Jump to content


Photo
- - - - -

The new guidelines for overtaking


  • Please log in to reply
85 replies to this topic

Poll: Driving Guidelines: Overtaking (45 member(s) have cast votes)

What do you think if the new guidelines?

  1. Love them! (2 votes [4.44%])

    Percentage of vote: 4.44%

  2. So far so good (1 votes [2.22%])

    Percentage of vote: 2.22%

  3. They are better, but not good (4 votes [8.89%])

    Percentage of vote: 8.89%

  4. To early to tell, but I'm skeptical (3 votes [6.67%])

    Percentage of vote: 6.67%

  5. Not good, the rules can easily be abused. (18 votes [40.00%])

    Percentage of vote: 40.00%

  6. I hate them! (15 votes [33.33%])

    Percentage of vote: 33.33%

  7. Other (2 votes [4.44%])

    Percentage of vote: 4.44%

Vote Guests cannot vote

#1 Analog

Analog
  • Member

  • 1,949 posts
  • Joined: July 24

Posted 03 May 2025 - 18:25

We have seen the new guidelines in play a few times now and personally I think they will need to be revised again. Push out or being pushed out will probably be standard for T1 and for most overtakes, simply because the rules say you can do it and since that is the best way of securing a position, that is what they will do. This is, I believe, problematic because it will change some fundamental racing etiquette, swipe away all remnants of "sporting behaviour",  and this will of course spread quickly to junior and feeder series. At the time of writing, there has been no decision regarding the Lawson/Alonso incident, but that is an interesting one and a situation that I think we will see many times; a driver on the inside drives as deep as possible but, as it turns out, not deep enough. Not deep enough to own the corner but to deep to give space. 

I think the guidelines encourage ruthlessness and the victims will be close racing and fairness. 

We will see.



Advertisement

#2 macjim

macjim
  • Member

  • 349 posts
  • Joined: February 10

Posted 03 May 2025 - 18:55

Too early for me tbh.

 

The anti Max rules have burned a few so far, I hated the way Max drove it just wan't fare but 'legal' in 2024.But listening to Kimi & Fernado it's clear they're expcting racing room but it's no longer required to be given by the overtaking driver, clearly something need to be communicated.

 

TBH Kimi, didn't deserve racing room, he'd lost the corner and should have slotted in  behind Oscar


Edited by macjim, 03 May 2025 - 18:55.


#3 Hellenic tifosi

Hellenic tifosi
  • Member

  • 7,782 posts
  • Joined: January 99

Posted 03 May 2025 - 19:04

What happened at T1 today is exactly the kind of racing I hate.

#4 noikeee

noikeee
  • Member

  • 25,289 posts
  • Joined: February 06

Posted 03 May 2025 - 19:08

My opinion on this subject is F1 are up their arse and don't know what they're doing. I really don't get it.



#5 Goron3

Goron3
  • Member

  • 5,456 posts
  • Joined: April 11

Posted 04 May 2025 - 11:07

Rewatching the sprint and honestly I think that was very poor race craft from Kimi. He didn't realise where Piastri was and he really should have just gone for the cutback instead of a hail mary move around the outside.

#6 sofarapartguy

sofarapartguy
  • Member

  • 1,356 posts
  • Joined: December 11

Posted 04 May 2025 - 11:14

Kimi lost the corner and would not have make it at that speed regardless of whether Oscar was there or was not. Just lack of experience in my view and nothing more. Judges was quick and right on that one. 



#7 Ali_G

Ali_G
  • Member

  • 38,523 posts
  • Joined: August 00

Posted 04 May 2025 - 11:20

What happened at T1 today is exactly the kind of racing I hate.


It is Fuji 2007 level dumb. This style of racing became normalised after that race sadly.

#8 Analog

Analog
  • Member

  • 1,949 posts
  • Joined: July 24

Posted 04 May 2025 - 11:23

As I see it:

1. Overtaking on the inside: Front axle ahead of the other car's mirror line on entry => Your corner, no need to leave space
2. Overtaking on the outside: Be ahead at entry (and apex?) => Your corner, must be given space.

 

So today, in Miami, Max will need to be around 1(?)  meter ahead of Lando at turn in point in order to have the right to any space. Same goes for Antonelli in his battle with Piastri.

