Jump to content


Photo

1980 Motocross 125cc World Championship question


  • Please log in to reply
7 replies to this topic

#1 Michael Ferner

Michael Ferner
  • Member

  • 7,569 posts
  • Joined: November 09

Posted 24 September 2025 - 08:38

Motocross (or scrambling, if you prefer) is rarely discussed on this forum, but I'm hoping that perhaps someone here remembers, or has the relevant magazines or books of the time to check.

 

At the Austrian 125cc Grand Prix at Launsdorf on April 13 in 1980, three of the top four finishers (winner Harry Everts, 3rd place Tetsumi Mitsuyasu and 4th place Craig Coleman) in the second heat ("moto") were initially disqualified because their bikes failed a weight check after the event. The teams (Yamaha and Suzuki) protested the decision, pointing out that the scales had not been calibrated for years, and that there were no weight stipulations in the FIM code, to which the organizers pointed out a supplement to the regulations of their event, and repeated the weighing at a calibrated scale the next day, confirming their decision. The FIM jury, however, reinstated the riders and refered the matter to FIM arbitration, which did not happen until the Autumn congress in Malta on October 19-25 (!). Swiss magazine Motorsport aktuell carried a terse note about the decision in their report of the Malta congress, stating that Everts, Mitsuyasu and Coleman "lost their points" from the event, or words to that effect, and that is all I can find on the matter in period sources.

 

The FIM site does not address the issue at all on their page about the Malta congress (FIM History - Flash Back 1980-1984 | FIM), but the (not always reliable!) memotocross.fr * site has all three riders struck from the results (2cm-1980-125-res-complet.pdf), and the following note amended:

 

GP Autriche : Harry Everts perd les points de sa 1ère place en 2è manche suite à une réclamation, mais il garde tout de même l'attribution de la victoire du GP

 

Now, this does not sound very plausible to me: if a competitor is disqualified, he can no longer be regarded as the winner, right? Confusingly, a little further down the page Coleman is then listed as having finished third overall after Everts's exclusion!

 

My interpretation of these words and the Motorsport aktuell note from the congress is that the FIM took an 'in-between' stand on the matter, much like the FIA at the 1963 French GP (Graham Hill) and 1983 Brazilian GP (Keke Rosberg), a "points penalty" instead of an outright disqualification, with the difference being mainly that the following finishers do not move up in the standings. Sadly, Motorsport aktuell had already published their year-end tables before the Malta congress, and I can't find corrected point standings in later issues, or in other magazines available to me (at least not without going through dozens of magazines with a very fine comb!). As best as I can determine right now, all intermediate standings in period magazines show the three riders with their points from the relevant heat still in place, so that doesn't help either.

 

It's just a minor thing, and the changes to the final standings minimal (Velkeneers would drop to 5th, and Rahier to 10th), but I like my records to be as accurate as possible, and this little discrepancy bugs me. Can anyone shed light on this, preferably from a period source?

 

 

* Needless to say, all available online sources copy their results from memotocross and are completely useless, as usual.



Advertisement

#2 ChiliFan

ChiliFan
  • Member

  • 207 posts
  • Joined: March 07

Posted 25 September 2025 - 06:08

If you weren't already aware, the excellent Grenier de Jean-Pol has a complete collection of the French magazine Moto Revue scanned and posted online. I had a quick look at the 1980 issues and found a brief mention of the FIM Congress decision in issue 2489 (page 52) and a points table from December in issue 2490 (page 37). Not sure if these will answer all your questions but I hope they help:

 

Moto Revue n2489 (18 December 1980): https://www.legrenie...hp?topic=9843.0

Moto Revue n2490 (24 December 1980): https://www.legrenie...hp?topic=9842.0



#3 Michael Ferner

Michael Ferner
  • Member

  • 7,569 posts
  • Joined: November 09

Posted 25 September 2025 - 10:11

Excellent, thank you very much!

 

Yes, I'm aware of the grenier, but as my French is pretty poor it wasn't really an option going through all of those magazines in the hope of finding a nugget! Thank you for finding it for me, now I need to translate and read it carefully to form a conclusion.  :up:



#4 Michael Ferner

Michael Ferner
  • Member

  • 7,569 posts
  • Joined: November 09

Posted 25 September 2025 - 14:05

This is the MR article from Dec 18:
 

Everts déclassé sur le tapis vert?
 
Les faits: à l'arrivée du G.P. d'Autriche 125, le second de la saison, la Suzuki de Harry Everts - qui vient de remporter les deux manches - pèse carrément 7 kg de moins que la limite... L'affaire est examinée au congrès FIM de Malte, et il est décidé de retirer les 15 points de la seconde manche à Everts... qui du coup devance encore l'Italien Rinaldi (TGM) de 5 points ! Explication (foireuse, mais le président de la commission cross est belge...) : le contrôle a été effectué après la seconde manche, il y'a donc doute pour la première ! Mais la fédé italienne vient de faire une seconde fois appel de cette décision, et l'affaire sera encore examinée en congrès extraordinaire  à Genève... Au bout du compte, les belges auront du mal à faire avaler que la moto d'Everts était plus lourde lors de la première manche que lors de la seconde... Et Rinaldi pourrait devenir un inattendu - et tardif  - champion du Monde pour le compte de TGM, firme qu'il a d'ailleurs quitté depuis pour Gilera !

