Someone is bound to die sooner or later in F1. Racing is dangerous, and that's all there is to it. I'm happy the sport is as safe as it is now, but I think in most areas it's as good as it needs to be, and in some areas, it's gone too far the other way. If the cars are safe enough, then the tracks don't necessarily need to be, but this doesn't stop the slaughter of classic circuits with miles of runoff.
What people need to realize is that we can't just look at it from a racing perspective when a driver is killed in a crash. Of course it sucks, because we're racing fans. We can empathize and understand better than if we're just one of those chumps who knows nothing about racing beyond the occasional crash (like IndyCar's 2011 finale) that is sufficiently-horrible for the mainstream news to show that night. Some of us may have even met a driver who was later killed in a crash.
But do we feel the same way when there's some dead skydiver on the news? Alpine skiier? Well no, we don't, but why not? Racing is just as much of a pointless adrenaline rush from the driver's perspective as other "sports", so we can hardly claim it's tragic when a driver is killed but not when some other speed freak in a different discipline heads to the great spawn screen in the sky. "Accident" is a tricky word to use, because what is accidental about a fatal crash, really? The driver didn't just happen to be there (and for that matter, neither did any marshals or spectators) and there really is no "wrong place, wrong time". Accepting the risks doesn't make it any less horrible, but it doesn't make it any more unfair. No one on that list accidentally became a racing driver. Sometimes, horrible **** will happen to you. Anyone with a list of names and an internet connection can find more than enough video and photo evidence of the kind of ridiculous risks you're taking, to be a willing participant in a sport with a vivid history of decapitating, dismembering, barbecuing, disfiguring, suffocating and on occasional just plain disintegrating it's athletes. Racing is 99.9% positive, but the God awful truth is a lot of nasty things can happen to you, and every racing driver who is competing at a high enough level for us to be talking about him here has had years to reconsider if he wants to continue racing.
Look how close Moreno Soeprapto came to just about the worst way to go, and only timely intervention from fellow driver James Winslow allowed him to... continue racing to this day.
http://www.youtube.c...h?v=ecBc05xdrLQI would find racing difficult to watch if this was still the 60s and 70s. I don't know if I would have had the stomach for it. I am extremely happy that the sport as a whole has gotten so safe that half the reason we find things like Wheldon/Simoncelli so shocking is because they're rare now. The feeling today is "How could this happen?", when 40 years ago, it was "There goes another friend". If it has to be one or the other, anyone in their right mind would take today's racing over that of 40 years ago from the standpoint of safety. If it has to be one or the other, I'd rather it be "too safe", then "not safe enough". But there has to be a happy medium. These aren't children, they're grown adults. If their adult decision is to accept the risks, good on them. Note that they also have ability to decide not to race as well. Of course, if their decision is to make the sport safer, it's really none of the fan's business to say no, but these threads tend to go in the direction that anyone who doesn't immediately ask for everything to be sunshine and butterflies just wants to see crashes, which sounds suspiciously to me like the kind of logic that if you have nothing to hide, you have no reason to be private. Stupid logic, in other words.
Logic almost as stupid as the suggestions of things like cockpits for single seaters, fenders for open-wheelers, and God knows what else gets brought up every time we see a big accident. I can't speak for anyone else, but my thoughts are that there is nothing wrong with pursuing ways to minimize the likelihood of injury or death to a racing driver:
but, I also think there are situations where the risk removed is so minimal, that the collective bullshit caused by the safety improvement is not worth it, just to possibly save one or two drivers in the next decade (again, drivers who chose to be there). This is how I look at cockpits for F1 cars, which could certainly prevent an injury or a death here and there, but seem at every curve in the road to be a massive overreaction. One death and one injury in the last ten seasons is not an epidemic desperately in need of a cure, specifically if that cure is lock drivers into cars that every season wind up inevitably upside down, on fire, stuck under barriers, and at more tracks than is really necessary, come within 30 feet of God damn lakes.
