2 replies to this topic

[Makarias]

Results of the Emilia-Romagna voting

Pos Name                3p  2p  1p  Tot Pts
 1  Max Verstappen      6   0   0   18  25
 2  Lando Norris        3   3   0   15  18
 3  Yuki Tsunoda        0   4   2   10  15
 4  Charles Leclerc     0   3   1    7  12
 5  Lance Stroll        0   1   4    6  10
 6  Nico Hülkenberg     0   0   5    5   8
 7  Oscar Piastri       0   0   5    5   6
 8  George Russell      0   0   2    2   4
 9  Lewis Hamilton      0   0   1    1   2

Places 6-7 decided by reversed WCC order.

* Max Verstappen's 46th ever win.
* Lando Norris' 32nd Yuki Tsunoda's fifth podium finish.
* Consecutive podium finishes for Tsunoda for the first time ever.
* Season best for Lance Stroll.

The entries

Votes that didn't comply with the voting system:
None.

Voting Championship 2024 standings:

Pos Name                   Pts BAH SAU  OZ JPN CHN MIA EMI MON CAN ESP AUT  GB HUN BEL NED ITA AZE SIN USA MEX BRA  LV QAT ABU
1)  Max Verstappen         127   1   1  10   1   2   6   1                                                                    
2)  Lando Norris           105   5       3   4   1   1   2                                                                    
3)  Charles Leclerc         77       3   5   3   5   3   4                                                                    
4)  Carlos Sainz            61   2       1   2                                                                                
5)  Yuki Tsunoda            59           2   6       2   3                                                                    
6)  Nico Hülkenberg         56   9   6   4   9   4   4   6                                                                    
7)  Fernando Alonso         45   6   5   7   7   3                                                                            
8)  Oscar Piastri           32       4   6           7   7                                                                    
9)  George Russell          28   3   8      10   8       8                                                                    
10) Sergio Perez            23   7   7       5  10                                                                            
11) Esteban Ocon            19      10           6   5                                                                        
12) Oliver Bearman          18       2                                                                                        
13) Lance Stroll            13  10       9               5                                                                    
14) Zhou Guanyu             12   4                                                                                            
15) Valtteri Bottas         10               8   7                                                                            
=   Lewis Hamilton          10       9           9   8   9                                                                    
17) Kevin Magnussen          8   8       8                                                                                    
18) Daniel Ricciardo         2                       9                                                                        
19) Pierre Gasly             1                      10                                                                        

Results of Rate the Race

Quality of racing: 5.83 average
Vote breakdown:
10  0
9   0
8   0
7   2 ##
6   3 ###
5   0
4   0
3   1 #
2   0
1   0
0   0

Satisfaction with results: 5.40 average
Vote breakdown:
10  0
9   0
8   0
7   1 #
6   2 ##
5   1 #
4   0
3   1 #
2   0
1   0
0   0

Second highest Quality of the season without being impressive in any way, but it feels like the action is heating up now so that's good.

2024 ratings:
GP          Quality   Satisfaction
Bahrain      3.20      3.25
Saudi Arabia 4.17      5.20
Australia    5.40      6.25
Japan        5.40      3.75
China        5.00      5.50
Miami        7.00      6.00
Emi-Romagna  5.83      5.40

Average Q&S per season
           #   Qual   Satis
2002      17   5.83   5.86
2003      16   6.36   6.42
2004      18   5.71   5.82
2005      19   5.87   5.76
2006      18   5.66   5.58
2007      17   5.80   6.10
2008      18   6.33   5.62
2009      17   5.99   6.41
2010      19   6.45   6.01
2011      19   6.93   6.27
2012      20   6.98   6.57
2013      19   6.30   5.73
2014      19   6.53   5.85
2015      19   5.91   5.11
2016      21   6.32   5.02
2017      20   5.93   4.63
2018      21   6.29   4.86
2019      21   6.29   4.96
2020      17   5.87   5.67
2021      22   6.03   5.53
2022      22   5.79   5.04
2023      22   5.72   4.72

[Anderis]

I can't quite figure out why your perception of this race was so different to mine. You all voted quality 6 or higher. For me, it was one of the most boring races I remember. I think the only thing that happened inside top8 all race was Piastri undercutting Sainz in the pits? Until 15 laps to go, it was barely a 2/10 for me. I bumped it to 3/10 for some tension between Norris and Verstappen towards the end of the race, but since Norris didn't even get within a DRS range until it was too late to attack, I don't think it deserves any bigger bump than that.

[Makarias]

Not speaking for others, but there being some late race tension for the race win is such a rare event nowadays that it's pretty refreshing. Discounting your 3, the average would have been 6.4 which is decent but not super high.