The problem, and the strength,  as I see it, is the lack of nuances in these guidelines. Norris will brake as late as possible in order to win the corner. He will also be on the inside, which means that he will have a later turn-in that Max. Same goes for Piastri behind and it will force both Max and Kimi to make an early decision to slot in behind. And same goes for all "couples" behind them which means the car on the inside will almost always go deep and the one on the outside, had it been forced to yield, will now be in the tracks a new bomber. 
 
Had the pole been on the inside, the pole sitter would only need to stay abreast to own the corner, something that is much easier to do, especially considering that the later turn in point allows for later braking.

Maybe I have interpreted the guidelines wrong, but I look forward to an interesting T1 now when all drivers knows what the rules are. 

 



#9 chrcol

chrcol
  • Member

  • 4,828 posts
  • Joined: March 11

Posted 04 May 2025 - 12:25

Which bit are you unhappy with?

 

Two incidents, one was minor with Piastri taking control of 1st corner, other was major with Lawson turning into Alonso after going off.

 

I think we seen in the last couple of years how bad the decisions were allowing drivers to run off track in driver to driver battles with no penalty, the favouring of the driver on the inside is the lesser evil in my opinion, the driver that makes the corner should generally be favoured.

Sadly some drivers just refuse to yield which would allow them to live another day, instead willing to collide if it means they dont lose that battle, or trying to hang on to a poor position on the track losing extra places.

 

To me turn 1 was no issue, fair racing, Lawson incident should have been Lawson penalty.


Edited by chrcol, 04 May 2025 - 12:30.


#10 Analog

Analog
  • Member

  • 1,949 posts
  • Joined: July 24

Posted 04 May 2025 - 13:00

Which bit are you unhappy with?

 

I guess my main concern is that I believe it will encourage dive-bombing and all but eliminate wheel-to-wheel racing.



#11 Ali_G

Ali_G
  • Member

  • 38,523 posts
  • Joined: August 00

Posted 04 May 2025 - 20:09

And this is what you get with these stupid rules.

#12 PitViperRacing

PitViperRacing
  • Member

  • 1,387 posts
  • Joined: October 21

Posted 04 May 2025 - 20:43

Honestly I actually like the rules so far. It's made it alot harder for the faster car to get ahead. Max's battles against the McLarens would have been over within a lap if not for his ability to defend the inside rabidly.

#13 MikeTekRacing

MikeTekRacing
  • Member

  • 19,136 posts
  • Joined: October 04

Posted 05 May 2025 - 04:55

I still hate them, happy at least they have been consistent.
In my book you should not encourage shoving others, yet it is now.

#14 KimiRaykkonen

KimiRaykkonen
  • New Member

  • 17 posts
  • Joined: October 10

Posted 05 May 2025 - 07:28

I don't see what the problem with 'all the time you have to leave the space' if applied correctly

 

much easier to judge than who's ahead at the apex rubbish, front wing relative to mirror etc.

 

If car A is overtaking car B on the inside into a corner, then A must leave a cars width on the corner exit, for B to try and hold on. I think A can brake later then B and block B from turning in preventing a switch back, as long as it doesn't run B off the road

 

If car A is lining up for an overtake and car B then defends down the inside, then it must leave a cars width on corner entry and exit for car A 

 

Simply then if you push a car off the track, wether you're the attacking or defending car, you will receive a penalty. 

 

Also think there needs to be a better way to apply penalties, as you see in some cases drivers sometimes accept the 5 second penalty as by the time they have to take it during the pitstop / at end of race its been nullified by the gap they've managed to make anyway. Perhaps they can have a penalty corner or zone that works like a joker in rallycross, that takes approx 5 seconds longer to complete, and must be done within 3 laps of receiving the penalty like a drive through used to be served. Or maybe an enforced slow zone / reduced power like in grand turismo game



#15 Tsarwash

Tsarwash
  • Member

  • 14,548 posts
  • Joined: August 10

Posted 05 May 2025 - 09:01

It will not be long until the only overtakes we ever see are DRS drive by's.



