Results from the FIA accident panel
Advertisement
Posted 03 December 2014 - 17:09
Posted 03 December 2014 - 17:23
It can be in karting particularly. It seems though that they are levelling part of the blame on the Marussia BBW system,Jeez, stamped on throttle and brake? Is that normal, I couldn't quite understand what it meant by the torque over ride
Posted 03 December 2014 - 17:27
So unsurprisingly the FIA panel finds no fault with the FIA. Knock me over with a feather. ![]()
If Jules was travelling too fast the biggest reason for that was the way the FIA/Charlie Whiting have eroded the double waved yellow rule over recent years. It's gone from "slow down, prepare to stop" to "demonstrate you've gone a tiny irrelevant bit slower than the previous lap". That's why he was going too fast - if he did it properly he'd be disadvantaged, they are forced into going to fast.
Guess it's much easier to blame the guy in a coma than it is to accept & deal with the consequences. ![]()
#ForzaJules
Edited by Lopek, 03 December 2014 - 17:28.
Posted 03 December 2014 - 17:35
That's the first time in a while that I've read something relating to an offical statement about F1 that is entirely sensible. i'm glad the start times are going to be reviewed, I've screamed about that for years. Expect more night races though!
Edited by Kristian, 03 December 2014 - 17:35.
Posted 03 December 2014 - 17:38
This is not relevant to Jules' recovery. Perhaps a mod could consider moving this post and replies to the appropriate thread where the causes of the accident and possible measures to avoid recurrence were being discussed?
Posted 03 December 2014 - 17:48
This is not relevant to Jules' recovery. Perhaps a mod could consider moving this post and replies to the appropriate thread where the causes of the accident and possible measures to avoid recurrence were being discussed?
It has now been split into a new thread by a mod. ![]()
Posted 03 December 2014 - 17:49
The report is very factual and fair - it does not apportion "blame" as such and is very specific in that
Posted 03 December 2014 - 18:16
It is considered fundamentally wrong to try and make an impact between a racing car and a large and heavy vehicle survivable. It is imperative to prevent a car ever hitting the crane and/or the marshals working near it.
![]()
The Clerk of the Course will impose a speed limit in any section of track where double yellow flags are being displayed.
- This is the right measure. I've been arguing for it, although I'm more than happy for the Accident Panel to donate my consultancy fee to a charity of their choice. Note it specifically says in the section of track where the flags are, not over the whole course. So they disagree with Whiting. I hope F1 will listen.
It is proposed that a regulation or guideline be established such that the Start time of an event shall not be less than 4 hours before either sunset or dusk, except in the case of night races.
It is also recommended that the F1 Calendar is reviewed in order to avoid, where possible, races taking place during local rainy seasons.
- Although Ecclestone will fight this. In fact, he probably already has, because I doubt the words "or guideline" were in the first draft...
But it's been raised as a safety concern by the Accident Panel now, so we'll see if the FIA continues to claim it's not a safety concern and just give FOM whatever calendar and event timetables it asks for. They may not be able to risk it anymore...
It is proposed that drivers acquiring a Super Licence for the first time should undertake a course to familiarise themselves with the procedures used by F1 in running and ensuring the safety of an event.
It is also proposed that new licence holders pass a test to ensure that they are familiar with all the relevant regulations.
Can't hurt, I guess.
Consideration will be given to a review of F1 risk, in order to ascertain whether there are any significant holes in the safety defences, such that an unforeseen combination of circumstances could result in a serious accident.
I think I posted something along these lines in the Virtual Safety Car thread. Examples of small risks being mitigated and much bigger risks being ignored are rife in motorsport, although thankfully most of the biggest risks which have led to serious accidents do get addressed. But I think some sort of systematic, holistic risk assessment would be a very good idea.
I find it hard to agree that there was nothing about the situation to differentiate it from the hundreds of other routine incidents that had been covered by local yellows in the previous eight years. You didn't need hindsight to know that the conditions were already worse than when the Race Director hadn't been prepared to allow the race to start, and worsening, and you didn't need hindsight to surmise that Sutil might have aquaplaned off on standing water, which gives rise to the risk of somebody else going off on the same bit of standing water. And you didn't need hindsight to recall 1994, where a very similar sequence of events occurred. However, the first recommendation, if implemented, is a much more constructive response than just blaming the Race Director, so I'm quite happy with this.
