Jump to content


Photo

1946 Grand Prix des Nations


  • Please log in to reply
12 replies to this topic

#1 D-Type

D-Type
  • Member

  • 9,860 posts
  • Joined: February 03

Posted 11 July 2025 - 23:44

Does anyone know what cars were eligible for this race?  The field appears to be all 1500cc supercharged cars.  Was it, like the 1946 Turin GP, run for 1.5 litre s/c and 4.5 litre u/s cars (although none competed), anticipating the new International Formula (Formula 1) which would come into effect in 1947. 

If so, it would displace the Turin race's somewhat dubious claim to be the first Formula 1 race.



Advertisement

#2 Vitesse2

Vitesse2
  • Administrator

  • 46,281 posts
  • Joined: April 01

Posted 12 July 2025 - 07:21

It was for supercharged cars up to 1500cc only. The Geneva section of the AC Suisse had reserved the date, July 21st, for 1500cc cars, on the provisional Swiss racing calendar for 1946 as early as August 1945. The Swiss authorities were well ahead of anyone else in issuing plans for post-war racing and hillclimbs. The AIACR's Commission Sportive would not be revived until February 1946, when it mandated the extension of the 1938-40 International Formula until the end of 1946 - although of course very few events were actually run to those limits during the year. The circuit used had previously been used (in a slightly shorter version) for motorcycle races - the Grand Prix de Genève in 1936 and 1937 and the Swiss Motorcycle Grand Prix in 1938 - and the Union Motocycliste Suisse had revived the national motorcycle Grand Prix on the same circuit the previous Sunday.

 

The newly renamed FIA did not finally announce the new International Formula until June 21st 1946: while there had been general agreement that it would be for 1500cc supercharged cars, for unblown engines the French had proposed a maximum of 3000cc, the British 4500cc (the Italians were indifferent!)



#3 GT40Man

GT40Man
  • Member

  • 30 posts
  • Joined: April 25

Posted 12 July 2025 - 09:00

Interesting…..

 

So no Talbot-Lagos or Delahayes could take part.

It looks like the Grand Prix at Albi, held a week earlier, was run to the same formula.



#4 Vitesse2

Vitesse2
  • Administrator

  • 46,281 posts
  • Joined: April 01

Posted 12 July 2025 - 10:58

Albi had always been run for 1500cc cars since it was first held in 1933, so - in a year of uncertainty, when French clubs were mostly holding races to rules which they hoped would attract the biggest fields - they stuck to what they knew. Albi also revived their motorcycle GP on the same day, which allowed Fergus Anderson to repeat his 350cc victory there in 1939 - although this time on a Velocette rather than a DKW.



#5 uechtel

uechtel
  • Member

  • 1,990 posts
  • Joined: April 01

Posted 13 July 2025 - 07:47

Does anyone know what cars were eligible for this race?  The field appears to be all 1500cc supercharged cars.  Was it, like the 1946 Turin GP, run for 1.5 litre s/c and 4.5 litre u/s cars (although none competed), anticipating the new International Formula (Formula 1) which would come into effect in 1947. 

If so, it would displace the Turin race's somewhat dubious claim to be the first Formula 1 race.

This is thinking from the wrong side. Formula 1 wasn´t in existence in 1946, neither in 1947. It was just a change of specifications of the International Formula, just like what had happened between 1937 and 1938. So the Torino race can not have been the first Formula 1 race.

 

Furthermore, by definition, the International Formula contained the regulations for the offficial national Grands Prix only. For everything else the organizers were free to choose a specific formula t their own choice. That could of course be identical to the technical set of regulations of the official International Formula, but not necessarily. Means at least de jure all the other races were just Formule Libre (or to be more precise "independent formula racing" - but nobody cared about such questions in those days, it becomes relevant only by trying to squeeze the past under today´s urge to build up a 'legacy' for the Formula 1 brand.)

 

So to me it appears that the Geneva race was just in contnuation of pre war 1.5 litre Voiturette racing, nothing more, nothing less. 


Edited by uechtel, 13 July 2025 - 10:06.


#6 Kvadrat

Kvadrat
  • Member

  • 990 posts
  • Joined: August 01

Posted 14 July 2025 - 03:36

This is thinking from the wrong side. Formula 1 wasn´t in existence in 1946, neither in 1947. It was just a change of specifications of the International Formula, just like what had happened between 1937 and 1938. So the Torino race can not have been the first Formula 1 race.

