. Front row starting positions? 19 for Williams to 10 for Benetton and 5 for Ferrari. Do you think that this only relates to qualifying? Inspite of the comic driving turned in by Damon and DC, the Williams cars led 527 laps to Benettons 481(454 by Schumacher to 27 by Herbert) and 113 for Ferrari. Hill had one more mechanical problem cost him a points finish than Schumacher(Hungary) did, but the cars were FAR from equal.

#18 magic

magic
  • Member

  • 5,678 posts
  • Joined: June 00

Posted 30 November 2000 - 21:56

ok todd,

dh was a promoted second/testdriver to real men like nm, ap and as.
dc a rookie.
jh a joke®.

ms an alltime great on his bloody own,
cause;
mh struggled in a tripplewinged oatley mac and jv drove in carts, senna dead and burried, ap retired and nm playing golf , gaining weight all the time.

if you take all this into account it all adds up to two things;
1.same engine as the williams.
2.byrne and brawn vs newey and head.

pretty much equal packages.
pretty much unequal drivers.

only when the '96 williams was so MUCH better than the '96 ferrari the second/testdriver could not lose.


#19 Megatron

Megatron
  • Member

  • 3,688 posts
  • Joined: January 99

Posted 30 November 2000 - 22:04

1995
Maybe 1994
1986
1982
Maybe 1973

Near misses include 1997, 1966, and 1993.

I wouldn't call the 2000 Ferrari inferior, but I don't think it was the best.

Advertisement

#20 magic

magic
  • Member

  • 5,678 posts
  • Joined: June 00

Posted 30 November 2000 - 22:06

91, megatron, 91.

#21 mhferrari

mhferrari
  • Member

  • 3,238 posts
  • Joined: August 00

Posted 30 November 2000 - 22:53

1991. The Williams FW13, I believe, was better than the MP4/7, or possibly MP4/8 I am not sure. The Williams definetly had the car to beat, however, due to reliabilty it didn't finish, but definetly a lot of Senna's victories were hard earned.

#22 Piquet_1

Piquet_1
  • Member

  • 344 posts
  • Joined: January 00

Posted 30 November 2000 - 22:56

1991= FW14

[p][Edited by Piquet_1 on 12-01-2000]

#23 magic

magic
  • Member

  • 5,678 posts
  • Joined: June 00

Posted 30 November 2000 - 23:11

active suspension, newey aero, head engineering, renaultpower,
semiautogears.

this combo dominated f1 in the 90's, starting 4 races into the '91 season.
only senna brilliance in spa and monza saving the title for the going down mac-honda.

#24 The Mirror

The Mirror
  • Member

  • 364 posts
  • Joined: June 99

Posted 30 November 2000 - 23:51

I'm going with 1991, Senna in the heavy, thirsty V-12 MP4/7. The 1995 Benetton was too good to be called inferior, methinks.


#25 Dudley

Dudley
  • Member

  • 9,250 posts
  • Joined: March 00

Posted 01 December 2000 - 00:43

mhferrari - 1991 was an FW14. 1992 btw was FW14B. They never bothered racing the FW15 that year because it wasn't worth the risk and therefore started 1993 with the by the VERY good FW15C.

#26 senninha

senninha
  • Member

  • 3,842 posts
  • Joined: May 99

Posted 01 December 2000 - 02:10

1991, for sure

#27 ASaSeN

ASaSeN
  • Member

  • 288 posts
  • Joined: November 00

Posted 01 December 2000 - 03:30

Year 2000 was the last year.
95 also.

Magic......In 95 Dc got more poles in a season that michael got........all while being a rookie.
Doesnt that clearly show you which car was faster?
And 95 was the only season DC has ever got more poles that michael in a season.

Thas pretty damning evidence.

#28 magic

magic
  • Member

  • 5,678 posts
  • Joined: June 00

Posted 01 December 2000 - 06:30

dh the ultrasmooth testdriver on an empty track was quite usefull.
put him in race with 21 other cars, and let him overtake you got a few dnf in sight.

#29 Force Ten

Force Ten
  • Member

  • 4,100 posts
  • Joined: April 99

Posted 01 December 2000 - 07:38

Magic, didn't Hill overtake something like 18 cars at Monza 1998? Seems like by 1998 Hill had a pretty firm grasp of overtaking in his hands. The earlier years it was not his forte for sure, probably also something to to with the fact he had basically no experience racing in midpack. When he was thrusted there, he learned and managed OK.

