Jump to content


Photo

Miscellaneous and Miscellany


  • Please log in to reply
17 replies to this topic

#1 DCapps

DCapps
  • Member

  • 1,086 posts
  • Joined: August 16

Posted 03 November 2025 - 19:18

Stumbled upon this today, with a sense of déjà vu all over again...

 

Peter Garnier, “Well Done, Hawthorn – Well Done, Moss,” Autocar, 24 October 1958, 663.

Looking back over the ten events in which, during 1958, the two [Hawthorn and Moss] have raced against each other, it is interesting to see how they have fared.

The table below shows how each has scored points in the ten grandes épreuves, points being awarded at the rate of 8, 6, 4, 3, 2, 1 for first to sixth positions, with an extra point for fastest lap. 

 

###



Advertisement

#2 ensign14

ensign14
  • Member

  • 68,876 posts
  • Joined: December 01

Posted 03 November 2025 - 22:25

I still go with the hypercorrection hypothesis.  Given a points system of 8/6/4/3/2 BUT NO 1 (other than FL) makes no sense whatsoever, editors who were not paying close attention simply added in a sixth place point to make it nice and consistent.



#3 DCapps

DCapps
  • Member

  • 1,086 posts
  • Joined: August 16

Posted 04 November 2025 - 02:07

I still go with the hypercorrection hypothesis.  Given a points system of 8/6/4/3/2 BUT NO 1 (other than FL) makes no sense whatsoever, editors who were not paying close attention simply added in a sixth place point to make it nice and consistent.

 

Was this also something also happening in the non-Anglophone press?

Or were those on Airstrip One simply more inclined to making such things up?

It would seem that much (as in most) of the ongoing confusion over Eff Wun (as in F175, etc) and so forth and so on appears to originate in the Motoring Yellow Press from Back in The Day.

With the Former Colonists simply lapping it up uncritically it would appear.

Clio wept.



#4 Michael Ferner

Michael Ferner
  • Member

  • 7,559 posts
  • Joined: November 09

Posted 04 November 2025 - 12:56

Why is this still controversial? Because wikipedia hasn't yet latched onto it??

 

This forum, many years ago already, confirmed in a multi-national press survey that sixth place was awarded one point in 1957 and '58, but not in '59. It's somehwere in the archive, Tim will probably find it in a jiffy!  :D



#5 Collombin

Collombin
  • Member

  • 10,930 posts
  • Joined: March 05

Posted 04 November 2025 - 15:22

A thread called "1957 French GP Rouen" turned into a pretty detailed discussion about it, probably what you are thinking of.

#6 DCapps

DCapps
  • Member

  • 1,086 posts
  • Joined: August 16

Posted 04 November 2025 - 15:33

Why is this still controversial? Because wikipedia hasn't yet latched onto it??

 

This forum, many years ago already, confirmed in a multi-national press survey that sixth place was awarded one point in 1957 and '58, but not in '59. It's somehwere in the archive, Tim will probably find it in a jiffy!  :D

 

Always wonderful to hear from you, Michael.

That the Wiki-world seems to have adopted the idea that AAA national championship racing history begins with 1916, then skips to 1920 and Gaston Chevrolet, is a bit mind-boggling and scary, which I was not aware of until very, very recently.

It was a bit unnerving to be honest; but, then again someone will probably rewrite it back to the Means/Catlin version.

No idea where Wiki-world is on this particular item and really don't care.

 

Is there something from the CSI in its meeting minutes or communiques confirming this?

Something that I obviously missed/overlooked in the archives? 

Basically, just curious given that such information should now be available.

Plus, hoping that someone will tackle the task of sorting out the CSI (and perhaps its successors) material for others to ponder.

Then again, we still lack a history of AAA national championship racing.

 

That the Brit motoring press (slavishly copied by their US counterparts) tended to consistently conflate the F1 rules with those of the world championship at the time (as we all probably did then as a result, so mea culpa) as well as tossed around terms such as "grandes épreuves" with abandon tends to be interesting in retrospect.

Interesting to see how the Continental motoring press handled all this by comparison. Perhaps not much better, but still, a nice topic to consider.

Did some digging into the French side of the equation, which tended to suggest that Jingoism and Journalistic Enthusiasm  was not unique to either side of the Channel.

 

Anyhow, this was just more of a way to keep the forum from sliding into the Sleep mode.

 

 

/////////////////////

 

Okay, the question is really this: what is the source, the documentation, the reference to the CSI meeting minutes, bulletin, championship regulation that allowed the 1957, 1958 multi-national press to state this as being unequivocally fact?

In other words: where is archival footnote?

Not that hard, really, just curious as to why this would be true.

This would, of course, apply to a multitude of other related items as well.

Just saying that a lot of baloney has been peddled by the motoring press in the past and is still floating around out there.

Facts do get in the way at times, but sometimes it is just nice to conform that they are facts in the first place.

If asking this is a problem, okay, my bad, sorry.


Edited by DCapps, 04 November 2025 - 20:12.


#7 Michael Ferner

Michael Ferner
  • Member

  • 7,559 posts
  • Joined: November 09

Posted 05 November 2025 - 10:00

A thread called "1957 French GP Rouen" turned into a pretty detailed discussion about it, probably what you are thinking of.

 
Yes, that seems to have been it, thanks:

 

1957 French GP Rouen - The Nostalgia Forum - The Autosport Forums

 

 
Okay, the question is really this: what is the source, the documentation, the reference to the CSI meeting minutes, bulletin, championship regulation that allowed the 1957, 1958 multi-national press to state this as being unequivocally fact?
In other words: where is archival footnote?
Not that hard, really, just curious as to why this would be true.
This would, of course, apply to a multitude of other related items as well.
Just saying that a lot of baloney has been peddled by the motoring press in the past and is still floating around out there.
Facts do get in the way at times, but sometimes it is just nice to conform that they are facts in the first place.
If asking this is a problem, okay, my bad, sorry.

 

Yes, it is a problem, because those meeting minutes, bulletins and championship regulations are not available at the moment. Waiting for that to surface at any point in the future is fine, but I'll go with the maligned motoring press in the meantime. After all, it's thanks to them that I became interested in the subject matter in the first place, and got 99.9999999 % of all the information I have been able to digest so far. They may not be perfect, but what is?

 

 

Then again, we still lack a history of AAA national championship racing..

 

It's (slowly) coming together. Slow, because I'm ignoring the word "national", and making it about AAA Championship Racing - ignoring everything outside the National Championship would make the most interesting period, the thirties, the least interesting one - I'll leave that to wikipedia.



#8 DCapps

DCapps
  • Member

  • 1,086 posts
  • Joined: August 16

Posted 05 November 2025 - 12:57

What is available at the moment on the Beta version of the FIA Library regarding the CSI meeting minutes and so forth is more than a bit hit and miss.

The 1980 material, bulletins, is rather good, but leading up to that, not so much.

If patient, one can piece together quite a bit into the early 1950s.

Potentially a treasure throve, but definitely a work in progress.

 

Michael, exactly the correct approach to take.

The AAA "national championship" series needs to be established within its context of all the other racing going on.

If anyone can do this, it is you.

I can do the AAA national championship events, but so can anyone taking the time to do so.

That stuff is floating around out there.

It is placing that year's events into perspective/context that makes the difference.

Easy to say, not that easy to do.

However, I know that you will do your best and it will be well worth the wait.

 

Don



#9 Michael Ferner

Michael Ferner
  • Member

  • 7,559 posts
  • Joined: November 09

Posted 05 November 2025 - 19:21

Thanks, Don, for expressing your confidence! Can I take that as a pre-order?  :lol:

 

Seriously, I can only hope to do justice to the subject, and for you to live enough to see it happen! For, I have come to the conclusion that there's no realistic hope of completing such an undertaking before I retire from work, which is still the best part of a decade away  :(

 

On the plus side, this gives me ample time to do MORE research!  :smoking:



#10 70JesperOH

70JesperOH
  • Member

  • 217 posts
  • Joined: January 21

Posted 08 November 2025 - 11:56

This thread made me look at my notes of "F1 1958". Bruce McLaren finished 5th at the German Grand Prix, but since he drove an F2 car, he did not receive the 2 points. In fact positions 5th - 9th and 11th and last were all F2 cars. That left Cliff Allison in 10th as 5th best F1 car, a Team Lotus-Climax. It could be argued that he should be the receiver of 2 points, but no!? I don't know the reason, except that he finished 10th.

 

Jesper



#11 DCapps

DCapps
  • Member

  • 1,086 posts
  • Joined: August 16

Posted 08 November 2025 - 14:43

So, do you go with the Formula One Register etc or Garnier etc? It has to be one or the other, yes? Which still leaves the GPvD and the Allison question. Anyone happen to have the GPvD regs or even the CSI material (if there was any...) relating to the race.

 

Of course, the Earth will still spin and wobble about the Sun if this "mystery" is not resolved, but curious given the mega-meta-massive focus on this series that it still seems a bit odd that there is even a possible question to be posed.

 

Just one of those curiosities from the Ancient Past.



