Jump to content


Photo

The best Formula 1 Season in the last 20 years


  • Please log in to reply
57 replies to this topic

#51 jimm

jimm
  • Member

  • 3,228 posts
  • Joined: June 99

Posted 19 September 2010 - 18:26

It's a interesting year, but I have to agree with you, this year is missing thiings like:

Basic untouched formula one rules
the major issue

In the last 20 years, which means 1990 -1994, the cars were just more balanced in terms of aero but not so bad we can drive behind cars and press on, dirty air in the last say 5 years has just become more acceptable which is silly as f1 is just hurting itself here, this can be improved.


I think were missing proper gladitorial title fights, I can't help but think of Briatore's comments a while ago, saying drivers are like taxi drivers, stop and go, when overtaking became difficult, you had pitstop and strategy, now you just have pitstop4 tyres, yet overtaking is still difficult and your limited with strategies, it's harder for the driver to make a difference other then qualifying on certain tracks.


Lack of testing and difficulity of in season development, means alot of driver's fates are decided 2 early in the season with how the car is born, I think the testing ban is silly, maybe they can cut it, but to stop it completely is wrong I think, new drivers need testing miles, testing new parts on weekends, maybe they could increase the sessions if they want to keep more races, and the fans can see more of their drivers/teams.


Alonso and Hamilton are challenging for the title ,but they've hardly seen or raced each other for a win this year, its' weird, it's not like Schumacher and Hakkinen who were tenths and thousandths off each other at Japan 2000 the whole weekend, qualifying to the race shows how driver/team go away, work and come to a track to fight for a title that's not been effected by things like not being able to test, to have 2 teams close together for 2 drivers to have some close exchanges makes f1 stand still, the end of season title showdowns in 94/97/98/99/2000/2003/20006.

Jerez 97, 3 drivers get the same time for quali before the race, that was cool.


1997 the last slick tyre season, with overtaking, pitstop strategies, is the type of season we should be having.


Lewis Hamilton vs Schumacher-if he's in a top car can make or would of made this year a classic
Hamilton and Alonso as teamates in 2007 beats any duels they had in 2010-which is pretty much none


The seaosn isn't over, it's been a interesting season, but the closeness of the championship isn't much about driver skill rather then all other factors of motor racing that keeps the title championship open, but because it's open, doesn't mean it's open and exciting the same way every weekend, alot of cars seem track specific, and when we want redbull vs ferrari, or mclaren vs ferrari, the drivers hardly race each other, as the competitive advantage keeps shifting, maybe that's interesting, but not when the season is closing up, if one driver is off the pace and crowds r expecting a close fight, that's dissappointing, and with budget cuts and cost saving/lack of testing, really preparing for showdowns and title fights may not have the same level of contest.


To put it bluntly
screw cost saving
give me qualifying engines
1 race engines, 1 qualifying engine
let it rip, don't hold back, push every lap, risk reliability, something we used to have, caution and f1 don't mean exciting.

We got great drivers
The show though is preventing it from living up to the past.

And any f1 season with Ayrton Senna in it is better then 2010, and he died back in 1994. I don't think we've see any driving that tops Senna and Schumacher's best of the past 20 years, qualifying was poorer without Ayrton, but worser in 2003 when they started tinkering with the show, so for sure this season can't be the best, alot of good drivers, but perhaps wasted with these rules and cars. I don't think we've seen 1 real stand out great drive, alot of very good drives, but nothing monumental to talk about for the next 20 years like were still talking about some of Senna and Schumacher's stuff of the past 20 years, maybe the rules are to blame and this how cost cutting nature, and were moving to even less engines in the future.

No more Sunday warm up from 2003 onwards
Can't touch the cars after qualifying until the race? Why, because maybe a random guessed set up will produce unpredictable results, which was the reason it was introduced in 2003 along with other rubbish.


Alot more can be done.


I could rewatch a classic 1993 race or a race in 1997/98/ and find alot of things



:lol: I think for it to be the best for you it has to feature Micheal Schumacher in the title hunt.

I actualy agree this is the best season since at least '86 and probably since 1983. At least 3 teams with 5 drivers real title threats. The points look really spread out but in reality it is very close with all the drivers around 1 race win worth of points from first. As Lewis showed, it only takes 1 DNF to completly change the look of the WDC...the WCC also quite close.

Advertisement

#52 Massa_f1

Massa_f1
  • Member

  • 5,630 posts
  • Joined: October 07

Posted 22 September 2010 - 22:07

One of the reasons the last few seasons in F1 have been thrilling championship battles is cause of the lack of consistency in todays drivers. People say that this is the best generation of drivers. They may well be the quickest but some of them are very inconsistent and its not down to the cars either cause this years Red Bull is at least on par with the Williams of 96 and one of there drivers should be guaranteed champion by now. Inconsistency has been the key.

#53 Ferrim

Ferrim
  • Member

  • 1,390 posts
  • Joined: October 07

Posted 22 September 2010 - 23:32

Only Red Bull's disasters has made this season interesting in the first place.