If you really like to throw stings out at Hill (and I know you do), please have some back too, by the end of 1998 the only significant overtaking Häkkinen had ever made (you know the one actually getting him somewhere) was Nurburgring and Eddie Irvine. (There was a race at 1997 when he qualified badly and ende up 6th in the race, pretty much alike Hill at Monza 1998.) Pretty much on par with Hill and his Hungary 1997... You know, I watch Finnish coverage, if there's evena a sniff of Häkkinen doing anything, I will hear it for sure.

#30 Ray Bell

Ray Bell
  • Member

  • 85,524 posts
  • Joined: December 99

Posted 01 December 2000 - 07:44

Can I put in a vote for 1991, when Jones and Reutemann were in Williams together. Carlos was pinching points (literally) off Jonesy, so they went to the final event with both of them and also Piquet in the running.

#31 Mickey

Mickey
  • Member

  • 2,870 posts
  • Joined: August 00

Posted 01 December 2000 - 11:48

Not trying to be pedantic, Ray, but obviously you are referring to 1981.

I'd add 1982 too, where Rosberg was WDC in a car that was not the best. Of course, one cannot overlook the fact that it would have surely been one of the Ferrari drivers taking the championship, had they not met tragedy.

#32 Ray Bell

Ray Bell
  • Member

  • 85,524 posts
  • Joined: December 99

Posted 01 December 2000 - 11:57

Right, Mickey, dead right, it was 1981 - that's the problem when you touch type numbers only periodically.

#33 Mickey

Mickey
  • Member

  • 2,870 posts
  • Joined: August 00

Posted 01 December 2000 - 12:01

Hehe, I know the feeling... that's why I've permanently given up touch typing :)

#34 Nathan

Nathan
  • Member

  • 10,703 posts
  • Joined: February 00

Posted 01 December 2000 - 16:26

If not '95 then '94.

#35 magic

magic
  • Member

  • 5,678 posts
  • Joined: June 00

Posted 01 December 2000 - 17:07

Force Ten, it's quite hard to overtake a car when your car is slower.
but when mh finally had a worhthy machine he overtook ms (spa'00)

#36 hannu

hannu
  • Member

  • 197 posts
  • Joined: September 00

Posted 01 December 2000 - 17:38

Now you all seem to forget a one thing. All kredit to MS but
the real factor in 1995 win was compination of following things: 1. Damon Hill was beated mentally that year which he later said and in this situation driver is hardlt in his best. 2. Benetton driving Traction control. Of course Ms
drove well and I´m not trying to let him down, Just let´s not forget that facts.

#37 Todd

Todd
  • Member

  • 18,936 posts
  • Joined: September 99

Posted 01 December 2000 - 18:07

hannu,

Nice 'facts'. The allegations of traction control were in 1994. :rolleyes:

#38 hannu

hannu
  • Member

  • 197 posts
  • Joined: September 00

Posted 01 December 2000 - 18:18

Do you really thing that If Benetton managed to escape in 1995 they suddenly stopped using TC? No way.

#39 Todd

Todd
  • Member

  • 18,936 posts
  • Joined: September 99

Posted 01 December 2000 - 18:27

Never mind. I remember who you are now.

Advertisement

#40 Bruce

Bruce
  • Member

  • 8,357 posts
  • Joined: December 98

Posted 01 December 2000 - 19:43

1995 - inferior car - but not by much.

1991 - inferior car - but not by much.

1986 - way inferior car - the prototype with how to lose the WDC through having 2 good drivers and no team orders.

1982 - WAY inferior car - but reliable.

1981 - inferior car coming up the middle again...

#41 John B

John B
  • Member

  • 8,138 posts
  • Joined: June 99

Posted 01 December 2000 - 20:06

The 1981 Brabham was pretty decent. It was in a world of its own in the early races (Rebaque passing Williams and Renaults with ease at Argentina) and only some bizarre tire strategy in the rain at Brazil kept Piquet from the early points lead. Even after the rule changes, Piquet was robbed of a dominant win in France by officials though he got a gift at Hockenheim. Brabham didn't look good in the WCC standings because they brought in a definite #2 for money. Williams was good all year, but only won 4 races. If Renault had been able to get their 1981 car on the track before June, Prost could have had his first title.[p][Edited by John B on 12-01-2000]

#42 RayB NSX

RayB NSX
  • New Member

  • 20 posts
  • Joined: November 00

Posted 01 December 2000 - 20:13

Off topic but wasnt 1991 the MP 4/6? I keep seeing people refer to the MP4/7 for 91.