#12 70JesperOH

70JesperOH
  • Member

  • 217 posts
  • Joined: January 21

Posted 08 November 2025 - 20:40

Simply, I don't know - and to a point I have to leave it at that. There are other matters of live to be lived. But cases like these, I find it interessing to try and replicate championships, race-by-race and points.

 

Jesper



#13 Roger Clark

Roger Clark
  • Member

  • 7,644 posts
  • Joined: February 00

Posted 19 November 2025 - 18:55

The Autocar 23 November 1956 said " Regulations have arrived from the F.i.A for next year's championships" and later:

 

(For the Drivers' Championship): "Points will be awarded as follows: For 1st place 8 points, 2nd place 6 points, 3rd place 4 points, 4th place 3 points, 2nd place 2 points, 6th place 1 point; to the driver (whether placed or not) who has achieved fastest lap, 1 point will be allocated"

 

Not the same as actually seeing the Regulations but fairly persuasive?

 

It also reported that where a car was shared between two or more drivers, the points would be "equally divided between all the drivers concerned, but granted only to drivers who have covered at least one-third of the course in the car in question".   This would affect Tony Brooks in the British Grand Prix as Moss took over on lap 26.


Edited by Roger Clark, 19 November 2025 - 18:55.


#14 DCapps

DCapps
  • Member

  • 1,086 posts
  • Joined: August 16

Posted 20 November 2025 - 22:17

Roger,

 

Good catch! for the November 1956 Autocar piece -- I somehow missed it.

 

Today, at the IMRRC, I went through a ton of Automobile Year issues (1957-1959), GP/F1 compilations, and so forth and so on, both contemporary and from later years.

 

It is all over the map. AY did the point for sixth for 1957, for example, but not for 1958 or 1959 (by then my eyes might have been a bit bleary...).

All -- as in all -- of the (Anglophone) compilations I checked (about 12-15+, I stopped counting) only did the 8-6-4-3-2-1 for FL, 1957-1959.

 

That said, it seems reasonable that the point for sixth place was added to the points schedule, at least for 1957, but somehow got lost in the translations.

 

This is just one of those odd, interesting things that pop up.



#15 Roger Clark

Roger Clark
  • Member

  • 7,644 posts
  • Joined: February 00

Posted 21 November 2025 - 18:33

In Motor Racing, November 1958, there was a report headed "CSI rulings for 1959". It included: "In future all world Championships will be decided on a similar system, points being awarded down to fifth place on the basis 8, 6, 4,3,2 a bonus point for fastest lap will still be awarded in Drivers' Championship events". The word fifth was in italics, which I took to imply a change, although it could be a change to the manufacturers' and sports car championships.

 

CSI proposals had to be ratified by the FIA and their Congress was in progress when the magazine went to press.  Reports of the Congress were dominated by the announcement of the 1961 Formula 1 and the reaction to it but there is no reason to think that the CSI ruling was changed.

 

We should also remember that all rulings from the FIA were in French and only versions in that language had any validity.



#16 Ray Bell

Ray Bell
  • Member

  • 85,502 posts
  • Joined: December 99

Posted 26 November 2025 - 21:29

It might only be a small thing, but...

 

I recall that when I was compiling results for publication in Racing Car News there were occasions when the official results issued by the race organisers didn't agree with the regulations governing the event.

 

The main cause for this was the introduction of 2-heat races in the Championship events. As an individual race they had to be subject to the same rules as any other race and from time to time the organisers would lose track of things like 'distance covered to qualify as finishers' and the like. When I found the anomolies I would produce a result panel in the magazine which reflected that.

 

One outstanding variation from the organisers' results which I wrote up but didn't reflect in the result panel was an 'endurance' race at Oran Park for touring cars in which a pit stop for a driver change had been necessary. Using a different strategy to everyone else - stopping as early as permitted for this change - the official timekeepers/lap scorers missed a lap of the actual winners'. But I didn't and wrote the report as I had scored it.



#17 DCapps

DCapps
  • Member

  • 1,086 posts
  • Joined: August 16

Posted 28 November 2025 - 02:23

Always keep in mind that in some instances, rules of the organizing club or national association could affect even a supposedly international event. 

Think A.C. de Monaco, for instance, or the ACF for another or even the ADAC...



#18 Michael Ferner

Michael Ferner
  • Member

  • 7,559 posts
  • Joined: November 09

Posted 05 December 2025 - 15:37

Always keep in mind that in some instances, rules of the organizing club or national association could affect even a supposedly international event. 

Think A.C. de Monaco, for instance, or the ACF for another or even the ADAC...

 

Very good point!!