Posted 03 December 2014 - 18:18
The report is very factual and fair - it does not apportion "blame" as such and is very specific in that
Hmm. It seems an attempt to specifically blame Jules and Marussia to me, even contradicting what Charlie Whiting has said in the past:
http://www.autosport....php/id/116271/
http://www.autosport....php/id/116360/
He's said that other drivers were going faster than Jules. Here (point 4) it's said that 'If drivers adhere to the requirements of double yellow flags, as set out in Appendix H, Art. 2.4.5.1.b, then neither competitors nor officials should be put in immediate or physical danger' which must mean that the FIA has been telling drivers it's OK to ignore the requirements. Otherwise where were the penalties for all the drivers who were too fast?
Point 10 might be true, but it doesn't answer any questions about supposed delay in getting Bianchi to the hospital. It just tells us 'nothing to see here. Move along.'
Point 3 is nonsense, since drivers have crashed at low speed. Was he too fast for the Marussia? Maybe, but again they're telling us 'there's nothing to see here' rather than giving us any reason to believe them.
Point 5 is untrue, since there've been plenty of questions in the past about running the race while tractors are alongside the track. Regulations may have been followed but that's not the point - the point is that the regulations may have been flawed. Which recommendation 1 surely suggests was the case.
I'm surprised that the Marussia's Brake-by-Wire system 'proved to be incompatible with the FailSafe settings' and also that the authorities hadn't checked that it was compatible before allowing them to use it.
A last point: Charlie Whiting had previously said 'the race start time is not really a matter for the FIA' so it's interesting to see the FIA now deciding that it is sometimes a matter for the FIA. Perhaps they've changed their minds under the influence of this crash? Perhaps it's just the way they've phrased their responses that make their words seem more like the result of eagerness to disavow all responsibility.
Edited by santori, 04 December 2014 - 06:32.
Posted 03 December 2014 - 18:22
However, the first recommendation, if implemented, is a much more constructive response than just blaming the Race Director, so I'm quite happy with this.
The 2 things don't have to be exclusive imo.
You can have constructive changes from what has been learned as well as understanding who was to blame for failings & handing out appropriate sanctions if necessary. Sadly this seems like an FIA whitewash when it comes to their own actions - not only on the day but more so the way the enforcement of safety rules have been eroded over recent years.
Posted 03 December 2014 - 18:35
Hmm. It seems an attempt to specifically blame Jules and Marussia to me, even contradicting what Charlie Whiting has said in the past:
http://www.autosport....php/id/116271/
http://www.autosport....php/id/116360/
He's said that other drivers were going faster than Jules. Here (point 4) it's said that 'If drivers adhere to the requirements of double yellow flags, as set out in Appendix H, Art. 2.4.5.1.b, then neither competitors nor officials should be put in immediate or physical danger' which must mean that the FIA has been telling drivers it's OK to ignore the requirements. Otherwise where were the penalties for all the drivers who were too fast?
Point 10 might be true, but it doesn't answer any questions about supposed delay in getting Bianchi to the hospital. It just tells us 'nothing to see here. Move along.'
Point 3 is nonsense, since drivers have crashed at low speed. Was he too fast for the Marussia? Maybe, but again they're telling us 'there's nothing to see here' rather than giving us any reason to believe them.
Point 5 is untrue, since there've been plenty of questions in the past about running the race while tractors are alongside the track. Regulations may have been followed but that's not the point - the point is that the regulations may have been flawed. Which recommendation 1 surely suggests was the case.
I'm surprised that the Marussia's Brake-by-Wire system 'proved to be incompatible with the FailSafe settings' and also that the authorities hadn't checked that it was compatible before allowing them to use it.