Here is a good reason not to have canopies in F1:

A little-known fact is that Heidfeld was quoted after the accident as saying
"I didn't think those Autosport forummers wanted Senna in the car this badly".I'm not sure which race that was, as Heidfeld was nearly barbecued twice in that season (interestingly, that's two times as many incidents in a season where a canopy could've caused a death to a driver who clearly had no problem at all surviving the incidents unscathed, compared to the one time in the previous ten seasons a canopy might have saved a driver (Massa), who as it turns out didn't need saving as he returned to racing the next year, continues to race to this day, and as far as I'm aware, has so far not once asked for cockpits in F1 cars).
A lot of the problems I have with this safety chase is that so much of it is just people running in circles, like a dog chasing their tail.
Every single safety improvement ever made in F1 has had unintended consequences, whether positive or negative. Here is a quick story to demonstrate this point: In 1970, barely any tracks had Armco barriers. Racing drivers, particularly in F1, found themselves needing a change of overalls more often than they should have, due to a distressing habit of their cars to end up hundreds of feet off the track due to lack of barriers. One simple mistake could land you upside down in a ravine, stuck in a tree, crashed into a building, or any other number of a dozen places racing cars generally shouldn't be. Bear in mind as well, that this was an era when often the only way to know there was an accident, is when your driver's car stopped showing up at the start line every lap. This usually was followed by clouds of smoke appearing through the trees. So, let's install Armco barriers. That will make the tracks safer. And indeed it did - no one can say for sure how many lives Armco saved, but undoubtedly there's plenty on the list over the past 40 or 50 years. Job well done?
Well, from the 1970 to 1975 Formula One seasons, Armco barriers also did this:
1970 Italy: Jochen Rindt hits armco barrier, is killed.
1973 Holland: Roger Williamson's car is overturned by poorly-installed Armco. Williamson burns to death in the resulting fire, unable to escape.
1973 USA: Francois Cevert is cut in half when his car pierces through an Armco barrier.
1974 South Africa: Peter Revson is killed in a collision with Armco
1974 USA: Helmuth Koenigg is decapitated when his car slides under Armco in an otherwise minor incident.
1975 Spain: 5 spectators are killed when Armco barriers launch Rolf Stommelen into the crowd.
This does not include countless other incidents (for example, Gerry Birrell) where Armco played a pivotal roll in causing a casualty. I'm not blaming a safety improvement for being the opposite: for all any of us know, the Armco prevented
more casualties in those accidents by protecting spectators and marshals. But no one can deny that a safety feature that was pushed for to be installed at all tracks played a critical part in several awful accidents. No one can deny that something the drivers themselves specifically asked for played a part in the deaths of a lot of people.
I know that makes for grim reading, but we have to remember that fact. There is absolutely nothing you can do to a racing car or a racing track that will only do exactly what you meant it to: everything will have side-effects, unintended consequences, and while I've got no problem experimenting and finding ways to minimize those consequences (innovation is a beautiful thing), we cannot pretend that it would only be a positive to have cockpits, or to have this or that. I've long thought, for instance, that higher cockpit sides may do a wonderful job preventing head injuries, but that they also may cause more accidents than otherwise would have happened due to their impact on peripheral vision. If Nico Hulkenberg gets into an accident this weekend because he couldn't see a car beside him, and is then saved by the high walls of the cockpit during the resulting crash, is that "safer"? I'm not saying I'm right about any of this but it's something we need to be thinking about.
During IndyCar's trip to Mid Ohio last year Justin Wilson broke his back in what looked like a minor crash. I was listening to Radio Le Mans and they were talking about possible changes to the track for next season. Again, tail-chasing. It does no good to change it after the damage has been done.
"Well, we have to get rid of that gravel trap, it flipped a car. Let's pave it all".Then a car has a stuck throttle, and what was once gravel (stuck throttle antidote) but now asphalt results in a leg-breaking crash.
"****, better put the gravel back for next year".Then a car flips instead of just calmly returning to the circuit, completely fine.
