You are only looking at one part of a complex machine.
It is not just about lift (downforce). It's about maximising the L/D ratio, IOW aerodynamic efficiency. It is why these cars are not 'wing' cars, they are 'venturi' cars.
I am no aerodynamicist, but I am not understanding what you mean by a deflector. If you are tying to increase the air pressure on the upper surface of the car, you are going down the path of flaps on an aeroplane wing. These increase the lift, at a massive cost in drag, ie the L/D ratio drops, the aircraft can then still fly, but only slowly - which is the whole point: reducing landing/takeoff speeds. We want fast cars everywhere, but especially on the straights.
The new regs allowing moveable aero may open up some opportunities along the lines you are thinking, but that is next year. Aero efficiency will still be the objective, but maybe there are situations where what you want is effectiveness, and sacrifice efficiency for that.