A last point: Charlie Whiting had previously said 'the race start time is not really a matter for the FIA' so it's interesting to see the FIA now deciding that it is sometimes a matter for the FIA. Perhaps they've changed their minds under the influence of this crash? Perhaps it's just the way they've phrased their responses that make their words seem more like the result of eagerness to disavow of all responsibility.
Don't forget this is the FIA's summary of a very long report. We don't know the half of what it says about the medical evacuation procedures, the fact that the helecopter couldn't land at the hospital, etc.
Point 3 about Bianchi not slowing sufficiently seems entirely reasonable to me. The fact that others were going faster doesn't necessarily mean they were also going too fast. It's not just the difference in cars; more significantly it's the difference in tyres. Some people were on brand new full wets. And it's a bit much to ask the accident panel to explain why no penalties were handed out to any of the other drivers.
I agree about point 5, but I think we should be happy with recommendation 1 as a response to that.
The point about the FailSafe system not being failsafe because the torque coordinator inhibits it is, frankly, extremely worrying. Quite what the torque controller has to do with braking I don't know, but this is something that could potentially cause a nasty accident and needs looking into, although it would appear in this case that the accident would have happened anyway and would have been extremely serious anyway.
Posted 03 December 2014 - 18:45
Some thoughts:
Posted 03 December 2014 - 18:59
Some thoughts:
- Conclusions 4) and 5) are a little contradictory. If you're not going to enforce yellow-flag rules then you have to neutralise the race in such situations.
- I'm not sure the assertion that without hindsight there's no need for a safety car. I half-expected one at the time, and this thread discusses many examples of how F1 had been getting lucky for a while before now, particularly with reference to the safety of the marshals.
- Fully agree with the assertion that the FIA's response should focus on preventing such an accident ever happening again, rather than modifying cars or cranes.
- Virtual safety car is a good idea; my concern, however, is that imposing it only a section of the course is potentially quite dangerous - what if a driver who goes through the accident zone at full speed just after the speed limit has been lifted comes across a driver just caught by the limit and still getting up to full speed?
- Totally agree with the four-hour rule.
- Also agree with the Super License rule - although I'd be concerned if a driver had made it all the way to F1 not knowing this stuff. I'd rather see that mandated for all competitors before their first race in any FIA-sanctioned series.
Posted 03 December 2014 - 19:15
Posted 03 December 2014 - 19:37
Posted 03 December 2014 - 20:14
I take it by that report that the BBW system was developed by Marussia and was not a brought in system? ![]()
Posted 03 December 2014 - 20:29
Edited by Petroltorque, 03 December 2014 - 21:33.
Posted 03 December 2014 - 20:39
A lot of smokescreen as it was to be expected.
The important thing is, they seem to have learned something from it.
Advertisement
Posted 03 December 2014 - 20:51
Before They appointed the panel I said in another post that the cause would be put down as driver error. It's not as though Bianchi is in any fit state to provide contradictory testimony. No criticism of the use of a plant digger to extract a car on the outside of a fast corner in wet conditions? WTF? Nor is any sensible person that they should design cars to withstand impacts with plant machinery. They should be looking at viable alternatives. They are as bad as Blatter and his band of merry men.
What a load of bloody nonsense. Bianchi ignoring double waved yellows was undoubtedly going to be listed among the issues - because he did.
I thought the report was well thought out and good ; finding a solution for removing stricken cars is an ongoing issue, so far one without a reasonable solution.
Posted 03 December 2014 - 21:01
If Jules was travelling too fast the biggest reason for that was the way the FIA/Charlie Whiting have eroded the double waved yellow rule over recent years.
What Whiting and his associates have tolerated and 'interpreted' in recent years is indeed troublesome, as is the leeway he's been given by the FIA. I think it is high time for him to 'explore exciting new career opportunities'.
But be that as it may, Bianchi himself had a responsibility in this as well. The FIA regulations are not at all unclear about what is expected of drivers under the circumstances.
It is indeed tragic that Bianchi has been put in this terrible state by the accident, but let's not overlook the fact that multiple Japanese volunteer marshals were very close to being hit by the out-of-control Marussia.
The rules about yellow flags are there to protect these marshals, and it is important that the drivers respect both these regulations and indeed the volunteers who make the racing possible.