#43 Piquet_1

Piquet_1
  • Member

  • 344 posts
  • Joined: January 00

Posted 01 December 2000 - 20:19

MP4/6 = 91 and start of 92

MP4/7 = most of 92

#44 Todd

Todd
  • Member

  • 18,936 posts
  • Joined: September 99

Posted 01 December 2000 - 20:41

Why doesn't anyone mention 1983? The Brabham BMW had its strengths, but Ferrari had 8 poles to Brabham's 2. The Brabham was also 3rd in WCC and 5th in completed laps.

#45 hannu

hannu
  • Member

  • 197 posts
  • Joined: September 00

Posted 01 December 2000 - 20:43

Todd, what do yuo mean? I`m not against Shuey. I know he is truly good driver and I really try to avoid nonsens that many athors write about MS AND Häkkinen. I try to thing with common sense and Try see things like they are. That I´m finnish has nothing (at least I try) to do that what I thing. I thing that MS and MH are both great and they really deserve titles they have, excpet 1994.

#46 John B

John B
  • Member

  • 8,138 posts
  • Joined: June 99

Posted 01 December 2000 - 21:35

Todd,

Patrese's long string of DNF's affected Brabham's stats for 1983, but I think the car was competitive at almost every track from the season opener Brazil to the finale at South Africa (crashes and flat tires cost several more wins - Imola, Detroit, possibly Holland). The Ferraris took a lot of points from each other (as opposed to Piquet and Prost) and were handicapped at several tracks by tires which were good in qualifying but clearly behind in the race.

Ironically, Piquet reversed his qualifying/race pattern the following year by winning 9 or 10 poles but never factoring in the title race due to many DNFs.

#47 Todd

Todd
  • Member

  • 18,936 posts
  • Joined: September 99

Posted 01 December 2000 - 21:52

John,

Competitive at almost every track doesn't mean that it was as good as the Ferrari, or even the Renault. Piquet and Prost both drove brilliantly to finish 1-2 in the title chase.

#48 mhferrari

mhferrari
  • Member

  • 3,238 posts
  • Joined: August 00

Posted 01 December 2000 - 22:01

Sorry about that, I get my MP4/, I should have counted back from 1995s MP4/10.

#49 mikedeering

mikedeering
  • Member

  • 3,522 posts
  • Joined: July 00

Posted 01 December 2000 - 22:15

1995 - Benetton was not that inferior to Williams - they had the same engine!!! Williams may have had a slightly better car, but still look at the facts - Coulthard won once, Herbert twice, yet I would rate DC above JH any day - OK luck figured with Herbert's wins but still...

Similarly , 1994 - at the start the Benetton was clearly better - possibly through cheating but whatever the reasons - the Williams was crap until mid season...

1991 - Williams was not quickest until Canada, after Senna had won 4 in a row - after that Williams was best car, but unreliable - then Honda made a big effort for Japan and I would say at Suzuka and Adelaide the McLaren was the best car again, so hard to tell - about equal.

1986 - McLaren definitely no where near Williams - nice one Alain, job well done.

1982 - Williams wasn't quickest - turbos were, but owing to various reaosns - unreliability and accidents mainly involving turbo drivers Rosberg won - but different to 1986 - Keke was very lucky to be WC - Prost in 1986 clearly deserved to be WC.

After that, well looking at the 70s I can't say anyone won with a slow car. How about 1962 - Hill in the BRM?

I think the issue is whether it counts if a fast car is unreliable - take 1991 and 1982 for example.

1986 was one of a kind - Williams didn't lose due to unreliability - they lost due partialy to team infighting and alot due to Prost always figuring in the points and being consistent - as Irvine said - "The World Championship is nothing special...unless you win it the way Alain did in 1986."

I am not a Prost fan particularly - I certainly prefered Senna in the late eighties, but fair play - 1986 was some achievement.

#50 John B

John B
  • Member

  • 8,138 posts
  • Joined: June 99

Posted 02 December 2000 - 00:19

Originally posted by Todd
John,

Competitive at almost every track doesn't mean that it was as good as the Ferrari, or even the Renault. Piquet and Prost both drove brilliantly to finish 1-2 in the title chase.



Granted, at least until September. The last races of the year were a Brabham benefit as they made a huge performance leap (fuel?) to close the year, most evident at the South Africa finale. Ferrari got hurt at several tracks (Ricard, Silverstone, Brands, Kyalami) by race tires that weren't considered up to Michelin's level.