Jump to content


Photo

The Death of Jean Bugatti


  • Please log in to reply
8 replies to this topic

#1 Vitesse2

Vitesse2
  • Administrator

  • 34,215 posts
  • Joined: April 01

Posted 12 February 2017 - 18:46

I've recently found on Kindle a book on Bugatti by Boddy, published by Sports Car Press in 1960. Its description of Le Patron's declining years is very much at odds with WF Bradley's in his biography of Bugatti - as is the account of Jean's death. Boddy claims that the cyclist involved was a postman and was riding down the centre of the road, whereas every other version I've read says that the cyclist (possibly drunk) emerged from a side turning. I shall shortly be going back to look at contemporary French press sources - thank you Gallica!

The truth of this appears to be a combination of both stories.

 

The first thing to note is that the roads in the area have been altered, due to the building of Strasbourg Airport. Originally there would essentially have been one long straight from just west of the junction of the D392 and the D127 south of Altorf, all the way to Entzheim. On Google Maps this is named Route de Strasbourg, becoming Rue General de Gaulle on the outskirts of Duttlenheim and Route de Schirmeck outside Duppigheim. Bugatti used a 3 kilometre section of the road between Duppigheim and Entzheim for testing.

 

East of Duppigheim, just past a Total service station, the road now curves south, before swinging back towards Entzheim. There is a junction with an un-named unclassified road which continues the line of the straight and on this junction there is a pyramidal stele bearing a memorial plaque to Jean Bugatti. According to the plaque, this was the site of the crash.

 

218006311_1.jpg

 

The old road is the one which continues on the left of this photograph. If you switch Google Maps to satellite view you can clearly see the line of the old road continuing across the service station forecourt and then across the airport, although the road itself now degenerates into an unmade farm track when it meets and follows the airport perimeter, before returning to its old line. Intriguingly, a little further on to the east, on the south side of the road, there is what appears to be another memorial stone and plaque, with a motorcycle helmet on top.

 

Just before it enters Entzheim, the road becomes Rue Jean Bugatti, which terminates at the roundabout where the D392 rejoins the old route.

 

So - what of the discrepancies? In l'Intransigeant, August 13 1939, there is a telephoned report from 'Our Special Correspondent, Strasbourg'. Although not specifically stated, this makes clear that Bugatti was travelling towards Entzheim, since the cyclist is said to have been heading from Entzheim towards Duppigheim. L'Intransigeant speculates that Jean might have been dazzled by the cyclist's headlight, but that seems unlikely to be the primary cause. As is obvious on Street View, the road is barely wide enough for one car, while Jean was reportedly travelling at well over 200km/h. This website (in French) claims the cyclist was on the left side of the road, but it looks like his positioning on it would have been immaterial - although Le Matin does say Jean swerved to his left in his attempt to avoid him.

 

This is how Boddy describes it. My annotations in red:

 

The factory used a stretch of road near Molsheim for high-speed testing with the knowledge [but not necessarily the approval!] of the authorities. It was necessary only to clear the circuit [circuit?] and then to station a couple to warn anyone trying to enter it. Jean set off to test a car, and Roland, his young brother, was stationed at one of the entrances. A postman [at 10.45 at night? Time from Le Matin], mounted on a bicycle, came along, and airily ignored Roland’s fervent warnings. Roland was only a boy, quite incapable of preventing the man by force [he was actually just a few days short of his seventeenth birthday]. The postman cycled down the middle of the road, where Jean discovered him when he came roaring around a bend [????]. He could not avoid hitting the man and at the same time keep control of the automobile, except by the wildest of wild good-luck, and he must have known this, being a very skillful driver. He tried, however, and did succeed in the first part of the maneuver: he missed the mailman. But the car got away from him, rolled, and he was killed..

It seems certain that Roland was present, as L'Intransigeant says that Jean's brother and d'autres collaborateurs intimes were there. Le Matin names a mechanic called Homère, who had accompanied Jean on the first two runs out and back, but Jean then did the third alone. And Robert Aumaitre was certainly there:

 

 

The cyclist was named by both Le Matin and Le Petit Parisien as Joseph Metz, from Dornach, which is 100km south. According to Le Petit Parisien he was 18 years old and on holiday, staying with friends in Duppigheim.

 

Charles Faroux, writing in La Vie Automobile two weeks later, suggested that the cyclist had 'in all likelihood reached the road by some dirt road or path which had escaped the control of the two surveillance and warning posts.'