Posted 03 December 2014 - 21:29
It looks like a sensible list of conclusions and recommendations to me. I noticed that Motorsport.com are running a headline saying the Accident Panel "blames Bianchi for Suzuka tragedy". That's not a very intelligent piece of journalism.
Posted 03 December 2014 - 21:34
Are we still going to put vehicles on the circuit when the SC isn't deployed?
Posted 03 December 2014 - 21:37
There has got to be a better acronym for that.I take it by that report that the BBW system was developed by Marussia and was not a brought in system?
Posted 03 December 2014 - 21:40
Dude, Have you ever seen a major accident that did not involve excessive speed. I'm asking, where is the accountability. In poor conditions, with stricken vehicles someone has to bear a duty of care for the participants, be it drivers or marshals. Why did Whiting remove the car without a safety car? Yes Bianchi was travelling too quickly for the conditions other wise he would not have gone off.What a load of bloody nonsense. Bianchi ignoring double waved yellows was undoubtedly going to be listed among the issues - because he did.
I thought the report was well thought out and good ; finding a solution for removing stricken cars is an ongoing issue, so far one without a reasonable solution.
Edited by Petroltorque, 03 December 2014 - 21:41.
Posted 03 December 2014 - 21:45
I'm surprised that the Marussia's Brake-by-Wire system 'proved to be incompatible with the FailSafe settings' and also that the authorities hadn't checked that it was compatible before allowing them to use it.
This is what confuses me the most ![]()
They (FIA) don't test if safety systems work before using them? ![]()
Posted 03 December 2014 - 22:21
It's a little bit underwhelming to be honest. Many of the long-term fans have probably asked themselves the question, what if this happened in Italy, and what would have happened (to FIA... after they applied for the criminal law to not include dangerous sports and was denied) if the collision had been fatal. Not so long ago certain F1 heads were not travelling to Italy because of their laws, and in 2000/01 after the death of the Marshall, the future of the Italian Grand Prix was under threat because of these rules. Then again, Bernie has been dropping hints that Italy might be gone from the calendar. Status Quo.
Edited by kamikaze1, 03 December 2014 - 22:23.
Posted 03 December 2014 - 22:50
Jumping on the throttle and brake at the same time is a technique called "The Andretti Stomp" I am not sure if any contemporary drivers use this technique, but maybe Jules did it on purpose, and for it to work correctly I would think that the torque override would need to be disabled.
This is entirely conjecture on my part, but maybe it is not the fault of Marusia, but a preference of Jules.
Posted 03 December 2014 - 22:56
Are we still going to put vehicles on the circuit when the SC isn't deployed?
They don't put vehicles on the circuit without a SC now, but they do allow recovery vehicles to go trackside. Which is one of the things I find odd - medical car on track, keeping off line and going in the same direction as race traffic, covered by white flags = unacceptable risk. Mobile crane in the direct firing line of a fast corner in aquaplaning conditions = not risky at all, no different to the hundreds of previous routine incidents covered under local yellows in the previous eight years. This is where the recommendation for a risk review comes in, because somebody needs to point out to Mr Whiting where his judgement of risk makes no sense.
Anyhow, I imagine the practice of allowing recovery vehicles trackside under local yellows will continue, but if the first recommendation is implemented, that's now okay, isn't it?
Posted 03 December 2014 - 23:05
Dude, Have you ever seen a major accident that did not involve excessive speed. I'm asking, where is the accountability. In poor conditions, with stricken vehicles someone has to bear a duty of care for the participants, be it drivers or marshals. Why did Whiting remove the car without a safety car? Yes Bianchi was travelling too quickly for the conditions other wise he would not have gone off.
Why not just leave Sutil's car where it was> These conclusions are expedient. It allows to status quo to remain without any serious changes to race controls procedures or personnel.
Find me an expert who thinks a culture of sacking people for a single mistake is compatible with a good safety culture, and I'll join you in calling for Whiting's head. No wonder the FIA isn't publishing the full report, and is highlighting the bits that appear to exonerate its people in its 1-page summary. It's protecting itself from potential litigation and, frankly, it's protecting itself from people like you who think the solution to everything is for somebody to lose his job.
And if you don't think the mandatory imposition of either a full-course caution (virtual safety car) or a speed-limited yellow flag zone for every incident is a serious change to race control's procedures, then I'm not sure how far-reaching a change would need to be in order to register with you?
Posted 03 December 2014 - 23:27
126 km/h the speed Bianchi hit the truck? Even half the speed is bad enough. Assuming all things the same, what would have been the appropriate speed under yellow for this accident to not happen?
I'm surprised that the Marussia's Brake-by-Wire system 'proved to be incompatible with the FailSafe settings' and also that the authorities hadn't checked that it was compatible before allowing them to use it.
At least that one deserves a serious question about the scruteneering(sp?) procedures. Before even checking the legality of a car, checking that safety systems work the way they are supposed to is IMO an absolute must for each and every car, at every race. Why did the FIA found out about the FailSafe system not being fail safe only after the accident? It does raise the question about other safety related issues concerning the cars. How will the FIA ensure that safety systems are at least 100% conform to the regulations, if not even better?
Posted 03 December 2014 - 23:36
So unsurprisingly the FIA panel finds no fault with the FIA. Knock me over with a feather.
If Jules was travelling too fast the biggest reason for that was the way the FIA/Charlie Whiting have eroded the double waved yellow rule over recent years. It's gone from "slow down, prepare to stop" to "demonstrate you've gone a tiny irrelevant bit slower than the previous lap". That's why he was going too fast - if he did it properly he'd be disadvantaged, they are forced into going to fast.
Guess it's much easier to blame the guy in a coma than it is to accept & deal with the consequences.
#ForzaJules
As much as I find Bianchi's accident very sad and I wish him recovery, I find it hard to disagree with the report. A lot of very good points about the speed that Bianchi carried and about no need for kneejerk reactions such as canopies. A lot of common sense, in my opinion.
Posted 03 December 2014 - 23:48
I don't see blame being apportioned myself. There is focus on Jules activity and the cars behaviour, but surely that is natural of any accident investigation. The primary issues of flags and procedures were already brought up at the initial meetings and statements and are indeed being acted upon.
Posted 04 December 2014 - 00:05
So unsurprisingly the FIA panel finds no fault with the FIA. Knock me over with a feather.
If Jules was travelling too fast the biggest reason for that was the way the FIA/Charlie Whiting have eroded the double waved yellow rule over recent years. It's gone from "slow down, prepare to stop" to "demonstrate you've gone a tiny irrelevant bit slower than the previous lap". That's why he was going too fast - if he did it properly he'd be disadvantaged, they are forced into going to fast.
Guess it's much easier to blame the guy in a coma than it is to accept & deal with the consequences.
#ForzaJules
Actually you only have to be a tiny irrelevant bit slower than your previous best time in the short sector concerned. You could be quicker than your previous lap and still be okay, particularly if the conditions are worse than earlier in the race. And I agree, it's all very well to say the drivers should slow down properly, but it's not a realistic option. If they did it every time there was a yellow flag it's no exaggeration to say many drivers would be out on their ear in pretty short order - it costs way too much time.
So I agree about that, but to be fair, recommendation 1 tells us that the panel did understand and recognise the problem. I doubt they saw their role, when they were asked to investigate on behalf of the FIA, as being publicly to criticise the FIA. That's why we get the 1-page summary and the WMSC gets the other 370-odd pages. If the panel has anything to say that might suggest that the FIA was culpable, they will tell it to the WMSC. They could tell it to the press or to the injured party's family if their aim was to make somebody other than Bianchi pay for this accident. But actually their job is not to do that, because they're an internal investigation panel. Their job is to identify the lessons to learn and to recommend measures to prevent recurrence, which is why if the panel wants to tell the FIA that it needs to learn lessons from its own culpable actions or inaction, it will say that to the FIA and not to the general public.
For our part, we're just stuck with looking at the recommendations and working out for ourselves if there's any criticism of the FIA implied within them. And there is, in recommendation 1. The panel does not think the previous yellow flag system, in the way in which it was enforced, was adequate, otherwise it would not have recommended that said system should be replaced.
