Jump to content


Photo
* - - - - 1 votes

Should tows be banned for Q3? [edited title]


  • Please log in to reply
16 replies to this topic

Poll: Qualifying tows (33 member(s) have cast votes)

Should qualifying tows be banned in the top 10 shoot out

  1. No - I like to see those (strategic) games (10 votes [30.30%])

    Percentage of vote: 30.30%

  2. No - While don't like seeing the messes the search for a tow creates, it's part of the game (19 votes [57.58%])

    Percentage of vote: 57.58%

  3. Yes - While I the strategic games, drivers should make their lap on their own (1 votes [3.03%])

    Percentage of vote: 3.03%

  4. Yes - It makes a mokkery of qualifying (3 votes [9.09%])

    Percentage of vote: 9.09%

Vote Guests cannot vote

#1 JL14

JL14
  • Member

  • 2,346 posts
  • Joined: October 22

Posted Today, 15:41

Should they, yes or no?

 

I actually expect not too many people will agree and the debate will more quickly turn into a '1-lap qualifying'-yes/no, BUT:

 

I just don't like these qualifying sessions where you see drivers tumble over each other to get in the best position for the biggest tow along the straights on their qualifying run. And to a lesser extend teammates (nr. 2's) driving around to tow the team's main driver.

So I would very much like to see these antics disappear from the pole shootout (Q3) and just have the driver/car-combination get their best lap on their own power.

 

The question then of course becomes, how would you enforce such a thing? Basically you want to encourage drivers to leave a decent gap to the car in front and discourage the driver in front to let the driver behind close up and benefit from a tow. There are multiple ways, some more simple, some requiring changes to the qualifying system, some general rules (all GPs), some 'hefty tow benefiting circuits'-only rules etc. For example:

  • The "1-lap qualifying":
    - Drivers get two times a run in a pre-described order (i.e. Q2 or championship order)
    - With a prescribed time-offset (i.e. 30s)
    - And a presribed min+max outlap duration (to keep the time-offset intact)
    - Mandated abort + automatic 200kph speed limit if the driver behind gets within slipstream distance (i.e. 6s)
  • The "take the slipstream advantage away":
    - The gap between drivers on a fast lap is measured at a set point before each straight
    - If this is below a presribed value (i.e. 6s at the start, 3s during the lap) SLM will be disabled for that driver on the following straight
  • The "remove the driver in front":
    - A driver can only start a valid fast lap when a prescribed time behind the driver in front at the start of the lap (i.e. 5s)
    - Automatic immediate 200kph speed limit for a driver if the driver behind gets within a certain time (i.e. 2s)
  • The "take the laptimes away":
    - A driver can only start a valid fast lap when a prescribed time behind the driver in front at the start of the lap (i.e. 5s)
    - Determined by stewards if a driver has benefitted from a tow (i.e. has run within 3s of the driver in front with both at speed and on the same line)
    - (All) laptime(s) from both drivers deleted
    - Or stewards determine which laps deleted (i.e. driver in front still genuinely pushing for a laptime/grid position improvement and rider behind picked up the slipstream instead of driving a different line -> laptime of driver behind deleted. Driver in front not genuinely pushing for a laptime/grid position improvement (i.e. significantly down on previous laptime, obviously backing off to let the driver behind get closer) and rider behind picked up the slipstream instead of driving a different line -> laptime of driver behind deleted + all laptimes of driver in front deleted. 


Advertisement

#2 Heyli

Heyli
  • RC Forum Host

  • 11,972 posts
  • Joined: May 17

Posted Today, 15:42

No, thank you

#3 IrvTheSwerve

IrvTheSwerve
  • Member

  • 9,312 posts
  • Joined: July 15

Posted Today, 15:52

Dear god.

 

Just no.

 

I had an aneurism just reading those hypothetical rules - F1 is complicated enough as it is.


Edited by IrvTheSwerve, Today, 15:53.


#4 STIGG

STIGG
  • Member

  • 608 posts
  • Joined: February 10

Posted Today, 16:03

Start the thread title with "should" and end with a question mark to save the rest of us a WTF moment.

To answer: no.

#5 ArchieTech

ArchieTech
  • Member

  • 5,690 posts
  • Joined: May 15

Posted Today, 16:06

I think it would be too open to a driver in front accidentally having a bad corner exit and bringing the driver into the window for the lap deletion. That could be even more impactful than some drivers getting a tow and others not.

 

As it is anyway I generally find tows quite an interesting demonstration of the team vs individual elements of F1, plus the addition of luck. So I'd leave it as an interesting variable.


Edited by ArchieTech, Today, 16:08.


#6 AlexPrime

AlexPrime
  • Member

  • 8,661 posts
  • Joined: September 17

Posted Today, 16:08

Yes. Sometimes the simplest solution is the best



#7 Sterzo

Sterzo
  • Member

  • 7,915 posts
  • Joined: September 11

Posted Today, 17:09

I'm afraid I haven't voted in the poll, as there is no "Do I look bovvered?" option.



#8 RainyAfterlifeDaylight

RainyAfterlifeDaylight
  • Member

  • 5,610 posts
  • Joined: February 15

Posted Today, 17:25

The problem is that sometimes towing happens unintentionally even between different teams so banning it, won't solve the problem unless there is a change of qualyfying format.



#9 LolaB0860

LolaB0860
  • Member

  • 4,158 posts
  • Joined: March 22

Posted Today, 17:35

What?

 

No, they can do whatever they want.



#10 STIGG

STIGG
  • Member

  • 608 posts
  • Joined: February 10

Posted Today, 18:19

Anyway, we had this issue at Monza in 2019 with half the field failing to set a time in Q3 as a result of everyone backing off.

The FIA introduced a maximum lap time afterwards and it hasn't really been an issue since then.

Upon review: No further action.

#11 PayasYouRace

PayasYouRace
  • Racing Simulators Forum Host

  • 59,665 posts
  • Joined: January 10

Posted Today, 18:27

What do you mean, ban tows? It's a basic part of the laws of physics.

The only way to avoid the effect is to have one car on the track at a time. You might not want the conversation to go to single-lap qualifying, but that's the only way to do it. Nothing is else enforceable or practical in any way. Plus, F1 fans in general are sick of overly complicated and restrictive rules that get in the way of pure competition.

 

Let the drivers figure it out themselves. If you can't slot yourself into an optimum track placement for the best hot lap, you should probably go back to your local kart track, because you're clearly not ready to be a Grand Prix driver.



#12 jonpollak

jonpollak
  • Member

  • 53,099 posts
  • Joined: March 00

Posted Today, 18:37

There needs to be a cull on ridiculous threads….

Not including any of mine however…

Jp

#13 MikeTekRacing

MikeTekRacing
  • Member

  • 19,166 posts
  • Joined: October 04

Posted Today, 19:00

No

#14 vlado

vlado
  • Member

  • 11,365 posts
  • Joined: September 06

Posted Today, 19:41

I was watching qualifying with a friend yesterday and she said if we take a shot every time the F1TV commentators say “slipstream” we would be wasted by the end of Q2

Edited by vlado, Today, 19:41.


#15 skicrack

skicrack
  • Member

  • 299 posts
  • Joined: March 15

Posted Today, 19:42

Of course not! And before coming up with something like this, how would you actually want to enforce it. I mean it's essentially physics, how do you wanna ban that? Give them a fixed distance between someone in front?

#16 Yamamoto

Yamamoto
  • Member

  • 2,418 posts
  • Joined: April 16

Posted Today, 20:24

Yes. Imagine the chaos of trying to figure out who has and hasn't broken the rules. The scope for debate is fantastic. Might get old quickly though, so perhaps just for a few, select rounds.



#17 Frood

Frood
  • Member

  • 13,710 posts
  • Joined: January 14

Posted Today, 20:41

Can’t the FIA just edit the .ini file to turn the slipstream strength down for Q3?