#16 mclara

mclara
  • Member

  • 3,469 posts
  • Joined: July 11

Posted 05 May 2025 - 09:26

Guidlines are explained well here:

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6gbTAHyzkrY



#17 Ali_G

Ali_G
  • Member

  • 38,523 posts
  • Joined: August 00

Posted 05 May 2025 - 10:21

I don't see what the problem with 'all the time you have to leave the space' if applied correctly

much easier to judge than who's ahead at the apex rubbish, front wing relative to mirror etc.

If car A is overtaking car B on the inside into a corner, then A must leave a cars width on the corner exit, for B to try and hold on. I think A can brake later then B and block B from turning in preventing a switch back, as long as it doesn't run B off the road

If car A is lining up for an overtake and car B then defends down the inside, then it must leave a cars width on corner entry and exit for car A

Simply then if you push a car off the track, wether you're the attacking or defending car, you will receive a penalty.

Also think there needs to be a better way to apply penalties, as you see in some cases drivers sometimes accept the 5 second penalty as by the time they have to take it during the pitstop / at end of race its been nullified by the gap they've managed to make anyway. Perhaps they can have a penalty corner or zone that works like a joker in rallycross, that takes approx 5 seconds longer to complete, and must be done within 3 laps of receiving the penalty like a drive through used to be served. Or maybe an enforced slow zone / reduced power like in grand turismo game



That’s effectively what the rules were since the dawn of time but somewhere in the last 20 years, this racing line, forcing cars off has become tolerated.

For some reason it’s not tolerated in oval racing and none of its proponents can state why.

#18 ensign14

ensign14
  • Member

  • 68,876 posts
  • Joined: December 01

Posted 05 May 2025 - 10:35

Honestly I actually like the rules so far. It's made it alot harder for the faster car to get ahead. Max's battles against the McLarens would have been over within a lap if not for his ability to defend the inside rabidly.

It's not really racing, though, is it?  Just stick to the inside line and if someone tries to get around the outside, shove them off.  You could programme a gibbon to do that.



#19 PitViperRacing

PitViperRacing
  • Member

  • 1,387 posts
  • Joined: October 21

Posted 05 May 2025 - 10:36

It's not really racing, though, is it? Just stick to the inside line and if someone tries to get around the outside, shove them off. You could programme a gibbon to do that.


Tell that to Piastri. He made it work

Advertisement

#20 ensign14

ensign14
  • Member

  • 68,876 posts
  • Joined: December 01

Posted 05 May 2025 - 10:42

Eventually, on better tyres.



#21 Analog

Analog
  • Member

  • 1,949 posts
  • Joined: July 24

Posted 05 May 2025 - 10:52

I voted " Not good, the rules can easily be abused," but I am currently leaning towards "So far so good"



#22 tempname11

tempname11
  • Member

  • 225 posts
  • Joined: June 14

Posted 05 May 2025 - 13:18

Mistakenly chose the first option, and not the second one. I enjoy the increased fighting spirit the rules seem to have brought. Yet, they are probably too complicated and some weird edge cases will again pop up. Particularly I am skeptical of the notion of "overtaking" and "defending" drivers. There will be cases where it's hard to say which is which.

#23 chrcol

chrcol
  • Member

  • 4,828 posts
  • Joined: March 11

Posted 05 May 2025 - 15:05

Guidlines are explained well here:

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6gbTAHyzkrY

Great video, and I think the new rules are progressive.  It shows as well I have interpreted the new rules correctly.



#24 IrvTheSwerve

IrvTheSwerve
  • Member

  • 9,300 posts
  • Joined: July 15

Posted 05 May 2025 - 15:15

As I said in the other thread, it’s over regulation.

 

It’s quite clear to see when a driver is being a bit of an idiot, leave it in the steward’s hands. We should focus on steward consistency instead.



#25 gillesfan76

gillesfan76
  • Member

  • 11,086 posts
  • Joined: July 16

Posted 05 May 2025 - 15:25

My opinion on this subject is F1 are up their arse and don't know what they're doing. I really don't get it.

 

This. They’ve f**ked it up so badly, there’s no point even dissecting it. It used to always be more of the balance of responsibility on the overtaker to overtake safely but now they’ve said that the defender bears the greater burden. Whatever, just messed up.



#26 Analog

Analog
  • Member

  • 1,949 posts
  • Joined: July 24

Posted 05 May 2025 - 16:50

This. They’ve f**ked it up so badly, there’s no point even dissecting it. It used to always be more of the balance of responsibility on the overtaker to overtake safely but now they’ve said that the defender bears the greater burden. Whatever, just messed up.

I think the good part of the guidelines is that the drivers know when to give up. The grey zone is much smaller.



#27 Goron3

Goron3
  • Member

  • 5,456 posts
  • Joined: April 11

Posted 05 May 2025 - 17:15

It's not really racing, though, is it? Just stick to the inside line and if someone tries to get around the outside, shove them off. You could programme a gibbon to do that.

This would leave you vulnerable to the cutback, just as Piastri did to Max.

Compare that to how Norris attempts to make moves.

The last thing I want in F1 is some kind of overtaking lane around the outside of corners.

#28 MikeTekRacing

MikeTekRacing
  • Member

  • 19,136 posts
  • Joined: October 04

Posted 05 May 2025 - 17:38

This would leave you vulnerable to the cutback, just as Piastri did to Max.

Compare that to how Norris attempts to make moves.

The last thing I want in F1 is some kind of overtaking lane around the outside of corners.

Max also practiced his T1 inside dive on Piastri, so he could be more efficient with Norris. He timed it perfectly with Norris while with Oscar he left it too late, locked up and overshot the move. 

The pace difference they had - they would have passed at any point.
Do you think with a closer car they would have made it work? Max would just protect the inside and push them out.

 

I think we will see less exciting, close, battles if we allow drivers to do this



#29 Ivanhoe

Ivanhoe
  • RC Forum Host

  • 19,120 posts
  • Joined: November 15

Posted 05 May 2025 - 17:44

I think both battles were pretty exciting.

#30 ANF

ANF
  • Member

  • 35,782 posts
  • Joined: April 12

Posted 05 May 2025 - 18:09

Two incidents, one was minor with Piastri taking control of 1st corner, other was major with Lawson turning into Alonso after going off.

Lawson was never completely off the track.

#31 Miles749

Miles749
  • Member

  • 985 posts
  • Joined: August 19

Posted 05 May 2025 - 19:31

The new rules mean that every car will defend the inside 100% of the time. 

 

It gives you two advantages:

1. Attacking car on the outside needs to have front axle ahead of your front axle at the apex

2. If the attacker is not ahead at apex, you don't need to leave him any space.

 

This means that defenders can just drive deep into the corner, hit the apex first on the inside and then slide wide. No need to take a tighter line as you don't need to leave space if you get to apex side by side.

 

On the other hand, if you are defending on the outside. 

1. Attacker needs to have front axle alongside your mirror prior and at apex (easier to do than in other case)

2. If attacker satisfies 1. then they don't need to give you space on outside.

 

 

These rules will mean that drivers when they see they satisfy one of the rules will intentionally run wide to run the other car off the road, legally. 


Edited by Miles749, 05 May 2025 - 19:33.


#32 1player

1player
  • Member

  • 2,784 posts
  • Joined: March 21

Posted 05 May 2025 - 19:36

I think both battles were pretty exciting.


I don’t think the battles we had were because of the new rules.

#33 noikeee

noikeee
  • Member

  • 25,289 posts
  • Joined: February 06

Posted 05 May 2025 - 19:46

The last thing I want in F1 is some kind of overtaking lane around the outside of corners.


There's no rule they can come up with to make this happen. 90% of the time it's much harder to pass around the outside, in any circuit racing (excluding ovals). Why do you think drivers always covered the inside?

#34 MikeTekRacing

MikeTekRacing
  • Member

  • 19,136 posts
  • Joined: October 04

Posted 05 May 2025 - 19:58

There's no rule they can come up with to make this happen. 90% of the time it's much harder to pass around the outside, in any circuit racing (excluding ovals). Why do you think drivers always covered the inside?

+1...and if the outside is so much quicker, that's where the defending car will stay



#35 Ali_G

Ali_G
  • Member

  • 38,523 posts
  • Joined: August 00

Posted 05 May 2025 - 21:14

+1...and if the outside is so much quicker, that's where the defending car will stay


Turn 3 at Zandvoort is literally the only place where the outside line is faster.