Posted 04 December 2014 - 00:10
Well said
Posted 04 December 2014 - 03:42
Why on earth a driver would apply throttle and brake at the sametime in that situation???
Unless he knew the car was designed to cut the engine with this procedure - and if so, Marussia can be facing serious legal action.
Edited by PedroBR, 04 December 2014 - 03:44.
Posted 04 December 2014 - 03:48
Then they need to find out why the hell Jules assumed it would work. If it should work, it didn´t because of a mechanical/eletrical/eletronical/whatever problem, or was it negligence by Marussia?
This cannot go unanswered.
Jumping on the throttle and brake at the same time is a technique called "The Andretti Stomp" I am not sure if any contemporary drivers use this technique, but maybe Jules did it on purpose, and for it to work correctly I would think that the torque override would need to be disabled.
This is entirely conjecture on my part, but maybe it is not the fault of Marusia, but a preference of Jules.
Posted 04 December 2014 - 05:02
Posted 04 December 2014 - 05:40
The report also says race director Charlie Whiting was correct not to call for a safety car while marshals dealt with Sutil's initial accident.
"The actions taken following Sutil's accident were consistent with the regulations, and their interpretation following 384 incidents in the preceding eight years," the report added.
Wow, I hadn't realized cars had needed to be retrieved by tractors on the outside of fast corners in the wet so many times in the last eight years.
Edited by Ryongsyong, 04 December 2014 - 05:40.
Advertisement
Posted 04 December 2014 - 06:14
Redreni, you raise some interesting points. The problem I have with the FIA as a whole is the lack of transparency. Perception is reality and the perception that Whiting's prime focus is to maintain the power of the commercial rights holder. There were a series of decisions that puts his position in question. The refusal to bring forward the start time on the grounds of safety instead putting that responsibility on the Race Promoter. There is also the his decision to surreptitiously alter the requirements of a double waved yellow to cutting a divers sector time to a delta of 0.2- 0.5s of the fastest. That can't be safe in changeable conditions. We have also discussed the safety car issue which the FIA report dismisses with the catch all of 'the benefit of hindsight'.Find me an expert who thinks a culture of sacking people for a single mistake is compatible with a good safety culture, and I'll join you in calling for Whiting's head. No wonder the FIA isn't publishing the full report, and is highlighting the bits that appear to exonerate its people in its 1-page summary. It's protecting itself from potential litigation and, frankly, it's protecting itself from people like you who think the solution to everything is for somebody to lose his job.
And if you don't think the mandatory imposition of either a full-course caution (virtual safety car) or a speed-limited yellow flag zone for every incident is a serious change to race control's procedures, then I'm not sure how far-reaching a change would need to be in order to register with you?
Edited by Petroltorque, 04 December 2014 - 06:22.
Posted 04 December 2014 - 08:34
Posted 04 December 2014 - 10:08
I would think the fail-safe system is explained in the 396-page report. Which would be an interesting read for a number of reasons.
Posted 04 December 2014 - 10:36
One thing I would like to know – there's no mention of it in the summary – is the Accident Panel's view on the time that passed between the accident and the deployment of the safety car and medical car. Charlie Whiting talked quite a bit about it at the press briefing in Sochi and brought up some interesting issues (the g-force alarm being destroyed, race control relying on track cameras...). Would like to hear if the panel could draw any conclusions.
Posted 04 December 2014 - 10:44
So unsurprisingly the FIA panel finds no fault with the FIA. Knock me over with a feather.
If Jules was travelling too fast the biggest reason for that was the way the FIA/Charlie Whiting have eroded the double waved yellow rule over recent years. It's gone from "slow down, prepare to stop" to "demonstrate you've gone a tiny irrelevant bit slower than the previous lap". That's why he was going too fast - if he did it properly he'd be disadvantaged, they are forced into going to fast.
Guess it's much easier to blame the guy in a coma than it is to accept & deal with the consequences.
