Why is this still controversial? Because wikipedia hasn't yet latched onto it??
This forum, many years ago already, confirmed in a multi-national press survey that sixth place was awarded one point in 1957 and '58, but not in '59. It's somehwere in the archive, Tim will probably find it in a jiffy! 
Always wonderful to hear from you, Michael.
That the Wiki-world seems to have adopted the idea that AAA national championship racing history begins with 1916, then skips to 1920 and Gaston Chevrolet, is a bit mind-boggling and scary, which I was not aware of until very, very recently.
It was a bit unnerving to be honest; but, then again someone will probably rewrite it back to the Means/Catlin version.
No idea where Wiki-world is on this particular item and really don't care.
Is there something from the CSI in its meeting minutes or communiques confirming this?
Something that I obviously missed/overlooked in the archives?
Basically, just curious given that such information should now be available.
Plus, hoping that someone will tackle the task of sorting out the CSI (and perhaps its successors) material for others to ponder.
Then again, we still lack a history of AAA national championship racing.
That the Brit motoring press (slavishly copied by their US counterparts) tended to consistently conflate the F1 rules with those of the world championship at the time (as we all probably did then as a result, so mea culpa) as well as tossed around terms such as "grandes épreuves" with abandon tends to be interesting in retrospect.
Interesting to see how the Continental motoring press handled all this by comparison. Perhaps not much better, but still, a nice topic to consider.
Did some digging into the French side of the equation, which tended to suggest that Jingoism and Journalistic Enthusiasm was not unique to either side of the Channel.
Anyhow, this was just more of a way to keep the forum from sliding into the Sleep mode.
/////////////////////
Okay, the question is really this: what is the source, the documentation, the reference to the CSI meeting minutes, bulletin, championship regulation that allowed the 1957, 1958 multi-national press to state this as being unequivocally fact?
In other words: where is archival footnote?
Not that hard, really, just curious as to why this would be true.
This would, of course, apply to a multitude of other related items as well.
Just saying that a lot of baloney has been peddled by the motoring press in the past and is still floating around out there.
Facts do get in the way at times, but sometimes it is just nice to conform that they are facts in the first place.
If asking this is a problem, okay, my bad, sorry.
Edited by DCapps, 04 November 2025 - 20:12.