It’s much more difficult to pass around the outside. Why on earth would you want to make it more difficult?

#36 pdac

pdac
  • Member

  • 20,942 posts
  • Joined: February 10

Posted 05 May 2025 - 22:01

Maybe I'm missing something here, but it seems to me that an overtaking strategy where two turns in opposite directions follow one another, is to hold the outside on the first turn and then get better traction into the inside of the next. If the defending car can boot you off of the track unless you're ahead at the first turn, then that strategy is gone.



#37 perky

perky
  • Member

  • 1,692 posts
  • Joined: April 25

Posted 05 May 2025 - 22:07

The new rules mean that every car will defend the inside 100% of the time. 

 

It gives you two advantages:

1. Attacking car on the outside needs to have front axle ahead of your front axle at the apex

2. If the attacker is not ahead at apex, you don't need to leave him any space.

 

This means that defenders can just drive deep into the corner, hit the apex first on the inside and then slide wide. No need to take a tighter line as you don't need to leave space if you get to apex side by side.

 

On the other hand, if you are defending on the outside. 

1. Attacker needs to have front axle alongside your mirror prior and at apex (easier to do than in other case)

2. If attacker satisfies 1. then they don't need to give you space on outside.

 

 

These rules will mean that drivers when they see they satisfy one of the rules will intentionally run wide to run the other car off the road, legally. 

 

Yeah and the bigger (and practically unsolvable) problem is that these days, and for some time, it's impossible to make up the disadvantage of the outside line with driving skill. The cars are just too close and their brakes too good for that.
 



#38 Celloman

Celloman
  • Member

  • 1,913 posts
  • Joined: October 05

Posted 05 May 2025 - 23:44

The new rules mean that every car will defend the inside 100% of the time. 

 

It gives you two advantages:

1. Attacking car on the outside needs to have front axle ahead of your front axle at the apex

2. If the attacker is not ahead at apex, you don't need to leave him any space.

 

This means that defenders can just drive deep into the corner, hit the apex first on the inside and then slide wide. No need to take a tighter line as you don't need to leave space if you get to apex side by side.

 

On the other hand, if you are defending on the outside. 

1. Attacker needs to have front axle alongside your mirror prior and at apex (easier to do than in other case)

2. If attacker satisfies 1. then they don't need to give you space on outside.

 

 

These rules will mean that drivers when they see they satisfy one of the rules will intentionally run wide to run the other car off the road, legally. 

Basically, yes. The only way to overtake on the outside is then what Piastri did basically by catching Max's overly aggressive defense out and simply braking more to make it back on the inside before the apex or alternatively, complete the overtake on the outside before the braking starts so you can switch back to cover the inside line.



#39 Miles749

Miles749
  • Member

  • 985 posts
  • Joined: August 19

Posted 06 May 2025 - 05:47

Yeah and the bigger (and practically unsolvable) problem is that these days, and for some time, it's impossible to make up the disadvantage of the outside line with driving skill. The cars are just too close and their brakes too good for that.
 

 

Which is exactly why they should be forced to leave enough room for the other car. If you have to leave enough space, in both cases (when there is visible overlap), it would be mean that the cars don't have to defend the inside like their lives depend on it, they can't force people off and we would get easier overtakes and more of them.

 

The rules as they stand are favoring defense over offense which is strange given that F1 goes through rule changes exactly for the reason of making overtaking easier. 


Edited by Miles749, 06 May 2025 - 05:48.


Advertisement

#40 Ferrim

Ferrim
  • Member

  • 1,659 posts
  • Joined: October 07

Posted 06 May 2025 - 06:15

It's a weird day when the driver leaving more room is Esteban Ocon...

I think his fight with Hamilton was a pretty good example of "leaving the space".

#41 Ali_G

Ali_G
  • Member

  • 38,523 posts
  • Joined: August 00

Posted 06 May 2025 - 07:28

It's a weird day when the driver leaving more room is Esteban Ocon...

I think his fight with Hamilton was a pretty good example of "leaving the space".



It was good driving from both drivers. The new rules effectively is trying to kill this type of racing by ending everything after a single corner.

#42 mclara

mclara
  • Member

  • 3,469 posts
  • Joined: July 11

Posted 06 May 2025 - 08:35

Great video, and I think the new rules are progressive.  It shows as well I have interpreted the new rules correctly.

The rules and guidelines are of course not the problem.

Its the drivers lack of willingness to battle clean thats the problem. 
GT drivers have no problems racing side by side for multiple corners whereas in Miami it took Max 2 corners before he was crossing the line. Again.



#43 pdac

pdac
  • Member

  • 20,942 posts
  • Joined: February 10

Posted 06 May 2025 - 09:59

The rules and guidelines are of course not the problem.

Its the drivers lack of willingness to battle clean thats the problem. 
GT drivers have no problems racing side by side for multiple corners whereas in Miami it took Max 2 corners before he was crossing the line. Again.

 

Drivers are not going to battle cleanly if the advantages to not doing so outweigh the disadvantages. It's the drivers that are the problem, but they are never going to provide the solution themselves.



#44 Ali_G

Ali_G
  • Member

  • 38,523 posts
  • Joined: August 00

Posted 06 May 2025 - 10:37

The rules and guidelines are of course not the problem.
Its the drivers lack of willingness to battle clean thats the problem.
GT drivers have no problems racing side by side for multiple corners whereas in Miami it took Max 2 corners before he was crossing the line. Again.



Why would Verstappen not drive other cars off the track when the rules allow him to?

#45 Analog

Analog
  • Member

  • 1,949 posts
  • Joined: July 24

Posted 06 May 2025 - 11:46

 

The rules as they stand are favoring defense over offense which is strange given that F1 goes through rule changes exactly for the reason of making overtaking easier. 

I don't agree, I think the rules simply say "you have to be this far up in order to complete the overtake, if you are not, any consequences are your responsibility". Overtaking on the outside have always been difficult and rare. Minimizing grey zones have always been a big part of rule changes and as I see it, they are smaller now. 



#46 mclara

mclara
  • Member

  • 3,469 posts
  • Joined: July 11

Posted 06 May 2025 - 11:56

Drivers are not going to battle cleanly if the advantages to not doing so outweigh the disadvantages. It's the drivers that are the problem, but they are never going to provide the solution themselves.

 

They manage it in other series. And the reason why we got here is because it wasn't properly policed from the beginning. Thats why we need this now.

 

Why would Verstappen not drive other cars off the track when the rules allow him to?

This has already been covered in the Mclaren team thread. Go look it up



#47 Ali_G

Ali_G
  • Member

  • 38,523 posts
  • Joined: August 00

Posted 06 May 2025 - 12:20

They manage it in other series. And the reason why we got here is because it wasn't properly policed from the beginning. Thats why we need this now.

This has already been covered in the Mclaren team thread. Go look it up


Could you at least answer it given this is the specific thread instead of me needing to trawl through page after page of another thread.

Edited by Ali_G, 06 May 2025 - 12:41.


#48 PayasYouRace

PayasYouRace
  • Racing Simulators Forum Host

  • 59,627 posts
  • Joined: January 10

Posted 06 May 2025 - 12:20



This has already been covered in the Mclaren team thread. Go look it up


Why would you go to the McLaren thread to read about driving standards and overtaking rules?

#49 ensign14

ensign14
  • Member

  • 68,876 posts
  • Joined: December 01

Posted 06 May 2025 - 13:06

I don't agree, I think the rules simply say "you have to be this far up in order to complete the overtake, if you are not, any consequences are your responsibility".

But we had a situation where Norris WAS LITERALLY AHEAD on the outside yet apparently Verstappen can still shove him off track without penalty.  Because apices or mirrors or some other FIA ****.



#50 SenorSjon

SenorSjon
  • Member

  • 21,121 posts
  • Joined: March 12

Posted 06 May 2025 - 13:19

Which is exactly why they should be forced to leave enough room for the other car. If you have to leave enough space, in both cases (when there is visible overlap), it would be mean that the cars don't have to defend the inside like their lives depend on it, they can't force people off and we would get easier overtakes and more of them.

 

The rules as they stand are favoring defense over offense which is strange given that F1 goes through rule changes exactly for the reason of making overtaking easier. 

 

This is a reaction to drivers hanging on the outside by braking very late and then claiming they got pushed off. It seems a bit of a no-win situation with the rules now.