#ForzaJules
Was that ever in doubt, face it apart form the jargon it was always going to be the case
Edited by LORDBYRON, 04 December 2014 - 10:47.
Posted 04 December 2014 - 11:24
Does anyone know exactly (or even approximately) what the role of the F1 Fail-safe system is?. I must admit I have never heard of it before this report and there appears to be no mention of it in the 2014 F1 Technical regulations.
I assume it must be something to do with controlling how the ECU systems operate when some mission critical sensor inputs are lost or give confusing data.
What are the design parameters for such a system and how thorough were they understood - having spent my whole working life designing and implementing software systems I know that most problems occur when the system inputs stray close to the edges of the assumed 'normal' values. e.g. when a driver stamps on the throttle and brakes at the same time
Presumably it's designed to overcome the stuck-throttle scenario? If a driver applies full brake and throttle (presumably for a defined period of time, to exclude minor brake/throttle overlap), the car assumes the throttle must be stuck open and cuts the engine. I'm surprised a driver would have wanted to rely on such a system in these circumstances, though,and I think there are a hell of a lot of unanswered questions here. But the summary of the report does say this may have affected the impact speed. it does not suggest that Jules could have avoided the accident without this issue. It seems difficult to believe that Jules would have tried to use the failsafe system to cut the engine while he still had a chance of recovering control of the car, so by the time this happened one assumes he must have already been on an irreversible collision course with the tractor. So I'd be surprised if Marussia could be held liable for the accident or the injuries, because how is anybody going to convince a court that Bianchi's prognosis would be any better today if the failsafe system had worked as intended, if it turns out he would still have taken a blow to the head from the tractor, albeit at maybe a few km/h less?
Posted 04 December 2014 - 11:54
The report also says race director Charlie Whiting was correct not to call for a safety car while marshals dealt with Sutil's initial accident.
"The actions taken following Sutil's accident were consistent with the regulations, and their interpretation following 384 incidents in the preceding eight years," the report added.
Wow, I hadn't realized cars had needed to be retrieved by tractors on the outside of fast corners in the wet so many times in the last eight years.
This is the most disturbing aspect of the report. That anybody, let alone the FIA, can defend the decision not to put out a safety car is utterly beyond me.
Posted 04 December 2014 - 11:57
Sounds like a pretty good presumption, I guess the fail-safe has been around for a no of years - I would imagine the new scenario this year is integrating the existing software with a BBW system that actively tries to take over control of rear wheel braking based on several input parameters. This to me looks like a scenario classic case for software integration problems, especially relating to boundary conditions. From experience these are difficult to specify/design/code, especially if the limits of data signals between the system do not entirely match. Even harder is trying to test such systems, especially if you are trying to do so using a simulation of the input systems as the associated hardware has itself not yet been built.Presumably it's designed to overcome the stuck-throttle scenario? If a driver applies full brake and throttle (presumably for a defined period of time, to exclude minor brake/throttle overlap), the car assumes the throttle must be stuck open and cuts the engine. I'm surprised a driver would have wanted to rely on such a system in these circumstances, though,and I think there are a hell of a lot of unanswered questions here.
Posted 04 December 2014 - 12:24
If you feel like making yourself irritated, do check out Joe Saward's blog and the sycophant commentary by the 'blame it on Jules' brigade...
http://joesaward.wor...t-panel-report/
I do love it when these hardmen internet journalists, pseudo-insider types seek to educate us, the great unwashed, as to harsh realities of motor racing. Motor racing is dangerous, blah, blah....
Never mind the fact that Villenueve, Brundle, Prost (could you find a braver lot?) all immediately saw the inherent stupidity (and incongruity within F1's at times overzelousness re: safety to point of sterility) of being put into a position to have an impact a giant construction vehicle...
Edited by fer312t, 04 December 2014 - 12:25.
Posted 04 December 2014 - 12:26
The failure of the throttle over-ride system is especially worrying in light of De Villota's similar accident. Was there ever any (published) conclusion about the system in that case?
Dave
Edited by xflow7, 04 December 2014 - 12:27.
Posted 04 December 2014 - 12:26
Your above link doesn't work!