 

Moreover, in most cases people don't realise that Formula 1 name means two absolutely different things. Formula 1 as a race series exist only from 1981, it wasn't before that. Instead, there was Formula 1 name for International Grand Prix class from 1948 till 1980. The 1970s was transitional period when World Championship often appeared to be called simply Formula 1, and then in 1980 it was applied for the first International racing series called FIA Formula One World Chamionship. Formula 1 before and after 1981 are two absolutely diffenet things. Whatever began in 1946 or 1948 and even 1950 it's not part of FIA Formula One World Chamionship which was created only in 1980 and started in 1981.



#7 ReWind

ReWind
  • Member

  • 3,853 posts
  • Joined: October 03

Posted 14 July 2025 - 10:53

Formula 1 before and after 1981 are two absolutely different things.

Different: yes. Absolutely different: no.
Yours is Hubert's school of thinking. It disregards all the continuous things that were there up to 1980 and persisted afterwards.



#8 DCapps

DCapps
  • Member

  • 1,086 posts
  • Joined: August 16

Posted 14 July 2025 - 14:36

"The past is a foreign country; they do things differently there." L.P. Hartley



#9 Kvadrat

Kvadrat
  • Member

  • 990 posts
  • Joined: August 01

Posted 15 July 2025 - 02:54

Different: yes. Absolutely different: no.
Yours is Hubert's school of thinking. It disregards all the continuous things that were there up to 1980 and persisted afterwards.

 

I perfectly realise continuation of Grand Prix racing into new form of Formula One series. But I believe we need to hyperbolise the question to raise it. Formula One myth of being started in 1950 killed Grand Prix racing understanding and is "Hubert's school of thinking. It disregards all the continuous things that were there up to 1950 and persisted afterwards". Situation in 1950 and 1981 was similar and 1981 was even much more revolutional. In 1950, there was no difference to 1949 as to how to run races and participate in them. Absolutely nothing new. But Formula One myth says there was everything new, absolutely different to 1949 because everything before 1950 was "unofficial". There were the same drivers, cars, teams and circuits both in 1949-50 and 1980-81. There was nothing new in races organization and participation in 1950 and there was completely new system in 1981 compared to 1980. Using the same drivers, cars, teams and circuits. But completely new system in form of international racing series which didn't exist before at all. Probably NASCAR was the first to create racing series out of various independent races in 1972. Bernie just tried to adopt the idea in Grand Prix racing but had no enough political power. Instead, Balestre did exactly what Ecclestone needed creating racing series with commercial rights from non-commercial WDC. That was real revolution which killed Grand Prix racing as a independent phenomenon. Formula One as it is today is not Grand Prix racing as it was in 1923-1980. It IS continuation but not the same.



#10 opplock

opplock
  • Member

  • 1,168 posts
  • Joined: January 10

Posted 15 July 2025 - 07:12

There were the same drivers, cars, teams and circuits both in 1949-50 and 1980-81. There was nothing new in races organization and participation in 1950 and there was completely new system in 1981 compared to 1980. Using the same drivers, cars, teams and circuits. But completely new system in form of international racing series which didn't exist before at all. 

 

An international racing series that never existed before? This momentous event went unnoticed by those of us who attended Grands Prix in 1981. A year I remember for the ridiculous cheating devices used to circumvent the 6cm ground clearance rule and witnessing Gilles' Monaco win. Judean Peoples Front or Peoples Front of Judea? 



#11 Kvadrat

Kvadrat
  • Member

  • 990 posts
  • Joined: August 01

Posted 15 July 2025 - 07:43

WDC 1950-80 wasn't a racing series like Formula One from 1981 or NASCAR Winston Cup from 1972. There were no championship entries. Competitors entered every single race which weren't under the same management. This system did not exist on international scene before Formula One was created in 1981. They united all races and competitors under the same commercial and legal management from 1981 and that was (and sadly still is) completely new system. The word "series" originally was often applied to chain of the same races, for example, "Monaco Grand Prix series from 1929". All championships over the world were the same as WDC 1950-1980, i.e. some motor club first announced points scoring rules but did not organize races themsenves, did not accept entries and did not pay starting and prize money. It just counted points at the end of the year and declared champion. In Formula One it's been different since 1981. Grand Prix racing was open for everybody (accepting international rules) to run races, built cars and race them. Formula One is completely closed commercial enterprise. They are completely different things albeit latter one was based on former one.



#12 GT40Man

GT40Man
  • Member

  • 30 posts
  • Joined: April 25

Posted 15 July 2025 - 09:45

It would be good if the title of this thread was corrected.
The event’s title was Grand Prix DES Nations.

#13 DCapps

DCapps
  • Member

  • 1,086 posts
  • Joined: August 16

Posted 15 July 2025 - 12:46

As Yogi Berra might put it, it is difficult to write history, especially about the past. -- Gordon Wood

– Gordon Wood