Bahrein: Vettel's car fails.
Australia: Vettel's car fails. Webber crashes on his own.
Malaysia: 1-2.
China: messed up with the weather conditions.
Spain: Vettel's car fails again.
Monaco: 1-2.
Turkey: infamous teammate crash (Vettel's fault)
Canada: wrong strategy.
Europe: Webber has an awful start and then crashes on his own.
Great Britain: they make contact and Vettel has a puncture.
Germany: Vettel tries a desperate move to avoid losing the lead and as a result also loses 2nd place. Webber has a very annonymous race.
Hungary: Vettel gets a penalty for falling too far behind the SC and loses a sure win.
Belgium: horrible start by Webber. Vettel crashes into Button.
Italy: more reliability woes for Vettel, although in the end they probably maximised their chances.


They've managed to screw up in 12 out of 14 races. Impressive... and if they hadn't people would be crying for rule changes and attacking the ban on refuelling for giving us such a boring season.

#54 AndreasF1

AndreasF1
  • Member

  • 1,200 posts
  • Joined: February 02

Posted 23 September 2010 - 00:21

I would agree that the 2010 season has been competitive and interesting. However, I don't feel that it quite has the "epic" quality of the Senna/Mansell/Prost battles of the early 1990s, or the Schumacher/Mika, Ferrari/McLaren tussles of 1998-2001.


I agree. 1990 with Senna vs Prost was epic!

#55 Mary Popsins

Mary Popsins
  • Member

  • 729 posts
  • Joined: July 09

Posted 23 September 2010 - 04:05

The season is more interesting for the drama than for the racing, but drama is good.

It's a bit like the Damon Hill/J Villeneuve years although today the drivers are generally more skilled (and too impetuous). It's not at the level of an Alonso v M Schumacher or Hamilton v Alonso season.

Another thing is the tracks and I can hardly see how a season which includes Bahrain, Sepang or Valencia could be the best ever.

#56 gricey1981

gricey1981
  • Member

  • 1,192 posts
  • Joined: October 09

Posted 23 September 2010 - 18:28

This thread cracks me up. Most of you have the rose tinted glasses on looking at yester year.

You want people at the front trading fast lap. Look at Button/Alonso in the very last race.

It has not really been about mistakes either. Button has made none.... Hamilton has made what one! Webber has always been underated - he got points in a Minardi for goodness sake. Alonso has made a couple and so has Vettel but even the "mighty" Senna made a bunch of mistakes. Look at brazil in 94 and Monz 88 tripping over the backmaker.

This thread stinks of "in my day things were better"

Its been a good season definatley. Although i liked the seasons when schumacher dominated. Thought it was a grand example of how to do it... so maybe my views should be taken with a pinch of salt


#57 hotstickyslick

hotstickyslick
  • Member

  • 3,418 posts
  • Joined: April 10

Posted 23 September 2010 - 18:32

The best F1 season in 22 years? I beg to differ.

I find the 2007 season much better in terms of drama, controversies, excitement, etc. The WDC was decided months later after the last race in Interlagos after the ICA found no merits in the fuel-temperature saga. Raikkonen triumphed over a rookie and a 2-time F1 champion by a single point. McLaren was docked USD100mil in the Spygate scandal. Renault was not found guilty of the same offense, and received a slap on the wrist in Spygate II.

IMHO, 2007 was the best season in the last 20 years or so.

You just summed up 2007, which had a good WDC fight, wasn't that good at all... Every race was won by either McLaren or Ferrari and the off-track dramas took away from the on-track ones.

#58 RealRacing

RealRacing
  • Member

  • 2,541 posts
  • Joined: February 12

Posted 16 December 2012 - 18:37

Hey I'm watching every single Formula 1 race since 1988 (22 years), and have downloaded races from the 60s, 70s, 80s.

I find this season to be the best Formula 1 season I have ever seen. The competition is closer and better then it has ever been before. Hamilton, Alonso, Schumacher, Button, Webber, Vettel,... an absolutely awesome field of drivers who in my opinion has more raw talent packed up in 1 grid then ever before.

Yeah you had the Sennas, Mansels, Prosts, Bergers, but was it really that hard back then to get to the top, sure it was hard, but not as hard as today, the competitiveness today all across the different motorsport series, from Kart to Formula cars, the talent density, the sheer numbers of drivers fighting to get into F1 is much bigger. So the current field of drivers in Formula 1, there talent level is just unbelievable high.

Then the racing, there are enough overtaking maneuvres, lots of close action, a close field, its possible to overtake, but its also possible to defend, it has the right mix. Thank God there is no KERS so every overtaking maneuvre is a legitimate one.

The new point system hides how close the battle for the championship really is, but if you look at it with the traditional point system, the fight is extremely close.

Its a great season for Formula 1, might be the best, but lets watch til the end. I wouldnt mind them not changing the rules at all for next season. We have found a winning formula (dont need KERS)



Found this thread looking for a clue of which season to download. I have also watched since 1987 or so, but would prefer to download one I haven't seen or one that's really worth repeating. In any case, where did you download the older seasons?

Cheers.