"Okay, let's pave it, but lay down some speed bumps".Then a car is launched over the barriers and into the trees.
"Damn, better put more barriers".Then a car crashes into the barriers and it takes half an hour to extricate the critically-injured driver.
"Fine, let's make it a chicane".Then the much harder breaking zone and trickier section causes five accidents in the next race, and countless break failures elsewhere on the track.
"Screw it, let's just go to Laguna Seca".I hope someone can at least see what I'm getting at with this. It's not anti-safety or anti-improvement, but we can't pretend anything is the be-all and end-all. As long as there is racing, there is a chance something bad will happen. There is a big, big difference from someone saying "Let's change the tracks every opportunity, and sucks to the consequences" than someone saying "You know, maybe putting that fireworks factory, gas station and oil refinery at the end of the main straight was a bad idea". I know this. I watch a hundred races a year, and I'd trade a kidney for a chance to race cars for a living (hell, I'll trade both kidneys for a ride in F1). And I'm just a dumbass watching racing on TV. I understand that there is a chance something bad will happen. I was sitting here shooting the breeze with many of you when Dan Wheldon's crash happened. I saw Greg Moore and Dale Earnhardt die live, when I was 8 and 9 years old respectively. I don't want to have to ever see anything like that again, but the risk of it happening, that element of danger, has to remain. At least
some of it does. It's as much a part of racing as wheels and engines. Half the charm of karting when I raced was how exciting it was to be doing something dangerous. I'd be sitting in the pits waiting to go out and think about how all week I just sat on my fat lazy ass doing nothing but waiting for the time next week to roll around where I could do something exciting for a change. And I was just a moron in a go-kart, not sending a car into Turn 1 at Indianapolis at 200mph. And it's so easy to be overwhelmed when a driver you were just watching battling for 3rd place one lap a go is now dead at the side of the track.
So easy to be overwhelmed and forget the thousands of hours of happiness racing brings you and me every year. In other words, there is a difference between something needing all our energy dedicated to preventing it happening, compared to something we should just try and make impossible, and then hope it doesn't happen too often. Can't speak for anyone else, but I think racing is just about as safe as it needs to be and I'd rather see more work done to consolidate and re-enforce what we already have, to make sure where we are with safety right now is as thoughtful as it can be, than to worry about gimmicky cockpits and potentially open up a whole new batch of problems. And I know if I was a driver (and to that small, embarrassingly-insignificant few years karting, I was), I knew the risk of injury for the rush and lifestyle was a reasonable price to pay, and that's what I'd be telling people now if I was one of the guys we all spend our time on this forum arguing about.
When things are going good, we talk about racing drivers like heroic combatants. When a crash happens, we talk about them like innocent victims.
It's probably somewhere in the middle.
And if you disagree with everything I've said here, don't worry. Racing will continue to get safer and safer. 40 years from now, our grandkids will probably be arguing over the wireless chips implanted in their brains about whether force fields to keep cars from leaving the circuit need to be implemented, when that trusty old Acme super glue we put along the track boundaries that stops a car from 200mph to 0 in a quarter of a second seems to be doing just fine. Maybe they'll talk about today's drivers the same way we look at those in the "dangerous" 70s and 80s. When we say "Gilles Villeneuve, now there was a brave guy", maybe in 2050 people will be watching Youtube footage of the 2012 Abu Dhabi Grand Prix and think "Damn, that Rosberg was a lunatic. Him and Karthikeyan, now that's when drivers were really
men". All I can say is that when it comes to improving safety, it takes very little time to lose some of the charm of racing. A tightrope walker suspended a perilous two feet over a giant trampoline with medics on hand in case of rug burn isn't my idea of an exciting sport to follow, and while we are definitely not so nancy-stated in racing that we're there yet, I can't help but admit to being a little disheartened when that seems to be the direction we're headed. At a safe speed, hopefully.
Edited by Andrew Hope, 12 November 2012 - 18:00.