 
(Machine) translated:
 
Everts downgraded on the green carpet? The facts: at the finish of the Austrian 125cc GP, the second of the season, Harry Everts' Suzuki—who had just won both rounds—weighed 7 kg under the limit... The matter was examined at the FIM Congress in Malta, and it was decided to strip Everts of his 15 points from the second round... who was thus still ahead of the Italian Rinaldi (TGM) by 5 points! Explanation (a lame one, but the president of the motocross commission is Belgian... ) : the test was carried out after the second round, so there's doubt about the first! But the Italian federation has just appealed this decision for a second time, and the case will be examined again at an extraordinary congress in Geneva... In the end, the Belgians will have a hard time getting people to accept that Everts' bike was heavier in the first round than in the second... And Rinaldi could become an unexpected - and late - World Champion for TGM, a firm he has since left for Gilera! 
 

Not really enlightnening, sadly. Like the Motorsport aktuell article, futile speculation about the weight of the bike in the first heat (no parc fermé conditions between motocross heats, so rather pointless), and short on facts. "Stripped of points", yes, but does that mean disqualification? The points table in the next issue does appear to say so, but it may have been an 'in-house' modification, not an official FIM document. And then that "explanation" by the biased (by implication! "...") Belgian president (Renè Bruneel, I think), what is that supposed to even mean? I'm not sure there will be any point in looking for news about this at the 1981 Spring congress. Unless this all is properly explained by a journalist with better work ethos, this will not be settled short of official FIM documentation, I'm afraid. :(


Edited by Michael Ferner, 25 September 2025 - 14:06.


#5 philippe7

philippe7
  • Member

  • 2,891 posts
  • Joined: August 03

Posted 25 September 2025 - 14:51

Michael, it seems quite clear to me. The "overall" victory issue is irrelevant since in Motocross each leg carries its own points, so the "overall" win is purely a .... what, prestige issue ? What happened is that the three "offenders" were stripped of their points from the second leg only - and Craig Coleman scored 10 points from his third place in the first leg, not from an overall position..... the debatable issue is that the FIM ruled that the wheighing having been done at the end of the second leg, there is no "absolute proof" that the bikes were underweight in the first leg as well...... ridiculous of course, as there was no way the bike could have lost 7 kilos between the two legs ..... but this decision, based on a legality "nitpicking", had the merit not to cause a late change of official world champion since Everts kept a 5 points advantage - which he would of course have lost if he had also been stripped for the 15 points of his first leg win.  The Italian federation appealed this FIM ruling but it obviously did not work since Everts is still to this day the official 1980 World Champion.....

 

I never knew Craig Coleman had scored World Championship points by the way , I had a nice conversation with him in Christchurch back in 2016 I think, he mentioned that he had done two seasons in Europe as a protégé of Gaston Rahier (who was somehow returning the exceptional hospitality that the Coleman family - then Suzuki importer - had offered him when he came to New Zealand for some promotional racing at least twice) where he rode in various internationals in 250 and 500 and the occasional 125 Grand Prix, but he never told me that he had scored points. 


Edited by philippe7, 25 September 2025 - 14:57.


#6 Michael Ferner

Michael Ferner
  • Member

  • 7,569 posts
  • Joined: November 09

Posted 26 September 2025 - 06:52

It's a bit of a technicality, yes. The question I'm trying to solve is whether the points were merely "stripped", or the positions vacated so that the following riders in the second heat moved up in the ranking, i.e. whether Velkeneers received 15 points or just 12, and Rahier 12 points or 6 etc. It's not a ground shaking difference but, of course, further down the championship points ranking the changes are more pronounced. Whether the overall win is import or not can be argued till the cows come home, is it only important when championship points are awarded? I think not, but mileage may vary... In this context, however, it's a vital question because if Everts stays overall winner, he can't have been removed from the results in the second heat, and if he was disqualified, Velkeneers would have been overall winner.

 

Since the bikes were not weighed after the first heat, the discussion about those points is totally irrelevant, and I wonder what the Italian federation really did appeal; Motorsport aktuell didn't have anything on that, I think it's a red herring.



#7 philippe7

philippe7
  • Member

  • 2,891 posts
  • Joined: August 03

Posted 26 September 2025 - 16:14

Michael, there is some misunderstanding there : if you look at the first table on the memotocross page you gave the link to, the one with the global championship classification and detail of points awarded at each leg, you can see that in the second leg of the Austrian Grand Prix, Velkeneers scored 15 points for first, Rahier 12 for second, Suzuki 10 for 3rd, etc ..... so yes, to answer your question, they were "moved up in the rankings". And the yearly total of points is correct - it is identical to the one published in moto-revue, incidentally. 

 

Further down the page, where there are the details of various podiums of each race, the Austria case is special since indeed , there are two "first" , Everts and Velkeneers. Torao Suzuki is 2nd and Craig Coleman third, having also kept the benefit of his 5th place in the second heat . Please note what is written in franzözich at the bottom of the table in question : " the classification of each grand prix is honorific, but can however influence the prize money. The calculation is not based on the number of points won in each leg - unlike the championship - but on the finishing order : 1st = 1pt, 2nd = 2pts, etc....."

So in this case, Everts appears "Winner" with 1+1 = 2pt, Velkeneers 1st (!) with 2+1 = 3pts, Suzuki 2nd and Coleman 3rd (both with 8 points, the added times of each leg decide the placing) 


Edited by philippe7, 26 September 2025 - 16:14.


#8 Michael Ferner

Michael Ferner
  • Member

  • 7,569 posts
  • Joined: November 09

Posted 29 September 2025 - 07:13

Thanks again, Philippe, but I fear we are talking at cross purposes! :D I know all the ins and outs of classification in motocross, what I'm trying to figure out is who made what mistake in reporting. Maybe it's just me, being overly fastidious, and everybody else is happy with the info provided - if this is so, just go ahead, nothing to see here :lol: But to me, there's a glaring contradiction there, waiting to be cleared.   ;)