Advertisement

#2 Tim Murray

Tim Murray
  • Moderator

  • 21,907 posts
  • Joined: May 02

Posted 13 February 2017 - 09:23

In her book The Bugatti Story Ettore's daughter L'Ebé put the time of the accident at '... about ten that evening. He went out after dining with the family ...'. She also stated that the young cyclist was so overcome with guilt that he committed suicide three years later.

#3 Vitesse2

Vitesse2
  • Administrator

  • 34,215 posts
  • Joined: April 01

Posted 13 February 2017 - 10:38

I think they'd probably started the test at about 10pm. Le Matin's report, which does specify 10.45, seems to say it was the first part of the third run; I think Aumaitre may perhaps be suggesting it was the fourth run?

 

From the little evidence I've found, I think they may have actually had a 3-kilometre 'flying speed' section measured for timing purposes, also using a kilometre or so at each end for acceleration and braking. Presumably the 'guards' would have been at each end, but there might have only been another couple of people 'on course' to work the timing equipment. So the cyclist could quite easily have entered the course undetected somewhere within those 3 kilometres. Quite a contrast to the massed ranks of NSKK men who lined the roadside at Dessau to make sure nobody transgressed ...



#4 Vitesse2

Vitesse2
  • Administrator

  • 34,215 posts
  • Joined: April 01

Posted 14 February 2017 - 16:19

There seem to have been at least three agency reports coming out of France about the accident, each of which gives a different time. As published in various French and Swiss papers:

 

Salut Public (Lyons) - vers 23 h.

 

Journal de Genève - vers 22 h.

L'Impartial (Neuchatel) - vers 22h.

 

Feuille d'Avis de Lausanne - vers minuit

La Revue (Lausanne) - vers minuit

L'Express (Neuchatel) - vers minuit

 

The midnight suggestion seems to come from Reuters - in Britain both The Observer and The Manchester Guardian went with 'midnight', crediting Reuter. The Sunday Times, which, like The Observer, also credited British United Press and was the only one to add Exchange Telegraph, went with 'after midnight'. The Times didn't mention the hour!



#5 cooper997

cooper997
  • Member

  • 2,390 posts
  • Joined: December 08

Posted 26 February 2017 - 08:04

There's about 3/4's of a page devoted to a C&SC visit to the Jean Bugatti monument in the June 1992 issue of that title.

 

Can scan or add here if required.

 

Stephen



#6 Vitesse2

Vitesse2
  • Administrator

  • 34,215 posts
  • Joined: April 01

Posted 12 August 2019 - 07:13

Eighty years ago today ...

 

2013-bugatti-veyron-grand-19_1600x0w.jpg

 

We can only guess at how the Bugatti company might have fared had Jean not died in 1939.



#7 Geoff E

Geoff E
  • Member

  • 1,371 posts
  • Joined: February 03

Posted 12 August 2019 - 07:53

Intriguingly, a little further on to the east, on the south side of the road, there is what appears to be another memorial stone and plaque, with a motorcycle helmet on top.

 

Photo of plaque https://image.routey...12e2ce5dce.jpeg



#8 Sebastian Tombs

Sebastian Tombs
  • Member

  • 2,066 posts
  • Joined: October 08

Posted 13 August 2019 - 00:32

The pic you refer to Geoff is amost certainly the actual accident site.  There used to be a notice next to the 'official' stone advising people to walk 1100metres down the farm track to the actual site.  That is where the Eclipse Stone you link is now erected.  So-called because it was erected on the 60th anniversary of his death, 11 August 1999, the very day that Europe's last total solar eclipse passed over this exact spot.  You can access it by car from the Duppigheim end but the locals are/were not too friendly.  Best to go from the Entzheim end through a new housing development, same caveats apply and more because the airport is used by European Parliament fat-cats once a month so Security or les flics might show an interest in you!.

 

Interestingly, the factory 'test track' was part of the Strasbourg Circuit used in the 1922 GP de l'A.C.F as shown on my pic.

 

q4mJtBz.jpg

 

ST :wave:



#9 Sebastian Tombs

Sebastian Tombs
  • Member

  • 2,066 posts
  • Joined: October 08

Posted 13 August 2019 - 00:51

Gordon Crosby's great painting of Nazzaro on FIAT and De Vizcaya on Bugatti in the Strasbourg event in '22 must be virtually passing the Jean accident site.

 

wzzXIok.jpg

 

ST :wave: