Two points:
1. F1 will decline without money. That money does not need to come from the manufacturers. With money F1 can continue to market itself and draw the audiences and, hence, the businesses. There's plenty of places F1 can look for money. If you have no audience, it's difficult to convince people to push money your way. If you have an 800 million following you it's not so tough.
2. Who says the manufacturers will leave. It sounds like their bluff will be called here. But F1 is the perfect place for them to market themselves and so I have my doubts that they will leave.
I think the model to look at is what happened between the FIA/F1 and Ferrari before and after the introduction of the cost-cap.
Ferrari were against the cap because it would cause problems with Italian labour laws, and warned that it would mean they would have to abandon the long-standing exclusivity as a factory team in F1.
The FIA/F1 looked at that trade-off, called their bluff and did it anyway. So post cost-cap, Ferrari spin up a Le Mans prototype effort for the first time in half a century.
And so F1 got its cost cap and became much more financially secure, Ferrari stayed put as an F1 team, and the WEC benefitted handsomely with the injection of hype that Ferrari's return brought with them.
If the FIA/F1 do this V8 plan for simpler, cheaper PUs... I too don't think a manufacturer like Mercedes leaves F1. But I also don't think it disbands the expertise and competitive edge it has built up in cutting edge motorsport electrification. I think they look for somewhere else to deploy and exploit it.
The WEC and Formula E could both be really excellent options for that come 2030-ish. Less of a given is something like WRC, but it's possible based on what I see.
So despite my misgivings about the power and intent of the fossil fuel lobby sitting behind the sustainable fuels mask, I think the whole World Championship-level of the sport does stand to be somewhat rebalanced by a plan like this.
It's ultimately the FIA's job to deliver that balance across its portfolio of championships, not FOM's... so it makes sense that it might end up being the FIA forcing this through.
Edited by Ben1445, 03 May 2026 - 16:07.